Study guide
2.3 Beneficial and Harmful Effects of Computing Innovations
Praxis Computer Science 5652
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Praxis 5652 Exam Overview and ETS Pseudocode
1.1 Praxis 5652 Test Facts, Scoring, and Registration 1.2 Official ETS Pseudocode Notation and Tracing Strategy
2 Chapter 2: Impacts of Computing: Innovation, Access, and Effects
2.1 Computing for Creativity, Problem Solving, Communication, and Innovation 2.2 Equal Access, the Digital Divide, and Accessibility 2.3 Beneficial and Harmful Effects of Computing Innovations
3 Chapter 3: Impacts of Computing: Intellectual Property, Ethics, Privacy, and Security
3.1 Intellectual Property: Copyright, Open Source, and Creative Commons 3.2 Ethical and Unethical Computing Practices and Their Implications 3.3 Privacy, Security, Data Collection, and Local vs. Cloud Storage
4 Chapter 4: Algorithms and Computational Thinking: Abstraction, Decomposition, Number Bases, and Representation
4.1 Abstraction and Abstraction Hierarchies 4.2 Decomposition, Pattern Recognition, and Developing Algorithms 4.3 Number Bases: Binary, Octal, Decimal, and Hexadecimal 4.4 Algorithm Formats: Natural Language, Flowcharts, Pseudocode, and Tracing
5 Chapter 5: Algorithms: Efficiency, Limits of Computing, and Randomization
5.1 Algorithm Efficiency: Linear, Quadratic, Exponential, and Logarithmic Growth 5.2 Limits of Computing: Unsolvable Problems, Intractability, and Heuristics 5.3 Randomization, Random vs. Pseudorandom Numbers, and Scaling to a Range
6 Chapter 6: Algorithms: Searching, Sorting, and Recursion
6.1 Searching Algorithms: Linear Search and Binary Search 6.2 Sorting Algorithms: Tracing, Comparisons, Correctness, and Efficiency 6.3 Recursion: Base Cases, Tracing, Errors, and Iterative Equivalents
7 Chapter 7: Programming: Variables, Data Types, Strings, and Expressions
7.1 Variables, Data Types, and Type Conversion 7.2 Strings and String Operations 7.3 Operators, Precedence, Expressions, and Formulas 7.4 Boolean Expressions, Truth Tables, and Boolean Algebra
8 Chapter 8: Programming: Selection, Iteration, and Writing Code
8.1 Sequence and Selection: if, else, Chained and Nested Conditions 8.2 Iteration: for, while, do … while, and repeat … until Loops 8.3 Reading, Completing, and Modifying Code
9 Chapter 9: Programming: Procedures, Arrays, and Data Structures
9.1 Procedures, Parameters, Return Values, Nested Calls, and Scope 9.2 Arrays, Lists, and Two-Dimensional Arrays 9.3 Stacks, Queues, and Dictionaries (Maps)
10 Chapter 10: Programming: Correctness, Errors, Testing, and Code Quality
10.1 Program Correctness: Preconditions, Postconditions, Invariants, and Testing vs. Proof 10.2 Error Types and Debugging Techniques 10.3 Choosing Useful Test Cases: Boundaries, Partitions, Coverage, and Regression 10.4 Extensibility, Modifiability, and Reusability: Constants and Parameterization 10.5 Documentation, Code Reviews, Peer Feedback, and End-User Feedback
11 Chapter 11: Programming: Events, Usability, Input Validation, and APIs
11.1 Event-Driven Programming, Asynchronous Events, and Concurrency 11.2 Usability, Meaningful Error Messages, and Input Validation vs. Verification 11.3 Libraries and APIs: Reading Definitions, Making Calls, and Weighing Trade-offs
12 Chapter 12: Programming: Languages, Tools, Paradigms, and Object-Oriented Design
