Study guide

15.2 Using Research, Evidence Tiers & Action Research

Praxis Principles of Learning and Teaching: Grades 7-12 5624

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Exam Overview & How Students Learn

1.1 Praxis 5624 Test Facts, Scoring & Qualifying Scores 1.2 How Students Construct Knowledge & Acquire Skills 1.3 Key Learning-Theory Terms: Schema to Conditioning

2 Chapter 2: Foundational Theorists & Adolescent Development

2.1 Piaget, Vygotsky, Bruner & Dewey in the Secondary Classroom 2.2 Bandura, Kohlberg, Gilligan & Bloom 2.3 Adolescent Development: Brain, Body, Identity & Variance

3 Chapter 3: Students as Diverse Learners

3.1 Learner Variables: Culture, Gender, SES & Prior Knowledge 3.2 Areas of Exceptionality and Their Impact on Learning 3.3 Disability Law in Practice: IDEA, Section 504 & ADA 3.4 Gifted and Talented Learners: Acceleration & Enrichment

4 Chapter 4: English Learners, Accommodations & UDL

4.1 English Language Acquisition and English Learners 4.2 Accommodations, Modifications & Universal Design for Learning

5 Chapter 5: Motivation & the Learning Environment

5.1 Thorndike, Watson, Skinner, Maslow & Erikson 5.2 Motivation Theories: SDT, Attribution, Expectancy-Value & Mindset 5.3 Classroom Management: Routines, Records, Space & Discipline 5.4 A Positive Learning Climate & Student Self-Motivation

6 Chapter 6: Planning Instruction

6.1 Standards, Frameworks & Instructional Alignment 6.2 Applying Behaviorism, Cognitivism, Social Learning & Constructivism 6.3 Scope, Sequence & Curriculum Alignment 6.4 Backward Design and Selecting Content 6.5 Writing Observable, Measurable Objectives in Three Domains

7 Chapter 7: Remediation, Resources & Interdisciplinary Planning

7.1 Planning Remediation and Tiered Support (MTSS/RTI) 7.2 Resources, Thematic & Interdisciplinary Units, and Planning Partners

8 Chapter 8: Instructional Models & Strategies

8.1 Direct Instruction, Hunter's Lesson Design & Closure 8.2 Indirect, Independent, Experiential & Interactive Models 8.3 Cooperative Learning Structures

9 Chapter 9: Thinking Skills, Differentiation & Grouping

9.1 Cognitive Processes: Critical & Creative Thinking, Reasoning, Problem Solving 9.2 Complex Cognitive Processes, Conceptual Change & Graphic Organizers 9.3 Supporting Strategies & Differentiated Instruction 9.4 Self-Regulation Skills, Group Configurations & Grouping Techniques

10 Chapter 10: Adjusting Instruction, Teachable Moments & Memory

10.1 Selecting Strategies, Monitoring & Adjusting, and Teachable Moments 10.2 Short-Term and Long-Term Memory in Instructional Planning

11 Chapter 11: Questioning & Discussion

11.1 Components of Effective Questioning and Wait Time 11.2 Purposes of Questioning and Question Levels 11.3 Helping Students Articulate Ideas and Think at Higher Levels 11.4 Discussion Models and a Safe, Open Forum

12 Chapter 12: Communication & Disciplinary Literacy

12.1 Verbal, Nonverbal, Cultural & Gender Dimensions of Communication 12.2 Communication Tools, Accessibility & Active Listening 12.3 Disciplinary Literacy and Reading Guides in Secondary Content Areas

13 Chapter 13: Classroom Assessment Strategies & Tools

13.1 Formal & Informal, Formative, Summative & Diagnostic Assessment 13.2 Creating and Selecting Assessment Formats 13.3 Student Self-Assessment and Peer Assessment 13.4 Rubrics, Checklists, Scoring Guides, Anecdotal Notes & Continuums

14 Chapter 14: Standardized Testing, Scores & Data

14.1 Standardized Tests: Achievement, Aptitude, Ability & Norm vs. Criterion 14.2 Validity, Reliability & Assessment Bias 14.3 Mean, Median, Mode, Standard Deviation & Derived Scores 14.4 Interpreting Test Data and Communicating Results 14.5 Using Assessment Data and Feedback to Improve Learning

