Study guide

9.1 Failure Theories, Static & Fluctuating Stress Design

PRC Mechanical Engineer Licensure Examination MELE

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Licensing Overview, Law & Professional Ethics

1.1 MELE Facts, RA 8495 & Board Organization 1.2 Code of Ethics for Mechanical Engineers & Professional Practice 1.3 Philippine Mechanical Engineering Code (PME Code) Governance & Legal Mandates

2 Chapter 2: Advanced Mathematics & Engineering Statistics

2.1 Differential & Integral Calculus in Engineering Applications 2.2 Differential Equations & Mathematical Modeling 2.3 Applied Engineering Statistics & Quality Control Probability

3 Chapter 3: Engineering Thermodynamics

3.1 Thermodynamic State Postulate, Properties & P-V-T Equations of State 3.2 First Law Analysis for Open & Closed Thermal Systems 3.3 Second Law, Entropy, Exergy & Reversibility Analysis

4 Chapter 4: Fluid Mechanics & Hydraulic Engineering

4.1 Fluid Statics, Manometry, Hydrostatic Force & Buoyancy 4.2 Fluid Kinematics, Dynamics & Bernoulli Equation 4.3 Pipe Flow, Friction Losses & Piping Network Analysis

5 Chapter 5: Heat Transfer & Thermal Systems

5.1 Conduction Heat Transfer & Thermal Insulation Design 5.2 Natural & Forced Convection Heat Transfer Correlations 5.3 Thermal Radiation & Industrial Heat Exchanger Design

6 Chapter 6: Mechanics & Strength of Materials

6.1 Statics & Dynamics of Rigid Bodies & Engineering Linkages 6.2 Normal, Shear & Triaxial Stress-Strain Relationships 6.3 Bending Stresses, Torsion & Column Buckling Analysis

7 Chapter 7: Engineering Economics & Financial Analysis

7.1 Time Value of Money & Cash Flow Equivalence Formulas 7.2 Asset Depreciation, Taxation & Economic Evaluation Methods 7.3 Break-Even Analysis, Payback Period & EOQ Inventory Models

8 Chapter 8: Engineering Materials & Metallurgy

8.1 Ferrous & Non-Ferrous Metals, Alloys & Polymers 8.2 Phase Diagrams, Iron-Carbon System & Heat Treatment 8.3 Mechanical Testing, Fatigue Failure & Fracture Mechanics

9 Chapter 9: Machine Elements & Stress Analysis

9.1 Failure Theories, Static & Fluctuating Stress Design 9.2 Power Transmission Shafts, Keys & Rigid/Flexible Couplings 9.3 Spur, Helical, Bevel & Worm Gear Design Calculations

10 Chapter 10: Power Transmission Components

10.1 Belts, V-Belts, Chains, Wire Ropes & Flywheels 10.2 Rolling Element & Hydrodynamic Journal Bearings 10.3 Mechanical Springs, Clutches & Industrial Brakes

11 Chapter 11: Manufacturing, Fasteners & GD&T

11.1 Threaded Fasteners, Rivets & Welded Joint Analysis 11.2 Manufacturing Processes, Machine Tools & Machining Calculations 11.3 Engineering Drawing, Limits, Fits, Tolerances & GD&T

12 Chapter 12: Power Plants, Boilers & Thermal Power Cycles

12.1 Steam Power Plants & Rankine Cycles 12.2 Steam Generators, Boilers & Combustion Engineering 12.3 Internal Combustion Engines: SI & CI Cycles 12.4 Gas Turbine Power Plants & Combined Cycles

13 Chapter 13: Renewable Energy, Fluid Machinery & Plant Systems

13.1 Hydroelectric, Geothermal & Renewable Energy Power Plants 13.2 Pumps & Hydraulic Machinery 13.3 Air Compressors, Fans & Blowers

14 Chapter 14: Refrigeration, HVAC & Building Mechanical Systems

14.1 Refrigeration Systems, Cycles & Refrigerants 14.2 Psychrometrics & Air Conditioning Systems 14.3 Piping/Ductwork Design, PME Code & Industrial Safety Management

9.1 Failure Theories, Static & Fluctuating Stress Design

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Ductile failure theories rely on shear capacity: Maximum Shear Stress (MSS/Tresca) sets τ m a x ≤ S y / 2 \tau_{max} \le S_y/2 τ ma x ​ ≤ S y ​ /2 while Distortion Energy (DE/von Mises) sets equivalent stress σ ′ ≤ S y \sigma' \le S_y σ ′ ≤ S y ​ , with DE being ~15% less conservative and more accurate for ductile metals.

