Study guide
Non-Organic Hearing Loss, Pseudohypacusis & Stenger Testing
Praxis Audiology 5343
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Acoustics, Psychoacoustics & Sound Measurement
Physics of Sound, Wave Propagation & Decibel Scales (SPL, HL, SL) Psychoacoustics, Equal Loudness Contours & Frequency Selectivity Speech Acoustics, Formant Structure & Auditory Perception
2 Auditory and Vestibular Anatomy and Physiology
Peripheral Auditory System: Outer, Middle & Inner Ear Transduction Vestibular End Organs, Semicircular Canals & Otolith Mechanics Central Auditory Pathways, Neuroanatomy & Lifespan Structural Maturation Auditory Behavior, Speech-Language Development & Effects of Hearing Loss Across the Lifespan
3 Auditory Pathologies, Genetics & Instrumentation
Outer, Middle, and Inner Ear Pathologies & Genetic Syndromes Nongenetic Systemic Conditions & Infectious Causes of Hearing and Balance Disorders Ototoxic Medications, Pharmacology & Monitoring Protocols Audiometric Instrumentation, Calibration Standards (ANSI S3.6) & Psychometrics
4 Prevention, Lifespan Screening & Hearing Conservation
Universal Newborn Hearing Screening & JCIH Protocols Pediatric and School-Age Hearing Screening Procedures Adult and Geriatric Hearing Screening & Self-Assessment Measures Screening for Speech-Language, Cognitive & Other Conditions and Screening Program Performance Occupational Hearing Conservation, Noise Exposure & OSHA Regulations Hearing Health Education, Fall-Risk Identification & Audiometric and Balance Monitoring
5 Behavioral Pure-Tone Audiometry & Masking
Clinical Preparation: Case History, Otoscopy & Selecting and Modifying Tests Air and Bone Conduction Pure-Tone Testing & Audiogram Interpretation Clinical Masking Principles, Interaural Attenuation & Plateau Method Non-Organic Hearing Loss, Pseudohypacusis & Stenger Testing
6 Speech Audiometry & Pediatric Behavioral Evaluation
Speech Detection & Recognition Thresholds (SDT/SRT) & Word Recognition (WRS) Speech-in-Noise Testing, PB-Max & Retrocochlear Rollover Diagnostics Central Auditory Processing Assessment: Dichotic, Temporal, Spatial & Low-Redundancy Tests Pediatric Behavioral Audiometry: BOA, VRA, and CPA
7 Acoustic Immittance & Middle Ear Diagnostics
Tympanometric Principles, Jerger Classification & Eustachian Tube Function Acoustic Reflex Thresholds, Reflex Arc Pathways & Reflex Decay Analysis Multi-Frequency Immittance, High-Frequency Probe Tones & Infant Protocols
8 Otoacoustic Emissions & Auditory Evoked Potentials
Transient and Distortion Product Otoacoustic Emissions (TEOAE & DPOAE) Auditory Brainstem Response (ABR) Diagnostic Protocols & Wave Analysis ASSR, Electrocochleography (ECochG) & Late Auditory Evoked Potentials
9 Vestibular & Balance Assessment
Videonystagmography (VNG), Oculomotor Tracking & Positional Nystagmus Bithermal Caloric Testing, Jongkees Formula & Rotational Chair Evaluation Video Head Impulse Test (vHIT), VEMP (cVEMP/oVEMP) & Dynamic Posturography (CDP) Integrating Assessment Results, Differential Diagnosis & Reporting
10 Hearing Aid Selection, Features & Prescriptive Fitting
Treatment Planning, Goal Setting, Progress Monitoring & Intervention Documentation Hearing Aid Components, Acoustic Transducers & Digital Signal Processing Prescriptive Fitting Targets (NAL-NL2 vs. DSL m[i/o]) & Dynamic Range CROS, BiCROS & Severe-to-Profound Fitting Strategies
11 Amplification Verification, Validation & Troubleshooting
Probe-Microphone Real-Ear Verification (REUR, REAR, REIG & RECD) ANSI S3.22 Electroacoustic Analysis & Quality Control Standards Clinical Validation Inventories (COSI, APHAB, SSQ) & Device Troubleshooting
12 Implantable Devices & Hearing Assistive Technology
Bone-Conduction Systems (BAHS) & Active Middle Ear Implants Cochlear Implants: Candidacy, Telemetry, MAPping Parameters & ABI Systems Hearing Assistive Technology, FM/DM Classroom Systems & Telecoils
