Study guide
5.4 Restorative Practices & Positive Behavior Support
Praxis School Psychologist 5403
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction: About the Praxis 5403 Exam
About the Praxis School Psychologist (5403) Exam
2 Chapter 1: Data-Based Decision Making & Assessment Frameworks
1.1 Problem-Solving Models & Problem Identification 1.2 Curriculum-Based Measurement & Progress Monitoring 1.3 Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS) Decision Rules 1.4 Background Information, Records Review & Screening 1.5 Ecological, Performance-Based & Technology-Supported Assessment
3 Chapter 2: Psychoeducational Assessment & Psychometrics
2.1 Measurement Theory, Reliability, & Validity 2.2 Standardized Score Interpretations & Distributions 2.3 Cognitive Theories & Processing Assessment 2.4 Achievement & Diagnostic Processing Assessment 2.5 Social-Emotional & Behavioral Assessment Methods 2.6 Developmental & Adaptive Behavior Assessment 2.7 Assessing Students with Low-Incidence Disabilities
4 Chapter 3: Consultation Models & Collaborative Practice
3.1 Behavioral Consultation Models 3.2 Mental Health & Organizational Consultation 3.3 Collaborative Communication & Interdisciplinary Teams
5 Chapter 4: Academic Interventions & Instructional Support
4.1 Evidence-Based Reading Interventions 4.2 Evidence-Based Math & Writing Interventions 4.3 Cognitive & Executive Functioning Supports 4.4 Universal Design for Learning (UDL), Accommodations, & Modifications 4.5 Effective Instruction: Evidence-Based Instructional Strategies 4.6 Factors & Influences on Academic Success
6 Chapter 5: Behavioral Assessment & Applied Behavior Interventions
5.1 Functional Behavior Assessment (FBA) 5.2 Behavior Intervention Plans (BIP) & Replacement Behaviors 5.3 Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) & Operant Conditioning 5.4 Restorative Practices & Positive Behavior Support 5.5 Classroom Organization & Management
7 Chapter 6: Mental Health Services & Child Psychopathology
6.1 Internalizing Disorders & Cognitive-Behavioral Interventions 6.2 Externalizing Disorders & Neurodevelopmental Conditions 6.3 School-Based Counseling Approaches & Group Interventions 6.4 Counseling Foundations: Core Skills, Theories & Developmental Adaptations 6.5 Trauma-Informed Practice in Schools 6.6 Prevention Science: Risk & Protective Factors, SEL, Social Skills & Conflict Resolution 6.7 Other Childhood Conditions, Biological Influences & Evaluating Mental Health Services
8 Chapter 7: Systems-Level Services & Schoolwide PBIS/MTSS
7.1 Schoolwide PBIS & Multi-Tiered Behavioral Systems 7.2 School Climate, Bullying Prevention, & Attendance 7.3 Systems Change & Program Evaluation 7.4 Systems-Level Data & Educational Policy: Needs Assessment, Retention, Tracking & Testing
9 Chapter 8: Crisis Prevention, Response & Family-Community Collaboration
8.1 School Crisis Preparedness & the PREPaRE Model 8.2 Suicide Risk Assessment & Behavioral Threat Assessment 8.3 Family-School Collaboration & Community Partnerships 8.4 Family Systems, Parenting & Home-Based Interventions 8.5 Interagency Collaboration & Transition Planning
10 Chapter 9: Diversity, Equity & Research Methodology
9.1 Culturally Responsive & Non-Discriminatory Assessment 9.2 Addressing Disproportionality & Implicit Bias in Schools 9.3 Research Designs, Statistics, & Evidence-Based Evaluation 9.4 Diversity, Individual Differences & Social Justice Advocacy 9.5 Evaluating Research Quality & Basic Statistics
11 Chapter 10: Legal, Ethical & Professional Standards in School Psychology
10.1 IDEA: Foundations, Evaluation & Eligibility 10.2 IDEA: IEPs, Procedural Safeguards & Discipline 10.3 Section 504, ADA, FERPA, & Federal Regulations 10.4 Landmark Case Law in School Psychology & Special Education 10.5 NASP Ethical Principles & Professional Standards 10.6 Student Rights: Consent, Confidentiality, Restraint & Seclusion, and Discipline 10.7 Professional Liability, Supervision & Lifelong Professional Growth
5.4 Restorative Practices & Positive Behavior Support
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Restorative justice fundamentally transforms school discipline by replacing retributive accountability (rule breaking -> blame -> exclusion) with relational accountability (identifying harm -> obligations -> active community repair).
The Social Discipline Window holds that the best behavioral outcomes come from the 'WITH' quadrant (Restorative: high control + high support), in contrast to 'TO' (Punitive/Authoritarian), 'FOR' (Permissive), or 'NOT' (Neglectful).
