Study guide
5.6 Norm-Referenced and Criterion-Referenced Assessment
Praxis English to Speakers of Other Languages 5362
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Foundations of Linguistics
1.1 Phonetics, Phonology, IPA, and Sound Systems of English 1.2 Morphology, Morphemes, and Word-Formation Processes 1.3 Syntax, Sentence Structure, and Grammatical Analysis 1.4 Semantics, Pragmatics, Speech Acts, and Context 1.5 Sociolinguistics, Dialects, Register, and World Englishes 1.6 Written Language Conventions, Orthography, and Rhetorical Structure 1.7 Parts of Speech: Structural, Semantic, and Functional Characteristics 1.8 Mechanics of Written English: Spelling, Punctuation, Capitalization, and Paragraph Formation 1.9 Communicative Competence: Grammatical, Sociolinguistic, Discourse, and Strategic 1.10 English Irregularities and Cross-Linguistic Comparison
2 Chapter 2: Foundations of Language Learning & Second Language Acquisition
2.1 Second Language Acquisition Theories, Hypotheses, and Frameworks 2.2 BICS, CALP, and Stages of Language Proficiency Development 2.3 L1 Transfer, Interlanguage, and Error Analysis Dynamics 2.4 Cognitive, Affective, and Individual Differences in SLA 2.5 Second Language Literacy, Phonics, and Decoding Processes 2.6 Socio-cultural, Family, and Environmental Influences on SLA 2.7 Receptive Before Productive: The Comprehension-Production Gap 2.8 Simultaneous and Sequential Bilingualism, Transfer, and Common Underlying Proficiency 2.9 Stages of Reading Development and the Purposes of Reading 2.10 Stages of Writing Development and Invented Spelling 2.11 Orthographic Systems, L1 Literacy Features, and Cross-Linguistic Literacy Transfer 2.12 Physical, Emotional, and Health Factors Affecting Student Performance
3 Chapter 3: Planning & Designing ESOL Instruction
3.1 Standards-Based Planning, Content Objectives, and Language Objectives 3.2 Sheltered Instruction Frameworks, SIOP, and Multimodal Scaffolding 3.3 Differentiation Strategies, Flexible Grouping, and Universal Design 3.4 Survey of ESOL Methods and Approaches: Selecting for Context 3.5 Designing Aligned Activities and Classroom Assessments from Objectives 3.6 Dialect Variation and Its Instructional Implications
4 Chapter 4: Implementing Instruction Across Language Domains
4.1 Developing Academic Listening and Speaking Competence 4.2 Developing Academic Reading, Text Complexity, and Vocabulary Tiers 4.3 Developing Academic Writing, Genre-Based Instruction, and Feedback 4.4 Technology to Support Language Development, Instruction, and Learning 4.5 Balanced Literacy and the Print-Rich, Language-Rich Environment 4.6 Activating Prior Knowledge and Selecting Accessible Instructional Materials 4.7 Adapting Instruction for English Learners with Disabilities and Gifted English Learners
5 Chapter 5: Assessment & Evaluation for Multilingual Learners
5.1 Placement, Diagnostic, Formative, and Summative Assessment Types 5.2 Technical Assessment Principles: Validity, Reliability, and Fairness 5.3 Distinguishing Language Proficiency from Content Achievement 5.4 Testing Accommodations and Universal Supports for ELLs 5.5 Data Interpretation, Progress Monitoring, Reclassification, and Dual Identification 5.6 Norm-Referenced and Criterion-Referenced Assessment 5.7 The Classroom Assessment Toolkit: Running Records, SOLOM, Checklists, and Inventories 5.8 Communicating Assessment Results to Students and Families
6 Chapter 6: Cultural Diversity & Culturally Responsive Pedagogy
6.1 Cultural Identity, Acculturation Stages, and Culture Shock Dynamics 6.2 Culturally Responsive Teaching, Funds of Knowledge, and Bias Mitigation 6.3 Intercultural Communication, Family Engagement, and Community Partnerships 6.4 The Interrelationship of Language and Culture 6.5 Cultural Variables in Second Language Acquisition and Teaching 6.6 Cultural Stereotyping, Bias, Bullying, and the Teacher's Own Cultural Lens
7 Chapter 7: Legal Foundations, Program Models & Professional Advocacy
7.1 Landmark Federal Court Cases, Legislation, and Student Rights 7.2 ESOL Program Delivery Models, Bilingual Approaches, and Push-in/Pull-out Structures 7.3 Co-Teaching, Interdisciplinary Collaboration, Professional Ethics, and Advocacy 7.4 The EL Teacher as Professional Resource and Advocate 7.5 Outside Resources, Networks, and Community Partnerships 7.6 Professional Growth, Reflective Practice, and the ESOL Acronym Landscape
5.6 Norm-Referenced and Criterion-Referenced Assessment
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Norm-referenced tests compare a student to a norming sample; criterion-referenced tests compare performance to a fixed standard.
Percentiles, stanines, and grade equivalents are norm-referenced score types; mastery levels and cut scores are criterion-referenced.
Norm-referenced results are invalid for English learners when the norming sample excluded them.
Criterion-referenced results tell a teacher which specific skills were and were not mastered, which is what instructional planning requires.
