Study guide
8.3 Collective Bargaining Process and Good-Faith Conduct
PHR Study Guide Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Orientation: PHR Eligibility, Format, Fees, Scoring, and Study Map
1.1 PHR Purpose and Operational Scope 1.2 Eligibility Pathways and Candidate Fit 1.3 Exam Format, Time, and Delivery 1.4 Fees, Refunds, and Application Planning 1.5 Scoring, Pass Rate, Retake, and Recertification 1.6 Seven-Domain Study Map
2 Business Management: HR Operations, Stakeholders, Culture, and Metrics
2.1 Business Management Domain Boundary 2.2 Organizational Context and Business Operations 2.3 Stakeholder Needs and HR Service Delivery 2.4 Culture, Values, and Ethics in HR Operations 2.5 Policies, Procedures, and Governance Controls 2.6 HR Metrics and Business Reporting
3 Workforce Planning, Job Analysis, Recruiting, Selection, and Onboarding
3.1 Operational Workforce Planning 3.2 Job Analysis and Job Documentation 3.3 Sourcing and Recruiting Pipeline 3.4 Screening, Interviewing, and Selection 3.5 Offers, Hiring, and Onboarding 3.6 Retention and Talent Acquisition Metrics
4 Learning and Development Needs Assessment, Training Design, and Evaluation
4.1 Training Needs Assessment 4.2 Learning Objectives and Instructional Design 4.3 Training Delivery and Implementation 4.4 Training Evaluation and Transfer 4.5 Career Development and Coaching 4.6 Succession Support and Capability Planning
5 Total Rewards: Compensation, Benefits, Leave, Pay Equity, and Recognition
5.1 Total Rewards Domain Scope and Answer Logic 5.2 Job Evaluation and Pay Structure Basics 5.3 Base Pay, Variable Pay, and Incentive Administration 5.4 Benefits Administration and ERISA Awareness 5.5 Leave Programs and Payroll-Adjacent Compliance 5.6 Pay Equity, Recognition, and Total Rewards Controls
6 Employee Engagement: Culture, Performance, Retention, and Wellbeing
6.1 Employee Engagement Domain Scope and Answer Logic 6.2 Culture, Values, and Workplace Climate 6.3 Engagement Surveys, Listening, and Action Planning 6.4 Performance Support, Feedback, and Coaching 6.5 Retention Drivers, Turnover, and Stay Conversations 6.6 Wellbeing, Recognition, and Sustainable Engagement
7 Employee Relations, Investigations, Discipline, Documentation, and Separations
7.1 Complaint Intake and Early Risk Triage 7.2 Investigation Planning and Neutral Fact-Finding 7.3 Documentation, Records, and Confidentiality 7.4 Corrective Action and Progressive Discipline 7.5 Grievance Handling, Conflict Resolution, and Employee Voice 7.6 Separations, Final Controls, and Retaliation Prevention
8 Labor Relations, NLRA, Collective Bargaining, and Workplace Rights
8.1 NLRA Foundations and Protected Concerted Activity 8.2 Organizing, Representation, and Election Readiness 8.3 Collective Bargaining Process and Good-Faith Conduct 8.4 Contract Administration, Management Rights, and Past Practice 8.5 Grievance-Arbitration and Unfair Labor Practice Risk 8.6 Strikes, Lockouts, and Contingency Planning
9 HR Information Management: HRIS, Records, Privacy, Reporting, and Metrics
9.1 HRIS Governance and Operational Ownership 9.2 Employee Records and Retention Controls 9.3 Data Privacy, Confidentiality, and Access 9.4 Reporting, Metrics, and HR Dashboards 9.5 Data Integrity, Audits, and System Controls 9.6 Compliance Workflows, Vendors, and Incident Response
10 PHR U.S. Employment Law Playbooks: FLSA, FMLA, ADA, Title VII, OSHA, and ERISA
10.1 Law Issue Spotting and HR Playbook Logic 10.2 FLSA Classification, Hours, and Overtime 10.3 FMLA, ADA, Leave, Accommodation, and Medical Confidentiality 10.4 Title VII, ADEA, EEO, Harassment, and Retaliation 10.5 OSHA, I-9, and Workplace Compliance Records 10.6 ERISA, Benefits Compliance, and Integrated Documentation
11 Timed Practice, Error Review, and Domain-Weighted Study Plan
11.1 Two-Hour Pacing and Question Triage 11.2 Domain-Weighted Practice Map 11.3 Wrong-Answer Taxonomy 11.4 Legal Versus Process Misses 11.5 Pretest Uncertainty and Confidence Scoring 11.6 Ninety-Day Retake Repair Plan
12 Final PHR Integrated Review, Exam Day, and Recertification Plan
12.1 Final Integrated Review Cycle 12.2 Exam-Day Logistics and Delivery 12.3 Last-Week Law and Domain Bridge 12.4 Operational HR Readiness Thresholds 12.5 Recertification Credit Plan 12.6 Post-Exam Results and Next Steps
8.3 Collective Bargaining Process and Good-Faith Conduct
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Collective bargaining covers mandatory subjects (wages, hours, and other terms and conditions), permissive subjects (negotiable but not to impasse), and illegal subjects (never bargainable).
