Study guide
13.3 Student Self-Assessment and Peer Assessment
Praxis Principles of Learning and Teaching: Grades 7-12 5624
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Exam Overview & How Students Learn
1.1 Praxis 5624 Test Facts, Scoring & Qualifying Scores 1.2 How Students Construct Knowledge & Acquire Skills 1.3 Key Learning-Theory Terms: Schema to Conditioning
2 Chapter 2: Foundational Theorists & Adolescent Development
2.1 Piaget, Vygotsky, Bruner & Dewey in the Secondary Classroom 2.2 Bandura, Kohlberg, Gilligan & Bloom 2.3 Adolescent Development: Brain, Body, Identity & Variance
3 Chapter 3: Students as Diverse Learners
3.1 Learner Variables: Culture, Gender, SES & Prior Knowledge 3.2 Areas of Exceptionality and Their Impact on Learning 3.3 Disability Law in Practice: IDEA, Section 504 & ADA 3.4 Gifted and Talented Learners: Acceleration & Enrichment
4 Chapter 4: English Learners, Accommodations & UDL
4.1 English Language Acquisition and English Learners 4.2 Accommodations, Modifications & Universal Design for Learning
5 Chapter 5: Motivation & the Learning Environment
5.1 Thorndike, Watson, Skinner, Maslow & Erikson 5.2 Motivation Theories: SDT, Attribution, Expectancy-Value & Mindset 5.3 Classroom Management: Routines, Records, Space & Discipline 5.4 A Positive Learning Climate & Student Self-Motivation
6 Chapter 6: Planning Instruction
6.1 Standards, Frameworks & Instructional Alignment 6.2 Applying Behaviorism, Cognitivism, Social Learning & Constructivism 6.3 Scope, Sequence & Curriculum Alignment 6.4 Backward Design and Selecting Content 6.5 Writing Observable, Measurable Objectives in Three Domains
7 Chapter 7: Remediation, Resources & Interdisciplinary Planning
7.1 Planning Remediation and Tiered Support (MTSS/RTI) 7.2 Resources, Thematic & Interdisciplinary Units, and Planning Partners
8 Chapter 8: Instructional Models & Strategies
8.1 Direct Instruction, Hunter's Lesson Design & Closure 8.2 Indirect, Independent, Experiential & Interactive Models 8.3 Cooperative Learning Structures
9 Chapter 9: Thinking Skills, Differentiation & Grouping
9.1 Cognitive Processes: Critical & Creative Thinking, Reasoning, Problem Solving 9.2 Complex Cognitive Processes, Conceptual Change & Graphic Organizers 9.3 Supporting Strategies & Differentiated Instruction 9.4 Self-Regulation Skills, Group Configurations & Grouping Techniques
10 Chapter 10: Adjusting Instruction, Teachable Moments & Memory
10.1 Selecting Strategies, Monitoring & Adjusting, and Teachable Moments 10.2 Short-Term and Long-Term Memory in Instructional Planning
11 Chapter 11: Questioning & Discussion
11.1 Components of Effective Questioning and Wait Time 11.2 Purposes of Questioning and Question Levels 11.3 Helping Students Articulate Ideas and Think at Higher Levels 11.4 Discussion Models and a Safe, Open Forum
12 Chapter 12: Communication & Disciplinary Literacy
12.1 Verbal, Nonverbal, Cultural & Gender Dimensions of Communication 12.2 Communication Tools, Accessibility & Active Listening 12.3 Disciplinary Literacy and Reading Guides in Secondary Content Areas
13 Chapter 13: Classroom Assessment Strategies & Tools
13.1 Formal & Informal, Formative, Summative & Diagnostic Assessment 13.2 Creating and Selecting Assessment Formats 13.3 Student Self-Assessment and Peer Assessment 13.4 Rubrics, Checklists, Scoring Guides, Anecdotal Notes & Continuums
14 Chapter 14: Standardized Testing, Scores & Data
14.1 Standardized Tests: Achievement, Aptitude, Ability & Norm vs. Criterion 14.2 Validity, Reliability & Assessment Bias 14.3 Mean, Median, Mode, Standard Deviation & Derived Scores 14.4 Interpreting Test Data and Communicating Results 14.5 Using Assessment Data and Feedback to Improve Learning
15 Chapter 15: Professional Growth, Research & Reflection
15.1 Professional Development Resources, Mentoring & Coaching 15.2 Using Research, Evidence Tiers & Action Research 15.3 Reflective Practice for Professional Growth
16 Chapter 16: Support Personnel, Families & Collaboration
16.1 School Support Personnel and Co-Teaching 16.2 Partnerships with Parents and Families 16.3 Teacher Leadership, Perceptions of Teachers & Community Partnerships 16.4 Collaborative Relationships and Professional Learning Communities
