Study guide
10.4 Landmark Case Law in School Psychology & Special Education
Praxis School Psychologist 5403
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction: About the Praxis 5403 Exam
About the Praxis School Psychologist (5403) Exam
2 Chapter 1: Data-Based Decision Making & Assessment Frameworks
1.1 Problem-Solving Models & Problem Identification 1.2 Curriculum-Based Measurement & Progress Monitoring 1.3 Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS) Decision Rules 1.4 Background Information, Records Review & Screening 1.5 Ecological, Performance-Based & Technology-Supported Assessment
3 Chapter 2: Psychoeducational Assessment & Psychometrics
2.1 Measurement Theory, Reliability, & Validity 2.2 Standardized Score Interpretations & Distributions 2.3 Cognitive Theories & Processing Assessment 2.4 Achievement & Diagnostic Processing Assessment 2.5 Social-Emotional & Behavioral Assessment Methods 2.6 Developmental & Adaptive Behavior Assessment 2.7 Assessing Students with Low-Incidence Disabilities
4 Chapter 3: Consultation Models & Collaborative Practice
3.1 Behavioral Consultation Models 3.2 Mental Health & Organizational Consultation 3.3 Collaborative Communication & Interdisciplinary Teams
5 Chapter 4: Academic Interventions & Instructional Support
4.1 Evidence-Based Reading Interventions 4.2 Evidence-Based Math & Writing Interventions 4.3 Cognitive & Executive Functioning Supports 4.4 Universal Design for Learning (UDL), Accommodations, & Modifications 4.5 Effective Instruction: Evidence-Based Instructional Strategies 4.6 Factors & Influences on Academic Success
6 Chapter 5: Behavioral Assessment & Applied Behavior Interventions
5.1 Functional Behavior Assessment (FBA) 5.2 Behavior Intervention Plans (BIP) & Replacement Behaviors 5.3 Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) & Operant Conditioning 5.4 Restorative Practices & Positive Behavior Support 5.5 Classroom Organization & Management
7 Chapter 6: Mental Health Services & Child Psychopathology
6.1 Internalizing Disorders & Cognitive-Behavioral Interventions 6.2 Externalizing Disorders & Neurodevelopmental Conditions 6.3 School-Based Counseling Approaches & Group Interventions 6.4 Counseling Foundations: Core Skills, Theories & Developmental Adaptations 6.5 Trauma-Informed Practice in Schools 6.6 Prevention Science: Risk & Protective Factors, SEL, Social Skills & Conflict Resolution 6.7 Other Childhood Conditions, Biological Influences & Evaluating Mental Health Services
8 Chapter 7: Systems-Level Services & Schoolwide PBIS/MTSS
7.1 Schoolwide PBIS & Multi-Tiered Behavioral Systems 7.2 School Climate, Bullying Prevention, & Attendance 7.3 Systems Change & Program Evaluation 7.4 Systems-Level Data & Educational Policy: Needs Assessment, Retention, Tracking & Testing
9 Chapter 8: Crisis Prevention, Response & Family-Community Collaboration
8.1 School Crisis Preparedness & the PREPaRE Model 8.2 Suicide Risk Assessment & Behavioral Threat Assessment 8.3 Family-School Collaboration & Community Partnerships 8.4 Family Systems, Parenting & Home-Based Interventions 8.5 Interagency Collaboration & Transition Planning
10 Chapter 9: Diversity, Equity & Research Methodology
9.1 Culturally Responsive & Non-Discriminatory Assessment 9.2 Addressing Disproportionality & Implicit Bias in Schools 9.3 Research Designs, Statistics, & Evidence-Based Evaluation 9.4 Diversity, Individual Differences & Social Justice Advocacy 9.5 Evaluating Research Quality & Basic Statistics
11 Chapter 10: Legal, Ethical & Professional Standards in School Psychology
10.1 IDEA: Foundations, Evaluation & Eligibility 10.2 IDEA: IEPs, Procedural Safeguards & Discipline 10.3 Section 504, ADA, FERPA, & Federal Regulations 10.4 Landmark Case Law in School Psychology & Special Education 10.5 NASP Ethical Principles & Professional Standards 10.6 Student Rights: Consent, Confidentiality, Restraint & Seclusion, and Discipline 10.7 Professional Liability, Supervision & Lifelong Professional Growth
10.4 Landmark Case Law in School Psychology & Special Education
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Brown v. Board of Education (1954) established under the 14th Amendment Equal Protection Clause that separate educational facilities are inherently unequal, serving as the constitutional foundation for special education advocacy.