13 Aural Rehabilitation, Tinnitus & Vestibular Management
Adult and Pediatric Aural Rehabilitation & Communication Strategies Tinnitus Management, Sound Therapy & Decreased Sound Tolerance Protocols Canalith Repositioning Maneuvers for BPPV & Vestibular Rehabilitation Therapy (VRT)
14 Ethics, Scope of Practice & Interprofessional Collaboration
ASHA and AAA Codes of Ethics, Ethical Decision-Making & Conflict of Interest Clinical Scope of Practice, CCC-A Credentialing, Licensure & Clinical Supervision Service Delivery Models, Practice Management, Risk Management & Advocacy Patient/Family Counseling & Interprofessional Practice in Education and Healthcare
15 Regulatory Compliance, Safety & Evidence-Based Practice
Federal Regulations (HIPAA, FERPA, ADA, OSHA), Billing Compliance & Infection Control Evidence-Based Practice, Research Methodology & Teleaudiology Service Delivery
Non-Organic Hearing Loss, Pseudohypacusis & Stenger Testing
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Pseudohypacusis (functional or non-organic hearing loss) denotes an exaggerated or fabricated hearing loss with no organic anatomical pathology, encompassing conscious deception (malingering, typically for monetary/disability gain) and unconscious conversion disorders (psychogenic loss).
Hallmark behavioral red flags include a pure-tone average to speech recognition threshold discrepancy ( ∣ PTA − SRT ∣ > 10 − 12 dB |\text{PTA} - \text{SRT}| > 10-12\,\text{dB} ∣ PTA − SRT ∣ > 10 − 12 dB , where SRT is consistently lower/better than PTA due to spondee loudness growth and acoustic envelope cues) and the absence of a shadow curve in apparent unilateral profound loss.
The Stenger phenomenon dictates that when two identical tones are presented simultaneously to both ears, the brain perceives the sound exclusively in the ear where the sensation level is higher, completely suppressing awareness of the tone in the contralateral ear.
The Stenger test is indicated for unilateral or asymmetrical hearing loss ( ≥ 20 dB \ge 20\,\text{dB} ≥ 20 dB difference); presenting a tone at + 10 dB SL +10\,\text{dB SL} + 10 dB SL in the better ear and − 10 dB -10\,\text{dB} − 10 dB relative to admitted threshold in the poorer ear produces a 'positive Stenger' when the patient stops responding, establishing non-organic loss.
The Minimum Stenger Level (MSL) quantifies the patient's true threshold within 10 − 15 dB 10-15\,\text{dB} 10 − 15 dB without patient cooperation, while objective physiological cross-checks—including Acoustic Reflex Thresholds at negative sensation levels, robust OAEs, and threshold ABR Wave V—provide definitive proof of normal auditory function.
Last updated: October 2026
Non-Organic Hearing Loss, Pseudohypacusis & Stenger Testing
Identifying and managing non-organic hearing loss is a vital clinical competency in audiology. Non-organic hearing loss occurs frequently in medical-legal compensation claims, veterans' disability evaluations, industrial injury litigation, pediatric school-avoidance behaviors, and psychiatric distress. Audiologists must identify false or exaggerated thresholds, estimate true hearing sensitivity, and maintain an objective, non-adversarial clinical relationship.
Diagnostic Terminology & Etiological Spectrum
Precise clinical terminology is legally and diagnostically essential in audiologic medical records.
Clinical Term Formal Definition Intentionality & Underlying Mechanism
Pseudohypacusis Demonstrable exaggeration or fabrication of auditory thresholds beyond true physiological sensitivity. Broad descriptive term; does not imply conscious versus unconscious intent. Highly preferred in clinical charting.
Non-Organic Hearing Loss Hearing loss in the absence of an identifiable organic, anatomical, or physiological lesion of the auditory system. Neutral clinical descriptor used interchangeably with pseudohypacusis.