Brittle materials lack significant plastic yielding and are analyzed using Maximum Normal Stress (Rankine) theory or Coulomb-Mohr and Modified Mohr theories to account for unequal tensile and compressive ultimate strengths ( S u c > S u t S_{uc} > S_{ut} S u c ​ > S u t ​ ).

Fluctuating cyclic stresses require evaluating mean stress σ m = ( σ m a x + σ m i n ) / 2 \sigma_m = (\sigma_{max} + \sigma_{min})/2 σ m ​ = ( σ ma x ​ + σ min ​ ) /2 and alternating stress σ a = ∣ σ m a x − σ m i n ∣ / 2 \sigma_a = |\sigma_{max} - \sigma_{min}|/2 σ a ​ = ∣ σ ma x ​ − σ min ​ ∣/2 against endurance limits modified by Marin factors.

Fatigue design criteria map non-zero mean stress performance: Goodman line (connects S e S_e S e ​ to S u S_u S u ​ ), Soderberg line (connects S e S_e S e ​ to S y S_y S y ​ , preventing yield), and ASME Elliptic criterion (quadratic curve between S e S_e S e ​ and S y S_y S y ​ ).

Stress concentration factors ( K t K_t K t ​ ) are reduced to fatigue notch factors ( K f = 1 + q ( K t − 1 ) K_f = 1 + q(K_t - 1) K f ​ = 1 + q ( K t ​ − 1 ) ) based on material notch sensitivity q q q for cyclic loading analysis.

Last updated: July 2026

9.1 Failure Theories, Static & Fluctuating Stress Design

Machine components in mechanical systems are subjected to static, dynamic, and fluctuating multiaxial loads. Mechanical engineering design requires predicting when a component will cease to fulfill its intended function due to excessive elastic deformation, permanent plastic deformation (yielding), or macroscopic fracture. The PRC Mechanical Engineering Licensure Examination (MELE) heavily tests static failure theories for both ductile and brittle materials, stress concentration factor calculations, and cyclic fatigue design criteria.

1. Static Failure Theories for Ductile Materials

Ductile materials are defined as those exhibiting a tensile elongation at fracture of ϵ f ≥ 0.05 \epsilon_f \ge 0.05 ϵ f ​ ≥ 0.05 (5%) and possessing yield strengths ( S y S_y S y ​ ) nearly equal in tension and compression ( S y t ≈ S y c S_{yt} \approx S_{yc} S y t ​ ≈ S yc ​ ). Failure in ductile materials is characterized by yield-initiated plastic slip along maximum shear planes.

Maximum Shear Stress (MSS) Theory (Tresca Criterion)

The Maximum Shear Stress theory states that yielding begins in a multiaxial stress state whenever the maximum shear stress τ m a x \tau_{max} τ ma x ​ in any element equals or exceeds the maximum shear stress present in a uniaxial tensile test specimen at the onset of yield ( S y / 2 S_y / 2 S y ​ /2 ).