15 Chapter 15: Professional Growth, Research & Reflection

15.1 Professional Development Resources, Mentoring & Coaching 15.2 Using Research, Evidence Tiers & Action Research 15.3 Reflective Practice for Professional Growth

16 Chapter 16: Support Personnel, Families & Collaboration

16.1 School Support Personnel and Co-Teaching 16.2 Partnerships with Parents and Families 16.3 Teacher Leadership, Perceptions of Teachers & Community Partnerships 16.4 Collaborative Relationships and Professional Learning Communities

17 Chapter 17: School Law, Rights & Professional Responsibilities

17.1 Privacy and Confidentiality: FERPA, PPRA & Student Searches 17.2 Equal Access, Title IX & Student Due Process 17.3 First Amendment Rights, Religion & Intellectual Freedom 17.4 Mandated Reporting of Abuse and Neglect, and Teacher Liability 17.5 Licensing, Tenure, Due Process & Professional Ethics 17.6 Copyright, Fair Use & the TEACH Act

18 Chapter 18: Analysis of Instructional Scenarios (Constructed Response)

18.1 Constructed-Response Format, the ETS Scoring Guide & Case Tasks 18.2 Case Practice: Diagnosing Learner Development and Motivation 18.3 Case Practice: Evaluating Instruction, Assessment & Collaboration

15.2 Using Research, Evidence Tiers & Action Research

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

ERIC, the What Works Clearinghouse, Evidence for ESSA, and peer-reviewed journals are core sources for research on teaching.

Only experimental and strong quasi-experimental designs support causal claims; correlational findings do not prove cause.

Effect size shows how large a difference is, while statistical significance only shows it is unlikely to be chance.

ESSA's evidence tiers are strong (experimental), moderate (quasi-experimental), promising (correlational with controls), and demonstrates a rationale.

Action research cycles through plan, act, observe, and reflect, using a question within the teacher's control and triangulated data.

Last updated: September 2026

Why Research Literacy Is a Teaching Competency

ETS asks candidates to understand the implications of research, views, ideas, and debates on teaching practices: to know resources for accessing research, to interpret data, results, and conclusions from research on teaching, and to relate those findings to a variety of educational situations. ETS's discussion questions also expect candidates to be able to read and understand articles and books about current views, ideas, and debates regarding best teaching practices.

Where to Find Research and Professional Debate

Source What it provides

ERIC (the Education Resources Information Center, run by the Institute of Education Sciences) A searchable database of education research and reports

What Works Clearinghouse practice guides Reviews of research on specific practices and programs, with evidence ratings

  • Evidence for ESSA (Johns Hopkins University) Ratings of programs against the ESSA evidence tiers
  • Regional Educational Laboratories Applied research and summaries for states and districts

Peer-reviewed journals (for example, American Educational Research Journal , Review of Educational Research ) Original studies and research syntheses

Practitioner journals and association publications Accessible summaries, position statements, and professional debate

Reading a Study Critically

Question and design. Is it an experiment with random assignment, a quasi-experiment with a comparison group, a correlational study, a qualitative study, or a meta-analysis? Only experimental and strong quasi-experimental designs support causal claims.

Sample. How many students, and how similar are they to yours?

Measures. Did the study measure the outcome you care about?

Results. How large was the effect, not just whether it was statistically significant? Cohen's rough conventions call effect sizes of about 0.2 small, 0.5 medium, and 0.8 large, although smaller effects can matter in education.

Limitations and funding. Did the authors acknowledge limits, and did a program's publisher fund the study?

Correlation is not causation. If students who complete more homework earn higher grades, homework may help, but motivation, prior achievement, and family support could explain both. Only a design that controls for these factors can show that homework causes the difference.

Views, Ideas, and Debates

Secondary teachers regularly encounter contested questions: how much homework helps; whether to track or detrack; grading practices such as minimum grades and standards-based grading; how much explicit instruction versus inquiry; limits on student phone use; and the role of AI tools. A professional response weighs the evidence, considers the local context, pilots a change, and collects data on the results rather than adopting or rejecting an idea on reputation alone.

