Study guide
Speech-in-Noise Testing, PB-Max & Retrocochlear Rollover Diagnostics
Praxis Audiology 5343
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Acoustics, Psychoacoustics & Sound Measurement
Physics of Sound, Wave Propagation & Decibel Scales (SPL, HL, SL) Psychoacoustics, Equal Loudness Contours & Frequency Selectivity Speech Acoustics, Formant Structure & Auditory Perception
2 Auditory and Vestibular Anatomy and Physiology
Peripheral Auditory System: Outer, Middle & Inner Ear Transduction Vestibular End Organs, Semicircular Canals & Otolith Mechanics Central Auditory Pathways, Neuroanatomy & Lifespan Structural Maturation Auditory Behavior, Speech-Language Development & Effects of Hearing Loss Across the Lifespan
3 Auditory Pathologies, Genetics & Instrumentation
Outer, Middle, and Inner Ear Pathologies & Genetic Syndromes Nongenetic Systemic Conditions & Infectious Causes of Hearing and Balance Disorders Ototoxic Medications, Pharmacology & Monitoring Protocols Audiometric Instrumentation, Calibration Standards (ANSI S3.6) & Psychometrics
4 Prevention, Lifespan Screening & Hearing Conservation
Universal Newborn Hearing Screening & JCIH Protocols Pediatric and School-Age Hearing Screening Procedures Adult and Geriatric Hearing Screening & Self-Assessment Measures Screening for Speech-Language, Cognitive & Other Conditions and Screening Program Performance Occupational Hearing Conservation, Noise Exposure & OSHA Regulations Hearing Health Education, Fall-Risk Identification & Audiometric and Balance Monitoring
5 Behavioral Pure-Tone Audiometry & Masking
Clinical Preparation: Case History, Otoscopy & Selecting and Modifying Tests Air and Bone Conduction Pure-Tone Testing & Audiogram Interpretation Clinical Masking Principles, Interaural Attenuation & Plateau Method Non-Organic Hearing Loss, Pseudohypacusis & Stenger Testing
6 Speech Audiometry & Pediatric Behavioral Evaluation
Speech Detection & Recognition Thresholds (SDT/SRT) & Word Recognition (WRS) Speech-in-Noise Testing, PB-Max & Retrocochlear Rollover Diagnostics Central Auditory Processing Assessment: Dichotic, Temporal, Spatial & Low-Redundancy Tests Pediatric Behavioral Audiometry: BOA, VRA, and CPA
7 Acoustic Immittance & Middle Ear Diagnostics
Tympanometric Principles, Jerger Classification & Eustachian Tube Function Acoustic Reflex Thresholds, Reflex Arc Pathways & Reflex Decay Analysis Multi-Frequency Immittance, High-Frequency Probe Tones & Infant Protocols
8 Otoacoustic Emissions & Auditory Evoked Potentials
Transient and Distortion Product Otoacoustic Emissions (TEOAE & DPOAE) Auditory Brainstem Response (ABR) Diagnostic Protocols & Wave Analysis ASSR, Electrocochleography (ECochG) & Late Auditory Evoked Potentials
9 Vestibular & Balance Assessment
Videonystagmography (VNG), Oculomotor Tracking & Positional Nystagmus Bithermal Caloric Testing, Jongkees Formula & Rotational Chair Evaluation Video Head Impulse Test (vHIT), VEMP (cVEMP/oVEMP) & Dynamic Posturography (CDP) Integrating Assessment Results, Differential Diagnosis & Reporting
10 Hearing Aid Selection, Features & Prescriptive Fitting
Treatment Planning, Goal Setting, Progress Monitoring & Intervention Documentation Hearing Aid Components, Acoustic Transducers & Digital Signal Processing Prescriptive Fitting Targets (NAL-NL2 vs. DSL m[i/o]) & Dynamic Range CROS, BiCROS & Severe-to-Profound Fitting Strategies
11 Amplification Verification, Validation & Troubleshooting
Probe-Microphone Real-Ear Verification (REUR, REAR, REIG & RECD) ANSI S3.22 Electroacoustic Analysis & Quality Control Standards Clinical Validation Inventories (COSI, APHAB, SSQ) & Device Troubleshooting
12 Implantable Devices & Hearing Assistive Technology