For a three-dimensional principal stress state where σ 1 ≥ σ 2 ≥ σ 3 \sigma_1 \ge \sigma_2 \ge \sigma_3 σ 1 ​ ≥ σ 2 ​ ≥ σ 3 ​ : τ m a x = σ 1 − σ 3 2 ≥ S y 2 \tau_{max} = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_3}{2} \ge \frac{S_y}{2} τ ma x ​ = 2 σ 1 ​ − σ 3 ​ ​ ≥ 2 S y ​ ​

Expressing this in terms of the design Factor of Safety ( N N N ): N = S y σ 1 − σ 3 = S y 2 τ m a x N = \frac{S_y}{\sigma_1 - \sigma_3} = \frac{S_y}{2 \tau_{max}} N = σ 1 ​ − σ 3 ​ S y ​ ​ = 2 τ ma x ​ S y ​ ​

For a two-dimensional (plane stress) state ( σ z = 0 , τ x z = τ y z = 0 ) (\sigma_z = 0, \tau_{xz} = \tau_{yz} = 0) ( σ z ​ = 0 , τ x z ​ = τ yz ​ = 0 ) , the principal stresses are calculated as: σ A , B = σ x + σ y 2 ± ( σ x − σ y 2 ) 2 + τ x y 2 \sigma_{A,B} = \frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2} \pm \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)^2 + \tau_{xy}^2} σ A , B ​ = 2 σ x ​ + σ y ​ ​ ± ( 2 σ x ​ − σ y ​ ​ ) 2 + τ x y 2 ​ ​

Case 1 (Same Signs): σ A , σ B > 0 \sigma_A, \sigma_B > 0 σ A ​ , σ B ​ > 0 or σ A , σ B < 0 \sigma_A, \sigma_B < 0 σ A ​ , σ B ​ < 0 . The third principal stress σ 3 = 0 \sigma_3 = 0 σ 3 ​ = 0 lies outside or inside, making τ m a x = max ⁡ ( ∣ σ A ∣ , ∣ σ B ∣ ) / 2 \tau_{max} = \max(|\sigma_A|, |\sigma_B|) / 2 τ ma x ​ = max ( ∣ σ A ​ ∣ , ∣ σ B ​ ∣ ) /2 .

Case 2 (Opposite Signs): σ A > 0 > σ B \sigma_A > 0 > \sigma_B σ A ​ > 0 > σ B ​ . Then σ 1 = σ A \sigma_1 = \sigma_A σ 1 ​ = σ A ​ and σ 3 = σ B \sigma_3 = \sigma_B σ 3 ​ = σ B ​ , so τ m a x = ( σ A − σ B ) / 2 \tau_{max} = (\sigma_A - \sigma_B) / 2 τ ma x ​ = ( σ A ​ − σ B ​ ) /2 .

Note: The MSS theory is conservative (underpredicts strength by up to 15%), making it safe and easy to apply in general machine design.

Distortion Energy (DE) Theory (von Mises / Octahedral Shear Stress)

The Distortion Energy theory states that yielding occurs when the distortion strain energy per unit volume in a stress state equals or exceeds the distortion strain energy per unit volume at the yield point in uniaxial tension or compression.

The equivalent von Mises stress σ ′ \sigma' σ ′ in a general 3D principal stress state is given by: σ ′ = ( σ 1 − σ 2 ) 2 + ( σ 2 − σ 3 ) 2 + ( σ 3 − σ 1 ) 2 2 \sigma' = \sqrt{\frac{(\sigma_1 - \sigma_2)^2 + (\sigma_2 - \sigma_3)^2 + (\sigma_3 - \sigma_1)^2}{2}} σ ′ = 2 ( σ 1 ​ − σ 2 ​ ) 2 + ( σ 2 ​ − σ 3 ​ ) 2 + ( σ 3 ​ − σ 1 ​ ) 2 ​ ​

For 2D plane stress states with normal stresses σ x , σ y \sigma_x, \sigma_y σ x ​ , σ y ​ and shear stress τ x y \tau_{xy} τ x y ​ : σ ′ = σ x 2 − σ x σ y + σ y 2 + 3 τ x y 2 ≤ S y \sigma' = \sqrt{\sigma_x^2 - \sigma_x \sigma_y + \sigma_y^2 + 3 \tau_{xy}^2} \le S_y σ ′ = σ x 2 ​ − σ x ​ σ y ​ + σ y 2 ​ + 3 τ x y 2 ​ ​ ≤ S y ​

The factor of safety under the Distortion Energy theory is: N = S y σ ′ N = \frac{S_y}{\sigma'} N = σ ′ S y ​ ​

Pure shear yield strength predicted by von Mises theory is S s y = 0.577 S y S_{sy} = 0.577 S_y S sy ​ = 0.577 S y ​ (compared to S s y = 0.50 S y S_{sy} = 0.50 S_y S sy ​ = 0.50 S y ​ under MSS). DE theory matches experimental yield data for ductile metals (steels, aluminum, titanium) with high precision.