Evaluating Educational Research Credibility: ESSA Evidence Tiers

Secondary educators are constantly bombarded by commercial vendors and curriculum publishers marketing "revolutionary" software, curricula, and instructional fads. To protect public funds and ensure student learning, educators must be equipped to critically evaluate the methodological soundness and empirical credibility of educational claims.

The federal Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) established a formal, four-tiered framework to define what constitutes an evidence-based intervention : +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

  • | ESSA TIERS OF EVIDENCE-BASED RESEARCH |
  • +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • | Tier 1: STRONG Evidence |
  • | * Supported by at least one well-designed, well-implemented randomized |
  • | controlled trial (RCT). Demonstrates statistically significant positive effect.|
  • | |
  • | Tier 2: MODERATE Evidence |
  • | * Supported by at least one well-designed, well-implemented quasi-experimental |
  • | study (matched comparison group, no random assignment). |
  • | |
  • | Tier 3: PROMISING Evidence |
  • | * Supported by at least one well-designed correlational study with statistical |
  • | controls for selection bias. |
  • | |
  • | Tier 4: DEMONSTRATES A RATIONALE |
  • | * Well-defined logic model grounded in empirical literature, with an ongoing |
  • | formal evaluation plan to measure outcomes. |
  • +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • Unmasking Commercial Fads and Pseudoscience: The Learning Styles Myth

A classic example of an unscientific pedagogical fad is the VARK "Learning Styles" theory (the belief that individuals learn fundamentally better when instruction is tailored strictly to their self-reported visual, auditory, reading, or kinesthetic preference).

The Scientific Consensus : Overwhelming empirical research across cognitive science and educational psychology has repeatedly demonstrated that catering to learning styles produces zero measurable improvement in academic achievement . While adolescents express personal preferences, human cognitive architecture processes conceptual meaning semantically.

The Evidence-Based Alternative : Rather than attempting to categorize students into rigid visual or auditory buckets, cognitive science validates Dual Coding Theory (Allan Paivio) and Universal Design for Learning (UDL) . Presenting information through integrated multimodal channels (e.g., combining verbal explanations with synchronized visual diagrams) benefits all adolescent learners, regardless of their self-perceived "style."

Practical Checklist for Evaluating Commercial Educational Programs

When evaluating a proposed instructional program, secondary educators should demand answers to five critical methodological questions:

Is the study published in a peer-reviewed academic journal? (Or is it an internal "white paper" funded and published by the software vendor itself?)

Was there an authentic comparison group? (Did researchers compare students using the product against an equivalent control group receiving high-quality standard instruction?)

Is the sample representative of our secondary student population? (Was the program tested on diverse adolescent learners in public middle and high schools, including English learners and students with disabilities?)

What was the effect size (e.g., Cohen's d)? (Is the demonstrated academic gain meaningful in practice, or merely a trivial difference that achieved statistical significance due to an enormous sample size?)

Have independent researchers replicated the results? (Has any researcher without a financial stake in the commercial program successfully reproduced the positive findings?)

Action Research in the Secondary Classroom

Action research is a systematic, reflective inquiry conducted by classroom practitioners in their own instructional settings to gather information about how their particular school operates, how they teach, and how well their students learn (Mills, 2011). Unlike traditional university-based academic research—which seeks broad generalizability and controlled laboratory conditions—action research focuses on localized, practical problem-solving .

The Cyclical Action Research Process

Action research operates as an iterative, continuous cycle comprising four core phases (the Lewin/Kemmis & McTaggart cycle): +---------------------------------------+

  • | 1. PLAN |
  • | * Identify problem of practice |
  • | * Formulate researchable question |
  • | * Review literature & select strategy|
  • +-------------------+-------------------+
  • |
  • v
  • +---------------------------------------+
  • | 2. ACT |
  • | * Implement targeted intervention |
  • | * Maintain instructional fidelity |
  • | * Execute over 4-8 weeks |
  • +-------------------+-------------------+
  • |
  • v
  • +---------------------------------------+
  • | 3. OBSERVE |
  • | * Collect triangulated data |
  • | * Quantitative & qualitative evidence|
  • | * Track student growth & engagement |
  • +-------------------+-------------------+
  • |
  • v
  • +---------------------------------------+
  • | 4. REFLECT |
  • | * Analyze data against question |
  • | * Draw pedagogical conclusions |
  • | * Share findings & modify next cycle |
  • +---------------------------------------+
  • 1. Formulating a Researchable Secondary Classroom Question

