Study guide
8.3 Mechanical Testing, Fatigue Failure & Fracture Mechanics
PRC Mechanical Engineer Licensure Examination MELE
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Licensing Overview, Law & Professional Ethics
1.1 MELE Facts, RA 8495 & Board Organization 1.2 Code of Ethics for Mechanical Engineers & Professional Practice 1.3 Philippine Mechanical Engineering Code (PME Code) Governance & Legal Mandates
2 Chapter 2: Advanced Mathematics & Engineering Statistics
2.1 Differential & Integral Calculus in Engineering Applications 2.2 Differential Equations & Mathematical Modeling 2.3 Applied Engineering Statistics & Quality Control Probability
3 Chapter 3: Engineering Thermodynamics
3.1 Thermodynamic State Postulate, Properties & P-V-T Equations of State 3.2 First Law Analysis for Open & Closed Thermal Systems 3.3 Second Law, Entropy, Exergy & Reversibility Analysis
4 Chapter 4: Fluid Mechanics & Hydraulic Engineering
4.1 Fluid Statics, Manometry, Hydrostatic Force & Buoyancy 4.2 Fluid Kinematics, Dynamics & Bernoulli Equation 4.3 Pipe Flow, Friction Losses & Piping Network Analysis
5 Chapter 5: Heat Transfer & Thermal Systems
5.1 Conduction Heat Transfer & Thermal Insulation Design 5.2 Natural & Forced Convection Heat Transfer Correlations 5.3 Thermal Radiation & Industrial Heat Exchanger Design
6 Chapter 6: Mechanics & Strength of Materials
6.1 Statics & Dynamics of Rigid Bodies & Engineering Linkages 6.2 Normal, Shear & Triaxial Stress-Strain Relationships 6.3 Bending Stresses, Torsion & Column Buckling Analysis
7 Chapter 7: Engineering Economics & Financial Analysis
7.1 Time Value of Money & Cash Flow Equivalence Formulas 7.2 Asset Depreciation, Taxation & Economic Evaluation Methods 7.3 Break-Even Analysis, Payback Period & EOQ Inventory Models
8 Chapter 8: Engineering Materials & Metallurgy
8.1 Ferrous & Non-Ferrous Metals, Alloys & Polymers 8.2 Phase Diagrams, Iron-Carbon System & Heat Treatment 8.3 Mechanical Testing, Fatigue Failure & Fracture Mechanics
9 Chapter 9: Machine Elements & Stress Analysis
9.1 Failure Theories, Static & Fluctuating Stress Design 9.2 Power Transmission Shafts, Keys & Rigid/Flexible Couplings 9.3 Spur, Helical, Bevel & Worm Gear Design Calculations
10 Chapter 10: Power Transmission Components
10.1 Belts, V-Belts, Chains, Wire Ropes & Flywheels 10.2 Rolling Element & Hydrodynamic Journal Bearings 10.3 Mechanical Springs, Clutches & Industrial Brakes
11 Chapter 11: Manufacturing, Fasteners & GD&T
11.1 Threaded Fasteners, Rivets & Welded Joint Analysis 11.2 Manufacturing Processes, Machine Tools & Machining Calculations 11.3 Engineering Drawing, Limits, Fits, Tolerances & GD&T
12 Chapter 12: Power Plants, Boilers & Thermal Power Cycles
12.1 Steam Power Plants & Rankine Cycles 12.2 Steam Generators, Boilers & Combustion Engineering 12.3 Internal Combustion Engines: SI & CI Cycles 12.4 Gas Turbine Power Plants & Combined Cycles
13 Chapter 13: Renewable Energy, Fluid Machinery & Plant Systems
13.1 Hydroelectric, Geothermal & Renewable Energy Power Plants 13.2 Pumps & Hydraulic Machinery 13.3 Air Compressors, Fans & Blowers
14 Chapter 14: Refrigeration, HVAC & Building Mechanical Systems
14.1 Refrigeration Systems, Cycles & Refrigerants 14.2 Psychrometrics & Air Conditioning Systems 14.3 Piping/Ductwork Design, PME Code & Industrial Safety Management
8.3 Mechanical Testing, Fatigue Failure & Fracture Mechanics
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Brinell hardness number ( H B HB H B ) relates empirically to the ultimate tensile strength ( S u S_u S u ) of carbon steels: S u ( MPa ) ≈ 3.45 × H B S_u (\text{MPa}) \approx 3.45 \times HB S u ( MPa ) ≈ 3.45 × H B or S u ( psi ) ≈ 500 × H B S_u (\text{psi}) \approx 500 \times HB S u ( psi ) ≈ 500 × H B .