12.1 Low- and High-Level Languages, Compilers and Interpreters, and IDEs 12.2 Programming Paradigms: Procedural, Object-Oriented, and Others 12.3 Classes, Objects, Instance Variables, Methods, and Encapsulation 12.4 Inheritance, Polymorphism, and Overloading vs. Overriding
13 Chapter 13: Data: Bits, Encoding, Compression, and Encryption
13.1 Bits and Bytes: Why Binary, Storage Calculations, and Signed Integers 13.2 Encoding Text, Images, and Sound 13.3 Lossless and Lossy Compression: Run-Length Encoding, Huffman Coding, and Media Formats 13.4 Encoding vs. Encryption, Symmetric and Public-Key Encryption, and Their Trade-offs
14 Chapter 14: Data: Analysis Tools, Simulation, Storage, and Collection
14.1 Analyzing Data with Spreadsheets: Cleaning, Transforming, and Visualizing 14.2 Simulation and Modeling 14.3 Files, Databases, and Storage Requirements: Scale, Redundancy, and Backup 14.4 Collecting, Aggregating, and Generating Data: Public Data Sets, Surveys, Sensors, and Crowdsourcing
15 Chapter 15: Computing Systems: Hardware, Operating Systems, and Computing Environments
15.1 Hardware Components and the Fetch–Decode–Execute Cycle 15.2 Operating Systems, Software Components, and Resource Issues 15.3 Embedded Systems, the Internet of Things, and Types of Computing Systems 15.4 Local, Network, and Cloud Computing and Storage; How Binary Data Are Stored
16 Chapter 16: Networks, the Internet, the Web, and Cybersecurity
16.1 Network Types and Wired and Wireless Communication 16.2 Network Hardware and Layered Network Models (OSI and TCP/IP) 16.3 Network Performance: Bandwidth, Latency, Load, and Estimating Needs 16.4 How the Internet Works: Protocols, IP Addressing, DNS, URLs, and Reliability 16.5 The Web: HTTP, HTML and Markup Languages, Browsers, Servers, and Clients 16.6 Cybersecurity: The Five Pillars, Strong Passwords, Security Strategies, and Trade-offs
2.3 Beneficial and Harmful Effects of Computing Innovations
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Most computing innovations are dual-use: the same capability that creates a benefit can also enable a harm.
Analyze an innovation by asking who benefits, who could be harmed, and whether each effect is social, economic, or cultural, intended or unintended.
Algorithmic bias can come from unrepresentative training data, historical bias in the data, proxy variables such as ZIP code, and feedback loops.
The 2018 Gender Shades study found commercial gender classifiers erred about 0.8% of the time on lighter-skinned men and up to 34.7% on darker-skinned women.
Common trade-offs pair convenience with privacy, security with civil liberties, and automation's productivity with job displacement.
Last updated: September 2026
What this competency asks
ETS asks you to understand beneficial and harmful effects of computing innovations and the trade-offs between them :
Analyze computing innovations in terms of their social, economic, and cultural impacts, both beneficial and harmful.
Identify trade-offs between beneficial and harmful effects.
A typical item describes a new technology and asks which uses are possible, which effect is harmful, or which trade-off is involved. One ETS sample question describes an application that combines a text file with recordings of a person's voice to produce realistic speech. It asks which uses are possible, and the correct answer is all three options: re-creating an unrecorded historical speech, fabricating slanderous audio, and fooling voice-activated security. The lesson is that one capability can produce both benefits and harms .