Bone-Conduction Systems (BAHS) & Active Middle Ear Implants Cochlear Implants: Candidacy, Telemetry, MAPping Parameters & ABI Systems Hearing Assistive Technology, FM/DM Classroom Systems & Telecoils
13 Aural Rehabilitation, Tinnitus & Vestibular Management
Adult and Pediatric Aural Rehabilitation & Communication Strategies Tinnitus Management, Sound Therapy & Decreased Sound Tolerance Protocols Canalith Repositioning Maneuvers for BPPV & Vestibular Rehabilitation Therapy (VRT)
14 Ethics, Scope of Practice & Interprofessional Collaboration
ASHA and AAA Codes of Ethics, Ethical Decision-Making & Conflict of Interest Clinical Scope of Practice, CCC-A Credentialing, Licensure & Clinical Supervision Service Delivery Models, Practice Management, Risk Management & Advocacy Patient/Family Counseling & Interprofessional Practice in Education and Healthcare
15 Regulatory Compliance, Safety & Evidence-Based Practice
Federal Regulations (HIPAA, FERPA, ADA, OSHA), Billing Compliance & Infection Control Evidence-Based Practice, Research Methodology & Teleaudiology Service Delivery
Speech-in-Noise Testing, PB-Max & Retrocochlear Rollover Diagnostics
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Performance-Intensity (PI-PB) functions differentiate conductive, cochlear, and retrocochlear pathologies: conductive losses shift the curve rightward without reducing PB-Max, cochlear losses depress PB-Max, and retrocochlear lesions produce marked rollover.
The Rollover Index is computed as RI = ( P B max − P B min ) / P B max \text{RI} = (PB_{\text{max}} - PB_{\text{min}}) / PB_{\text{max}} RI = ( P B max − P B min ) / P B max , where an RI > 0.45 \text{RI} > 0.45 RI > 0.45 on PAL PB-50 lists (or roughly 0.25 0.25 0.25 to 0.35 0.35 0.35 on NU-6 lists) suggests an eighth nerve lesion such as vestibular schwannoma.
Speech-in-noise evaluation captures real-world communication impairment that standard quiet tests miss, identifying deficits associated with cochlear synaptopathy ('hidden hearing loss') and auditory processing disorders.
The QuickSIN protocol quantifies Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) loss via SNR Loss = 25.5 − Total Words Correct \text{SNR Loss} = 25.5 - \text{Total Words Correct} SNR Loss = 25.5 − Total Words Correct ; losses > 15 dB > 15\,\text{dB} > 15 dB (severe) indicate that hearing aids alone are unlikely to suffice and remote microphone technology (FM/DM) is strongly recommended.
BKB-SIN provides a validated sentence-in-noise alternative for pediatrics and adults with severe impairment, whereas WIN and HINT quantify lexical recognition and binaural spatial release from masking.
Last updated: October 2026
Speech-in-Noise Testing, PB-Max & Retrocochlear Rollover Diagnostics
Pure-tone audiometry and quiet word recognition testing assess only basic auditory sensitivity and maximal speech resolution under idealized, anechoic conditions. However, patients rarely complain of communication breakdowns in quiet, isolated sound booths; their primary functional deficit occurs in dynamic, competitive acoustic environments featuring multi-talker babble and reverberation. Furthermore, quiet testing frequently demonstrates ceiling effects that fail to expose neural transmission bottlenecks characteristic of retrocochlear lesions. Suprathreshold Performance-Intensity functions, retrocochlear rollover quantification, and speech-in-noise test batteries provide the essential diagnostic bridge between laboratory audibility and real-world auditory disability.
Performance-Intensity (PI) Functions for Speech
A Performance-Intensity (PI) function is a graphical plot illustrating a patient's speech recognition accuracy (percentage correct on the ordinate) across systematic increments of speech presentation level in dB HL \text{dB HL} dB HL or dB SL \text{dB SL} dB SL (on the abscissa).
