Study guide

9.3 Supporting Strategies & Differentiated Instruction

Praxis Principles of Learning and Teaching: Grades 7-12 5624

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Exam Overview & How Students Learn

1.1 Praxis 5624 Test Facts, Scoring & Qualifying Scores 1.2 How Students Construct Knowledge & Acquire Skills 1.3 Key Learning-Theory Terms: Schema to Conditioning

2 Chapter 2: Foundational Theorists & Adolescent Development

2.1 Piaget, Vygotsky, Bruner & Dewey in the Secondary Classroom 2.2 Bandura, Kohlberg, Gilligan & Bloom 2.3 Adolescent Development: Brain, Body, Identity & Variance

3 Chapter 3: Students as Diverse Learners

3.1 Learner Variables: Culture, Gender, SES & Prior Knowledge 3.2 Areas of Exceptionality and Their Impact on Learning 3.3 Disability Law in Practice: IDEA, Section 504 & ADA 3.4 Gifted and Talented Learners: Acceleration & Enrichment

4 Chapter 4: English Learners, Accommodations & UDL

4.1 English Language Acquisition and English Learners 4.2 Accommodations, Modifications & Universal Design for Learning

5 Chapter 5: Motivation & the Learning Environment

5.1 Thorndike, Watson, Skinner, Maslow & Erikson 5.2 Motivation Theories: SDT, Attribution, Expectancy-Value & Mindset 5.3 Classroom Management: Routines, Records, Space & Discipline 5.4 A Positive Learning Climate & Student Self-Motivation

6 Chapter 6: Planning Instruction

6.1 Standards, Frameworks & Instructional Alignment 6.2 Applying Behaviorism, Cognitivism, Social Learning & Constructivism 6.3 Scope, Sequence & Curriculum Alignment 6.4 Backward Design and Selecting Content 6.5 Writing Observable, Measurable Objectives in Three Domains

7 Chapter 7: Remediation, Resources & Interdisciplinary Planning

7.1 Planning Remediation and Tiered Support (MTSS/RTI) 7.2 Resources, Thematic & Interdisciplinary Units, and Planning Partners

8 Chapter 8: Instructional Models & Strategies

8.1 Direct Instruction, Hunter's Lesson Design & Closure 8.2 Indirect, Independent, Experiential & Interactive Models 8.3 Cooperative Learning Structures

9 Chapter 9: Thinking Skills, Differentiation & Grouping

9.1 Cognitive Processes: Critical & Creative Thinking, Reasoning, Problem Solving 9.2 Complex Cognitive Processes, Conceptual Change & Graphic Organizers 9.3 Supporting Strategies & Differentiated Instruction 9.4 Self-Regulation Skills, Group Configurations & Grouping Techniques

10 Chapter 10: Adjusting Instruction, Teachable Moments & Memory

10.1 Selecting Strategies, Monitoring & Adjusting, and Teachable Moments 10.2 Short-Term and Long-Term Memory in Instructional Planning

11 Chapter 11: Questioning & Discussion

11.1 Components of Effective Questioning and Wait Time 11.2 Purposes of Questioning and Question Levels 11.3 Helping Students Articulate Ideas and Think at Higher Levels 11.4 Discussion Models and a Safe, Open Forum

12 Chapter 12: Communication & Disciplinary Literacy

12.1 Verbal, Nonverbal, Cultural & Gender Dimensions of Communication 12.2 Communication Tools, Accessibility & Active Listening 12.3 Disciplinary Literacy and Reading Guides in Secondary Content Areas

13 Chapter 13: Classroom Assessment Strategies & Tools

13.1 Formal & Informal, Formative, Summative & Diagnostic Assessment 13.2 Creating and Selecting Assessment Formats 13.3 Student Self-Assessment and Peer Assessment 13.4 Rubrics, Checklists, Scoring Guides, Anecdotal Notes & Continuums

14 Chapter 14: Standardized Testing, Scores & Data

14.1 Standardized Tests: Achievement, Aptitude, Ability & Norm vs. Criterion 14.2 Validity, Reliability & Assessment Bias 14.3 Mean, Median, Mode, Standard Deviation & Derived Scores 14.4 Interpreting Test Data and Communicating Results 14.5 Using Assessment Data and Feedback to Improve Learning