PARC (1971) and Mills (1972) established the right to education for all children with disabilities, establishing that school districts cannot deny FAPE due to fiscal constraints or claims of student 'ineducability'.
The Supreme Court in Endrew F. v. Douglas County (2017) overturned the de minimis standard from Rowley (1982), mandating that an IEP must be reasonably calculated to enable a child to make progress appropriate in light of the child's circumstances through 'appropriately ambitious' goals.
Larry P. v. Riles (1979/1986) permanently enjoined California public schools from utilizing standardized intelligence tests to identify or place African American students into EMR/special education classes due to cultural and racial test bias.
Cedar Rapids v. Garret F. (1999) established the bright-line physician rule, requiring districts to fund and provide continuous nursing services under related services so long as they do not require the services of a licensed physician.
Last updated: September 2026
Landmark Case Law in School Psychology & Special Education
Statutory frameworks such as IDEA and Section 504 did not emerge in a legislative vacuum; they were forged through decades of civil rights litigation, constitutional challenges, and landmark judicial decisions. School psychologists must understand not merely statutory text, but the common-law precedents that define the legal boundaries of their clinical work. Judicial rulings interpret the Equal Protection and Due Process Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment , establish the substantive standards of Free Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) , govern assessment bias and disproportionality, delineate the boundaries of related services, and dictate mental health professionals' legal duties when violence or self-harm threatens school communities.
The Constitutional Architecture of Special Education
The legal foundation of special education rests upon the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution :
Equal Protection Clause : Prohibits states from denying any person within their jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. If a state chooses to provide public education to nondisabled children, it cannot arbitrarily exclude or segregate children with disabilities.
Due Process Clause : Guarantees that the state cannot deprive individuals of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. Public education is recognized as a protected property interest; therefore, classifying, segregating, or expelling a student requires procedural safeguards (notice, objective evaluations, hearings). [14th Amendment: Equal Protection & Due Process]
- │
- ▼
- [Brown v. Board of Education (1954)]
- Separate is inherently unequal
- Education is a right on equal terms
- │
- ┌──────────────────────┴──────────────────────┐
- ▼ ▼
- [PARC v. Commonwealth (1971)] [Mills v. Board of Ed (1972)]
- FAPE for intellectual disability • Extended to all disabilities
- Zero-reject foundation • Budget deficits cannot justify exclusion
- │ │
- └──────────────────────┬──────────────────────┘
- │
- ▼
- [P.L. 94-142 (EAHCA / IDEA, 1975)]
- │
- ┌──────────────────────┼──────────────────────┐
- ▼ ▼ ▼
- [Rowley (1982)] [Larry P. (1979)] [Garret F. (1999)]
- Some educational benefit • IQ test ban (CA) • Continuous nursing
- Basic floor of opportunity for Black students • Physician bright-line
- │ │ │
- ▼ ▼ ▼
- [Endrew F. (2017)] [Hobson (1967)] [Timothy W. (1989)]
- Appropriately ambitious • Tracking banned • Zero reject absolute
- Progress in light of based on tests • No educability test
- circumstances
- The Foundational Precedents: Right to Education
- 1. Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka (1954)
Constitutional Basis : Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection Clause.
Core Holding : In a unanimous decision authored by Chief Justice Earl Warren, the U.S. Supreme Court held that state-sanctioned racial segregation in public schools is unconstitutional, declaring that "separate educational facilities are inherently unequal." The Court established that where the state has undertaken to provide an opportunity for education, it is a right which must be made available to all on equal terms.
Significance for School Psychology : Although Brown addressed racial desegregation, disability advocates recognized that segregating or excluding children with disabilities from public schools violated the exact same constitutional principle. Brown served as the foundational legal and conceptual engine for the disability rights movement.