Functional Hearing Loss Hearing loss where the auditory system functions abnormally during behavioral testing despite organic integrity. Medical-legal descriptor; synonymous with non-organic loss.
Malingering The deliberate, conscious fabrication or exaggeration of physical symptoms for secondary gain. Conscious, intentional deception driven by external incentives (financial compensation, disability ratings, litigation, military exemption).
Psychogenic Hearing Loss True non-organic hearing loss resulting from psychological conflict, trauma, or emotional stress. Unconscious, non-volitional symptom generation (DSM-5 conversion disorder/somatic symptom disorder). The patient genuinely believes they are deaf.
Factitious Disorder Deliberate fabrication of symptoms to assume the sick role without external monetary incentives. Conscious symptom fabrication driven by internal psychiatric needs (Münchausen syndrome).
Medical-Legal Charting Caveat: Audiologists should never document "malingering" in the medical record. Malingering denotes legal and criminal intent, which cannot be proven by behavioral test results alone. Always use objective terms: "Results demonstrate non-organic hearing loss / pseudohypacusis" or "Behavioral thresholds are inconsistent with objective electrophysiologic measures."
Clinical Behavioral Indicators & "Red Flags"
Experienced clinicians recognize behavioral patterns that signal pseudohypacusis prior to and during audiometric testing:
Inconsistent Intake vs. Formal Test Behaviors
Casual Communication vs. Booth Straining: The patient converses effortlessly with the clinician in the waiting room at normal speech levels ( 50 − 60 dB SPL 50-60\,\text{dB SPL} 50 − 60 dB SPL ) without visual cues, but in the sound suite demonstrates exaggerated straining, cupping their ears, or claiming inability to hear speech presented at 70 dB HL 70\,\text{dB HL} 70 dB HL .
Exaggerated Reliance on Lipreading: The patient stares intensely at the clinician's mouth and covers their own ears, yet immediately ceases this behavior when the clinician speaks softly while writing or facing away.
Pure-Tone Audiometric Behaviors
Unusual Response Latencies: Excessively slow, hesitant, or delayed responses. The patient waits several seconds after tone termination before pressing the response button, attempting to evaluate tone loudness.
False-Positive Absence: A total absence of false-positive responses. Patients with organic hearing loss near threshold frequently guess or demonstrate occasional false alarms; patients with pseudohypacusis rarely respond unless they are certain a sound is above their chosen criteria.
Ascending vs. Descending Discrepancy ( > 10 dB > 10\,\text{dB} > 10 dB ): In organic hearing loss, ascending and descending thresholds agree within ± 5 dB \pm 5\,\text{dB} ± 5 dB . In pseudohypacusis, descending thresholds are routinely 10 − 20 dB 10-20\,\text{dB} 10 − 20 dB better (lower) than ascending thresholds because the patient loses their mental "loudness anchor" as sound intensity decreases.
The Pediatric "Yes-No" Test: In children feigning hearing loss, instruct: "Say 'Yes' when you hear the beep, and say 'No' when you don't hear it." A child with pseudohypacusis will consistently reply "No" immediately following sub-threshold tone presentations, proving auditory detection.
- The Classic PTA-SRT Discrepancy
- The Audiological Cross-Check Rule
In an organic hearing loss, the 3-frequency pure-tone average (PTA across 500, 1000, and 2000 Hz) and the Speech Recognition Threshold (SRT) must agree within ± 6 dB \pm 6\,\text{dB} ± 6 dB (maximum allowable variance ± 10 − 12 dB \pm 10-12\,\text{dB} ± 10 − 12 dB in sharply sloping losses when using the 2-frequency Fletcher average):
- ∣ PTA − SRT ∣ ≤ 6 − 10 dB |\text{PTA} - \text{SRT}| \le 6-10\,\text{dB} ∣ PTA − SRT ∣ ≤ 6 − 10 dB
- The Pseudohypacusic Discrepancy Pattern
In non-organic hearing loss, a dramatic discrepancy is observed where the SRT is significantly better (lower in dB HL) than the PTA :
PTA − SRT > 12 dB ( frequently 20 − 50 dB better ) \text{PTA} - \text{SRT} > 12\,\text{dB} \quad (\text{frequently } 20-50\,\text{dB better}) PTA − SRT > 12 dB ( frequently 20 − 50 dB better )
Psychoacoustic Mechanism: Why is the SRT consistently better than the PTA in pseudohypacusis?
