Study guide

16.3 Relevancy of Facts

LAW-GAT — Law Graduate Assessment Test Pakistan

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

1.1 About the LAW-GAT Exam 1.2 How to Study for LAW-GAT

2 Constitutional History of Pakistan

2.1 Tamiz-ud-Din & Dosso: Early Constitutional Crises 2.2 Asma Jilani & Nusrat Bhutto: Martial Law Legitimacy 2.3 Landmark Cases 1993–2001

3 Constitution 1973: Fundamental Rights

3.1 Preamble & Constitutional Structure 3.2 Core Fundamental Rights 3.3 Principles of Policy & Rights Enforcement

4 Constitution 1973: Parliament & Judicature

4.1 Parliament (Articles 50–89) 4.2 The Judicature Framework (Articles 175–212) 4.3 Superior Courts Jurisdiction Highlights

5 International Law

5.1 United Nations Charter Essentials 5.2 International Court of Justice

6 English Jurisprudence (Salmond)

6.1 Definition & Nature of Jurisprudence (Salmond) 6.2 Sources of Law; Rights and Duties 6.3 Ownership, Possession, Persons & Liability

7 Islamic Jurisprudence (Nyazee)

7.1 Sources of Islamic Law 7.2 Usul al-Fiqh & Classification of Rules 7.3 Ijtihad, Taqlid, Maqasid & Applied Concepts

8 Civil Procedure Code: Core Sections

8.1 Jurisdiction, Res Judicata & Preliminary Sections (Preamble–s.12) 8.2 Place of Suing (Sections 15–20) 8.3 Execution Questions (s.47) & Commissions (s.75) 8.4 Appeals (ss.96, 104, 115) & Inherent Powers (s.151)

9 CPC Orders: Parties & Pleadings

9.1 Order 1 — Parties to Suits 9.2 Orders 6–7 — Pleadings & Plaint 9.3 Orders 8–9 — Written Statement, Appearance & Default

10 CPC Orders: Injunctions & Appeals

10.1 Order 39 — Temporary Injunctions & Interlocutory Orders 10.2 Orders 41 & 43 — Appeals from Decrees and Appealable Orders

11 Pakistan Penal Code: General Provisions

11.1 Chapter 2 — General Explanations & Definitions 11.2 Chapter 4 — General Exceptions

12 PPC Offences: Body & Property

12.1 Chapter 16 — Offences Affecting the Human Body 12.2 Chapter 16-A — Wrongful Restraint & Wrongful Confinement 12.3 Chapter 17 — Offences Against Property

13 CrPC: Definitions, Arrest & Security

13.1 Chapter 1 — Preliminary Definitions 13.2 Chapter 5 — Arrest, Escape & Retaking 13.3 Chapters 7–8 — Compelling Production & Security for Peace

14 CrPC: Nuisance, Investigation & Proceedings

14.1 Chapters 10–11 — Public Nuisance & Temporary Orders 14.2 Chapter 14 — FIR & Police Investigation 14.3 Chapters 16–17 — Complaints & Commencement of Proceedings

15 CrPC: Appeals & Bail

15.1 Chapter 31 — Appeals 15.2 Chapter 39 — Bail

16 Qanoon-e-Shahadat: Structure, Competence & Relevancy

16.1 Qanoon-e-Shahadat Order 1984 — Structure & Applicability 16.2 Competence of Witnesses 16.3 Relevancy of Facts

17 QSO: Admissions, Oral & Documentary Evidence

17.1 Admissions and Confessions 17.2 Oral Evidence 17.3 Documentary Evidence

18 QSO: Burden of Proof, Estoppel & Examination

18.1 Burden of Proof 18.2 Estoppel & Privileged Communications 18.3 Examination of Witnesses

19 Professional Ethics (Bar Council Rules)

19.1 Bar Council Rules Framework (Chapter XII) 19.2 Duties to the Client 19.3 Duties to Court, Colleagues & the Profession 19.4 Misconduct, Advertising, Fees & Discipline

16.3 Relevancy of Facts

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Article 18 QSO: evidence may be given in a suit or proceeding of the existence or non-existence of every fact in issue and of such other facts as are declared relevant by the Order—and of no others

Distinguish facts in issue (facts that directly establish the right/liability asserted) from relevant facts (connected facts the Order makes receivable to prove or disprove facts in issue)