Restorative practices exist on an explicit continuum ranging from informal universal tools (affective statements, restorative questions) to structured group dialogues (proactive and responsive circles) and formal Tier 3 restorative conferences.
Schoolwide PBIS and Restorative Practices are complementary frameworks within MTSS: PBIS provides behavioral predictability and explicit expectations, while Restorative Practices provide relational depth and equitable conflict resolution.
Trauma-informed behavior support reframes chronic behavioral challenges from willful defiance to autonomic nervous system dysregulation, prioritizing neurobiological 'felt safety' and adult co-regulation over punitive exclusionary discipline.
Last updated: September 2026
Restorative Practices & Positive Behavior Support
Contemporary school psychology has undergone a paradigm shift away from exclusionary, zero-tolerance disciplinary models toward multi-tiered, restorative, and trauma-informed behavioral systems ( NASP Practice Model Domains 2, 7, & 8 ). Decades of empirical research demonstrate that traditional punitive discipline—such as out-of-school suspensions, expulsions, and corporal punishment—fails to deter problem behavior, disproportionately harms minoritized youth and students with disabilities, and actively fuels the school-to-prison pipeline . In response, school psychologists lead the integration of Restorative Practices with Schoolwide Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS) to create equitable, predictable, and relationally supportive educational communities.
Restorative Justice vs. Retributive Discipline
Restorative justice is an educational and philosophical framework rooted in indigenous traditions that views misconduct not primarily as a violation of institutional rules, but as an injury to interpersonal relationships and community trust. Rather than asking how to punish the offender, restorative justice asks how to heal the harm and restore community balance. Two Disciplinary Paradigms Compared
- Retributive Discipline Restorative Justice
- ┌──────────────────────────────┐ ┌──────────────────────────────┐
- │ • What rule was broken? │ │ • Who was harmed? │
- │ • Who broke it? │ VS │ • What are their needs? │
- │ • What punishment is │ │ • Whose obligation is it to │
- │ deserved? │ │ repair the harm? │
- └──────────────┬───────────────┘ └──────────────┬───────────────┘
- ▼ ▼
- Exclusion & Alienation Healing & Reintegration
- (Zero-Tolerance, OSS) (Circles, Agreements)
- Analytical Comparison: Retributive vs. Restorative Paradigms
Disciplinary Dimension Retributive / Punitive Model Restorative Justice Model
Core Focus Focuses on the rule violation and establishing guilt. Focuses on the interpersonal harm caused and repairing relationships.
Primary Questions "What rule was broken? Who did it? What punishment do they deserve?" "What happened? Who was impacted? What needs to be done to make things right?"
Accountability Defined Passive accountability: The offender passively absorbs a punishment (e.g., sitting at home on suspension). Active accountability: The offender actively confronts the impact of their actions, takes direct responsibility, and completes tangible restitution.
Role of the Victim Peripheral or ignored: The state/school is the victim; the actual harmed individual has no voice in the outcome. Central: The harmed party's voice, safety, emotional needs, and desired repairs drive the resolution.
Community Role Bystanders or represented by punitive administrators. Active participants: Community members create a circle of support and hold both parties accountable.
Long-Term Impact Breeds resentment, social stigma, academic regression, and high recidivism rates. Fosters empathy, social-emotional competence, relational repair, and reintegration into the school community.
The Social Discipline Window
Developed by Paul McCold and Ted Wachtel (International Institute for Restorative Practices, IIRP) , the Social Discipline Window conceptualizes behavioral leadership across two independent, fundamental dimensions:
Control : The establishment of high expectations, clear boundaries, firm limit-setting, and accountability.
Support : The provision of emotional warmth, active listening, nurturing, scaffolding, and relational empathy. The Social Discipline Window
- HIGH
- ▲
- │ TO (Punitive) │ WITH (Restorative)
- │ • Authoritarian │ • Authoritative
- │ • Retributive / Coercive│ • High Accountability
- │ • Stigmatizing │ • High Relational Support
- CONTROL │ "Doing things TO" │ "Doing things WITH"
- (Boundaries) ├──────────────────────────┼──────────────────────────
- │ NOT (Neglectful) │ FOR (Permissive)
- │ • Indifferent │ • Paternalistic
- │ • Apathetic │ • Excusing Misconduct
- │ • Giving up │ • Rescuing from Consequences
- │ "Doing NOTHING" │ "Doing things FOR"
- │ │
- └──────────────────────────┴──────────────────────────►
- LOW SUPPORT HIGH
- (Nurturance / Care)
- The Four Leadership Quadrants
High Control + Low Support = TO (Punitive / Authoritarian) : School personnel manage behavior through rigid rules, coercion, and aggressive punishment. Students are treated as objects to be controlled ("I am doing this to you"). Breeds rebellion, deceit, and adversarial climates.