Spondee Loudness Growth & Redundancy: Spondaic words (bisyllabic words with equal stress: baseball , hotdog , ice cream , cowboy ) possess broad spectral energy and high semantic redundancy. The psychometric intelligibility function for spondees is exceptionally steep, rising from 0 % 0\% 0% to 100 % 100\% 100% over a narrow dynamic range of only 8 − 10 dB 8-10\,\text{dB} 8 − 10 dB .
Cognitive Loudness Estimation: It is cognitively difficult for an untrained listener to judge loudness sensation for complex speech. At 10 − 15 dB 10-15\,\text{dB} 10 − 15 dB above true threshold, spondees sound remarkably clear and loud. The patient perceives the word clearly and involuntarily repeats it, assuming it is being presented at a high conversational level. Conversely, single pure tones allow the patient to consciously suppress responses until a specific subjective loudness criterion is met.
Diagnostic Warning: An SRT that is significantly poorer (worse) than the PTA ( ∣ SRT − PTA ∣ > 10 dB |\text{SRT} - \text{PTA}| > 10\,\text{dB} ∣ SRT − PTA ∣ > 10 dB with poor speech) does not indicate pseudohypacusis. This pattern suggests retrocochlear pathology, Auditory Neuropathy Spectrum Disorder (ANSD), central auditory processing disorder, cognitive decline, or non-native language fluency.
- Absence of Expected Cross-Hearing ("Shadow Curves")
- Physical Laws of Cranial Transmission
In patients reporting an apparent severe or profound unilateral hearing loss, the physical laws of interaural attenuation dictate that cross-hearing must occur during unmasked testing:
Supra-aural headphones: IA = 40 dB \text{IA} = 40\,\text{dB} IA = 40 dB .
Insert earphones: IA \text{IA} IA about 50 − 70 dB 50-70\,\text{dB} 50 − 70 dB (frequency dependent).
Bone conduction vibrator: IA = 0 dB \text{IA} = 0\,\text{dB} IA = 0 dB .
The Shadow Curve Diagnostic Marker
If a patient reports a normal left ear ( 0 − 10 dB HL 0-10\,\text{dB HL} 0 − 10 dB HL ) and claims a total, profound right-ear hearing loss (no responses at 90 − 110 dB HL 90-110\,\text{dB HL} 90 − 110 dB HL unmasked):
When a tone is presented to the right ear at 100 dB HL 100\,\text{dB HL} 100 dB HL via supra-aural headphones, the sound cross-attenuates by 40 dB 40\,\text{dB} 40 dB and arrives at the left cochlea at 60 dB HL 60\,\text{dB HL} 60 dB HL .
Because the left cochlea has a 0 − 10 dB HL 0-10\,\text{dB HL} 0 − 10 dB HL threshold, the left cochlea perceives that sound with a roaring sensation level of + 50 dB SL +50\,\text{dB SL} + 50 dB SL !
A patient with true organic unilateral deafness cannot prevent their normal ear from hearing that crossed tone ; they will reliably respond, producing an unmasked shadow curve at 40 − 50 dB HL 40-50\,\text{dB HL} 40 − 50 dB HL .
If the patient produces unmasked right-ear thresholds of 100 dB HL 100\,\text{dB HL} 100 dB HL or "no response" without a shadow curve, this violates basic cranial acoustic physics. The absence of a shadow curve in unilateral profound hearing loss is definitive proof of non-organic hearing loss .
- The Stenger Phenomenon & Clinical Stenger Protocol
- The Psychoacoustic Stenger Phenomenon
Discovered by German otolaryngologist Paul Stenger in 1900, the Stenger phenomenon states:
When two identical acoustic signals (identical frequency and phase) are presented simultaneously to both ears, the brain perceives the sound exclusively in the ear where the sound has a higher sensation level (SL). The listener is completely unaware of the sound presented to the contralateral ear.