High-yield connected-fact articles: same transaction (Art. 19), occasion/cause/effect (Art. 20), motive/preparation/conduct (Art. 21), explanatory/introductory facts (Art. 22), conspiracy/things said or done by conspirator (Art. 23)

Character is relevant only in the limited ways the Order allows (civil vs criminal differences); judicial notice facts need not be proved when the Court must notice them

MCQ decision framework: identify facts in issue → ask which relevancy article connects the tendered fact → exclude pure propensity/character misuse and remote speculation

Last updated: August 2026

16.3 Relevancy of Facts

Quick Answer: Under Article 18 QSO , evidence may be given of facts in issue and of facts declared relevant by the Order— and of no others . Relevancy is a closed statutory list of connections (same transaction, cause/effect, motive/preparation/conduct, explanatory facts, conspiracy, state of mind, accident vs intention, course of business, character in limited ways, etc.). LAW-GAT scoring turns on naming the right connection and excluding remote or propensity material that no article makes relevant.

Why relevancy dominates early QSO marks

Before confessions and documents, examiners test whether you know what may be proved at all . A brilliant witness on an irrelevant fact is still useless. Build a reflex: Is this a fact in issue? If not, which Article makes it relevant?

Facts in issue versus relevant facts

Concept Meaning Example (civil) Example (criminal)

Fact in issue Fact from which the existence/non-existence of the right, liability, or disability asserted/denied necessarily follows (alone or with other facts) Whether defendant signed the contract; whether price was paid Whether accused caused the death; whether intention/knowledge existed as charged

Relevant fact Fact connected with a fact in issue in a manner declared relevant by the Order Prior negotiations explaining ambiguous term (if Art. 22 fits); payment of earnest money as preparation Motive, preparation, flight as conduct; weapons purchase; things said in conspiracy

Article 18 states the gatekeeping principle: evidence may be given of the existence or non-existence of every fact in issue and of such other facts as are hereinafter declared to be relevant , and of no others .

Working definitions (Art. 2 culture)

“Relevant” means connected with another fact in any of the ways the relevancy articles refer to.

Relevancy is not the same as “interesting,” “prejudicial,” or “what the public wants to hear.”

A fact can be logically interesting yet statutorily irrelevant —exclude it.

  • Core connected-fact articles (must-memorize cluster)
  • Article 19 — Facts forming part of the same transaction

Facts which, though not in issue, are so connected with a fact in issue as to form part of the same transaction are relevant, whether they occurred at the same time and place or at different times and places .

Label Teaching name Exam use

Same transaction Res gestae (common-law label; cite Art. 19 ) Words/acts bound up with the event so they are part of it

Example: During a robbery, the victim’s cry “Thieves—catch them!” and the simultaneous flight of named persons may form part of the same transaction.

Article 20 — Occasion, cause, or effect

Facts which are the occasion , cause , or effect (immediate or otherwise) of relevant facts or facts in issue, or which constitute the state of things under which they happened, or which afforded an opportunity for their occurrence or transaction, are relevant.

  • Connector Illustration
  • Occasion Public festival creating crowd in which a fight erupted
  • Cause Poison purchased shortly before death in a poisoning case
  • Effect Blood stains / injuries following an alleged assault
  • Opportunity Accused alone with deceased at the only access time
  • Article 21 — Motive, preparation, and previous or subsequent conduct

Any fact is relevant which shows or constitutes motive or preparation for any fact in issue or relevant fact. The conduct of any party (or agent) to a suit/proceeding in reference to such suit/proceeding or in reference to any fact in issue or relevant fact—and the conduct of any person an offence against whom is the subject of a proceeding—is relevant if such conduct influences or is influenced by any fact in issue or relevant fact, and whether it was previous or subsequent .

Explanations/illustrations culture (exam): Statements accompanying/explaining conduct, and absconding/flight themes, are classic Art. 21 teaching illustrations—always tie back to the statutory connectors ( motive / preparation / conduct ).

  • Sub-head Typical evidence
  • Motive Enmity, debt, jealousy, gain
  • Preparation Buying weapon, reconnoitering house, arranging alibi documents
  • Previous conduct Prior threats linked to the charge
  • Subsequent conduct Flight, concealment, false explanation, attempt to tamper

Trap: Motive is relevant , not a substitute for proof of the actus. Absence of proved motive does not automatically acquit; presence of motive does not automatically convict.

