Study guide
20.5 Feedback Control Systems & Research Methods
PRC Registered Electrical Engineer REE
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Overview, RA 7920 & Electrical Engineering Ethics
1.1 PRC Board of Electrical Engineering & REE Examination Overview 1.2 Republic Act No. 7920 (New Electrical Engineering Law) & License Classes 1.3 Code of Ethics & Professional Practice for Electrical Engineers
2 Chapter 2: Math — Algebra, Trig & Geometry
2.1 Algebraic Equations, Polynomials & Complex Numbers 2.2 Trigonometry — Identities, Triangles & Spherical Trig 2.3 Analytic & Solid Geometry
3 Chapter 3: Engineering Mathematics — Calculus & Differential Equations
3.1 Differential Calculus, Limits, Derivatives & Applications 3.2 Integral Calculus, Integration Techniques & Area/Volume Applications 3.3 Ordinary Differential Equations & Initial-Value Problems
4 Chapter 4: Engineering Mathematics — Advanced Math & Transform Methods
4.1 Laplace Transforms, Inverse Transforms & Circuit Applications 4.2 Fourier Series, Fourier Transforms & Frequency-Domain Analysis 4.3 Vector Analysis, Linear Algebra, Matrices & Complex Analysis
5 Chapter 5: Engineering Mathematics — Probability, Statistics & Engineering Data Analysis
5.1 Probability Theory, Counting Techniques & Bayes' Theorem 5.2 Engineering Data Analysis I — Descriptive Statistics & Probability Distributions 5.3 Engineering Data Analysis II — Confidence Intervals, Hypothesis Testing & Regression
6 Chapter 6: Engineering Mathematics — Numerical Methods & Analysis
6.1 Numerical Root-Finding & Solution of Linear Systems 6.2 Interpolation, Numerical Integration & Numerical Solution of ODEs
7 Chapter 7: ESAS — Physics, Chemistry & Computer Fundamentals
7.1 Physics for Engineers 7.2 General Chemistry & Materials Science 7.3 Computer Fundamentals, Programming & Data Logic 7.4 Logic Circuits, Switching Theory & Microprocessor Systems
8 Chapter 8: ESAS — Mechanics & Thermal-Fluid Engineering
8.1 Engineering Mechanics — Statics & Dynamics 8.2 Strength of Materials & Mechanics of Deformable Bodies 8.3 Thermal-Fluid Engineering — Thermodynamics & Fluid Mechanics
9 Chapter 9: ESAS — Engineering Economics, Management & Contracts
9.1 Engineering Economics & Depreciation 9.2 Engineering Management & Ethics 9.3 Philippine Electrical Engineering Law, Code & Contracts 9.4 Technopreneurship 101 & Management of Engineering Projects
10 Chapter 10: PEC 1 — Safety, Sizing & Protection
10.1 PEC Fundamentals, Safety Standards & Grounding/Bonding 10.2 Conductor Sizing, Ampacity Adjustment & Voltage Drop 10.3 Overcurrent Protection, Branch Circuit & Feeder Sizing 10.4 Basic Occupational Safety & Health (BOSH) and Electrical Safety Standards
11 Chapter 11: PEC 1 & 2 — Equipment & Utility Systems
11.1 PEC Equipment Installation & Wiring Methods 11.2 Utility Systems, Transformers & Switchgear 11.3 Special Occupancies & Hazardous Locations
12 Chapter 12: Electrical Professional — DC & AC Circuit Fundamentals
12.1 DC Circuit Analysis & Network Theorems 12.2 Single-Phase AC Circuits & Phasor Analysis 12.3 Balanced & Unbalanced Three-Phase AC Circuits
13 Chapter 13: Electrical Professional — EM Fields & Transients
13.1 Electrostatics, Magnetostatics & Maxwell's Equations 13.2 Electromagnetic Waves & Transmission Line Fields 13.3 First-Order & Second-Order Circuit Transients
14 Chapter 14: Electrical Professional — Electronics, Industrial Electronics & Communications
14.1 Electronics 1 & 2 — Semiconductor Devices & Analog Circuits 14.2 Electrical Apparatus & Devices — Industrial Electronics & Power Converters 14.3 Fundamentals of Electronic Communications
15 Chapter 15: Electrical Professional — Transformers & DC Machines
15.1 Single-Phase & Three-Phase Transformers 15.2 Transformer Connections & Special Transformers 15.3 DC Generators & DC Motors
16 Chapter 16: Electrical Professional — AC Synchronous & Induction Machinery
16.1 Synchronous Generators (Alternators) 16.2 Synchronous Motors & Special AC Machines 16.3 Three-Phase & Single-Phase Induction Motors