The Marin equation modifies endurance limit for real-world components: S e = k a k b k c k d k e k f S e ′ S_e = k_a k_b k_c k_d k_e k_f S'_e S e = k a k b k c k d k e k f S e ′ .
Goodman and Soderberg fatigue failure criteria account for mean stress ( σ m \sigma_m σ m ): Goodman uses S u S_u S u ( σ a S e + σ m S u = 1 n \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_u} = \frac{1}{n} S e σ a + S u σ m = n 1 ), whereas Soderberg conservatively uses yield strength S y S_y S y ( σ a S e + σ m S y = 1 n \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_y} = \frac{1}{n} S e σ a + S y σ m = n 1 ).
Impact testing evaluates Ductile-to-Brittle Transition Temperature (DBTT); BCC metals (carbon steels) become brittle at low temperatures, whereas FCC metals (austenitic stainless steels) retain cryogenic toughness.
Fracture mechanics evaluates brittle catastrophic failure via stress intensity factor K I = Y σ π a K_I = Y \sigma \sqrt{\pi a} K I = Yσ πa ; unstable fracture occurs when K I ≥ K I c K_I \ge K_{Ic} K I ≥ K I c (plane strain fracture toughness).
Last updated: July 2026
8.3 Mechanical Testing, Fatigue Failure & Fracture Mechanics
PRC MELE Core Focus: Mechanical testing and component failure evaluation are mandatory competence areas for mechanical engineers. Board exam problems test standardized tensile test calculations, hardness scale conversions, Charpy impact dynamics, DBTT behavior, fatigue life modeling using Marin factors, fluctuating stress criteria (Goodman, Soderberg, Gerber, ASME-elliptic), and linear elastic fracture mechanics ( K I , K I c K_I, K_{Ic} K I , K I c ).
1. Tensile Testing & Property Calculations (ASTM E8)
The standard tensile test measures the deformation response of a material under uniaxial tensile loading.
Key Engineering & True Relationships
Engineering Stress ( σ \sigma σ ) & Engineering Strain ( ϵ \epsilon ϵ ): σ = F A 0 , ϵ = Δ L L 0 = L − L 0 L 0 \sigma = \frac{F}{A_0}, \quad \epsilon = \frac{\Delta L}{L_0} = \frac{L - L_0}{L_0} σ = A 0 F , ϵ = L 0 Δ L = L 0 L − L 0
True Stress ( σ true \sigma_{\text{true}} σ true ) & True Strain ( ϵ true \epsilon_{\text{true}} ϵ true ): Assuming constant specimen volume ( A L = A 0 L 0 A L = A_0 L_0 A L = A 0 L 0 ): σ true = σ ( 1 + ϵ ) \sigma_{\text{true}} = \sigma (1 + \epsilon) σ true = σ ( 1 + ϵ ) ϵ true = ln ( L L 0 ) = ln ( 1 + ϵ ) \epsilon_{\text{true}} = \ln\left(\frac{L}{L_0}\right) = \ln(1 + \epsilon) ϵ true = ln ( L 0 L ) = ln ( 1 + ϵ )
Hooke's Law & Modulus of Elasticity ( E E E ): σ = E ⋅ ϵ ( in elastic region, σ ≤ S y ) \sigma = E \cdot \epsilon \quad (\text{in elastic region, } \sigma \le S_y) σ = E ⋅ ϵ ( in elastic region, σ ≤ S y )
Ductility Measures: % EL = L f − L 0 L 0 × 100 % , % RA = A 0 − A f A 0 × 100 % \% \text{EL} = \frac{L_f - L_0}{L_0} \times 100\%, \quad \% \text{RA} = \frac{A_0 - A_f}{A_0} \times 100\% % EL = L 0 L f − L 0 × 100% , % RA = A 0 A 0 − A f × 100%
Modulus of Resilience ( U r U_r U r ) & Modulus of Toughness ( U t U_t U t ): U r = S y 2 2 E ( Elastic strain energy density to yield ) U_r = \frac{S_y^2}{2E} \quad (\text{Elastic strain energy density to yield}) U r = 2 E S y 2 ( Elastic strain energy density to yield ) U t ≈ ( S y + S u 2 ) ⋅ ϵ f ( Total work per unit volume to fracture ) U_t \approx \left(\frac{S_y + S_u}{2}\right) \cdot \epsilon_f \quad (\text{Total work per unit volume to fracture}) U t ≈ ( 2 S y + S u ) ⋅ ϵ f ( Total work per unit volume to fracture )
2. Hardness Testing Standards & Approximations
Hardness measures a material's localized resistance to plastic deformation by indentation.