Psychometric Slopes: Spondees vs. Monosyllables
PI-Spondee Function: As noted in basic speech audiometry, spondees contain high lexical redundancy, balanced stress, and dual acoustic syllables. The psychometric slope of the PI-spondee function is exceptionally steep, averaging 10 % 10\% 10% to 12 % 12\% 12% per decibel near threshold. It rises rapidly from 0 % 0\% 0% to 100 % 100\% 100% over a narrow span of 10 − 12 dB 10-12\,\text{dB} 10 − 12 dB .
PI-PB Function (Phonetically Balanced Monosyllables): Monosyllabic words (NU-6, CID W-22) lack linguistic redundancy. The slope of the PI-PB function in normal-hearing individuals is substantially shallower, averaging 4 % 4\% 4% to 5 % 5\% 5% per decibel . Normal listeners require approximately 25 − 30 dB 25-30\,\text{dB} 25 − 30 dB above their SRT (i.e., + 25 +25 + 25 to + 30 dB SL +30\,\text{dB SL} + 30 dB SL ) to attain maximum discrimination, reaching a 100 % 100\% 100% ceiling that plateaus stably up to high presentation levels ( 90 − 100 dB HL 90-100\,\text{dB HL} 90 − 100 dB HL ).
Morphological Profiles Across Auditory Pathologies
The morphology of the PI-PB function serves as an invaluable differential diagnostic indicator across the peripheral and central auditory pathways:
Conductive Hearing Loss: The middle ear attenuation acts as a simple mechanical volume control. The entire PI-PB function maintains its normal steep slope ( 4 − 5 % / dB 4-5\%/\text{dB} 4 − 5%/ dB ) and reaches a normal ceiling ( 96 − 100 % 96-100\% 96 − 100% ), but the curve is shifted horizontally to the right by an amount precisely equal to the air-bone gap.
Cochlear (Sensorineural) Hearing Loss: Damage to the active cochlear amplifier (outer hair cell loss) and elevated basilar membrane damping cause two characteristic alterations:
The slope of the curve becomes shallower ( 2 − 3 % / dB 2-3\%/\text{dB} 2 − 3%/ dB ).
The maximum score ( PB-Max ) is depressed (typically between 50 % 50\% 50% and 90 % 90\% 90% depending on the severity of inner hair cell loss and high-frequency configuration).
At high presentation levels ( 85 − 100 dB HL 85-100\,\text{dB HL} 85 − 100 dB HL ), the curve reaches a plateau, occasionally showing a slight, physiologically benign drop ( < 10 − 15 % < 10-15\% < 10 − 15% ) due to mechanical distortion and recruitment.
Retrocochlear (Eighth Nerve) Pathology: Pathologies affecting the acoustic nerve (cranial nerve VIII)—such as vestibular schwannomas (acoustic neuromas), cerebellopontine angle meningiomas, or auditory neuropathy spectrum disorder—produce a catastrophic breakdown in speech processing at high intensities known as rollover .
PB-Max & The Retrocochlear Rollover Phenomenon
PB-Max is defined as the absolute maximum word recognition percentage achieved by a patient at any presentation level across their individual Performance-Intensity function. It represents the patient's ultimate speech recognition potential when audibility is maximized.
Neurophysiological Mechanism of Rollover
In normal auditory nerve fibers, increasing stimulus intensity accelerates neural firing rates and recruits adjacent fibers up to physiological saturation. However, when an acoustic neuroma compresses the eighth cranial nerve, or when demyelinating disease impairs axonal conduction:
The compressed, demyelinated fibers cannot sustain high-frequency action potential generation.
Under high-intensity acoustic drive, neural refractoriness increases, synaptic transmitter stores at the inner hair cell ribbon synapse become depleted, and neural conduction blocks occur.
Crucially, the spatial and temporal phase-locking of the neural volley is obliterated. The central nervous system receives a severely desynchronized, degraded neural discharge, resulting in a paradoxical, dramatic collapse in speech intelligibility as the stimulus is made louder.
