Study guide

21.2 Environmental Law, Water Rights, Oil & Gas

NALS Professional Paralegal PP

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: The PP Examination: Structure, Scoring & Current Status

1.1 The Four PP Parts, the 70% Per-Part Standard & Retake Rules 1.2 Eligibility, Online Delivery, Required Texts & Recertification

2 Chapter 2: Grammar, Syntax & Language Mechanics

2.1 Grammar, Syntax & Subject-Verb Agreement in Legal Documents 2.2 Punctuation, Mechanics & the Serial Comma 2.3 Word Choice, Commonly Confused Terms & Legal Spelling Standards

3 Chapter 3: Legal Drafting, Formatting & Professional Expression

3.1 Numbers, Dates & Capitalization Rules in Formal Filings 3.2 Composition, Plain-English Principles & Concise Legal Writing 3.3 Professional Legal Correspondence: Client Letters, Transmittals & Memoranda

4 Chapter 4: Advanced Legal Terminology

4.1 Latin Terms in Legal Usage 4.2 Legal Terms of Art, Doublets & Terminology Traps

5 Chapter 5: Law Office Records Management & Filing Rules

5.1 Records Management Principles, Alphabetic Indices & Cross-References 5.2 Filing Procedures: Preparing Material, Charge-Out Methods & Retention of Files 5.3 Alphabetic Filing Rules: Personal, Business, Organizational & Government Names

6 Chapter 6: Law Office Technology & Systems

6.1 Computer Hardware Components & Equipment Characteristics 6.2 Software, Operating Systems, Computer Systems & the Internet 6.3 Conflicts-Check Systems, Docket Automation & Electronic Document Processing

7 Chapter 7: Law Firm Billing, Accounting & Banking Procedures

7.1 Accounting Terminology, Balance Sheets, Income Statements & Timekeeping Records 7.2 Billing Clients, Retainers, Contingent & Forwarding Fees, Collection Charges & Advances 7.3 Firm and Trust Bank Accounts, Deposits, Endorsements, Checks & Special Instruments

8 Chapter 8: The American Legal System & Legal Authority

8.1 The Nature of Law, Common Law vs. Civil Law & Categorizing the Law 8.2 Federal and State Court Structures, Jurisdiction & Venue 8.3 Sources of Law & the Hierarchy of Legal Authority 8.4 Alternative Dispute Resolution: Negotiation, Mediation & Arbitration 8.5 Conflicts of Law & Legal and Court Systems Information

9 Chapter 9: Legal Research & Bluebook Citation Rules

9.1 Primary vs. Secondary Sources & Research Methodologies 9.2 Citators, Updating the Law & Electronic Legal Research 9.3 Bluebook Citation Rules for Cases, Statutes & Secondary Materials

10 Chapter 10: Civil Litigation Procedure & Pretrial Practice

10.1 Legal and Equitable Actions, Causes of Action, Parties & Special Procedures 10.2 Pretrial Pleadings: Complaints, Answers, Counterclaims & Service 10.3 Civil Discovery: Interrogatories, Depositions, RFPs & ESI Management 10.4 Pretrial Motions, Summary Judgment & Injunctions

11 Chapter 11: Trial Practice, Investigation & Office Procedures

11.1 Trial Preparation, Evidence Handling, Jury Instructions & Post-Trial Procedure 11.2 Costs, Execution of Judgment & Appeals 11.3 Factual Investigation & Client/Witness Interviewing 11.4 Law Office Docketing, Court Deadlines & Records Management

12 Chapter 12: Professional Responsibility & Unauthorized Practice of Law

12.1 NALS Code of Ethics & ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct 12.2 Unauthorized Practice of Law (UPL) & Permissible Paralegal Boundaries 12.3 Confidentiality, Non-Disclosure & Electronic Information Security 12.4 Attorney-Client Privilege & the Work Product Doctrine

13 Chapter 13: Conflicts, Financial Ethics & Professional Judgment

13.1 Conflicts of Interest, Imputation & Ethical Walls 13.2 Financial Ethics: Client Trust Accounts (IOLTA), Retainers & Billing 13.3 Candor to the Tribunal, Fairness & Ex Parte Communications 13.4 Professional Judgment, Human Relations & Ethical Problem-Solving

