Study guide
6.6 Tools for Social Welfare Policy Analysis
PRC Social Worker Licensure Examination Philippines
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: HBSE - Philippine Social Realities & Social Problem Analysis
1.1 Social Realities and the Perspectives-Tools for Analysing Them 1.2 Poverty: Types, Dimensions, and Approaches to Measurement 1.3 Neoliberalism, Globalisation, and Their Implications for Social Work 1.4 The Basic Sectors of Philippine Society: Situations, Struggles, and Responsive Programmes 1.5 The Anatomy of Social Problems and Theories of Social Problems
2 Chapter 2: HBSE - Developmental Theories & Personality Foundations
2.1 Psychodynamic and Behavioral Theories of Human Development 2.2 Cognitive and Moral Development Theories 2.3 Humanistic, Existential, and Systems Perspectives 2.4 Life-Span Development, Biopsychosocial Milestones, and Developmental Crises
3 Chapter 3: HBSE - Filipino Family Dynamics, Culture & Social Systems
3.1 Filipino Family Structures, Kinship Networks, and Dynamics 3.2 Indigenous Concepts and Filipino Cultural Values in Social Work 3.3 Social Deviance, Marginalization, and Vulnerable Sectors 3.4 Gender and Development (GAD), Intersectionality, and Contemporary Philippine Realities 3.5 Emotional and Behavioural Disorders: Recognition and Social Work Response 3.6 The Group, Organisation and Community as Social Systems
4 Chapter 4: HBSE - Social Change, Development Perspectives & Social Movements
4.1 Concepts, Patterns, Processes and Sources of Social Change 4.2 Conceptions and Dimensions of Development 4.3 Social Change and Development Theories 4.4 Perspectives and Approaches on Social Development 4.5 Social Movements and Their Impact on Philippine Society
5 Chapter 5: SWPPS - History, Philosophy & Philippine Social Legislation
5.1 Historical Evolution of Social Welfare in the Philippines and Internationally 5.2 RA 4373 and RA 10847: Legal Regulation and Licensure of Social Work in the Philippines 5.3 Philippine Child, Youth, and Family Protection Laws 5.4 Special Legislation for Vulnerable Sectors
6 Chapter 6: SWPPS - Ethics, Welfare Administration & Social Security
6.1 Philippine Social Work Code of Ethics and Ethical Standards 6.2 Social Welfare Administration: Organizational Structure, Planning, Budgeting, and Supervision 6.3 Philippine Social Protection Programs and Services 6.4 Social Security and Safety Nets in the Philippines 6.5 Social Welfare Policy Making, Financing and Implementation 6.6 Tools for Social Welfare Policy Analysis
7 Chapter 7: SWPPS - Social Work Statistics
7.1 The Nature, Role and Uses of Statistics in Social Work 7.2 Descriptive Statistics: Presentation, Central Tendency, Variability and Standard Scores 7.3 Sampling Distributions, Probability and Inferential Statistics 7.4 Hypothesis Testing, ANOVA and Tests of Association
8 Chapter 8: SWPPS - Social Work Research 1 & 2
8.1 Social Work Research: Nature, Principles and Ethics 8.2 The Research Process: Problem, Hypothesis, Framework and Review of Literature 8.3 Research Designs and Methodologies for Data Collection and Analysis 8.4 Research Instrumentation, Data Gathering, Tabulation and Analysis 8.5 Research Presentation, Validation and Dissemination
9 Chapter 9: SWPPS - Social Welfare Project & Program Development and Management
9.1 Perspectives and Concepts in Social Welfare Project Development and Management 9.2 The Project Management Cycle: Identification, Planning, Implementation, Monitoring and Evaluation 9.3 Tools of Analysis and the Gender-Responsive Project Proposal
10 Chapter 10: Practice I - Foundations of Social Casework
10.1 Principles and Core Concepts of Social Casework 10.2 The Helping Relationship, Communication, and Interviewing Skills in Casework 10.3 Intake, Social Investigation, and Data Gathering Methods in Casework 10.4 Social Diagnosis and Problem Formulation: Person-in-Environment Assessment
11 Chapter 11: Practice I - Interventions, Documentation & Field Instruction
11.1 Casework Models and Modalities 11.2 Treatment Planning, Goal Setting, and Progress Monitoring with Individuals and Families 11.3 Case Documentation and the Social Case Study Report (SCSR) 11.4 Evaluation, Termination, Referral, and Field Instruction Supervision in Practice I 11.5 Social Work Counselling: Context, Mandates, Scope and Limits 11.6 Counselling Perspectives, Models, Roles, Techniques and Contemporary Issues 11.7 Fields and Settings of Social Work Practice 11.8 Emerging Trends and Specialisations in Philippine Social Work
12 Chapter 12: Practice I - Field Instruction I: Institutional Placement with Individuals & Families
12.1 Field Instruction I: Beginning Phase — Engagement, Assessment and Planning 12.2 Field Instruction I: Middle Phase — Plan Intervention in an Institutional Setting 12.3 Field Instruction I: Ending Phase — Termination, Monitoring, Evaluation, Documentation and Supervision