Hardness Test Indenter Geometry Applied Load Hardness Formula / Scale Key Applications & Conversion Notes
Brinell (HB) 10 mm 10\text{ mm} 10 mm hardened steel or carbide ball 3000 kgf 3000\text{ kgf} 3000 kgf H B = 2 P π D ( D − D 2 − d 2 ) HB = \frac{2P}{\pi D \left(D - \sqrt{D^2 - d^2}\right)} H B = π D ( D − D 2 − d 2 ) 2 P Cast irons, heavy forgings, raw stock. Impression diameter d d d measured by optical microscope.
Rockwell (HRC) 120 ∘ 120^\circ 12 0 ∘ Diamond Brale Cone 150 kgf 150\text{ kgf} 150 kgf H R C = 100 − e HRC = 100 - e H RC = 100 − e (depth increment) Quenched and tempered steels, high-strength alloys ( 20 − 70 HRC 20 - 70\text{ HRC} 20 − 70 HRC ).
Rockwell (HRB) 1 / 16 inch 1/16\text{ inch} 1/16 inch ( 1.588 mm 1.588\text{ mm} 1.588 mm ) steel ball 100 kgf 100\text{ kgf} 100 kgf H R B = 130 − e HRB = 130 - e H RB = 130 − e Soft steels, brass, aluminum, copper ( 0 − 100 HRB 0 - 100\text{ HRB} 0 − 100 HRB ).
Vickers (HV) 136 ∘ 136^\circ 13 6 ∘ Diamond Square Pyramid 1 − 120 kgf 1 - 120\text{ kgf} 1 − 120 kgf H V = 1.8544 P d 2 HV = 1.8544 \frac{P}{d^2} H V = 1.8544 d 2 P Microstructural phases, thin cases, weld cross-sections.
Knoop (HK) Elongated Diamond Pyramid 10 − 1000 gf 10 - 1000\text{ gf} 10 − 1000 gf H K = 14.229 P l 2 HK = 14.229 \frac{P}{l^2} HK = 14.229 l 2 P Microhardness, brittle ceramics, surface plating layers.
Ultimate Tensile Strength ( S u S_u S u ) Estimation for Carbon Steels
In MELE calculations, empirical equations estimate UTS directly from Brinell Hardness ( H B HB H B ): S u ( MPa ) ≈ 3.45 × H B S_u (\text{MPa}) \approx 3.45 \times HB S u ( MPa ) ≈ 3.45 × H B S u ( psi ) ≈ 500 × H B S_u (\text{psi}) \approx 500 \times HB S u ( psi ) ≈ 500 × H B
3. Impact Testing & Transition Temperature (DBTT)
Impact testing evaluates material behavior under high strain rates and triaxial stress states.
Charpy V-Notch Test (ASTM E23): A standard bar ( 10 × 10 × 55 mm 10\times10\times55\text{ mm} 10 × 10 × 55 mm ) with a 2 mm 2\text{ mm} 2 mm deep 45 ∘ 45^\circ 4 5 ∘ V-notch is supported as a simple beam and struck behind the notch by a swinging pendulum mass m m m . Impact energy absorbed is: E impact = m g ( h − h ′ ) ( in Joules or ft-lbf ) E_{\text{impact}} = m g (h - h') \quad (\text{in Joules or ft-lbf}) E impact = m g ( h − h ′ ) ( in Joules or ft-lbf )
Izod Test: The specimen is clamped vertically as a cantilever beam and struck on the notched face.
Ductile-to-Brittle Transition Temperature (DBTT):
BCC Metals (e.g., Carbon Steels): Experience a sharp drop in impact energy absorption at lower temperatures (transitioning from ductile shear fracture to brittle cleavage).