17 Chapter 17: Electrical Professional — Power Plants & Energy Conversion
17.1 Hydroelectric, Thermal & Combined Cycle Power Plants 17.2 Renewable Energy Systems & Geothermal Power Plants 17.3 Power Plant Economics, Load Curves & Energy Conversion
18 Chapter 18: Electrical Professional — Transmission & Distribution
18.1 Transmission Line Parameters & Performance Models 18.2 Mechanical Overhead Line Design, Underground Cables & Insulators 18.3 Distribution Systems, Substation Layouts & Power Flow Control
19 Chapter 19: Electrical Professional — Power System Analysis
19.1 The Per-Unit System, Base Conversion & Impedance Diagrams 19.2 Symmetrical Components & Unbalanced Fault Analysis 19.3 Load Flow, Economic Dispatch & Power System Stability
20 Chapter 20: Electrical Professional — Protection, Control, Instrumentation & Illumination
20.1 Power System Protection & Protective Relaying 20.2 Industrial Motor Control, Logic Circuits & PLC Automation 20.3 Electrical Instrumentation, Transducers & Measurement Systems 20.4 Illumination Engineering, Lighting Design & Photometrics 20.5 Feedback Control Systems & Research Methods
20.5 Feedback Control Systems & Research Methods
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Instrumentation & Control, Feedback Control System and Research Methods form topic H of the Enhanced TOS Electrical Engineering subject, weighted 4.50% of the exam and 10 of the 100 items.
Closed-loop transfer function is G/(1 + GH) for negative feedback; the characteristic equation 1 + GH = 0 fixes every closed-loop pole and therefore all stability behaviour.
A second-order system has ωn = √(K) and ζ set by the damping term; percent overshoot depends on ζ alone, while settling time is roughly 4/(ζωn).
Routh-Hurwitz determines stability from sign changes in the first column without solving for the roots; any missing or negative coefficient already proves instability.
In a PID controller, proportional action reduces but never eliminates steady-state error, integral action eliminates it while adding phase lag, and derivative action improves damping while amplifying noise.
Last updated: August 2026
20.5 Feedback Control Systems & Research Methods
Topic H of the Electrical Engineering subject in the PRC Enhanced Table of Specifications (PRBEE Resolution No. 40, s. 2024 ) is Instrumentation & Control, Feedback Control System and Research Methods , weighted 4.50% of the whole examination and 10 of the 100 Electrical Engineering items . Earlier sections of this chapter covered instrumentation, transducers and PLC-based industrial control; this section covers the feedback control theory and the research methodology that complete the topic. Governor speed control, automatic voltage regulation, load-frequency control and every process loop in a power plant are applications of exactly this material.
1. Open Loop versus Closed Loop
- Feature Open loop Closed loop (feedback)
- Uses output measurement No Yes
- Disturbance rejection None Good
- Accuracy Depends on calibration Self-correcting
- Stability Inherently stable if plant is Can become unstable
- Cost and complexity Low Higher
- Example Timer-based lighting contactor Generator AVR, turbine governor
Feedback buys accuracy and disturbance rejection at the price of possible instability — the central trade-off of the whole topic.
2. Transfer Functions and Block Diagram Reduction
The transfer function is the Laplace-domain ratio of output to input at zero initial conditions: G ( s ) = C ( s ) R ( s ) G(s) = \frac{C(s)}{R(s)} G ( s ) = R ( s ) C ( s )
For a negative feedback loop with forward path G ( s ) G(s) G ( s ) and feedback path H ( s ) H(s) H ( s ) : C ( s ) R ( s ) = G ( s ) 1 + G ( s ) H ( s ) \frac{C(s)}{R(s)} = \frac{G(s)}{1 + G(s)H(s)} R ( s ) C ( s ) = 1 + G ( s ) H ( s ) G ( s )
For positive feedback the denominator becomes 1 − G ( s ) H ( s ) 1 - G(s)H(s) 1 − G ( s ) H ( s ) . When H ( s ) = 1 H(s) = 1 H ( s ) = 1 the system is unity feedback , and the loop reduces to G / ( 1 + G ) G/(1+G) G / ( 1 + G ) .