Grade-equivalent scores are the most misinterpreted score type and should never be read as a recommended placement level.
Last updated: August 2026
5.6 Norm-Referenced and Criterion-Referenced Assessment
The ETS content outline names this distinction explicitly: the candidate "knows the difference between norm-referenced and criterion-referenced assessments and how they are used with ELs," and recognizes both the consequences of norm-referenced comparison for English learners and the instructional utility of criterion-referenced information. The distinction is not about the test items — it is about what the score is compared to .
1. The Core Contrast
- Norm-referenced (NRT) Criterion-referenced (CRT)
- Answers the question "How does this student compare to other students ?" "What can this student actually do ?"
- Reference point A norming sample of test-takers A fixed standard, objective, or cut score
Score types Percentile rank, stanine, normal curve equivalent, grade equivalent, standard score Percent correct, mastery/non-mastery, performance level, proficiency-level descriptor
Item design Items chosen to spread scores out ; very easy and very hard items are discarded Items chosen to represent the standard ; everyone can, in principle, score 100%
Distribution Designed to produce a bell curve; half of all students are below average by construction No fixed distribution; all students could reach mastery
Primary uses Screening, program eligibility, comparison to a population Instructional planning, progress monitoring, grading, standards accountability
Examples Cognitive ability batteries; nationally normed achievement tests Unit tests, state standards assessments, ELP performance-level determinations, rubric-scored performance tasks
The bell-curve consequence
A norm-referenced test is engineered so that scores spread. That means "below average" is a statistical position, not a diagnosis. Fifty percent of the norming population scores below the median by design. A parent told their child is "below the 50th percentile" has been given a ranking, not a description of what the child knows.
2. Decoding Norm-Referenced Score Types
Score type What it means Common misreading
Percentile rank Percent of the norming group this student outscored (e.g., 62nd percentile = outscored 62%) Mistaken for percent correct
Stanine Nine-point band; 4-6 is the average range Treated as a fine-grained measure
Normal curve equivalent (NCE) Percentile rescaled to equal intervals so scores can be averaged Confused with percentile
Standard score Distance from the mean in standard-deviation units (often mean 100, SD 15) Read as a percentage
Grade equivalent (GE) The grade level at which this raw score would be the median The most dangerous score type on any report
The grade-equivalent trap
A 4th grader who earns a grade equivalent of 7.2 has not demonstrated 7th-grade skills. It means her raw score equals the median raw score of 7th graders on the 4th-grade test — a test containing no 7th-grade content. Grade equivalents are extrapolated, unequal-interval estimates and should never be used to set placement, select texts, or write goals. The same logic runs the other way: a 6th-grade EL with a GE of 2.4 has not been shown to "read like a 2nd grader."
3. Why Norm-Referenced Tests Distort English Learner Performance
This is the point the exam presses hardest, and it follows directly from the norming-sample bias discussed in Section 5.2.
The comparison group is inappropriate. If the norming sample consisted overwhelmingly of native English speakers, then comparing a developing multilingual learner to it produces a ranking against a population the student is not a member of. The resulting percentile measures English proficiency as much as the target construct.
Language becomes construct-irrelevant variance. On a nationally normed science or mathematics test delivered in English, an EL's score confounds content knowledge with English reading ability (Section 5.3).
Consequences compound. Low norm-referenced scores drive placement into remedial tracks, exclusion from gifted screening (Section 4.7), and over-referral to special education (Section 5.5) — outcomes documented as disproportionality, not as accurate measurement.
Cultural content bias. Items presuppose U.S.-specific background knowledge that is unrelated to the skill being measured.
Legitimate uses remain. Norm-referenced data is not useless: it can flag a student for further examination, and it is required for some eligibility determinations. The rule is that a norm-referenced score alone may never drive a high-stakes decision about an English learner. It must be triangulated with criterion-referenced data, native-language performance, work samples, and observation over time.
4. Why Criterion-Referenced Data Drives Instruction
Criterion-referenced results answer the question a teacher actually needs answered on Monday morning.
- Report says Instructional value
- "38th percentile in reading" None. It ranks the student; it names no skill
"Mastered main idea and sequencing; not yet mastered inference from context clues" Directly actionable — the next lesson writes itself
This is why progress monitoring, rubric-scored performance tasks, and standards-based grading are criterion-referenced by design (Section 5.5), and why English language proficiency assessments report performance-level descriptors — Entering, Emerging, Developing, Expanding, Bridging, Reaching — rather than percentiles. A descriptor states what the student can do with language; a percentile states only where they rank.
A note on ELP assessments
Annual ELP assessments such as ACCESS for ELLs and ELPA21 are criterion-referenced against English language development standards . That is precisely why their results can be used for reclassification decisions (Section 5.5): a proficiency-level determination is a statement about attainment of a defined standard, not a ranking against other test-takers.
5. Choosing the Right Tool
- Purpose Use
- Decide what to teach tomorrow Criterion-referenced (formative, rubric, mastery check)
- Determine whether a student met a standard Criterion-referenced
- Make a reclassification/exit decision Criterion-referenced ELP determination plus multiple measures
- Screen a large population for follow-up Norm-referenced, with caution
Establish eligibility requiring population comparison Norm-referenced, with native-language and nonverbal data alongside