FCC Metals (e.g., 304 Stainless Steel, Aluminum, Copper): Retain high energy absorption down to cryogenic temperatures (no DBTT).
Failure Case: Historical ship hull failures (e.g., Liberty ships in WWII) occurred when operating below the DBTT of structural steel.
4. Fatigue Testing & S-N Curves
Fatigue causes over 80-90% of operational mechanical component failures under cyclic stress levels well below the static yield strength.
S-N Curve & Endurance Limit
Rotating Beam Test (ASTM E466): Determines stress amplitude ( S S S ) vs. number of cycles to failure ( N N N ).
Unworked Endurance Limit ( S e ′ S'_e S e ′ ): For plain carbon and alloy steels ( N ≥ 10 6 cycles N \ge 10^6 \text{ cycles} N ≥ 1 0 6 cycles ): S e ′ = { 0.50 S u & for S u ≤ 1400 MPa ( 200 ksi ) 700 MPa ( 100 ksi ) & for S u > 1400 MPa ( 200 ksi ) S'_e = \begin{cases} 0.50 S_u \& \text{for } S_u \le 1400\text{ MPa } (200\text{ ksi}) \\ 700\text{ MPa } (100\text{ ksi}) \& \text{for } S_u > 1400\text{ MPa } (200\text{ ksi}) \end{cases} S e ′ = { 0.50 S u & for S u ≤ 1400 MPa ( 200 ksi ) 700 MPa ( 100 ksi ) & for S u > 1400 MPa ( 200 ksi )
For non-ferrous alloys (aluminum, copper), no true endurance limit exists; fatigue strength S N S_N S N is reported at a specified life (e.g., N = 5 × 10 8 cycles N = 5 \times 10^8 \text{ cycles} N = 5 × 1 0 8 cycles ).
Marin Modification Factors
The fully corrected endurance limit S e S_e S e for a real mechanical component is: S e = k a ⋅ k b ⋅ k c ⋅ k d ⋅ k e ⋅ k f ⋅ S e ′ S_e = k_a \cdot k_b \cdot k_c \cdot k_d \cdot k_e \cdot k_f \cdot S'_e S e = k a ⋅ k b ⋅ k c ⋅ k d ⋅ k e ⋅ k f ⋅ S e ′
where:
k a k_a k a (Surface Factor): k a = a S u b k_a = a S_u^b k a = a S u b (Ground: a = 1.58 , b = − 0.085 a=1.58, b=-0.085 a = 1.58 , b = − 0.085 ; Machined/Cold-drawn: a = 4.51 , b = − 0.265 a=4.51, b=-0.265 a = 4.51 , b = − 0.265 ; Hot-rolled: a = 57.7 , b = − 0.718 a=57.7, b=-0.718 a = 57.7 , b = − 0.718 ; As-forged: a = 272 , b = − 0.995 a=272, b=-0.995 a = 272 , b = − 0.995 for S u S_u S u in MPa).
k b k_b k b (Size Factor): For rotating/bending shafts ( d d d in mm): k b = { 1.24 d − 0.107 & for 2.79 ≤ d ≤ 51 mm 1.51 d − 0.157 & for 51 < d ≤ 254 mm k_b = \begin{cases} 1.24 d^{-0.107} \& \text{for } 2.79 \le d \le 51\text{ mm} \\ 1.51 d^{-0.157} \& \text{for } 51 < d \le 254\text{ mm} \end{cases} k b = { 1.24 d − 0.107 & for 2.79 ≤ d ≤ 51 mm 1.51 d − 0.157 & for 51 < d ≤ 254 mm
k c k_c k c (Load Factor): k c = 1.0 k_c = 1.0 k c = 1.0 for bending, k c = 0.85 k_c = 0.85 k c = 0.85 for axial load, k c = 0.59 k_c = 0.59 k c = 0.59 for pure torsion/shear.
k d k_d k d (Temperature Factor): k d = 1.0 k_d = 1.0 k d = 1.0 for T ≤ 450 ∘ C T \le 450^\circ\text{C} T ≤ 45 0 ∘ C .
k e k_e k e (Reliability Factor): 90 % ⟹ 0.897 90\% \implies 0.897 90% ⟹ 0.897 ; 95 % ⟹ 0.868 95\% \implies 0.868 95% ⟹ 0.868 ; 99 % ⟹ 0.814 99\% \implies 0.814 99% ⟹ 0.814 ; 99.9 % ⟹ 0.753 99.9\% \implies 0.753 99.9% ⟹ 0.753 .
k f k_f k f (Miscellaneous Factor): Accounts for corrosion, residual stress, fretting, plating.