17 Chapter 17: School Law, Rights & Professional Responsibilities
17.1 Privacy and Confidentiality: FERPA, PPRA & Student Searches 17.2 Equal Access, Title IX & Student Due Process 17.3 First Amendment Rights, Religion & Intellectual Freedom 17.4 Mandated Reporting of Abuse and Neglect, and Teacher Liability 17.5 Licensing, Tenure, Due Process & Professional Ethics 17.6 Copyright, Fair Use & the TEACH Act
18 Chapter 18: Analysis of Instructional Scenarios (Constructed Response)
18.1 Constructed-Response Format, the ETS Scoring Guide & Case Tasks 18.2 Case Practice: Diagnosing Learner Development and Motivation 18.3 Case Practice: Evaluating Instruction, Assessment & Collaboration
13.3 Student Self-Assessment and Peer Assessment
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Self-assessment builds metacognition and self-regulation when students use explicit criteria and exemplars.
Peer assessment multiplies feedback and sharpens evaluative judgment but requires training, protocols, and monitoring.
Self- and peer assessment work best as feedback that feeds goals and revision, not as the grade of record.
Protocols such as two stars and a wish, warm and cool feedback, and the ladder of feedback keep peer comments specific and respectful.
Co-creating rubrics from anonymous exemplars makes success criteria transparent.
Last updated: September 2026
Why Self- and Peer Assessment Are a Competency
ETS asks candidates to understand the rationale for and uses of student self-assessment and peer assessment : to define them, give examples of each mode, and explain their strengths and limitations. One of ETS's discussion questions asks how a teacher might use student self-evaluations effectively.
Modes of Self-Assessment
Mode How it works Secondary example
Rubric self-scoring Students score their own work against criteria before submitting Highlighting where a draft meets each row of the argument rubric
Checklists Students confirm required elements are present A lab-report checklist completed before submission
Learning logs and reflective journals Students record what they learned, what confused them, and next steps A weekly math journal
Exam wrappers After a test, students analyze errors and study strategies "Which questions did I miss, how did I study, and what will I change?"
Traffic-light or confidence ratings Students rate understanding as green, yellow, or red Color cards during a lesson, followed by a check question
Goal-setting conferences Students set and review goals with the teacher A quarterly conference using portfolio evidence
Modes of Peer Assessment
Peer editing with a rubric, structured protocols such as "two stars and a wish" or warm and cool feedback, gallery walks with criterion-based comments, and peer conferences all give students practice applying criteria to someone else's work, which often sharpens their judgment of their own.
Strengths and Limitations
Strengths Limitations and safeguards
Self-assessment Builds metacognition and self-regulation; makes criteria meaningful; supports goal setting Students may over- or underestimate; improves with clear criteria, exemplars, practice, and comparison with teacher feedback
Peer assessment Gives more feedback than one teacher can; develops evaluative judgment; builds collaboration Popularity bias, vague praise, or harsh criticism; needs training, protocols, and teacher monitoring, and works best as feedback rather than the grade of record
Self-evaluations are most effective when students use explicit criteria and exemplars, when the teacher compares self-ratings with the actual work and discusses differences, and when the results feed into goals and revision rather than directly into grades.
Assessment AS Learning: Self-Assessment and Metacognitive Regulation
Educational researcher Lorna Earl introduced a vital paradigm distinguishing three relationships between assessment and learning:
Assessment OF Learning : Summative verification of cumulative achievement.
Assessment FOR Learning : Formative monitoring by teachers to adapt instruction.