15 Chapter 15: Professional Growth, Research & Reflection

15.1 Professional Development Resources, Mentoring & Coaching 15.2 Using Research, Evidence Tiers & Action Research 15.3 Reflective Practice for Professional Growth

16 Chapter 16: Support Personnel, Families & Collaboration

16.1 School Support Personnel and Co-Teaching 16.2 Partnerships with Parents and Families 16.3 Teacher Leadership, Perceptions of Teachers & Community Partnerships 16.4 Collaborative Relationships and Professional Learning Communities

17 Chapter 17: School Law, Rights & Professional Responsibilities

17.1 Privacy and Confidentiality: FERPA, PPRA & Student Searches 17.2 Equal Access, Title IX & Student Due Process 17.3 First Amendment Rights, Religion & Intellectual Freedom 17.4 Mandated Reporting of Abuse and Neglect, and Teacher Liability 17.5 Licensing, Tenure, Due Process & Professional Ethics 17.6 Copyright, Fair Use & the TEACH Act

18 Chapter 18: Analysis of Instructional Scenarios (Constructed Response)

18.1 Constructed-Response Format, the ETS Scoring Guide & Case Tasks 18.2 Case Practice: Diagnosing Learner Development and Motivation 18.3 Case Practice: Evaluating Instruction, Assessment & Collaboration

9.3 Supporting Strategies & Differentiated Instruction

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

ETS's supporting strategies are modeling, developing self-regulation skills, scaffolding, differentiating instruction, guided practice, and coaching.

Scaffolds are temporary; once students use a support well, the next step is to withdraw it.

Tomlinson's teachers differentiate content, process, product, and environment according to readiness, interest, and learning profile.

Tiered tasks share the same learning goal but vary complexity and support, and all tiers must be respectful, meaningful work.

Differentiation fails when it lowers cognitive demand for struggling students or gives advanced students more of the same.

Last updated: September 2026

Six Strategies for Supporting Student Learning

ETS names six strategies for supporting student learning: modeling, developing self-regulation skills, scaffolding, differentiating instruction, guided practice, and coaching . They work together as a progression from teacher support toward student independence.

Strategy What it is Secondary example Moves toward independence by

Modeling Demonstrating a skill or thought process, often with a think-aloud The teacher annotates a poem aloud, naming each decision Having students model for one another

Developing self-regulation skills Teaching students to set goals, plan, monitor, and reflect Students track progress on a research project with a milestone checklist Shifting from teacher-set to student-set goals

Scaffolding Temporary support matched to the task and removed as competence grows Sentence starters for a first lab conclusion Fading the support, for example by asking students to create their own word list next time

Differentiating instruction Adjusting content, process, product, or environment to readiness, interest, and learning profile Tiered readings on the same historical question Regrouping as data change

Guided practice Students practice with the teacher monitoring and giving immediate feedback Pairs solve problems while the teacher circulates Moving to independent practice once accuracy is high

Coaching Individualized observation, prompts, and feedback while a student performs Conferring with a writer about one revision goal Asking the student to diagnose the next goal

A central principle: a scaffold is temporary . When students use a support effectively, the next step is to withdraw it and ask them to do that part themselves. Leaving scaffolds in place indefinitely creates dependence. This section then examines differentiated instruction in depth, since ETS's case tasks repeatedly ask candidates to meet the needs of a wide range of learners.

Theoretical Foundations: Carol Ann Tomlinson's Model

Differentiated instruction is an instructional philosophy and pedagogical model developed extensively by Carol Ann Tomlinson. Rather than viewing a classroom as a monolithic collective that must be taught identically, differentiated instruction recognizes that secondary classrooms encompass a wide spectrum of cognitive readiness, background knowledge, linguistic proficiencies, cultural traditions, and adolescent interests. Tomlinson defines differentiation as a teacher's proactive response to learner needs shaped by mindset, guided by general principles of differentiation, and enacted through adjustments to curricular elements.