5. Fatigue Failure Criteria for Fluctuating Stress
When cyclic loading involves a non-zero mean stress ( σ m \sigma_m σ m ):
Fluctuating Stress Components σ a = ∣ σ max − σ min 2 ∣ ( Alternating Stress ) \sigma_a = \left|\frac{\sigma_{\text{max}} - \sigma_{\text{min}}}{2}\right| \quad (\text{Alternating Stress}) σ a = 2 σ max − σ min ( Alternating Stress ) σ m = σ max + σ min 2 ( Mean Stress ) \sigma_m = \frac{\sigma_{\text{max}} + \sigma_{\text{min}}}{2} \quad (\text{Mean Stress}) σ m = 2 σ max + σ min ( Mean Stress ) Stress Ratio R = σ min σ max , Amplitude Ratio A = σ a σ m \text{Stress Ratio } R = \frac{\sigma_{\text{min}}}{\sigma_{\text{max}}}, \quad \text{Amplitude Ratio } A = \frac{\sigma_a}{\sigma_m} Stress Ratio R = σ max σ min , Amplitude Ratio A = σ m σ a
Design Equations (Factor of Safety n n n )
Modified Goodman Line: σ a S e + σ m S u = 1 n \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_u} = \frac{1}{n} S e σ a + S u σ m = n 1
Soderberg Line (Most Conservative): σ a S e + σ m S y = 1 n \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_y} = \frac{1}{n} S e σ a + S y σ m = n 1
Gerber Parabola (Best fit to experimental data): σ a S e + ( σ m S u ) 2 = 1 n \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \left(\frac{\sigma_m}{S_u}\right)^2 = \frac{1}{n} S e σ a + ( S u σ m ) 2 = n 1
ASME Elliptic Criterion: ( σ a S e ) 2 + ( σ m S y ) 2 = 1 n 2 \left(\frac{\sigma_a}{S_e}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{\sigma_m}{S_y}\right)^2 = \frac{1}{n^2} ( S e σ a ) 2 + ( S y σ m ) 2 = n 2 1
Palmgren-Miner Linear Damage Rule
For multi-stress level cumulative fatigue: D = ∑ i = 1 k n i N i = n 1 N 1 + n 2 N 2 + ⋯ + n k N k ≤ 1.0 D = \sum_{i=1}^{k} \frac{n_i}{N_i} = \frac{n_1}{N_1} + \frac{n_2}{N_2} + \dots + \frac{n_k}{N_k} \le 1.0 D = i = 1 ∑ k N i n i = N 1 n 1 + N 2 n 2 + ⋯ + N k n k ≤ 1.0
where n i n_i n i is applied cycles at stress σ i \sigma_i σ i , and N i N_i N i is fatigue life at σ i \sigma_i σ i . Failure occurs when cumulative damage D = 1.0 D = 1.0 D = 1.0 .
6. Linear Elastic Fracture Mechanics (LEFM)
LEFM analyzes components containing pre-existing microcracks or flaws under load.
Stress Intensity Factor ( K I K_I K I )
Mode I (Opening Mode) stress field near a crack tip: K I = Y ⋅ σ ⋅ π a K_I = Y \cdot \sigma \cdot \sqrt{\pi a} K I = Y ⋅ σ ⋅ πa
where:
K I K_I K I = Stress intensity factor ( MPa ⋅ m \text{MPa}\cdot\sqrt{\text{m}} MPa ⋅ m or ksi ⋅ in \text{ksi}\cdot\sqrt{\text{in}} ksi ⋅ in ).
Y Y Y = Dimensionless geometry correction factor ( Y = 1.0 Y = 1.0 Y = 1.0 for an internal crack of length 2 a 2a 2 a in an infinite plate; Y = 1.12 Y = 1.12 Y = 1.12 for an edge crack of length a a a ).