13 Chapter 13: Practice II - Foundations of Social Group Work
13.1 Concepts, History, and Theoretical Models of Social Group Work 13.2 Group Dynamics, Structures, Norms, Cohesion, and Interaction Patterns 13.3 Pre-Group Planning, Intake, Composition, and Group Formation 13.4 Stages of Group Development
14 Chapter 14: Practice II - Group Work Helping Process & Program Media
14.1 The Helping Process in Groups: Leadership Roles, Worker Interventions, and Mutual Aid 14.2 Program Media and Activities in Group Work: Selection, Design, and Therapeutic Application 14.3 Group Work in Specialized Settings 14.4 Group Evaluation, Termination, Follow-Up, and Field Supervision in Practice II 14.5 Group Work Intervention Models and Approaches 14.6 Field Instruction II: Individual-Focused Assessment and Planning in Group Work 14.7 Field Instruction II: Group-Focused Assessment and Planning
15 Chapter 15: Practice III - Foundations of Community Organization & COPAR
15.1 Concepts, Principles, and Models of Community Organization 15.2 Community Organizing Participatory Action Research (COPAR): Pre-Entry, Site Selection, and Entry Phase 15.3 Community Integration, Sensitization, and Participatory Action Research / Social Investigation 15.4 Core Group Formation, Leadership Identification, and Capability Building in Communities
16 Chapter 16: Practice III - Mobilization, Advocacy & Community Practice
16.1 Community Mobilization, Action-Reflection-Action Sessions, and Collective Problem Solving 16.2 Coalition Building, Resource Mobilization, Networking, and Policy Advocacy 16.3 Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation (PME), Phase-Out, and Turnover to People's Organizations (POs) 16.4 Field Instruction in Community Practice: Professional Roles, Safety, and Community Ethics 16.5 Community Education and Training: Theoretical Basis, Perspectives and Principles 16.6 Training Needs Assessment and Community Training Design 16.7 Roles and Skills of the Social Work Trainer in Community Education
17 Chapter 17: SWLE Overview, PRC Regulations & Board Examination Strategy
17.1 SWLE Examination Structure, PRC Grading System, and Board Regulations 17.2 Enhanced Table of Specifications Analysis and High-Yield Board Exam Competencies 17.3 Mastering Situational Questions, Case Analysis, and Board Exam Day Strategies
6.6 Tools for Social Welfare Policy Analysis
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Sub-topic D.3 of the Social Welfare Policies TOS carries ten items on identifying and applying tools of policy analysis and examining ethical issues in policy making.
Policy analysis asks four questions: what problem is addressed, who benefits and who bears the cost, how is it delivered and financed, and what effects does it produce.
Gilbert and Terrell's framework analyses any social policy through four dimensions: the basis of allocation, the nature of the provision, the delivery structure and the mode of finance.
Selectivity targets by means test and is administratively cheaper per recipient but generates stigma and exclusion error; universality reaches everyone but costs more.
Ethical issues in policy making include conditionality, paternalism, deservingness framing, data privacy in targeting and the political use of assistance.
Last updated: September 2026
6.6 Tools for Social Welfare Policy Analysis
Blueprint anchor. TOS sub-topic D.3 Tools for Policy Analysis carries 10 items : identifying tools for policy analysis, applying them in policy analysis and development, identifying ethical issues in social work applicable to policy making, and examining the tools to improve policy development.
1. What Policy Analysis Is
Policy analysis is the systematic examination of a policy's problem definition, content, structure, effects and alternatives. Two orientations:
Analysis of policy — descriptive and evaluative: what does this policy do, and with what effect?
Analysis for policy — prescriptive: what should be done, and which option is best?
A registered social worker does both: evaluating an existing programme's exclusion error is analysis of policy; recommending a documentary alternative is analysis for policy.
2. The Basic Analytical Sequence
Define the problem the policy claims to address. Whose definition prevailed, and what alternative framings were excluded?
Identify the goals and objectives , including unstated ones.
Describe the policy's content — eligibility, benefit, delivery, financing.
Identify the target population and estimate coverage, take-up, exclusion error and inclusion error.
Trace the effects — intended, unintended, distributional, and effects on behaviour.
Assess against criteria — adequacy, equity, efficiency, effectiveness, feasibility, rights compliance.
Compare alternatives , including doing nothing.
Recommend , addressed to the body able to act.