2. Static Failure Theories for Brittle Materials

Brittle materials (fracture elongation ϵ f < 0.05 \epsilon_f < 0.05 ϵ f ​ < 0.05 , such as gray cast iron, hardened steel, and ceramics) fail by catastrophic fracture without significant plastic yield. Compressive ultimate strength ( S u c S_{uc} S u c ​ ) is typically much higher than tensile ultimate strength ( S u t S_{ut} S u t ​ ) ( S u c ≫ S u t S_{uc} \gg S_{ut} S u c ​ ≫ S u t ​ ).

Maximum Normal Stress (MNS) Theory (Rankine Criterion)

States that failure occurs when the maximum principal tensile stress σ 1 \sigma_1 σ 1 ​ reaches the ultimate tensile strength S u t S_{ut} S u t ​ , or when the minimum principal compressive stress σ 3 \sigma_3 σ 3 ​ reaches the ultimate compressive strength S u c S_{uc} S u c ​ : N = S u t σ 1 or N = S u c ∣ σ 3 ∣ N = \frac{S_{ut}}{\sigma_1} \quad \text{or} \quad N = \frac{S_{uc}}{|\sigma_3|} N = σ 1 ​ S u t ​ ​ or N = ∣ σ 3 ​ ∣ S u c ​ ​

Limitation: MNS theory works well in Quadrant I (both principal stresses tensile), but overpredicts strength in Quadrant IV where shear components are high.

Coulomb-Mohr & Modified Mohr Theories

Coulomb-Mohr accounts for unequal tensile and compressive properties by constructing envelope tangents to compression and tension stress circles: σ 1 S u t − σ 3 S u c = 1 N ( for σ 1 ≥ 0 ≥ σ 3 ) \frac{\sigma_1}{S_{ut}} - \frac{\sigma_3}{S_{uc}} = \frac{1}{N} \quad (\text{for } \sigma_1 \ge 0 \ge \sigma_3) S u t ​ σ 1 ​ ​ − S u c ​ σ 3 ​ ​ = N 1 ​ ( for σ 1 ​ ≥ 0 ≥ σ 3 ​ )

Modified Mohr Theory adjusts the failure locus in Quadrant IV ( σ 1 > 0 > σ 3 ) (\sigma_1 > 0 > \sigma_3) ( σ 1 ​ > 0 > σ 3 ​ ) to better fit experimental brittle fracture data:

If σ 1 > 0 > σ 3 \sigma_1 > 0 > \sigma_3 σ 1 ​ > 0 > σ 3 ​ and ∣ σ 3 / σ 1 ∣ ≤ 1 |\sigma_3 / \sigma_1| \le 1 ∣ σ 3 ​ / σ 1 ​ ∣ ≤ 1 : Failure occurs when σ 1 = S u t \sigma_1 = S_{ut} σ 1 ​ = S u t ​ .

If σ 1 > 0 > σ 3 \sigma_1 > 0 > \sigma_3 σ 1 ​ > 0 > σ 3 ​ and ∣ σ 3 / σ 1 ∣ > 1 |\sigma_3 / \sigma_1| > 1 ∣ σ 3 ​ / σ 1 ​ ∣ > 1 : ( S u c − S u t ) σ 1 S u c S u t − σ 3 S u c = 1 N \frac{(S_{uc} - S_{ut}) \sigma_1}{S_{uc} S_{ut}} - \frac{\sigma_3}{S_{uc}} = \frac{1}{N} S u c ​ S u t ​ ( S u c ​ − S u t ​ ) σ 1 ​ ​ − S u c ​ σ 3 ​ ​ = N 1 ​ .