σ \sigma σ = Nominal applied tensile stress.
a a a = Crack length (for edge crack) or half-length (for internal crack).
- Fracture Criterion & Plane Strain Fracture Toughness ( K I c K_{Ic} K I c )
- Brittle catastrophic failure occurs when: K I ≥ K I c K_I \ge K_{Ic} K I ≥ K I c
where K I c K_{Ic} K I c is the critical plane strain fracture toughness (a fundamental material property measured per ASTM E399).
Critical Crack Size ( a c a_c a c ) & Allowable Stress ( σ c \sigma_c σ c ) a c = 1 π ( K I c Y ⋅ σ ) 2 , σ c = K I c Y π a a_c = \frac{1}{\pi} \left(\frac{K_{Ic}}{Y \cdot \sigma}\right)^2, \quad \sigma_c = \frac{K_{Ic}}{Y \sqrt{\pi a}} a c = π 1 ( Y ⋅ σ K I c ) 2 , σ c = Y πa K I c
Griffith Theory of Brittle Fracture
For ideal brittle solids (glass, ceramics), crack propagation stress is: σ f = 2 E γ s π a \sigma_f = \sqrt{\frac{2 E \gamma_s}{\pi a}} σ f = πa 2 E γ s
where γ s \gamma_s γ s is specific surface energy. Orowan modified this for metals by incorporating plastic work energy γ p \gamma_p γ p : σ f = 2 E ( γ s + γ p ) π a \sigma_f = \sqrt{\frac{2 E (\gamma_s + \gamma_p)}{\pi a}} σ f = πa 2 E ( γ s + γ p )
- 7. Worked Engineering Calculations
- Calculation 1: Fatigue Safety Factor (Goodman vs. Soderberg)
Problem: A machine shaft manufactured from AISI 1045 cold-drawn steel ( S u = 600 MPa , S y = 420 MPa S_u = 600\text{ MPa}, S_y = 420\text{ MPa} S u = 600 MPa , S y = 420 MPa ) operates under a fluctuating axial load producing σ max = 250 MPa \sigma_{\text{max}} = 250\text{ MPa} σ max = 250 MPa and σ min = − 50 MPa \sigma_{\text{min}} = -50\text{ MPa} σ min = − 50 MPa . The fully corrected endurance limit is S e = 200 MPa S_e = 200\text{ MPa} S e = 200 MPa .
Calculate the factor of safety n n n using:
The Modified Goodman criterion.
The Soderberg criterion.
Solution:
Compute mean stress ( σ m \sigma_m σ m ) and alternating stress ( σ a \sigma_a σ a ): σ m = σ max + σ min 2 = 250 + ( − 50 ) 2 = 100 MPa \sigma_m = \frac{\sigma_{\text{max}} + \sigma_{\text{min}}}{2} = \frac{250 + (-50)}{2} = 100\text{ MPa} σ m = 2 σ max + σ min = 2 250 + ( − 50 ) = 100 MPa σ a = σ max − σ min 2 = 250 − ( − 50 ) 2 = 150 MPa \sigma_a = \frac{\sigma_{\text{max}} - \sigma_{\text{min}}}{2} = \frac{250 - (-50)}{2} = 150\text{ MPa} σ a = 2 σ max − σ min = 2 250 − ( − 50 ) = 150 MPa
Modified Goodman Factor of Safety: σ a S e + σ m S u = 1 n G ⟹ 150 200 + 100 600 = 1 n G \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_u} = \frac{1}{n_G} \implies \frac{150}{200} + \frac{100}{600} = \frac{1}{n_G} S e σ a + S u σ m = n G 1 ⟹ 200 150 + 600 100 = n G 1 0.750 + 0.1667 = 0.9167 = 1 n G ⟹ n G = 1 0.9167 = 1.0909 ≈ 1.09 0.750 + 0.1667 = 0.9167 = \frac{1}{n_G} \implies n_G = \frac{1}{0.9167} = 1.0909 \approx 1.09 0.750 + 0.1667 = 0.9167 = n G 1 ⟹ n G = 0.9167 1 = 1.0909 ≈ 1.09