Differentiated instruction is firmly anchored in Lev Vygotsky's Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) . Vygotsky posited that optimal cognitive growth occurs when learning tasks are situated just beyond a student's current independent mastery level, requiring instructional scaffolding to achieve success. If an instructional task is far above a student's ZPD, the learner experiences acute frustration and cognitive shutdown. Conversely, if a task falls well below the student's ZPD, the learner experiences boredom and cognitive stagnation. In a heterogeneous high school class, a single standardized assignment cannot simultaneously reside within the ZPD of every adolescent. Differentiation provides the pedagogical mechanisms to calibrate challenge and support dynamically.

The driving engine of differentiated instruction is continuous formative assessment . Formative assessment is not merely an evaluative event at the end of a unit; rather, it is an ongoing diagnostic compass. Teachers employ pre-assessments (diagnostic assessments administered before instruction) to establish baseline student readiness, deploy ongoing formative checks during instruction (exit tickets, think-pair-share, brief polls, quick-writes) to track conceptual growth, and utilize summative assessments to evaluate cumulative mastery. +---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

  • | CAROL ANN TOMLINSON'S DIFFERENTIATION FRAMEWORK |
  • +---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • | TEACHERS CAN DIFFERENTIATE: |
  • | 1. CONTENT --> What students learn & how they access information |
  • | 2. PROCESS --> How students make sense of and internalize concepts |
  • | 3. PRODUCT --> How students demonstrate mastery and apply knowledge |
  • | 4. ENVIRONMENT--> Physical layout and emotional classroom climate |
  • +---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • | ACCORDING TO STUDENT TRAITS (Assessed continuously): |
  • | A. READINESS --> Current skill level, prior knowledge & proximity to ZPD |
  • | B. INTEREST --> Personal passions, hobbies, career goals & curiosities |
  • | C. PROFILE --> Cultural habits, preferred working environments & modalities |
  • +---------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  • The Four Curricular Elements of Differentiation

Tomlinson's model identifies four primary classroom elements that secondary educators can modify to meet adolescent learning needs:

1. Content: What Students Learn and Access

Content encompasses the knowledge, concepts, facts, principles, and skills that students are expected to learn, as well as the instructional mechanisms through which they access that information. While state standards dictate the core goals, the vehicles through which content is delivered can be varied:

Leveled and Multi-Lexile Texts : In an 8th-grade social studies unit exploring the American Industrial Revolution, the teacher provides three textual versions of an archival speech: an unabridged primary document, a modern English transcription, and a version with simplified sentence structures and side-margin vocabulary glossaries. Crucially, all three texts convey identical historical arguments and thematic concepts, enabling every student to participate in the ensuing seminar.

Curriculum Compacting : A targeted strategy specifically designed for high-achieving or gifted learners. Before launching a unit on quadratic equations in Algebra I, the teacher administers a rigorous pre-assessment. Students who demonstrate 90% or higher mastery are excused from redundant introductory lectures and repetitive homework. Instead, their curriculum is "compacted," freeing instructional time to engage in advanced, self-directed mathematical investigations, such as modeling real-world physics trajectories using parabolic vectors.

Learning Contracts : Negotiated formal agreements between the secondary educator and an individual student or small cohort. A learning contract outlines specific learning standards to be mastered, student-selected resources, working deadlines, and benchmarks for self-assessment, granting the student autonomy over the pace and order of content acquisition.

2. Process: How Students Make Sense of Ideas

Process refers to the cognitive activities, sense-making exercises, and instructional tasks students undertake to internalize, question, and assimilate complex content into their cognitive schemas. Sense-making is essential; students do not truly own concepts until they manipulate, analyze, and apply them.

Tiered Activities : The cornerstone of process differentiation. In a tiered activity, the teacher creates two or three levels of a task that share an identical fundamental learning objective and essential question, but vary in their level of abstractness, complexity, open-endedness, and required scaffolding. For example, during a 9th-grade biology lab on cellular respiration, all tiers investigate metabolic rates. Tier 1 students follow a semi-structured protocol with guided data tables and visual cues; Tier 2 students follow a standard inquiry protocol requiring independent variable graphing; Tier 3 students are tasked with designing their own experimental setup to test an unpredicted variable (e.g., pH variance on yeast metabolism) with open-ended hypothesis testing.

Differentiated Graphic Organizers : Providing varying scaffolds for information synthesis. Striving students receive a structured cause-and-effect organizer with partially completed sentence starters and directional arrows, while advanced students receive an open relational matrix requiring them to map multi-causal historical feedback loops.