3. Factor of Safety ( N N N ) Determination

The Factor of Safety N N N is defined as: N = Material Strength (Yield or Ultimate) Allowable Design Stress N = \frac{\text{Material Strength (Yield or Ultimate)}}{\text{Allowable Design Stress}} N = Allowable Design Stress Material Strength (Yield or Ultimate) ​

Selection Guidelines in ME Practice

N = 1.25 − 1.50 N = 1.25 - 1.50 N = 1.25 − 1.50 : Highly controlled conditions, well-known loads, lightweight aerospace applications.

N = 1.50 − 2.00 N = 1.50 - 2.00 N = 1.50 − 2.00 : Standard mechanical engineering design with known materials and moderate environmental shock.

N = 2.00 − 3.00 N = 2.00 - 3.00 N = 2.00 − 3.00 : Applications with loading uncertainty, dynamic impact, or brittle materials.

N = 3.00 − 4.00 + N = 3.00 - 4.00+ N = 3.00 − 4.00 + : Hazardous environments, human safety critical structures (elevators, pressure vessels).

4. Fluctuating Stress & Fatigue Failure Design

Machine elements like crankshafts, turbine blades, and gears experience cyclic loading where fracture occurs at stresses far below static yield strength due to microcrack nucleation and propagation.

Stress Components in Cyclic Loading

For a stress waveform varying between maximum stress σ m a x \sigma_{max} σ ma x ​ and minimum stress σ m i n \sigma_{min} σ min ​ :

Mean Stress ( σ m \sigma_m σ m ​ ): σ m = σ m a x + σ m i n 2 \sigma_m = \frac{\sigma_{max} + \sigma_{min}}{2} σ m ​ = 2 σ ma x ​ + σ min ​ ​

Alternating Stress ( σ a \sigma_a σ a ​ ): σ a = ∣ σ m a x − σ m i n ∣ 2 \sigma_a = \frac{|\sigma_{max} - \sigma_{min}|}{2} σ a ​ = 2 ∣ σ ma x ​ − σ min ​ ∣ ​

  • Stress Ratio ( R R R ): R = σ m i n σ m a x R = \frac{\sigma_{min}}{\sigma_{max}} R = σ ma x ​ σ min ​ ​
  • Amplitude Ratio ( A A A ): A = σ a σ m A = \frac{\sigma_a}{\sigma_m} A = σ m ​ σ a ​ ​
  • Modified Endurance Limit ( S e S_e S e ​ )

The rotary-beam specimen endurance limit S e ′ S_e' S e ′ ​ is modified for real components using Marin factors: S e = k a k b k c k d k e k f S e ′ S_e = k_a k_b k_c k_d k_e k_f S_e' S e ​ = k a ​ k b ​ k c ​ k d ​ k e ​ k f ​ S e ′ ​

Where S e ′ ≈ 0.50 S u t S_e' \approx 0.50 S_{ut} S e ′ ​ ≈ 0.50 S u t ​ for steels with S u t ≤ 1400 MPa S_{ut} \le 1400 \text{ MPa} S u t ​ ≤ 1400 MPa ( 200 kpsi 200 \text{ kpsi} 200 kpsi ).

  • k a k_a k a ​ : Surface factor (ground, machined, cold-drawn, forged)
  • k b k_b k b ​ : Size factor
  • k c k_c k c ​ : Reliability factor
  • k d k_d k d ​ : Temperature factor
  • k e k_e k e ​ : Duty cycle / operating stress factor
  • k f k_f k f ​ : Miscellaneous effects factor
  • Stress Concentration & Fatigue Notch Factor