Soderberg Factor of Safety: σ a S e + σ m S y = 1 n S ⟹ 150 200 + 100 420 = 1 n S \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_y} = \frac{1}{n_S} \implies \frac{150}{200} + \frac{100}{420} = \frac{1}{n_S} S e σ a + S y σ m = n S 1 ⟹ 200 150 + 420 100 = n S 1 0.750 + 0.2381 = 0.9881 = 1 n S ⟹ n S = 1 0.9881 = 1.0120 ≈ 1.01 0.750 + 0.2381 = 0.9881 = \frac{1}{n_S} \implies n_S = \frac{1}{0.9881} = 1.0120 \approx 1.01 0.750 + 0.2381 = 0.9881 = n S 1 ⟹ n S = 0.9881 1 = 1.0120 ≈ 1.01
Calculation 2: Critical Crack Size Determination
Problem: An alloy steel pressure vessel wall ( K I c = 65 MPa ⋅ m K_{Ic} = 65\text{ MPa}\cdot\sqrt{\text{m}} K I c = 65 MPa ⋅ m ) is subjected to a nominal hoop tensile stress σ = 320 MPa \sigma = 320\text{ MPa} σ = 320 MPa . Non-destructive ultrasonic inspection can reliably detect internal cracks with total length 2 a ≥ 8.0 mm 2a \ge 8.0\text{ mm} 2 a ≥ 8.0 mm . Assuming Y = 1.0 Y = 1.0 Y = 1.0 :
Calculate the critical internal crack half-length a c a_c a c and total length 2 a c 2a_c 2 a c .
Determine if the ultrasonic NDT system is adequate to prevent catastrophic fracture.
Solution:
Apply LEFM fracture formula: K I c = Y σ π a c ⟹ 65 = ( 1.0 ) ( 320 ) π a c K_{Ic} = Y \sigma \sqrt{\pi a_c} \implies 65 = (1.0)(320) \sqrt{\pi a_c} K I c = Yσ π a c ⟹ 65 = ( 1.0 ) ( 320 ) π a c π a c = 65 320 = 0.203125 \sqrt{\pi a_c} = \frac{65}{320} = 0.203125 π a c = 320 65 = 0.203125 π a c = ( 0.203125 ) 2 = 0.041260 m \pi a_c = (0.203125)^2 = 0.041260\text{ m} π a c = ( 0.203125 ) 2 = 0.041260 m a c = 0.041260 π = 0.013133 m = 13.13 mm a_c = \frac{0.041260}{\pi} = 0.013133\text{ m} = 13.13\text{ mm} a c = π 0.041260 = 0.013133 m = 13.13 mm
Total critical internal crack length 2 a c = 2 × 13.13 mm = 26.26 mm 2a_c = 2 \times 13.13\text{ mm} = 26.26\text{ mm} 2 a c = 2 × 13.13 mm = 26.26 mm .
Since the NDT resolution ( 8.0 mm 8.0\text{ mm} 8.0 mm ) is well below the critical crack length ( 26.26 mm 26.26\text{ mm} 26.26 mm ), the inspection system will reliably detect dangerous flaws before catastrophic fracture occurs ( 8.0 mm < 26.26 mm 8.0\text{ mm} < 26.26\text{ mm} 8.0 mm < 26.26 mm ).
8. MELE Exam Tips
Tip
Standard Tensile Equations: σ true = σ ( 1 + ϵ ) \sigma_{\text{true}} = \sigma(1+\epsilon) σ true = σ ( 1 + ϵ ) and ϵ true = ln ( 1 + ϵ ) \epsilon_{\text{true}} = \ln(1+\epsilon) ϵ true = ln ( 1 + ϵ ) apply only up to necking ( ϵ ≤ ϵ u \epsilon \le \epsilon_u ϵ ≤ ϵ u ).
Endurance Limit Shortcut: For steel, unworked S e ′ ≈ 0.5 S u S'_e \approx 0.5 S_u S e ′ ≈ 0.5 S u when S u ≤ 1400 MPa S_u \le 1400\text{ MPa} S u ≤ 1400 MPa ( 200 ksi 200\text{ ksi} 200 ksi ).
Fatigue Line Hierarchy: Soderberg is the most conservative (uses S y S_y S y ), Goodman is standard design practice (uses S u S_u S u ), Gerber is best empirical fit (parabolic).
Internal vs Edge Cracks: For an internal crack of total length L L L , a = L / 2 a = L/2 a = L /2 . For an edge crack of depth d d d , a = d a = d a = d .