Interest-Based Learning Stations : Secondary classrooms feature designated stations where students rotate to explore an overarching concept through distinct lenses (e.g., in a literature unit on dystopian fiction, one station examines governmental surveillance through technology, another analyzes sociological class stratification, and a third evaluates historical propaganda posters).

3. Product: How Students Demonstrate Mastery

Product refers to the culminating assessments, tangible artifacts, or performance tasks through which secondary learners demonstrate their depth of understanding, synthesis, and application of unit standards.

Choice Boards and Tic-Tac-Toe Product Menus : A structured grid of nine assessment tasks aligned to specific learning targets. Students choose three contiguous options to form a line (like Tic-Tac-Toe) or pick one task from designated cognitive categories. In a 10th-grade geometry unit on spatial geometry, choices might include: constructing a 3D architectural scale model with surface-area calculations, authoring a step-by-step digital construction manual for a contractor, or coding a computer algorithm that calculates volumetric displacement.

RAFT Assignments (Role, Audience, Format, Topic) : A powerful, highly differentiated product strategy that combines creative expression with rigorous domain analysis. Each student (or the teacher) selects a specific configuration of four variables:

Role : Who are you speaking/writing as? (e.g., Galileo Galilei, a red blood cell, an abolitionist newspaper editor)

Audience : Whom are you addressing? (e.g., the Roman Inquisition, a sedentary human heart, undecided voters in 1860)

Format : What physical or digital genre will you produce? (e.g., a formal legal defense brief, an urgent biochemical dispatch, a newspaper broadside)

Topic : What core concept or conflict is being examined? (e.g., defending heliocentrism, pleading for cardiovascular exercise, arguing against the Fugitive Slave Act)

Tiered Rubrics : While product formats may vary, rubrics share identical core assessment criteria evaluating conceptual mastery, evidence usage, and analytical precision, ensuring equitable grading rigor.

4. Learning Environment: The Physical and Affective Climate

The learning environment encompasses both the physical configuration of the classroom and the socio-emotional climate that dictates how students interact, risk failure, and collaborate.

Physical Configuration : Creating diverse physical micro-zones within a secondary classroom, including quiet, independent study carrels with noise-dampening headphones; round tables for collaborative group deliberation; standing desks; and an open carpeted or tech-equipped zone for digital media production.

Psychological Climate : Cultivating an atmosphere of psychological safety, mutual respect, and growth mindset. The teacher explicitly normalizes mistakes as essential data points in the learning process and ensures that all assigned tasks are "respectful tasks"—meaning every student, regardless of tier, engages in meaningful, cognitively rich work rather than demeaning, low-level drill.

Note

A "respectful task" is an essential concept on the Praxis PLT exam. If a teacher gives advanced students an engaging, creative engineering simulation while relegating struggling students to copying vocabulary definitions out of the glossary, the teacher has violated the principle of respectful tasks. Both tasks must be equally engaging, intellectually honest, and standard-aligned.

  • Differentiating According to Student Traits: Readiness, Interest, and Profile
  • Readiness and the Zone of Proximal Development

Readiness refers to a student's current knowledge, conceptual understanding, and skill level in relation to a specific learning target. It is critical to recognize that readiness is not synonymous with fixed general ability or IQ . A student may exhibit advanced readiness in mathematical algebraic reasoning while exhibiting low readiness in written narrative composition. Assessing readiness requires continuous diagnostic data collection (e.g., pre-tests, skill inventories, KWL charts) to place students in their optimal ZPD.

Interest and Adolescent Motivation

Adolescent psychology dictates that intrinsic motivation surges when learning connects directly to personal passions, extracurricular hobbies, cultural concerns, and future career aspirations. Differentiating by interest involves integrating student passions into the curriculum without compromising rigor. For example, during an 11th-grade physics unit on momentum and kinetic energy, students select an area of personal interest to analyze: the biomechanics of soccer headers, the engineering of roller coaster loops, automotive crash safety systems, or competitive skateboard half-pipe physics.

Learning Profile and Sociocultural Considerations

Learning profile addresses how a student processes information, interacts with others, and works most effectively. It is shaped by:

Cultural Orientations : Cultural preferences for collaborative communal learning (interdependence) versus solitary, competitive learning (individualism); oral storytelling traditions versus written analytical discourse.