A framework for analyzing any innovation
- Question to ask Why it matters
- What does the innovation make easier, faster, or cheaper? Identifies the intended benefit
Who are the stakeholders (users, non-users, workers, communities)? Harms often fall on people who never chose the technology
What are the social effects (relationships, safety, civic life)? Communication, misinformation, polarization, isolation
- What are the economic effects (jobs, costs, markets)? New industries and roles; displacement of others
- What are the cultural effects (language, art, norms)? Global sharing, preservation, homogenization
- What unintended uses or consequences are possible? Misuse, dual use, and side effects
- Worked examples
Innovation Beneficial effects Harmful effects
Social media Connects distant family and communities; organizing and activism Misinformation spreads quickly; harassment; privacy loss; engagement-driven feeds can amplify outrage
GPS and location services Navigation, emergency location, logistics efficiency Tracking of people without consent; location data sold to third parties
E-commerce Wider selection, lower prices, access for rural and homebound shoppers Pressure on local stores; warehouse labor conditions; packaging waste
Voice and image generation (AI) Accessibility tools, creative production, restoring lost audio Deepfakes, fraud, impersonation that defeats voice authentication
Facial recognition Finding missing persons; unlocking devices Mass surveillance; higher error rates for some groups; wrongful identification
Automation and robotics Fewer injuries in dangerous jobs; higher productivity Displacement of routine jobs; need for retraining
Streaming and digital media Global access to music, film, and educational content Weaker income for some artists; dominance of a few platforms and languages
Algorithmic bias: an important class of harm
Algorithmic bias is systematic unfairness in the output of an automated system, often against a demographic group. It usually arises without anyone intending it.
Where bias comes from
Unrepresentative training data. If a group is underrepresented in the data, a model learns less about that group and makes more errors on it. The Gender Shades study (Buolamwini and Gebru, 2018) tested commercial gender classifiers. They erred about 0.8% of the time for lighter-skinned men but up to 34.7% for darker-skinned women, and the benchmark data sets they examined were overwhelmingly lighter-skinned.
Historical bias. Data can accurately record a biased past. Reuters reported in 2018 that Amazon abandoned an experimental résumé-screening model. The model had learned from ten years of mostly male hiring data and penalized résumés containing the word "women's," as in "women's chess club captain."
Proxy variables. Removing race or sex from the inputs does not guarantee fairness, because other features such as ZIP code, school attended, or shopping patterns can correlate with them. A widely used health-risk algorithm studied by Obermeyer and colleagues ( Science , 2019) used past health-care spending as a proxy for health need. Because less money had historically been spent on Black patients with the same conditions, the model underestimated their need.
Feedback loops. A predictive-policing tool trained on past arrests sends more officers to the same neighborhoods. More patrols produce more recorded arrests there, which the tool then reads as confirmation.
Consequences
ProPublica's 2016 analysis of the COMPAS recidivism tool found that Black defendants who did not reoffend were almost twice as likely as white defendants who did not reoffend to be labeled higher risk. The tool's makers disputed the analysis. The debate illustrates a deeper point: common mathematical definitions of fairness (equal error rates versus equally accurate risk scores, for example) generally cannot all be satisfied at once when groups have different base rates. Choosing among them is an ethical and policy decision, not only a technical one.
Mitigation strategies
Collect representative data and measure accuracy separately for each group.
Audit outcomes before and after deployment. For example, U.S. employment guidance uses a four-fifths (80%) rule as a rough flag: a selection rate for any group below 80% of the highest group's rate suggests adverse impact.
Include diverse, interdisciplinary teams and affected communities in design.
Prefer explainable models for high-stakes decisions, and give people a way to understand and appeal automated decisions.
Keep a human in the loop for consequential decisions such as benefits, hiring, and criminal justice.
Recognizing trade-offs
A trade-off exists when gaining one benefit costs something else.
- Trade-off One side Other side
- Convenience vs. privacy Free, personalized apps and services Behavioral tracking and data sale
Security vs. civil liberties Camera networks and license-plate readers help solve crimes Loss of anonymity; chilling effects on lawful assembly
Productivity vs. employment Automation lowers costs and injuries Routine jobs disappear faster than workers can retrain
Speed vs. due process Automated eligibility decisions in seconds Errors are hard to see and slow to appeal
Openness vs. safety Open platforms encourage creativity and free expression Harder to prevent harassment and misinformation
When a question asks for the best statement about an innovation, prefer the answer that names both a benefit and a cost. Avoid answers that claim a technology is purely good or purely harmful.