The characteristic equation is 1 + G ( s ) H ( s ) = 0 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0 1 + G ( s ) H ( s ) = 0
Its roots are the closed-loop poles, and every question about stability, overshoot and settling time is ultimately a question about where those roots lie. Poles in the left half of the s-plane give a stable system; any pole in the right half gives instability ; poles on the imaginary axis give sustained oscillation.
Reduction rules: blocks in cascade multiply, blocks in parallel add, and a feedback loop collapses by the formula above. Mason's gain formula handles multiple-loop signal flow graphs.
- 3. Transient Response
- First-Order System G ( s ) = K τ s + 1 G(s) = \frac{K}{\tau s + 1} G ( s ) = τ s + 1 K
Step response reaches 63.2% of final value at t = τ t = \tau t = τ and 98.2% at 4 τ 4\tau 4 τ . There is no overshoot and no oscillation.
Second-Order System C ( s ) R ( s ) = ω n 2 s 2 + 2 ζ ω n s + ω n 2 \frac{C(s)}{R(s)} = \frac{\omega_n^{2}}{s^{2} + 2\zeta\omega_n s + \omega_n^{2}} R ( s ) C ( s ) = s 2 + 2 ζ ω n s + ω n 2 ω n 2
- Damping ratio Behaviour Pole locations
- ζ = 0 \zeta = 0 ζ = 0 Undamped, sustained oscillation On the imaginary axis
- 0 < ζ < 1 0 < \zeta < 1 0 < ζ < 1 Underdamped — oscillatory with overshoot Complex conjugate, left half plane
- ζ = 1 \zeta = 1 ζ = 1 Critically damped — fastest without overshoot Real, repeated
- ζ > 1 \zeta > 1 ζ > 1 Overdamped — sluggish, no overshoot Real, distinct
Performance measures: ω d = ω n 1 − ζ 2 % O S = 100 e − π ζ / 1 − ζ 2 \omega_d = \omega_n\sqrt{1-\zeta^{2}} \qquad\qquad \%OS = 100\,e^{-\pi\zeta/\sqrt{1-\zeta^{2}}} ω d = ω n 1 − ζ 2 % OS = 100 e − π ζ / 1 − ζ 2 t p = π ω d t s ≈ 4 ζ ω n ( 2 % band ) t r ≈ 1.8 ω n t_p = \frac{\pi}{\omega_d} \qquad t_s \approx \frac{4}{\zeta\omega_n} \ (2\%\text{ band}) \qquad t_r \approx \frac{1.8}{\omega_n} t p = ω d π t s ≈ ζ ω n 4 ( 2% band ) t r ≈ ω n 1.8
Percent overshoot depends on ζ \zeta ζ alone , not on ω n \omega_n ω n . Common values worth memorising: ζ = 0.5 \zeta = 0.5 ζ = 0.5 gives 16.3% overshoot, ζ = 0.707 \zeta = 0.707 ζ = 0.707 gives 4.3%, and ζ = 0.8 \zeta = 0.8 ζ = 0.8 gives 1.5%.
4. Steady-State Error and System Type
System type is the number of pure integrators ( 1 / s 1/s 1/ s terms) in the open-loop transfer function.
- Type Step input Ramp input Parabolic input
- 0 e s s = 1 1 + K p e_{ss} = \dfrac{1}{1+K_p} e ss = 1 + K p 1 Infinite Infinite
- 1 Zero e s s = 1 K v e_{ss} = \dfrac{1}{K_v} e ss = K v 1 Infinite
2 Zero Zero e s s = 1 K a e_{ss} = \dfrac{1}{K_a} e ss = K a 1 K p = lim s → 0 G ( s ) H ( s ) , K v = lim s → 0 s G ( s ) H ( s ) , K a = lim s → 0 s 2 G ( s ) H ( s ) K_p = \lim_{s\to 0}G(s)H(s), \quad K_v = \lim_{s\to 0}sG(s)H(s), \quad K_a = \lim_{s\to 0}s^{2}G(s)H(s) K p = s → 0 lim G ( s ) H ( s ) , K v = s → 0 lim s G ( s ) H ( s ) , K a = s → 0 lim s 2 G ( s ) H ( s )
Adding an integrator removes steady-state error to that input class but adds 90° of phase lag, eroding stability margin. That trade-off is the entire reason PID exists.
- 5. Stability Analysis
- Routh-Hurwitz Criterion
Build the Routh array from the characteristic polynomial coefficients. The number of right-half-plane roots equals the number of sign changes in the first column ; the system is stable only if there are none.