The Rollover Index (RI) Formula
To objectively quantify the severity of the rollover phenomenon and differentiate benign cochlear hearing loss from retrocochlear lesions, James Jerger and Susan Jerger (1971) formulated the Rollover Index (RI) : RI = P B max − P B min P B max \text{RI} = \frac{PB_{\text{max}} - PB_{\text{min}}}{PB_{\text{max}}} RI = P B max P B max − P B min where:
P B max PB_{\text{max}} P B max : The highest percentage correct score obtained across the entire PI function.
P B min PB_{\text{min}} P B min : The lowest percentage correct score obtained at a presentation level higher than the level that produced P B max PB_{\text{max}} P B max .
Diagnostic Thresholds for Retrocochlear Pathology
Diagnostic criteria for the Rollover Index vary with the word list, because harder lists produce lower PB-Max values:
PAL PB-50 Word Lists (original criterion): RI > 0.45 ⟹ Suggests Retrocochlear Pathology \text{RI} > 0.45 \implies \text{Suggests Retrocochlear Pathology} RI > 0.45 ⟹ Suggests Retrocochlear Pathology (Jerger and Jerger, 1971; Dirks et al., 1977).
NU-6 Word Lists (common clinical lists): a lower criterion of roughly RI ≥ 0.25 \text{RI} \ge 0.25 RI ≥ 0.25 (Bess, Josey, and Humes, 1979) to 0.35 0.35 0.35 (Meyer and Mishler, 1985) is used.
Rollover is a screening sign, not a diagnosis: a positive result leads to medical referral and MRI.
Step-by-Step Clinical Calculation Example
A 52-year-old patient presents with asymmetric sensorineural hearing loss and unilateral left-sided tinnitus. The audiologist administers NU-6 word lists across multiple intensity levels to evaluate the left ear's PI function:
- 60 dB HL : 56 % 60\,\text{dB HL}: 56\% 60 dB HL : 56%
- 75 dB HL : 80 % 75\,\text{dB HL}: 80\% 75 dB HL : 80%
- 85 dB HL : 82 % ⟹ P B max 85\,\text{dB HL}: 82\% \implies PB_{\text{max}} 85 dB HL : 82% ⟹ P B max
- 95 dB HL : 52 % 95\,\text{dB HL}: 52\% 95 dB HL : 52%
- 105 dB HL : 36 % ⟹ P B min 105\,\text{dB HL}: 36\% \implies PB_{\text{min}} 105 dB HL : 36% ⟹ P B min
Applying the Rollover Index formula: RI = 0.82 − 0.36 0.82 = 0.46 0.82 ≈ 0.561 \text{RI} = \frac{0.82 - 0.36}{0.82} = \frac{0.46}{0.82} \approx 0.561 RI = 0.82 0.82 − 0.36 = 0.82 0.46 ≈ 0.561 Clinical Interpretation: Because the calculated Rollover Index of 0.56 0.56 0.56 exceeds both the NU-6 criterion (about 0.25 0.25 0.25 to 0.35 0.35 0.35 ) and the stricter PB-50 criterion of 0.45 0.45 0.45 , this represents a positive rollover test . The patient must be immediately referred to neurotology for diagnostic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the internal auditory canals and cerebellopontine angle.
The Clinical Rationale for Speech-in-Noise (SIN) Testing
For decades, clinical audiometry relied almost exclusively on pure-tone audiograms and quiet word recognition scores. This diagnostic paradigm suffers from severe clinical blind spots:
The "Hidden Hearing Loss" Conundrum: Many patients present with substantial, debilitating complaints of understanding conversation in group settings, restaurants, and meetings, yet exhibit normal or near-normal pure-tone audiograms ( 0 − 20 dB HL 0-20\,\text{dB HL} 0 − 20 dB HL ). Animal and human temporal bone studies demonstrate cochlear synaptopathy —loss of synaptic connections between inner hair cells and low-spontaneous-rate, high-threshold auditory nerve fibers. These low-spontaneous-rate fibers are essential for coding speech in background noise but contribute negligibly to detection of soft pure tones in quiet.