Good-faith bargaining under Section 8(d) requires meeting at reasonable times with the intent to reach agreement, but neither side must concede any specific proposal.
The employer must furnish relevant information the union requests for bargaining and administration, such as wage and benefit data.
After a lawful impasse on mandatory subjects, an employer may implement its last, best, and final offer; unilateral mid-term changes to mandatory subjects without bargaining are a Section 8(a)(5) violation.
Last updated: June 2026
What bargaining covers: three categories of subjects
Collective bargaining is the process of negotiating a contract over employment terms with the employees' elected representative. Section 8(d) defines the duty and divides subjects into three categories the PHR loves to test:
Category Definition Example
Mandatory Wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment Pay rates, overtime, seniority, layoffs, health benefits, grievance procedure, safety
Permissive Lawful but not required; may negotiate, may not bargain to impasse Internal union affairs, benefits for already-retired workers, identity of the bargaining agent
Illegal Cannot be included even by agreement Closed-shop clauses, hot-cargo agreements, discriminatory terms
A party may insist on a mandatory subject all the way to impasse; insisting on a permissive subject to impasse is itself a ULP.
Who sits at the table and union security
The union bargains as the exclusive representative of everyone in the unit, members and nonmembers alike, so an employer cannot bypass the union to negotiate individually with represented employees ( direct dealing is a ULP). Contracts in non-right-to-work states may include union-security clauses: a union shop requires employees to join (or pay fees) after a grace period of at least 30 days (7 days in construction); an agency shop requires fee payment without formal membership; maintenance-of-membership keeps current members in for the contract term; and a dues check-off authorizes payroll deduction of dues.
Closed shops (membership required before hire) are illegal under Taft-Hartley. These terms are recurring PHR vocabulary.
Good faith does not mean agreement
Good-faith bargaining means approaching negotiations with an open mind and intent to reach agreement: meeting at reasonable times and places, sending representatives with authority, exchanging proposals, and not engaging in surface bargaining (going through the motions with no real intent to agree). It does not require either side to make a concession or accept any particular term — a common PHR distractor claims good faith means saying yes to union proposals.
Bad-faith indicators include: refusing to meet, delaying tactics, withdrawing already-agreed items, bypassing the union to deal directly with employees, and refusing to furnish relevant information. The employer must provide relevant information the union needs to bargain and administer the contract — wage scales, benefit costs, staffing data — though confidential or proprietary data may get accommodations.
Impasse and lawful implementation
If the parties bargain in good faith on a mandatory subject and reach a genuine impasse (a deadlock after exhausting prospects of agreement), the employer may lawfully implement terms reasonably comprehended within its last, best, and final offer . Impasse can be broken by changed circumstances, new proposals, or a union concession, reviving the duty to bargain. The Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service (FMCS) may assist; under Section 8(d), a party seeking to modify a contract must give 60 days' notice and notify FMCS 30 days before any strike or lockout.
Bargaining strategies and stages
PHR items sometimes name negotiation approaches. Distributive (positional) bargaining is a win-lose contest over a fixed pie — the classic wage haggle. Integrative (interest-based) bargaining seeks mutual-gain solutions by focusing on underlying interests, expanding options, and joint problem-solving; many parties use it for non-economic issues. The typical sequence runs through preparation (data gathering and costing), ground rules, presentation of demands, narrowing and trading, and closing.
As issues are settled, the parties initial tentative agreements (TAs) ; the full package then goes to the union membership for a ratification vote , and TAs are not binding until ratified.
HR's role and a worked example
HR supports bargaining by costing proposals (translating cents-per-hour into total annual cost across the unit), preparing lawful responses to information requests, keeping accurate caucus and table notes, aligning operating managers on what the company can live with, and then converting ratified language into payroll, HRIS configuration, benefit enrollment, and supervisor guidance. HR also tracks the Section 8(d) timelines and coordinates with the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service (FMCS) when a mediator is needed.
Worked example: mid-contract, an operations manager wants to change shift start times for represented employees next week. Because hours are a mandatory subject, HR must check the contract language and the duty to bargain before implementing — a unilateral change to a mandatory term during the contract, absent a clear management-rights waiver, is a Section 8(a)(5) refusal-to-bargain violation. Common traps: treating scheduling as an automatic management right when a CBA and bargaining duty are in play; equating hard bargaining with bad faith; or insisting to impasse on a permissive subject, which itself is a ULP.
First contracts, costing, and total compensation
A first contract after a new certification is the hardest to reach; the Board treats failure to bargain a first agreement seriously, and prolonged delay can itself signal bad faith. When costing proposals, HR should think in total compensation , not just base wage: a proposed 50-cent raise must be loaded with payroll taxes, overtime impact, pension or 401(k) match, and health-premium increases to show the true annual cost across the unit. HR also models roll-up effects — how a base increase cascades through shift differentials, overtime, and benefit formulas.
Presenting bargaining proposals as accurate, defensible numbers keeps management aligned and supports an honest claim of inability to pay if the employer ever pleads financial hardship, which (if asserted) obligates the employer to open its books to substantiate the claim.