The foundation of effective action research is a well-crafted question. Researchable questions are specific, actionable, focused on teacher practice within the classroom's locus of control, and linked to measurable adolescent learning outcomes.

Flawed (Non-Researchable) Question : "Does adolescent poverty decrease high school students' motivation to complete homework?"

Why it fails : It examines external socioeconomic variables outside the teacher's immediate control, treats motivation as a fixed deficit, and yields no actionable pedagogical intervention.

Exemplary (Researchable) Question : "How does the implementation of structured, 5-minute peer-editing protocols using an analytic rubric impact 10th-grade students' ability to synthesize primary source evidence in argumentative history essays?"

Why it succeeds : It isolates a clear independent instructional variable (structured peer editing with an analytic rubric), targets a specific secondary cohort (10th-grade history), and evaluates an observable, measurable academic outcome (primary source synthesis in essays).

2. Data Collection and Triangulation

To ensure validity and credibility, action researchers must practice data triangulation —collecting at least three distinct, independent sources of qualitative and quantitative evidence. Relying on a single metric (such as a single quiz score) introduces severe measurement error. [ Triangulated Data Matrix ]

  • |
  • +-------------------------------+-------------------------------+
  • | | |
  • v v v
  • Quantitative Data Qualitative Data Observational Data
  • * Pre- and post-tests * Student focus group notes * Teacher field notes
  • * CFA mastery percentages * Open-ended survey responses * Peer observation tallies
  • * Rubric sub-scores * Student self-reflection logs * Time-on-task matrices
  • 3. Analyzing Evidence to Modify Instruction

Data analysis in action research does not require advanced multivariate statistics. Practitioners utilize inductive thematic coding for qualitative data (identifying recurring themes in student reflections) and descriptive statistics for quantitative data (calculating percentage gains, median scores, and disaggregating by learner sub-populations). The ultimate goal is pedagogical modification: determining whether the intervention produced meaningful cognitive growth and identifying specific adjustments required for the next instructional iteration.

4. Disseminating Findings and Collective Inquiry

Action research achieves maximum institutional power when findings are not kept secret. Sharing outcomes during department PLC meetings, district professional development sessions, or regional educational conferences builds collective teacher efficacy. Even when an intervention fails to produce expected gains, sharing that outcome prevents colleagues from repeating ineffective strategies and initiates a new cycle of collaborative problem-solving.

  • Disciplinary Scenarios in Secondary Classrooms
  • Secondary Humanities: 11th-Grade ELA Action Research

The Problem : Ms. Thornton notices that her 11th-grade students participate minimally during full-class discussions of complex literary texts, with conversations dominated by the same three extroverted students.

Action Research Plan : Ms. Thornton formulates the question: "What is the effect of integrating structured Silent Socratic Discussions (digital collaborative annotation boards) prior to oral seminars on the equity and analytical depth of adolescent discourse?"

Action & Observation : Over a 6-week unit on American transcendentalism, Ms. Thornton implements 15 minutes of silent digital annotations before every spoken seminar. She triangulates data: (1) a rubric-based tally of oral textual citations, (2) digital platform contribution logs, and (3) an anonymous student perception survey.

Reflection & Impact : Data reveals oral participation among previously silent students increased by 140%, and textual citations in analytical essays rose by 35%. Students reported that silent written brainstorming lowered their affective filter and gave them the confidence to speak. Ms. Thornton presents these findings at the regional language arts symposium.

Common Exam Traps

Confusing Action Research with Academic Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs) : Action research is conducted by classroom teachers in their own naturalistic environments to solve immediate problems of practice. It does not require withholding instruction from a "control group" of students, which would be ethically unacceptable in a secondary classroom.