Assessment AS Learning : The active involvement of the student in monitoring and regulating their own cognitive processes.
In Assessment AS Learning , secondary students do not passively wait for an adult authority to tell them whether their work is good or bad. Instead, they act as critical connectors who internalize academic standards, evaluate their own progress against descriptive rubrics, identify personal skill gaps, and adjust their learning behaviors. Developing this evaluative judgment is vital for secondary students preparing for postsecondary education and adult careers.
Structured Peer-Assessment Protocols for Secondary Classrooms
Adolescent peer dynamics can complicate peer evaluation. If secondary teachers simply tell adolescents to "switch papers and give each other feedback," the process often degrades into superficial proofreading, unhelpful generic praise ( "It looks good!" ), or socially devastating personal criticism. To make peer assessment productive, objective, and emotionally safe, teachers must implement structured, scaffolded protocols:
1. Two Stars and a Wish
Structure : The peer reviewer must identify two specific, evidence-based strengths that meet the rubric criteria ( Two Stars ) and formulate one actionable, forward-looking recommendation for improvement ( One Wish ).
Classroom Value : Balances positive validation with constructive critique, preventing adolescents from feeling entirely demoralized or deceptively flattered.
2. Warm and Cool Feedback (Tuning Protocol)
Warm Feedback : Descriptive statements affirming how the work successfully satisfies learning targets ( "Your opening paragraph effectively hooks the reader by using contrasting statistical evidence on teenage sleep deprivation" ).
Cool Feedback : Non-judgmental, probing questions that challenge the author to consider alternative perspectives or address logical gaps ( "I wonder how your argument would address the counterargument that later school start times disrupt athletic schedules?" ).
3. The Ladder of Feedback
A structured four-step sequence developed by Project Zero at Harvard: Clarify (ask clarifying questions about unclear points) -> Value (highlight distinct strengths) -> State Concerns (identify potential weaknesses without judgment) -> Suggest (offer concrete next steps).
Student-Involved Rubric Co-Creation: Fostering Metacognition & Ownership
Traditional classroom assessment treats rubrics as compliance instruments handed down from teacher to student on the day of assignment submission. However, contemporary cognitive learning theory (rooted in Vygotsky's social constructivism and self-regulated learning frameworks) demonstrates that co-creating rubrics with secondary students fundamentally enhances academic engagement and conceptual understanding.
The Step-by-Step Co-Creation Protocol
Examining Anonymous Anchor Exemplars : The teacher provides students with three to four anonymous samples of past student work illustrating varied levels of quality (e.g., an exceptional paper, an average paper with specific flaws, and an incomplete/confused paper).
Collaborative Discourse & Trait Extraction : Students work in small groups to analyze the samples, answering guided questions: What makes Sample A so compelling? Why does Sample C fail to persuade you? Students record observable differences on chart paper.
Synthesizing Departmental Criteria : Through facilitated whole-class discussion, the teacher and students consolidate these traits into four or five core categories (e.g., Strength of Claim , Credibility of Sources , Logical Flow ).
Drafting Descriptive Performance Levels : Students articulate what performance looks like at each level using their own language, which the teacher refines into rigorous, objective behavioral descriptors.
Self-Assessment and Peer Calibration : Before submitting their own work, students use the co-created rubric to evaluate their own drafts and conduct structured peer reviews, writing justifications citing specific rubric criteria.
Metacognitive Benefits for Adolescents
Demystifies Success Criteria : Adolescents often perceive grading as arbitrary or subjective ( "The teacher just doesn't like my writing style" ). Co-creation renders the evaluation criteria explicit, objective, and transparent.
Shifts Motivation from Extrinsic to Intrinsic : When students participate in defining excellence, they develop genuine psychological ownership over the learning standards rather than viewing the rubric as an external compliance checklist.
Builds Metacognitive Monitoring : As students evaluate mentor texts and draft descriptors, they internalize the cognitive habits required to monitor and adjust their own academic performance in real time.
Common Exam Traps
Self-assessment without criteria. "How do you think you did?" produces guesses, not judgment.
Peer ratings as final grades. Use peer assessment for feedback and learning.
Skipping training. Students need modeling and practice before they can give useful feedback.