Environmental Preferences : Environmental requirements regarding ambient lighting, acoustic levels, physical movement, and temperature.

Cognitive Processing Habits : Preferences for inductive discovery (moving from specific examples to general rules) versus deductive reasoning (starting with an overarching principle and applying it to cases); holistic/big-picture orientation versus sequential/detail-oriented analysis.

Warning

Do not confuse a student's learning profile with rigid sensory "learning styles" (such as asserting that a student is strictly an auditory learner who cannot learn from visual text). Differentiating by learning profile means offering flexible environmental conditions, collaborative structures, and processing modes, not restricting instructional delivery to a single sensory channel.

Comprehensive Secondary Differentiation Matrix

The following matrix illustrates how the four curricular elements interact with secondary disciplinary content:

Curricular Element Secondary Exemplar 1: 8th-Grade Physical Science Secondary Exemplar 2: 10th-Grade English Language Arts Secondary Exemplar 3: 11th-Grade US History

Content Providing leveled lab reading guides; curriculum compacting for students demonstrating mastery of the periodic table; audio-recorded science articles with embedded diagrams. Utilizing multi-lexile translations of Shakespeare's Macbeth (original folio alongside modern English side-by-side); providing audiobooks synced to digital text. Compacting the New Deal unit for advanced students to conduct archival oral history projects; providing primary sources accompanied by visual political cartoons.

Process Tiered laboratory investigations on thermal energy transfer: Tier 1 conducts guided calorie measurement; Tier 2 alters insulation materials; Tier 3 calculates thermodynamic entropy. Tiered analytical stations analyzing character tragic flaws: Tier 1 uses structured graphic organizers; Tier 2 conducts paired dialectical journaling; Tier 3 evaluates historical scholarly critique. Tiered primary document analysis of the Civil Rights movement: Tier 1 examines speeches with guided annotation questions; Tier 2 evaluates competing ideological platforms; Tier 3 synthesizes counter-narratives.

Product Choice board for energy conservation: drafting a municipal energy policy, constructing an insulated prototype thermos, or delivering an informational video campaign. RAFT writing assignment: Role: Lady Macbeth, Audience: Scottish Court, Format: Secret diary entry or formal public proclamation, Topic: Denying complicity in regicide. Authoring a historical museum exhibit proposal, scripting and filming a documentary news segment, or writing a comparative foreign policy position paper.

Environment Designating specific lab zones: quiet calculation carrels, hands-on fabrication tables, and computer simulation stations with safety protocols. Offering flexible seating during independent writing workshops, including quiet focus carrels and collaborative peer-conferencing nooks. Arranging parliamentary horseshoe seating for structured debates and quiet research carrels for archival document analysis.

Common Pitfalls and Exam Traps

Pitfall 1: "Watering Down" the Curriculum for Struggling Learners : The most pervasive differentiation error on the Praxis PLT exam is lowering cognitive demand. When a teacher asks struggling 9th graders to merely match vocabulary definitions while advanced peers synthesize multiple primary texts, the teacher is not differentiating—they are denying struggling students access to essential grade-level standards. True differentiation maintains identical cognitive complexity (e.g., analysis, evaluation) while modifying the degree of scaffolding and support.

Pitfall 2: "More of the Same" Busywork for Advanced Learners : Giving a gifted high school student 50 geometry proofs instead of 25, or requiring them to clean beakers or act as an unpaid "peer tutor" for struggling classmates whenever they finish early, represents a failure of differentiation. Advanced learners require greater depth, abstractness, novelty, and complexity , not increased volume of routine work.

Pitfall 3: Static, Permanent Ability Tracking : Assigning students to fixed, immutable "low," "middle," or "high" reading groups or math tracks stigmatizes adolescents, damages academic self-efficacy, and exacerbates systemic achievement gaps. Differentiation requires fluid, dynamic regrouping that shifts constantly based on diagnostic formative data.

Pitfall 4: Grading on Effort Alone or Grading Different Tiers on Inequitable Scales : A student completing a Tier 1 scaffolded assignment must be capable of earning the highest grade if they achieve full mastery of the underlying standard. Grading must reflect progress toward and mastery of essential standards, not compliance or task volume.