Geometric discontinuities (fillets, keyways, holes) increase local stresses. The geometric stress concentration factor K t K_t K t ​ is converted to the fatigue notch factor ( K f K_f K f ​ ) using notch sensitivity q q q ( 0 ≤ q ≤ 1 0 \le q \le 1 0 ≤ q ≤ 1 ): K f = 1 + q ( K t − 1 ) K_f = 1 + q(K_t - 1) K f ​ = 1 + q ( K t ​ − 1 ) σ a , a c t u a l = K f σ a , n o m i n a l \sigma_{a,actual} = K_f \sigma_{a,nominal} σ a , a c t u a l ​ = K f ​ σ a , n o mina l ​

5. Fatigue Failure Criteria (Fluctuating Stress with Non-Zero Mean Stress)

When a machine part experiences both alternating stress σ a \sigma_a σ a ​ and tensile mean stress σ m \sigma_m σ m ​ , safe fatigue life boundaries are represented on an S-N mean stress diagram.

Fatigue Criterion Governing Equation Application / Characteristics

Goodman Line σ a S e + σ m S u t = 1 N \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}} = \frac{1}{N} S e ​ σ a ​ ​ + S u t ​ σ m ​ ​ = N 1 ​ Standard linear criterion; conservative for tensile mean stress.

Soderberg Line σ a S e + σ m S y = 1 N \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_y} = \frac{1}{N} S e ​ σ a ​ ​ + S y ​ σ m ​ ​ = N 1 ​ Most conservative criterion; prevents static yielding as well as fatigue.

ASME Elliptic ( σ a S e ) 2 + ( σ m S y ) 2 = ( 1 N ) 2 \left(\frac{\sigma_a}{S_e}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{\sigma_m}{S_y}\right)^2 = \left(\frac{1}{N}\right)^2 ( S e ​ σ a ​ ​ ) 2 + ( S y ​ σ m ​ ​ ) 2 = ( N 1 ​ ) 2 Quadratic parabolic locus; provides realistic boundary for ductile materials.

Gerber Parabola σ a S e + ( σ m S u t ) 2 = 1 N \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \left(\frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}}\right)^2 = \frac{1}{N} S e ​ σ a ​ ​ + ( S u t ​ σ m ​ ​ ) 2 = N 1 ​ Fits average experimental failure points; less conservative. Alternating Stress (σa)

  • ^
  • S_e| \ (Soderberg Line: connects S_e & S_y)
  • | \ (Goodman Line: connects S_e & S_ut)
  • | \ (ASME Elliptic: curve between S_e & S_y)
  • | \
  • +-----+-------+-------------> Mean Stress (σm)
  • 0 S_y S_ut
  • 6. Worked Machine Design Example: Fluctuating Bending Calculation
  • Problem Statement

A machine shaft made of AISI 1045 cold-drawn steel has an ultimate tensile strength S u t = 650 MPa S_{ut} = 650 \text{ MPa} S u t ​ = 650 MPa and yield strength S y = 400 MPa S_y = 400 \text{ MPa} S y ​ = 400 MPa . The modified endurance limit of the shaft at a critical fillet section is S e = 200 MPa S_e = 200 \text{ MPa} S e ​ = 200 MPa . The nominal bending stress at the fillet fluctuates dynamically between σ m i n = − 50 MPa \sigma_{min} = -50 \text{ MPa} σ min ​ = − 50 MPa and σ m a x = + 250 MPa \sigma_{max} = +250 \text{ MPa} σ ma x ​ = + 250 MPa . Theoretical stress concentration factor at the fillet is K t = 1.65 K_t = 1.65 K t ​ = 1.65 , and the material notch sensitivity is q = 0.80 q = 0.80 q = 0.80 .

Calculate:

The fatigue notch factor K f K_f K f ​ .

The actual nominal mean stress σ m \sigma_m σ m ​ and alternating stress σ a \sigma_a σ a ​ .

The design factor of safety N N N using the Goodman criterion .

The design factor of safety N N N using the Soderberg criterion .

Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Compute Fatigue Notch Factor K f K_f K f ​ K f = 1 + q ( K t − 1 ) = 1 + 0.80 ( 1.65 − 1 ) = 1 + 0.80 ( 0.65 ) = 1 + 0.52 = 1.52 K_f = 1 + q(K_t - 1) = 1 + 0.80(1.65 - 1) = 1 + 0.80(0.65) = 1 + 0.52 = 1.52 K f ​ = 1 + q ( K t ​ − 1 ) = 1 + 0.80 ( 1.65 − 1 ) = 1 + 0.80 ( 0.65 ) = 1 + 0.52 = 1.52

Step 2: Calculate Mean Stress σ m \sigma_m σ m ​ and Alternating Stress σ a \sigma_a σ a ​ σ m = σ m a x + σ m i n 2 = 250 + ( − 50 ) 2 = 200 2 = 100 MPa \sigma_m = \frac{\sigma_{max} + \sigma_{min}}{2} = \frac{250 + (-50)}{2} = \frac{200}{2} = 100 \text{ MPa} σ m ​ = 2 σ ma x ​ + σ min ​ ​ = 2 250 + ( − 50 ) ​ = 2 200 ​ = 100 MPa σ a , n o m i n a l = ∣ σ m a x − σ m i n ∣ 2 = 250 − ( − 50 ) 2 = 300 2 = 150 MPa \sigma_{a,nominal} = \frac{|\sigma_{max} - \sigma_{min}|}{2} = \frac{250 - (-50)}{2} = \frac{300}{2} = 150 \text{ MPa} σ a , n o mina l ​ = 2 ∣ σ ma x ​ − σ min ​ ∣ ​ = 2 250 − ( − 50 ) ​ = 2 300 ​ = 150 MPa

Applying K f K_f K f ​ to alternating stress (mean stress is unnotched for ductile materials under fatigue): σ a = K f ⋅ σ a , n o m i n a l = 1.52 × 150 MPa = 228 MPa \sigma_a = K_f \cdot \sigma_{a,nominal} = 1.52 \times 150 \text{ MPa} = 228 \text{ MPa} σ a ​ = K f ​ ⋅ σ a , n o mina l ​ = 1.52 × 150 MPa = 228 MPa

Step 3: Factor of Safety using Modified Goodman Line σ a S e + σ m S u t = 1 N \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_{ut}} = \frac{1}{N} S e ​ σ a ​ ​ + S u t ​ σ m ​ ​ = N 1 ​ 228 200 + 100 650 = 1 N \frac{228}{200} + \frac{100}{650} = \frac{1}{N} 200 228 ​ + 650 100 ​ = N 1 ​ 1.1400 + 0.1538 = 1.2938 = 1 N 1.1400 + 0.1538 = 1.2938 = \frac{1}{N} 1.1400 + 0.1538 = 1.2938 = N 1 ​ N = 1 1.2938 = 0.773 N = \frac{1}{1.2938} = 0.773 N = 1.2938 1 ​ = 0.773

Interpretation: Because N < 1.0 N < 1.0 N < 1.0 , the component will fail in fatigue prior to infinite life under the Goodman criterion.

Step 4: Factor of Safety using Soderberg Line σ a S e + σ m S y = 1 N \frac{\sigma_a}{S_e} + \frac{\sigma_m}{S_y} = \frac{1}{N} S e ​ σ a ​ ​ + S y ​ σ m ​ ​ = N 1 ​ 228 200 + 100 400 = 1 N \frac{228}{200} + \frac{100}{400} = \frac{1}{N} 200 228 ​ + 400 100 ​ = N 1 ​ 1.1400 + 0.2500 = 1.3900 = 1 N 1.1400 + 0.2500 = 1.3900 = \frac{1}{N} 1.1400 + 0.2500 = 1.3900 = N 1 ​ N = 1 1.3900 = 0.719 N = \frac{1}{1.3900} = 0.719 N = 1.3900 1 ​ = 0.719

Conclusion: Soderberg criterion yields N = 0.719 N = 0.719 N = 0.719 , which is even more conservative than Goodman ( N = 0.773 N = 0.773 N = 0.773 ), confirming finite life.

Loading diagram... Fatigue Design Failure Lines for Cyclic Loading with Mean Stress