Patient Candidacy for the Stenger Test
The Stenger test is indicated whenever an asymmetrical hearing loss is present, defined as an interaural threshold difference of 20 dB 20\,\text{dB} 20 dB or greater at any test frequency ( 250 − 8000 Hz 250-8000\,\text{Hz} 250 − 8000 Hz ) or for speech stimuli (Speech Stenger).
Step-by-Step Stenger Test Protocol
Consider a patient with the following admitted thresholds at 1000 Hz 1000\,\text{Hz} 1000 Hz :
Better Ear (Right): Admitted Threshold = 10 dB HL = 10\,\text{dB HL} = 10 dB HL
Poorer Ear (Left): Admitted Threshold = 70 dB HL = 70\,\text{dB HL} = 70 dB HL (Interaural difference = 60 dB ≥ 20 dB = 60\,\text{dB} \ge 20\,\text{dB} = 60 dB ≥ 20 dB )
Step 1 (Better Ear Verification): Present tone to the better ear alone at + 10 dB SL +10\,\text{dB SL} + 10 dB SL ( 10 + 10 = 20 dB HL 10 + 10 = 20\,\text{dB HL} 10 + 10 = 20 dB HL ). Patient responds reliably.
Step 2 (Poorer Ear Verification): Present tone to the poorer ear alone at 10 dB 10\,\text{dB} 10 dB below admitted threshold ( 70 − 10 = 60 dB HL 70 - 10 = 60\,\text{dB HL} 70 − 10 = 60 dB HL ). Patient does not respond (consistent with their admitted 70 dB 70\,\text{dB} 70 dB threshold).
Step 3 (Simultaneous Stenger Presentation): Present both tones simultaneously using an interlocked dual-channel audiometer:
Better Ear (Right): 20 dB HL 20\,\text{dB HL} 20 dB HL ( + 10 dB SL +10\,\text{dB SL} + 10 dB SL )
Poorer Ear (Left): 60 dB HL 60\,\text{dB HL} 60 dB HL ( − 10 dB -10\,\text{dB} − 10 dB below admitted threshold)
Interpreting Stenger Test Results
Result Type Patient Action Underlying Psychoacoustic Mechanism Diagnostic Interpretation
Negative Stenger Patient RESPONDS The true threshold in the poorer ear is indeed ≥ 60 dB HL \ge 60\,\text{dB HL} ≥ 60 dB HL ; therefore, the 60 dB 60\,\text{dB} 60 dB tone in that ear is inaudible. The patient hears only the audible + 10 dB SL +10\,\text{dB SL} + 10 dB SL tone in the better ear and presses the response button. Organic Hearing Loss. Confirms that the poorer ear threshold is genuinely at least 60 dB HL 60\,\text{dB HL} 60 dB HL .
Positive Stenger Patient DOES NOT RESPOND The true threshold in the poorer ear is actually normal or mild (e.g., 15 dB HL 15\,\text{dB HL} 15 dB HL ). Therefore, the 60 dB 60\,\text{dB} 60 dB tone is heard at + 45 dB SL +45\,\text{dB SL} + 45 dB SL in the poorer ear, while the better ear receives only + 10 dB SL +10\,\text{dB SL} + 10 dB SL . By the Stenger phenomenon, the tone is perceived loudly and exclusively in the poorer ear. Because the patient is feigning deafness in that ear, they refuse to respond. However, if the tone in the poorer ear were truly inaudible, they would have responded to the clearly audible + 10 dB SL +10\,\text{dB SL} + 10 dB SL tone in the good ear! Non-Organic Hearing Loss (Pseudohypacusis). Proves conclusively that the true threshold in the poorer ear is better than the level presented ( < 60 dB HL < 60\,\text{dB HL} < 60 dB HL ).
Minimum Stenger Level (MSL) Procedure
The Minimum Stenger Level (MSL) procedure allows the audiologist to accurately estimate true auditory threshold in the poorer ear without the patient's active cooperation:
Keep the tone in the better ear fixed at + 10 dB SL +10\,\text{dB SL} + 10 dB SL ( 20 dB HL 20\,\text{dB HL} 20 dB HL ).
Introduce the tone to the poorer ear at 0 dB HL 0\,\text{dB HL} 0 dB HL simultaneously. The patient responds (heard in better ear).