Article 22 — Facts necessary to explain or introduce

Facts necessary to explain or introduce a fact in issue or relevant fact, or which support/rebut an inference suggested by such a fact, or which establish identity of person/thing, fix time/place , or show relation of parties who are involved, are relevant insofar as they are necessary for that purpose.

  • Use Example
  • Explain Diagram of premises where shooting occurred
  • Identity Distinctive scar; voice identification foundation
  • Time/place Clock / GPS / call-data foundation facts
  • Relationship Proof that A is B’s employee when agency matters
  • Article 23 — Conspiracy: things said or done by conspirator

Where there is reasonable ground to believe that two or more persons have conspired together to commit an offence or an actionable wrong, anything said, done, or written by any one of such persons in reference to their common intention , after the time when such intention was first entertained by any one of them, is a relevant fact as against each of the persons believed to be so conspiring, as well for the purpose of proving the existence of the conspiracy as for showing that any such person was a party to it.

  • Element Checklist
  • Foundation Reasonable ground to believe conspiracy
  • Actors Two or more persons
  • Material Things said, done, or written by a conspirator
  • Link In reference to common intention
  • Timing After intention first entertained by any one of them
  • Use Prove conspiracy and participation

Trap: Treating every co-accused’s confession as automatically Art. 23 conspiracy evidence without the conspiracy foundation. Confession articles are a separate regime (next chapter). Art. 23 is about conspirator acts/statements in reference to common design , not a free pass to ignore confession safeguards.

Article 24 — When facts not otherwise relevant become relevant

Facts not otherwise relevant are relevant if they are inconsistent with any fact in issue or relevant fact, or if by themselves or with other facts they make the existence or non-existence of any fact in issue or relevant fact highly probable or improbable .

This is the Order’s controlled “probability” valve—not an invitation to dump life history into the record.

  • Related relevancy themes (still in the relevancy family)
  • State of mind, body, or bodily feeling

Facts showing the existence of any state of mind (intention, knowledge, good faith, negligence, rashness, ill-will, etc.) or state of body/bodily feeling are relevant when the existence of such state is in issue or relevant—subject to the Order’s limits on proving such states through specific instances as worded in the bare articles.

Accident versus intentional/system

When there is a question whether an act was accidental or intentional , or done with a particular knowledge/intention, the fact that such act formed part of a series of similar occurrences in which the person doing the act was concerned is relevant.

Course of business

When there is a question whether a particular act was done, the existence of any course of business , according to which it naturally would/would not have been done, is relevant (e.g., posting practices, office routines).

Damages, rights, and customs

In suits for damages , facts tending to enable the Court to determine the amount are relevant.

When right or custom is in question, facts showing the right/custom’s creation, claimed exercise, instances, and related transactions are relevant as the Order provides.

Admissions overview (pointer only)

Admissions are a major relevancy/proof bridge: statements suggesting any inference as to a fact in issue or relevant fact, made by specified persons in specified circumstances, are relevant under the admissions articles (beginning with the article that defines admission and following articles on by whom admissions may be made, against whom proved, oral admissions as to contents of documents, etc.).

For this section: know that admissions are relevant and often high-impact; the detailed confession-versus-admission, involuntariness, and police-custody rules are the next chapter’s scoring core. Do not confuse:

  • Tool Typical use
  • Admission Civil and criminal; party’s statement usable as relevant evidence under admissions articles
  • Confession Criminal; more protective exclusionary rules
  • Art. 23 conspiracy material Common design statements/acts of conspirators with foundation
  • Character when relevant (high-level)

Character evidence is not generally a free-for-all “he is a bad person, therefore guilty” doctrine. The Order limits when character is relevant—classically along these teaching lines (read exact articles in your bare Order):

Context General teaching rule

Civil cases Character to prove conduct imputed is generally irrelevant , except where character itself is a fact in issue (and damages may allow character affecting amount)

Criminal cases Previous good character of the accused is generally relevant ; previous bad character is generally not relevant except in reply when the accused has adduced good character (and other limited statutory openings)

As affecting damages Character of the person injured/wronged may be relevant to quantum

Trap: Prosecuting with pure propensity (“he stole before, so he stole now”) without a character article or other relevancy hook (system/accident series, etc.).