Two necessary conditions can be checked by inspection before building the array: all coefficients must be present and all must have the same sign . A missing or negative coefficient proves instability immediately, with no array required.
Root Locus
Plots closed-loop pole paths as gain K K K varies from 0 to infinity. The locus starts at the open-loop poles and ends at the open-loop zeros or at infinity, and any branch crossing into the right half plane marks the gain at which the system goes unstable.
Frequency Response
- Margin Definition Healthy design value
- Gain margin Additional gain in dB tolerable before instability, read where phase = −180° 6–12 dB
- Phase margin Additional phase lag tolerable, read where gain = 0 dB 30°–60°
The Nyquist criterion relates encirclements of the −1 point to right-half-plane poles. On a Bode plot, a system is stable when the gain crosses 0 dB before the phase reaches −180°, and phase margin correlates with damping — roughly ζ ≈ P M / 100 \zeta \approx PM/100 ζ ≈ PM /100 for a well-behaved second-order system.
6. PID Control ν ( t ) = K p e ( t ) + K i ∫ e ( t ) d t + K d d e ( t ) d t ⟹ G c ( s ) = K p + K i s + K d s \nu(t) = K_p e(t) + K_i\int e(t)\,dt + K_d\frac{de(t)}{dt} \qquad \Longrightarrow \qquad G_c(s) = K_p + \frac{K_i}{s} + K_d s ν ( t ) = K p e ( t ) + K i ∫ e ( t ) d t + K d d t d e ( t ) ⟹ G c ( s ) = K p + s K i + K d s
- Action Rise time Overshoot Settling time Steady-state error Stability
- Increase K p K_p K p Decreases Increases Small change Decreases but never zero Degrades
- Increase K i K_i K i Decreases Increases Increases Eliminates Degrades
- Increase K d K_d K d Small change Decreases Decreases No effect Improves
Proportional-only control always leaves an offset — this is the classic examination point. Integral action removes it but adds phase lag and can cause integral windup when the actuator saturates, which is why practical controllers clamp the integrator. Derivative action improves damping but amplifies measurement noise, so it is filtered or omitted on noisy loops such as flow control.
Ziegler-Nichols ultimate-cycle tuning: increase K p K_p K p until sustained oscillation begins at ultimate gain K u K_u K u and period T u T_u T u , then set K p = 0.6 K u K_p = 0.6K_u K p = 0.6 K u , T i = 0.5 T u T_i = 0.5T_u T i = 0.5 T u , T d = 0.125 T u T_d = 0.125T_u T d = 0.125 T u for a PID controller.
7. Research Methods
The same TOS topic names Research Methods , reflecting the capstone design and research project required by CHED Memorandum Order No. 88, s. 2017.
- Concept Meaning
- Research problem and objectives The gap addressed and the specific measurable aims
- Review of related literature Establishes what is known and locates the gap
- Independent vs. dependent variable What is manipulated versus what is measured
- Conceptual / theoretical framework The model relating the variables
- Quantitative vs. qualitative design Numerical measurement versus interpretive inquiry
- Experimental vs. descriptive Manipulation with a control group versus observation without
Population and sampling Probability sampling (random, stratified, systematic, cluster) versus non-probability (purposive, convenience)
- Validity vs. reliability Measures the right thing versus measures consistently
- Null hypothesis and significance level Tested with the inferential statistics of the Mathematics subject
- IMRaD structure Introduction, Methods, Results and Discussion
- Citation and plagiarism Attribution obligations under the Revised Code of Ethics, Article II
An engineering capstone or technical report is judged on the same criteria the PRC applies to a Professional Electrical Engineer technical report: clarity of the problem, soundness of method, defensibility of results and originality of contribution.
- Solved Board Exam Examples
- Example 1: Closed-Loop Transfer Function
A unity-feedback system has forward transfer function G ( s ) = 10 s ( s + 4 ) G(s) = \dfrac{10}{s(s+4)} G ( s ) = s ( s + 4 ) 10 . Find the closed-loop transfer function, ω n \omega_n ω n , ζ \zeta ζ and the percent overshoot.