14 Chapter 14: Contracts & Commercial Law

14.1 Contract Formation: Offer, Acceptance, Consideration & Mutual Assent 14.2 Defenses to Formation, Contract Interpretation & Remedies for Breach 14.3 UCC Article 2: Sales, Warranties & Commercial Transactions

15 Chapter 15: Torts & Civil Liabilities

15.1 Negligence: Duty, Breach, Causation & Damages 15.2 Defenses to Negligence & Comparative Fault Principles 15.3 Intentional Torts, Strict Liability & Products Liability 15.4 Products Liability: Defenses, Limitations on Liability, Filing the Lawsuit & Practice

16 Chapter 16: Business Organizations & Corporate Governance

16.1 Sole Proprietorships, General Partnerships & Limited Partnerships 16.2 Limited Liability Companies (LLCs): Formation, Operating Agreements & Management 16.3 Corporations: Formation, Governance, Fiduciary Duties & Corporate Formalities

17 Chapter 17: Real Property & Estate Administration

17.1 Real Property Estates, Concurrent Ownership, Deeds & Title Examination 17.2 Real Estate Transactions, Closing Documents, Mortgages & Leases 17.3 Wills, Intestacy, Testamentary Formalities & Advance Directives 17.4 Trusts, Probate Administration & Non-Probate Asset Transfers 17.5 Conservatorships & Guardianships

18 Chapter 18: Family Law & Criminal Practice

18.1 Family Law: Marriage, Divorce, Custody, Support & Property Division 18.2 Criminal Law: Substantive Crimes, Elements & Defenses 18.3 Criminal Procedure: 4th, 5th & 6th Amendment Protections 18.4 Commencement of Proceedings, Misdemeanor Practice, Right to Counsel, Grand Jury & Disclosure 18.5 Plea Bargains, Trial Procedure, Sentencing & Post-Trial Motions 18.6 Juvenile Certification, Extradition, Habeas Corpus, Probation & Parole, Expungement & Sealing

19 Chapter 19: Administrative, Regulatory & Bankruptcy Law

19.1 Administrative Law Practice: Rulemaking, Adjudications & Judicial Review 19.2 Bankruptcy Law: Liquidation (Ch. 7), Reorganization (Ch. 11) & Wage Earner (Ch. 13) 19.3 Intellectual Property & Regulatory Compliance Basics

20 Chapter 20: Employment, Labor & Benefits Law

20.1 Federal Civil Rights & Employment Discrimination 20.2 Labor Law, Wage and Hour Rules & Employee Rights 20.3 Workers' Compensation, Pension & Profit-Sharing Plans

21 Chapter 21: Regulatory, Commercial & Specialized Practice Areas

21.1 Consumer Protection & Antitrust Law 21.2 Environmental Law, Water Rights, Oil & Gas 21.3 Admiralty & Maritime Law 21.4 Taxation Practice Basics 21.5 Immigration Law Basics

21.2 Environmental Law, Water Rights, Oil & Gas

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

NALS lists environmental, water, and oil and gas as three separate areas of law under Part 4 Legal Knowledge.

CERCLA imposes strict, joint and several, and retroactive liability on four categories of potentially responsible parties, and the innocent landowner and bona fide prospective purchaser defenses require all appropriate inquiries such as a Phase I environmental site assessment.

NEPA is procedural: it compels federal agencies to study and disclose environmental effects of major federal actions, not to choose the least damaging alternative.

Eastern states generally follow riparian rights tied to land bordering a watercourse, while western states generally follow prior appropriation under which the first to put water to beneficial use has the senior right.

The mineral estate is dominant over the surface estate once severed, giving the mineral owner an implied right of reasonable surface use to extract the minerals.

Last updated: September 2026

21.2 Environmental Law, Water Rights, Oil & Gas

Note

NALS PP Exam Blueprint Focus : Environmental, water, and oil and gas each appear as separate entries among the twenty-five areas of law NALS lists under Part 4 Legal Knowledge. They are grouped here because they all allocate rights in natural resources and because a single real estate or energy transaction routinely touches all three.