Judicial notice themes

Certain facts need not be proved because the Court takes judicial notice of them.

  • Idea Exam meaning
  • Facts judicially noticeable Need not be proved by party evidence in the ordinary way

Facts of which Court must take judicial notice Listed public/constitutional/geographical/official facts as the Order enumerates (laws, public festivals, territories, seals, etc.—check bare list)

Party strategy Do not waste proof on what the Court must notice; do not assume the Court notices private business customs without evidence

Trap: Expecting judicial notice of a private WhatsApp quarrel “everyone knows about.” Judicial notice is for notorious/public/official classes of fact, not private dispute narratives.

  • Decision framework for MCQs (use every time) STEP 1 — Name the fact in issue
  • (What must be true for the claim/charge to succeed?)

STEP 2 — Is the tendered fact itself a fact in issue?

  • YES → Art. 18 allows it
  • NO → go to Step 3

STEP 3 — Which connector article fits?

  • Same transaction? → Art. 19
  • Occasion/cause/effect/opportunity? → Art. 20
  • Motive/preparation/conduct? → Art. 21
  • Explain/introduce/identity/time/place? → Art. 22
  • Conspiracy common intention material? → Art. 23 (+ foundation)
  • Inconsistent / highly probable-improbable? → Art. 24
  • State of mind/body? series showing intention vs accident?
  • course of business? damages/custom? → related relevancy articles
  • Character? → only if character articles open the door
  • Admission/confession? → admissions/confession articles (next chapter)
  • STEP 4 — Exclude
  • Pure propensity without statutory hook
  • Remote speculation
  • Privileged/incompetent material (competence & privilege chapters)
  • STEP 5 — Remember Art. 18’s closing gate: if no article makes it relevant, it is out
  • Mini table — pick the article
  • Tendered fact Best first article to test
  • Cry during assault 19 same transaction
  • Purchase of knife day before 21 preparation (also 20 cause/opportunity themes)
  • Long-standing enmity 21 motive
  • Flight after FIR 21 subsequent conduct
  • Map of crime scene 22 explain/introduce
  • Co-conspirator email about plan 23 (with conspiracy foundation)

Weather on date of accident if judicially notorious / official record themes Judicial notice or public document proof path as fits

  • “Accused is generally dishonest” in chief by prosecution Character limits — usually out
  • Classic exam scenarios

Scenario A — Res gestae: Immediately after a stabbing, a bystander who saw the blow shouts the assailant’s name. Defence: hearsay. Analysis: may be receivable as part of the same transaction under Art. 19 if truly bound up with the event (facts matter).

Scenario B — Motive only: Prosecution proves only that accused owed deceased money, nothing more. Motive under Art. 21 is relevant but not sufficient alone to prove the killing.

Scenario C — Conspiracy foundation missing: Prosecution tenders a third person’s private diary entry as “conspiracy evidence” without reasonable ground of conspiracy. Art. 23 foundation fails.

Scenario D — Character reply: Accused leads evidence of good character; prosecution replies with bad character as the Order allows. Timing ( in reply ) is the exam point.

Scenario E — Irrelevant prejudice: Multiple prior unrelated brawls offered only to show accused is violent. Without system/accident or character-door opening, fails Art. 18 gate.

Scenario F — Opportunity: Proof that only the accused had the key to a locked room at the time of theft— Art. 20 opportunity/state-of-things relevance.

High-yield exam traps

Treating relevancy as common-sense “anything helpful.” Art. 18 is a closed gate .

Confusing fact in issue with every background story.

Using motive as conclusive proof.

Labelling all co-accused statements as Art. 23 without conspiracy foundation.

Importing free US-style character assassination.

Forgetting judicial notice can remove the need to prove listed public facts.

Mixing admissions/confessions rules into pure Art. 19–23 answers without reading the stem.

Citing Evidence Act section numbers instead of QSO Articles .

One-line revision card

Art. 18 only facts in issue + facts declared relevant · 19 same transaction · 20 occasion/cause/effect/opportunity · 21 motive/preparation/conduct · 22 explain/introduce/identity/time/place · 23 conspiracy common-intention acts/words (with foundation) · 24 inconsistent / highly probable-improbable · character limited · judicial notice need not be proved · admissions/confessions = next deep dive · MCQ method: issue → connector article → exclude propensity/remote facts.