Solution. C R = G 1 + G = 10 / [ s ( s + 4 ) ] 1 + 10 / [ s ( s + 4 ) ] = 10 s 2 + 4 s + 10 \frac{C}{R} = \frac{G}{1+G} = \frac{10/[s(s+4)]}{1 + 10/[s(s+4)]} = \frac{10}{s^{2} + 4s + 10} R C = 1 + G G = 1 + 10/ [ s ( s + 4 )] 10/ [ s ( s + 4 )] = s 2 + 4 s + 10 10
Comparing with the standard form ω n 2 / ( s 2 + 2 ζ ω n s + ω n 2 ) \omega_n^{2}/(s^{2}+2\zeta\omega_n s + \omega_n^{2}) ω n 2 / ( s 2 + 2 ζ ω n s + ω n 2 ) : ω n = 10 = 3.162 rad/s , 2 ζ ω n = 4 ⟹ ζ = 4 2 ( 3.162 ) = 0.632 \omega_n = \sqrt{10} = 3.162 \text{ rad/s}, \qquad 2\zeta\omega_n = 4 \implies \zeta = \frac{4}{2(3.162)} = \boxed{0.632} ω n = 10 = 3.162 rad/s , 2 ζ ω n = 4 ⟹ ζ = 2 ( 3.162 ) 4 = 0.632 % O S = 100 e − π ( 0.632 ) / 1 − 0.632 2 = 100 e − 1.9855 / 0.7749 = 100 e − 2.5623 = 7.71 % \%OS = 100\,e^{-\pi(0.632)/\sqrt{1-0.632^{2}}} = 100\,e^{-1.9855/0.7749} = 100\,e^{-2.5623} = \boxed{7.71\%} % OS = 100 e − π ( 0.632 ) / 1 − 0.63 2 2 = 100 e − 1.9855/0.7749 = 100 e − 2.5623 = 7.71%
Settling time is t s ≈ 4 / ( ζ ω n ) = 4 / 2.0 = 2.0 t_s \approx 4/(\zeta\omega_n) = 4/2.0 = 2.0 t s ≈ 4/ ( ζ ω n ) = 4/2.0 = 2.0 s.
Example 2: Routh-Hurwitz Stability Limit
For what range of K K K is the system with characteristic equation s 3 + 6 s 2 + 11 s + K = 0 s^{3} + 6s^{2} + 11s + K = 0 s 3 + 6 s 2 + 11 s + K = 0 stable?
Solution. Building the Routh array: s 3 1 11 s 2 6 K s 1 66 − K 6 0 s 0 K \begin{array}{c|cc} s^{3} & 1 & 11 \\ s^{2} & 6 & K \\ s^{1} & \dfrac{66-K}{6} & 0 \\ s^{0} & K & \end{array} s 3 s 2 s 1 s 0 1 6 6 66 − K K 11 K 0
Stability requires no sign change in the first column, so both 66 − K 6 > 0 \dfrac{66-K}{6} > 0 6 66 − K > 0 and K > 0 K > 0 K > 0 : 0 < K < 66 \boxed{0 < K < 66} 0 < K < 66
At exactly K = 66 K = 66 K = 66 the s 1 s^1 s 1 row vanishes and the system sustains oscillation at ω = 11 = 3.317 \omega = \sqrt{11} = 3.317 ω = 11 = 3.317 rad/s — the ultimate gain and frequency a Ziegler-Nichols tuning procedure would find experimentally.
Example 3: Steady-State Error and Controller Choice
A Type 0 system with G ( s ) H ( s ) = 20 ( s + 2 ) ( s + 5 ) G(s)H(s) = \dfrac{20}{(s+2)(s+5)} G ( s ) H ( s ) = ( s + 2 ) ( s + 5 ) 20 is subjected to a unit step. Find the steady-state error, and state what controller action removes it.
Solution. K p = lim s → 0 20 ( s + 2 ) ( s + 5 ) = 20 10 = 2.0 K_p = \lim_{s\to 0}\frac{20}{(s+2)(s+5)} = \frac{20}{10} = 2.0 K p = s → 0 lim ( s + 2 ) ( s + 5 ) 20 = 10 20 = 2.0 ≠ s s = 1 1 + K p = 1 3 = 0.333 or 33.3 % \ne_{ss} = \frac{1}{1+K_p} = \frac{1}{3} = \boxed{0.333 \text{ or } 33.3\%} = ss = 1 + K p 1 = 3 1 = 0.333 or 33.3%
Raising the proportional gain reduces this offset but can never eliminate it, because e s s → 0 e_{ss} \to 0 e ss → 0 only as K p → ∞ K_p \to \infty K p → ∞ . Adding integral action makes the system Type 1 and drives the step-input steady-state error to exactly zero, at the cost of 90° of added phase lag that must be paid for with reduced gain or added derivative action.