  • Part One: Environmental Law
  • The Major Federal Statutes

Statute What it does

National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) Requires federal agencies to assess the environmental effects of major federal actions significantly affecting the human environment

Clean Air Act National ambient air quality standards, state implementation plans, permitting for new and modified sources

Clean Water Act Prohibits discharge of pollutants from a point source to waters of the United States without an NPDES permit; Section 404 governs dredge and fill in wetlands

Safe Drinking Water Act Standards for public water systems; underground injection control

Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) Cradle-to-grave regulation of hazardous waste generation, transport, treatment, storage, and disposal, tracked by manifest

  • CERCLA (Superfund) Liability and cleanup for releases of hazardous substances at contaminated sites
  • Toxic Substances Control Act Chemical inventory, testing, and restrictions
  • Endangered Species Act Prohibits taking of listed species; consultation and incidental take permitting
  • FIFRA Pesticide registration and labeling
  • Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act Reporting of chemical inventories and toxic releases

Tip

NEPA is procedural, not substantive. It forces an agency to study and disclose environmental consequences and to consider alternatives. It does not require the agency to pick the environmentally preferable option. An agency that fully documents the harm and proceeds anyway has complied with NEPA. The process runs categorical exclusion, then environmental assessment leading either to a finding of no significant impact or to a full environmental impact statement.

CERCLA Liability

CERCLA liability is strict , joint and several , and retroactive — it reaches conduct that was entirely lawful when it occurred.

The four categories of potentially responsible parties

PRP category Who it captures

Current owner or operator Whoever owns or operates the facility now, even if they contributed nothing to the contamination

  • Owner or operator at the time of disposal Historic owners and operators during the disposal period
  • Arrangers (generators) Those who arranged for disposal or treatment of hazardous substances
  • Transporters Those who transported and selected the disposal site

The first category is what makes environmental due diligence indispensable in real estate practice: a purchaser who never spilled anything can become fully liable for a predecessor's contamination simply by taking title.

Defenses

The statutory defenses are narrow: an act of God, an act of war, and the third-party defense. Two derivative protections built on the third-party defense do the real work in transactions:

Protection Requirement

Innocent landowner Acquired the property without knowledge of contamination after conducting all appropriate inquiries before acquisition

Bona fide prospective purchaser Acquired with knowledge of contamination but performed all appropriate inquiries, disposed of nothing, and complies with continuing obligations including care and cooperation

Contiguous property owner Adjacent owner contaminated by migration from a neighboring site, with comparable diligence and cooperation requirements

All appropriate inquiries is satisfied by a compliant Phase I environmental site assessment : records review, site reconnaissance, interviews, and a report identifying recognized environmental conditions. A Phase I involves no sampling; if it identifies recognized environmental conditions, a Phase II with sampling and laboratory analysis follows. A Phase I has a limited shelf life and must be updated to remain current for the protections.

Cleanup and cost recovery

EPA may perform the cleanup and recover costs, or compel PRPs to perform it. PRPs may sue each other for contribution to allocate costs by equitable factors, and settling parties obtain contribution protection. Brownfields programs and state voluntary cleanup programs offer liability relief in exchange for supervised remediation, and institutional controls such as deed restrictions and environmental covenants often accompany a completed cleanup.

  • Part Two: Water Rights
  • Surface Water: Two Systems

Riparian rights Prior appropriation

Where Generally the eastern United States, where water is plentiful Generally the western United States, where water is scarce

Who holds the right Owners of land bordering the watercourse Whoever first put water to beneficial use , regardless of land location

Basis of priority All riparians share; use must be reasonable relative to other riparians First in time, first in right — seniority governs

Effect of non-use Right generally persists Right may be forfeited or abandoned for non-use

In shortage Riparians share the reduction Senior rights are satisfied in full before junior rights receive anything

Transferability Tied to the riparian land Often transferable separately from land

Some states apply a hybrid system recognizing riparian rights established before a statutory date and appropriative rights thereafter.

The prior appropriation elements are intent to appropriate, diversion, and application to a beneficial use , with the priority date fixed at initiation. Modern statutes administer the system through permits and adjudicated decrees, and a call by a senior right holder in a dry year shuts off junior diverters entirely.

Federal reserved water rights attach to federal reservations such as tribal lands and national parks, with a priority date as of the reservation and no requirement of actual diversion.