Ceiling Effects of Quiet Testing: Monosyllabic words presented at + 30 − 40 dB SL +30-40\,\text{dB SL} + 30 − 40 dB SL in quiet fail to tax auditory processing. Patients with moderate sensory loss frequently achieve 90 % 90\% 90% scores in quiet booths, misleading clinicians and patients regarding the true extent of their disability.
Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) Dynamics: In real-world listening, communication success is dictated not by absolute decibel level, but by the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) : SNR = Target Speech Level (dB) − Competing Noise Level (dB) \text{SNR} = \text{Target Speech Level (dB)} - \text{Competing Noise Level (dB)} SNR = Target Speech Level (dB) − Competing Noise Level (dB) Normal-hearing listeners can comprehend connected speech at negative or zero SNRs (e.g., 0 dB 0\,\text{dB} 0 dB to − 3 dB -3\,\text{dB} − 3 dB SNR). Individuals with sensorineural hearing loss require a significantly more positive SNR ( + 5 dB +5\,\text{dB} + 5 dB to + 15 dB +15\,\text{dB} + 15 dB ) to achieve equal comprehension due to widened cochlear filters and degraded temporal resolution.
- Standardized Speech-in-Noise Evaluation Protocols
- 1. QuickSIN (Quick Speech-in-Noise Test)
Developed by Killion, Niquette, Gudmundsen, Revit, and Banerjee (2004), the QuickSIN is the most widely adopted clinical test for quantifying SNR loss.
Stimuli & Structure: Employs low-context sentences formulated by the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE). Sentences feature low semantic predictability (e.g., "The birch canoe slid on the smooth planks" ), forcing listeners to rely purely on acoustic-phonetic processing. Each sentence contains 5 scored keywords .
Competing Noise: Four-talker babble (three female voices and one male voice), creating a realistic, energetically and informational masking background.
Presentation Methodology: A complete test list consists of 6 sentences presented at pre-recorded, decreasing SNRs in 5 dB 5\,\text{dB} 5 dB decrements: + 25 dB , + 20 dB , + 15 dB , + 10 dB , + 5 dB , and 0 dB SNR +25\,\text{dB}, +20\,\text{dB}, +15\,\text{dB}, +10\,\text{dB}, +5\,\text{dB}, \text{and } 0\,\text{dB SNR} + 25 dB , + 20 dB , + 15 dB , + 10 dB , + 5 dB , and 0 dB SNR . The speech is fixed at a comfortable suprathreshold level (typically 70 dB HL 70\,\text{dB HL} 70 dB HL for pure-tone averages ≤ 45 dB HL \le 45\,\text{dB HL} ≤ 45 dB HL , or "Loud but OK" for greater hearing losses).
SNR Loss Mathematical Formulation: SNR Loss = 25.5 − Total Words Correct \text{SNR Loss} = 25.5 - \text{Total Words Correct} SNR Loss = 25.5 − Total Words Correct Mathematical Derivation: By the Spearman-Kärber method, the SNR for 50% correct (SNR-50) equals 27.5 27.5 27.5 (the 25 dB 25\,\text{dB} 25 dB starting SNR plus half the 5 dB 5\,\text{dB} 5 dB step) minus the total words correct. Normal-hearing listeners have an SNR-50 of about 2 dB 2\,\text{dB} 2 dB , so SNR loss = ( 27.5 − words correct ) − 2 = 25.5 − words correct = (27.5 - \text{words correct}) - 2 = 25.5 - \text{words correct} = ( 27.5 − words correct ) − 2 = 25.5 − words correct .
SNR Loss Category Quantitative Value Real-World Listening Ability Recommended Hearing Technology Intervention
Normal / Near Normal 0 − 3 dB 0 - 3\,\text{dB} 0 − 3 dB Functions similarly to normal-hearing listeners in noise; minimal handicap. Standard amplification; omnidirectional microphones or mild directional processing.
Mild SNR Loss 3 − 7 dB 3 - 7\,\text{dB} 3 − 7 dB Experiences noticeable difficulty in noisy social gatherings and restaurants. Hearing aids with directional microphone arrays and digital noise reduction algorithms.