Low Control + Low Support = NOT (Neglectful / Indifferent) : Personnel are apathetic, disengaged, and fail to provide either standards or emotional care ("I am doing nothing "). Leads to chaotic, unsafe school environments.
Low Control + High Support = FOR (Permissive / Paternalistic) : Personnel excuse chronic misbehavior, rationalize defiance, and rescue students from natural consequences ("I will do this for you"). Deprives students of developing accountability and self-regulation.
High Control + High Support = WITH (Restorative / Authoritative) : Personnel maintain rigorous, non-negotiable expectations while simultaneously providing immense emotional scaffolding and personal warmth ("I will work with you"). This is the restorative sweet spot. Misconduct is directly confronted and held accountable, but within a framework of unconditional human dignity and relational connection.
The Continuum of Restorative Practices
Restorative practices do not consist exclusively of formal crisis circles. They exist on an explicit continuum that progresses from proactive, informal daily communication to intensive, formal Tier 3 interventions. Continuum of Restorative Practices (IIRP)
- INFORMAL ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────► FORMAL
- ┌──────────────┬──────────────┬──────────────┬──────────────┬──────────────┐
- │ Affective │ Restorative │ Impromptu │ Proactive │ Formal │
- │ Statements │ Questions │ Chats │ & Responsive│ Restorative │
- │ ("I feel") │ (Reflection) │ (Hallway) │ Circles │ Conferences │
- └──────────────┴──────────────┴──────────────┴──────────────┴──────────────┘
- Tier 1 Universal (80-90%) Tier 2 (10-15%) Tier 3 (1-5%)
- 1. Affective Statements
Affective statements are brief, authentic personal statements made by educators expressing their human feelings in response to specific positive or negative student actions. They transform mechanical commands into humanizing feedback.
Mechanical / Coercive : "Tyler, stop talking and open your book right now!"
Affective Statement : "Tyler, I feel frustrated and worried when people talk while I'm giving instructions, because I want to ensure everyone has the tools to succeed today."
Psychological Impact : Humanizes the educator, models emotional literacy, and teaches students that their actions impact others' emotional well-being without triggering defensiveness.
2. Restorative Questions
When an incident of harm occurs, educators replace interrogative, blame-inducing questions ("Why did you do that?") with standardized, non-defensive Restorative Question Sets :
Phase of Inquiry Questions for the Person Who Caused Harm Questions for the Person Harmed
1. Reflection on Event • What happened? What were you thinking at the time? • What did you think when you realized what happened?
2. Examining Impact • What have you thought about since? Who has been affected by what you did, and in what way? • What impact has this incident had on you and others? What has been the hardest thing for you?
3. Repairing Harm • What do you think you need to do to make things right? What can you do to ensure this doesn't happen again? • What do you think needs to happen to make things right? What would help you feel safe?
3. Impromptu Restorative Chats
Brief, 3- to 5-minute semi-structured conversations conducted by a teacher, counselor, or school psychologist in the hallway or classroom immediately following minor peer friction. Using restorative questions, the facilitator guides both students to articulate their feelings, acknowledge impact, and agree on an immediate mutual repair.
4. Proactive & Community-Building Circles (Tier 1)
Conducted regularly in homerooms or academic classrooms (e.g., morning meetings). Students and teachers sit in an unbroken physical circle using a designated talking piece and shared circle norms. Used to establish core classroom values, discuss current events, build social capital, and foster mutual empathy before conflicts arise.
5. Responsive / Problem-Solving Circles (Tier 2)
Convened when a specific classroom-level disturbance, micro-aggression, or recurring interpersonal friction impacts a group of students. The facilitator guides participants to discuss how the incident affected classroom safety and collectively design shared solutions.
6. Formal Restorative Conferences (Tier 3)
A formal, highly structured conference facilitated by a trained restorative practitioner to resolve serious disciplinary incidents (e.g., severe physical assaults, significant theft, hate speech, bullying). The conference brings together the person who caused harm, the person harmed, their families, and community supporters. Following a rigid script, all participants share their experiences, culminating in the drafting and signing of a written Restorative Agreement that specifies concrete restitution, community service, counseling, and academic support.