Increase the tone level in the poorer ear in 5 dB 5\,\text{dB} 5 dB steps while maintaining the tone in the better ear at 20 dB HL 20\,\text{dB HL} 20 dB HL .
The lowest intensity in the poorer ear at which the patient stops responding is the Minimum Stenger Level (MSL) .
Clinical Rule: The patient's true auditory threshold in the poorer ear is typically within 10 − 15 dB 10-15\,\text{dB} 10 − 15 dB of the MSL!
Objective Physiological Cross-Checks
When non-organic hearing loss is confirmed or suspected, behavioral thresholds cannot be used for clinical decision-making. Objective physiological cross-checks provide unassailable proof of true auditory sensitivity independent of patient volition.
1. Acoustic Reflex Thresholds (ARTs)
Normal ART Range: Stapedial acoustic reflexes in normal ears occur at pure-tone levels of 70 − 95 dB HL 70-95\,\text{dB HL} 70 − 95 dB HL ( 70 − 90 dB SL 70-90\,\text{dB SL} 70 − 90 dB SL ). In sensory hearing losses up to 50 − 60 dB HL 50-60\,\text{dB HL} 50 − 60 dB HL , recruitment preserves reflexes at normal absolute levels ( 75 − 95 dB HL 75-95\,\text{dB HL} 75 − 95 dB HL ).
The "Negative Sensation Level" Rule: An acoustic reflex cannot occur below the true behavioral threshold of an ear. If a patient claims an admitted behavioral threshold of 85 dB HL 85\,\text{dB HL} 85 dB HL , but ipsilateral acoustic reflexes are robustly elicited at 75 dB HL 75\,\text{dB HL} 75 dB HL (a − 10 dB SL -10\,\text{dB SL} − 10 dB SL presentation!), pseudohypacusis is definitively proven.
2. Otoacoustic Emissions (OAEs: DPOAE & TEOAE)
Physiology: Distortion Product (DPOAE) and Transient-Evoked (TEOAE) otoacoustic emissions measure outer hair cell (OHC) electromotility within the organ of Corti.
Clinical Cross-Check: Robust, normal OAEs (signal-to-noise ratio ≥ 6 dB \ge 6\,\text{dB} ≥ 6 dB with reproducibility > 70 % > 70\% > 70% ) require normal middle-ear transmission and outer hair cell integrity, which occurs only when pure-tone thresholds are ≤ 25 − 30 dB HL \le 25-30\,\text{dB HL} ≤ 25 − 30 dB HL .
If a patient produces an audiogram showing a 60 dB HL 60\,\text{dB HL} 60 dB HL sensorineural loss, but exhibits normal Type A tympanograms and robust, full-spectrum DPOAEs, a substantial sensorineural hearing loss is objectively ruled out. (Note: Intact OAEs with abnormal behavioral thresholds can also indicate Auditory Neuropathy Spectrum Disorder; verify with acoustic reflexes and ABR).
3. Threshold Auditory Brainstem Response (ABR)
Tone-burst ABR (at 500, 1000, 2000, and 4000 Hz) provides frequency-specific electrophysiologic threshold estimation; after nHL-to-eHL correction, estimates usually fall within about 10 − 20 dB 10-20\,\text{dB} 10 − 20 dB of behavioral thresholds.
Identification of Wave V down to 15 − 20 dB nHL 15-20\,\text{dB nHL} 15 − 20 dB nHL provides objective, medical-legal proof of normal peripheral and brainstem auditory pathway transmission.
Ethical Clinical Management & De-escalation Strategy
When pseudohypacusis is identified, confronting the patient aggressively ( "You are faking this test" ) is therapeutically counterproductive, destroys rapport, and prompts defensiveness or legal confrontation.
The "Re-Instruction Escape Hatch"
The gold standard audiologic strategy is providing the patient with an honorable, face-saving exit:
Pause the evaluation and remove the earphones.
Reinstruct using honest, neutral phrasing that does not accuse: "Some of your responses are not lining up with our other measurements, which can happen when people wait until a sound is clearly loud. Let's review the instructions: press the button for even the faintest sound you think you hear, even if it seems far away."
Re-test ascending thresholds starting at low intensities. This face-saving re-instruction often resolves the discrepancy without confrontation.