Groundwater Doctrines

  • Doctrine Rule
  • Absolute dominion (English rule) An overlying owner may pump without liability, subject to limited exceptions
  • Reasonable use (American rule) Pumping must be for a reasonable use, ordinarily on the overlying land
  • Correlative rights Overlying owners share a common supply proportionally in times of shortage
  • Prior appropriation Groundwater is allocated by seniority like surface water

Many states now manage groundwater through permits, designated management areas, and pumping limits, and increasingly recognize the hydrologic connection between groundwater and surface flows.

Related Concepts

Diffused surface water — runoff not in a defined channel; states apply the common enemy rule, the civil law rule, or a reasonable use rule to drainage disputes.

Navigability determines public rights of use and the boundary of state title to submerged lands.

Accretion, reliction, avulsion, and erosion govern how boundaries move when a watercourse shifts.

  • Part Three: Oil & Gas
  • Severance and the Dominant Mineral Estate

Land ownership can be split into a surface estate and a mineral estate . Once severed, the two can be conveyed, taxed, and encumbered independently.

Warning

The mineral estate is dominant. The mineral owner holds an implied right to make reasonable use of the surface as necessary to explore for and produce the minerals — access roads, well pads, pipelines — even over the surface owner's objection. Surface owners protect themselves through negotiated surface use agreements and, in some states, statutory accommodation doctrines requiring the operator to accommodate existing surface uses where reasonable alternatives exist.

The mineral estate comprises a bundle of rights: the right to develop, the right to lease (the executive right), the right to receive bonus payments, the right to receive delay rentals, and the right to receive royalty. Each can be conveyed separately, which is why title work in producing areas is intricate. A royalty interest is a non-cost-bearing share of production; a working interest bears the costs of drilling and operating.

The Rule of Capture and Correlative Rights

Under the rule of capture , an owner acquires title to the oil and gas produced from wells on that owner's land even if the hydrocarbons migrated from beneath a neighbor's tract. The rule drove wasteful competitive drilling, so states responded with correlative rights and conservation regulation: well spacing rules, allowable production limits, and prohibitions on waste, administered by a state conservation commission or oil and gas board.

The Oil and Gas Lease

An oil and gas lease is, in most producing states, a conveyance of an interest in real property rather than a simple lease.

  • Clause Function
  • Granting clause Conveys the right to explore, drill, and produce, and describes the leased premises

Habendum clause Sets the primary term , a fixed number of years, continuing into a secondary term for so long as oil or gas is produced in paying quantities

Royalty clause The lessor's cost-free share of production, historically one-eighth and frequently higher in modern leases

  • Bonus A lump sum paid at signing
  • Delay rental Payment to defer the obligation to drill during the primary term
  • Pooling clause Authorizes the lessee to combine the tract with others into a drilling unit
  • Shut-in royalty Maintains the lease when a well capable of production is shut in for lack of a market
  • Force majeure Extends obligations during specified events beyond the lessee's control

Pugh clause Severs undeveloped acreage or deeper formations from the held acreage at the end of the primary term

Courts also imply covenants into oil and gas leases, including duties to develop reasonably, to protect against drainage, and to market production.

Pooling and Unitization

Pooling combines small tracts into a single drilling unit satisfying spacing requirements, either voluntarily under a lease pooling clause or by compulsory or forced pooling ordered by the state regulator when an owner refuses to join. Unitization combines a whole field or reservoir for coordinated operation, typically for secondary recovery. Production anywhere in the unit is allocated to all tract owners by their proportionate share, which means production from a neighbor's tract can hold an owner's lease and generate royalty.

The Paralegal Workstream

  • Task Content
  • Title runsheets and chains Trace surface and mineral conveyances separately through the county records
  • Division orders Confirm decimal interests before revenue is distributed
  • Lease abstracting Extract terms, expiration dates, and obligations into a lease database
  • Regulatory filings Permits to drill, completion reports, spacing and pooling applications
  • Curative work Affidavits of heirship, corrective deeds, releases of expired leases
  • Environmental diligence Coordinate Phase I assessments and regulatory database reviews on acquisitions

Loading diagram... CERCLA Liability and the Diligence That Defeats It