Schoolwide PBIS Tier Alignment with Restorative Practices
Schoolwide Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS) and Restorative Practices are not competing initiatives; they are functionally synergistic. PBIS provides the behavioral infrastructure, explicit predictability, and data-monitoring framework (e.g., Office Discipline Referrals [ODRs]), while Restorative Practices supply the relational depth, communication protocols, and restorative accountability. Multi-Tiered Integration: PBIS & Restorative Practices
- Tier 3: Intensive (1-5%)
- PBIS: Individualized FBA/BIP, Wraparound Systems, Crisis Safety Plans
- Restorative: Formal Restorative Conferences, Re-Entry Circles Post-Discipline
- Tier 2: Targeted (10-15%)
- PBIS: Check-In/Check-Out (CICO), Social Skills Instructional Groups
- Restorative: Responsive Problem-Solving Circles, Restorative CICO Mentorship
- Tier 1: Universal (80-90%)
- PBIS: Explicit 3-5 Behavioral Expectations Matrix, 4:1 Positive Praise Ratio
- Restorative: Proactive Community Circles, Affective Statements, Restorative Chats
- Re-Entry Circles: Dismantling Disciplinary Recidivism
A critical Tier 3 restorative protocol is the Restorative Re-Entry Circle . When a student returns to school following an extended suspension, expulsion, or placement in an alternative setting, traditional schools treat the student as an outcast, which virtually guarantees future disciplinary exclusion. In a restorative re-entry circle, school psychologists assemble the student, parents, administrators, and general educators prior to classroom entry . The circle establishes a welcoming, clean slate, reviews individualized academic/behavioral accommodations, and coordinates mutual support, dramatically reducing disciplinary recidivism.
Trauma-Informed Positive Behavior Support
A critical competency for contemporary school psychologists is understanding the neurobiology of trauma and Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) . Chronic exposure to developmental trauma, domestic violence, neglect, or systemic oppression alters brain architecture, creating an over-sensitized amygdala, impaired prefrontal executive functioning, and chronic autonomic hyper-arousal.
Dysregulation vs. Willful Defiance
Traditional punitive discipline labels traumatized students as "malicious," "defiant," or "bad." A trauma-informed behavioral framework fundamentally reframes challenging externalizing behavior:
Core Neurobiological Insight: For students with trauma histories, challenging behavior often is not calculated, willful defiance. It is frequently the outward sign of an autonomic nervous system in survival mode (Fight, Flight, Freeze, or Fawn) attempting to cope with perceived threat or overwhelming stress.
Neurobiological Principles: The Three R's (Dr. Bruce Perry)
Dr. Bruce Perry's Neurosequential Model establishes that educators cannot reason with a dysregulated child. Intervention must follow the sequential hierarchy of brain processing: Perry's Neurosequential Processing Hierarchy
- [3. REASON] Cortical (Executive Function) ──► "Reflective problem-solving,
- ▲ restorative questions, teaching"
- │
- [2. RELATE] Limbic (Emotional Attachment) ──► "Empathy, validation, non-verbal
- ▲ attunement, connection"
- │
- [1. REGULATE] Brainstem (Autonomic Arousal) ──► "Felt safety, breathing, calm
- voice, physical space"
Regulate (Brainstem) : Before any verbal reasoning can occur, the student's nervous system must experience "Felt Safety" (Dr. Karyn Purvis). Adults must lower their voice volume, use warm vocal prosody, step back, and provide regulatory sensory inputs (deep breathing, physical space, hydration).
Relate (Limbic) : The educator connects relationally with the student through emotional attunement, validating their distress ("I can see how overwhelming this feels right now").
Reason (Neocortex) : Only after the student is fully regulated and emotionally connected can the educator engage the prefrontal cortex in reflective reasoning, restorative questioning, or consequence processing.
- Critiques of Zero-Tolerance Policies & The School-to-Prison Pipeline
- The Failure of Zero Tolerance
Originating from the federal Gun-Free Schools Act of 1994, zero-tolerance policies mandate predetermined, severe exclusionary punishments (typically out-of-school suspensions or expulsions) for specific infractions, regardless of the context, intent, or developmental history. The American Psychological Association (APA) Zero Tolerance Task Force (2008) reviewed the evidence, and NASP reached similar conclusions:
No Deterrent Effect : Zero-tolerance policies do not improve school safety, student behavior, or academic achievement.
Adverse Academic & Life Outcomes : Suspension and expulsion are associated with higher odds of grade retention, dropout, and juvenile justice contact (e.g., the Texas Breaking Schools' Rules study, 2011).
The School-to-Prison Pipeline : By pushing struggling students out of the protective academic environment into unsupervised community settings, exclusionary discipline funnels vulnerable youth directly into the juvenile and adult criminal legal systems.
Disparate Impact & Discipline Disproportionality
Federal Civil Rights Data Collection (CRDC) consistently demonstrates pervasive, systemic racial and disability disparities in exclusionary discipline:
Black students are suspended and expelled at two to four times the rate of their white peers, and research finds the gap is largest for subjective infractions (e.g., "defiance," "disrespect," "insubordination").
Students with disabilities (particularly emotional disturbance and ADHD) receive out-of-school suspensions at roughly twice the rate of students without disabilities.
NASP Position : NASP calls on school psychologists to audit discipline data, advocate against zero-tolerance policies, and help replace exclusionary discipline with restorative, trauma-informed, multi-tiered positive behavior support.