3. Gilbert and Terrell's Four Dimensions
The standard analytical framework in social welfare policy asks four questions of any policy:
Dimension Question Options
Basis of allocation Who is eligible, and on what basis? Attributed need (category membership); compensation (past contribution or injury); diagnostic differentiation (professional assessment); means test
Nature of provision What is given? Cash, in-kind goods, services, vouchers, credits, opportunities, power (a seat at the table)
Delivery structure Through what organisational arrangement? National agency, local government, non-government partner, contracted provider, community-based
Mode of finance Where does the money come from, and how does it flow? General taxation, contributions, user fees, grants, loans; block grant, matching grant, or reimbursement
Applying all four dimensions to any Philippine social protection programme is the fastest route to a complete policy description — and item stems are frequently built by describing one dimension and asking candidates to name it.
- 4. The Standing Policy Debates
- Selectivity Versus Universality
- Selective (means-tested) Universal
- Eligibility Proven need Category membership or citizenship
- Cost Lower gross cost Higher gross cost
- Administration Costly to assess and verify Simple to administer
- Errors High exclusion error Inclusion of the non-poor
- Stigma Substantial Minimal
- Take-up Depressed by stigma and documentation High
- Political durability Weak; a programme for the poor is easily cut Strong; broad constituency
- Cash Versus In-Kind
- Cash In-kind
- Respects self-determination Yes — recipients decide No — the agency decides
- Administrative cost Low High: procurement, storage, distribution
- Targeting of use Cannot be directed Directed to the intended good
- Local economy effect Stimulates local trade May displace local traders
- Political defensibility Vulnerable to "misuse" narratives Easier to defend visually
- Conditional Versus Unconditional
Conditionality attaches behavioural requirements — school attendance, health visits — to a transfer. It is defended as building human capital and criticised as paternalistic, as penalising households whose non-compliance is caused by service absence rather than by unwillingness, and as adding a compliance-monitoring burden that consumes worker time.
5. Analytical Tools
- Tool Output
- Problem tree and objective tree Causal structure of the problem and the objectives that follow
- Stakeholder and power analysis Who supports, who opposes, who decides
- Cost-benefit and cost-effectiveness analysis Comparison of options by value or by cost per unit of outcome
- Distributional / incidence analysis Who gains and who pays, by income group, sex, region
Gender analysis and gender-responsive budgeting Differential effects on women and men; whether the budget funds them
- Rights-based analysis Claim-holders, duty-bearers, and accountability mechanisms
- Policy brief Two pages: problem, evidence, options, recommendation
- Force field analysis Driving and restraining forces around a proposed change
- Feasibility appraisal Technical, financial, administrative and political viability
- 6. Ethical Issues in Social Welfare Policy Making
The TOS names ethical issues explicitly, and the recurring ones are:
Paternalism versus self-determination. Conditionality and in-kind provision both substitute the state's judgement for the recipient's.
Deservingness framing. Distinguishing "deserving" from "undeserving" poor is a moral judgement dressed as an eligibility rule, and it is inconsistent with the profession's value of the dignity and worth of the person.
Stigma as a rationing device. Making a benefit unpleasant to claim reduces take-up among exactly the people least able to advocate for themselves.
Data privacy in targeting. Household assessment collects sensitive personal information; its storage, sharing and use are governed by data privacy law and by the profession's confidentiality standard.
Political use of assistance. Conditioning or appearing to condition assistance on political support corrupts the entitlement and is an ethical violation for the worker who participates in it.
Exclusion error as harm. A targeting rule that reliably excludes a knowable group is not a neutral technical parameter; it is a distributive decision with identifiable victims.
Voice. Policies affecting a sector made without that sector's participation violate the participation principle even when the substance is benign.
Sustainability and intergenerational equity. Committing future budgets or depleting resources shifts cost onto people who cannot yet object.
7. Worked Practice Application
A municipality proposes to replace its cash-based emergency food assistance with a monthly grocery pack procured centrally, arguing that recipients "misuse" cash.
Four-dimension analysis.
Basis of allocation: unchanged means test; the exclusion error in the existing list is not addressed.
Nature of provision: changed from cash to in-kind — the substantive change.
Delivery: new procurement, storage and distribution burden falling on an office with no additional staff.
Finance: same budget line, but a larger share is consumed by administration and logistics.
Evaluation against criteria.
Adequacy: the pack's contents are uniform, so households with dietary, infant or medical needs are worse served.
Efficiency: administrative cost rises; the per-household value of assistance falls.
Equity: distant barangays incur transport cost to collect, an in-kind burden cash did not impose.
Rights and self-determination: the change is premised on a deservingness judgement about recipients' competence, unsupported by evidence.
Local economy: central procurement diverts spending from barangay sari-sari stores, several of which are themselves assisted households' livelihoods.
Ethical assessment. The "misuse" premise is a deservingness framing. Before removing an entire population's discretion, the office should establish whether misuse actually occurs and at what rate.
Recommendation. Retain cash as the default; offer an in-kind option to households that request it; address the specific documented cases of concern through case management rather than through a population-wide restriction; and redirect the analysis to the exclusion error in the eligibility list, which affects far more households than the alleged misuse.