Moderate SNR Loss 7 − 15 dB 7 - 15\,\text{dB} 7 − 15 dB Severe breakdown in background noise; directional mics alone are insufficient. Hearing aids with binaural beamforming directional arrays and dedicated noise suppression; trial of remote microphone.
Severe SNR Loss > 15 dB > 15\,\text{dB} > 15 dB Comprehension collapses even in mild noise; speech in noise is perceived as noise. Remote microphone (FM/DM) technology is strongly recommended ; hearing aids alone rarely overcome this deficit.
Critical Test-Retest Rule: A single QuickSIN list has a 95 % 95\% 95% critical difference of about ± 2.7 dB \pm 2.7\,\text{dB} ± 2.7 dB . To achieve high clinical precision, an audiologist must average at least two lists (reducing the 95 % 95\% 95% critical difference to ± 1.9 dB \pm 1.9\,\text{dB} ± 1.9 dB ) or three lists for medicolegal or research applications.
2. BKB-SIN (Bamford-Kowal-Bench Speech-in-Noise)
Target Population: Specifically designed for pediatric patients (developmental age 5 years 5\,\text{years} 5 years and older), cochlear implant candidates, and adults with severe cognitive impairment or limited English proficiency who cannot process complex IEEE sentences.
Stimuli: Employs syntactically simple BKB sentences (1st to 2nd-grade reading level; e.g., "The clown had a funny face" ) with 3 scored keywords per sentence.
Acoustic Progression: Sentences are presented in four-talker babble from + 21 dB +21\,\text{dB} + 21 dB down to − 6 dB SNR -6\,\text{dB SNR} − 6 dB SNR in 3 dB 3\,\text{dB} 3 dB steps .
Scoring: SNR-50 = 23.5 − Total Key Words Correct \text{SNR-50} = 23.5 - \text{Total Key Words Correct} SNR-50 = 23.5 − Total Key Words Correct SNR loss is then the listener's SNR-50 minus the age-appropriate normal SNR-50 published in the test manual.
3. WIN (Words in Noise Test)
Stimuli: Monosyllabic words from the Northwestern University Auditory Test No. 6 (NU-6) presented in multi-talker babble (Wilson et al.).
Methodology: Assesses word recognition in noise at 7 discrete SNRs ( + 24 dB +24\,\text{dB} + 24 dB to 0 dB 0\,\text{dB} 0 dB in 4 dB 4\,\text{dB} 4 dB steps). Because it utilizes isolated monosyllables, the WIN strips away all sentence-level syntactic and contextual cues, directly testing the auditory periphery's ability to extract lexical tokens from competing noise.
4. HINT (Hearing in Noise Test)
Adaptive Methodology: Developed by Nilsson, Soli, and Sullivan (1994). Unlike fixed-level tests, the HINT is an adaptive test that measures the Speech Reception Threshold in Noise (SRT-N) —the precise SNR in dB \text{dB} dB required for the listener to correctly repeat 50 % 50\% 50% of presented sentences.
Stimulus & Noise Setup: Continuous speech-spectrum noise is delivered at a fixed sound pressure level (typically 65 dB A 65\,\text{dB A} 65 dB A ). The speech level increases or decreases in 2 − 4 dB 2-4\,\text{dB} 2 − 4 dB adaptive steps based on the accuracy of the preceding sentence.
Spatial Release from Masking: HINT evaluates spatial hearing by presenting sentences under three soundfield speaker configurations: (1) Noise Front ( 0 ∘ 0^\circ 0 ∘ ), (2) Noise Right ( 90 ∘ 90^\circ 9 0 ∘ ), and (3) Noise Left ( 270 ∘ 270^\circ 27 0 ∘ ). A Composite Threshold is computed. Comparing frontal noise to asymmetric noise conditions objectively measures the patient's head shadow advantage and central binaural squelch (spatial release from masking, which typically provides a 3 − 5 dB 3-5\,\text{dB} 3 − 5 dB benefit in healthy binaural systems).