2. Pennsylvania Association for Retarded Children (PARC) v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (1971)
Jurisdiction : U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
Core Holding : The Pennsylvania state statute allowed public schools to exclude children who had not reached a "mental age of five years" by the first grade. The federal court entered a consent agreement establishing that the Commonwealth could not deny any child with an intellectual disability access to a free public program of education and training. The court established that all children can benefit from education, affirmed the principle of Zero Reject , and mandated a legal preference for placement in regular public school classes rather than specialized institutions.
3. Mills v. Board of Education of District of Columbia (1972)
Jurisdiction : U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.
Core Holding : Expanded the principles of PARC beyond intellectual disability to children with all physical, mental, behavioral, and emotional disabilities who were being systematically excluded from D.C. public schools without due process.
The Fiscal Defense Struck Down : The school board argued that providing specialized educational programs for all disabled students would be financially impossible due to severe municipal budget deficits. Judge Joseph Waddy issued a monumental holding: Lack of financial funds cannot justify excluding children with disabilities from public education . If funds are deficient, the expenditure cuts must be apportioned equitably across both disabled and nondisabled children; disabled children cannot bear the brunt of fiscal crises.
Together, PARC and Mills led directly to Congress enacting Public Law 94-142 in 1975.
Defining FAPE: Rowley to Endrew F.
4. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982)
Supreme Court Landmark : First U.S. Supreme Court case to interpret the substantive meaning of FAPE under P.L. 94-142.
Facts : Amy Rowley was a deaf elementary student with excellent lip-reading skills. She was performing above the average of her class and advancing from grade to grade with the aid of an FM wireless hearing apparatus, speech therapy, and tutor. Her parents requested a full-time, sign-language classroom interpreter. The district refused, arguing Amy did not require an interpreter to receive an adequate education.
Supreme Court Holding : The Supreme Court reversed the lower courts, ruling in favor of the school district. The Court held that FAPE does not require a school district to maximize the potential of each handicapped child commensurate with the opportunity provided non-handicapped children. IDEA guarantees a "basic floor of opportunity" consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services (often described as the "Chevrolet standard" rather than the "Cadillac standard").
The Two-Prong Rowley Inquiry :
Procedural Prong : Has the State complied with the procedures set forth in the Act?
Substantive Prong : Is the IEP reasonably calculated to enable the child to receive educational benefits ? For children fully integrated in regular classrooms, this benefit is typically demonstrated by passing marks and advancement from grade to grade.
5. Endrew F. v. Douglas County School District (2017)
Supreme Court Landmark : Unanimous decision (8-0) authored by Chief Justice John Roberts, fundamentally elevating the substantive standard of FAPE and overturning 35 years of lower-court misinterpretations of Rowley .
Facts : Endrew F. ("Drew") was an autistic child with severe behavioral challenges whose IEP goals remained virtually unchanged from year to year. His parents placed him in a private school specializing in autism (Firefly Autism House), where his behavior stabilized and academic progress accelerated. Drew's parents sought tuition reimbursement under IDEA, arguing the public district's IEP was inadequate. The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled for the district, holding that Rowley required an IEP to provide only "merely more than de minimis" (trivial or negligible) educational benefit.
Supreme Court Holding : The Supreme Court unanimously rejected and overturned the de minimis standard. Chief Justice Roberts wrote:
"To meet its substantive obligation under the IDEA, a school must offer an IEP reasonably calculated to enable a child to make progress appropriate in light of the child's circumstances... For a child fully integrated in the regular classroom, an IEP typically should... be reasonably calculated to enable the child to achieve passing marks and advance from grade to grade. But for a child not fully integrated in the regular classroom... his educational program must be appropriately ambitious in light of his circumstances... The goals may differ, but every child should have the chance to meet challenging objectives."
Clinical Impact for School Psychologists : School psychologists can no longer defend stagnant, repetitive, or low-expectation IEPs by pointing to minimal passing grades or trivial progress. IEP goals must be individualized, rigorous, and "appropriately ambitious," backed by robust baseline data and aggressive progress monitoring.
- Assessment Bias & Disproportionality in Special Education
- 6. Hobson v. Hansen (1967)
Jurisdiction : U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia (Judge J. Skelly Wright).
Core Holding : D.C. public schools utilized a rigid educational "tracking" system where students were placed into academic tracks (honors, general, basic/remedial) based on standardized group aptitude test scores administered in early elementary school. Because the standardized tests were normed on middle-class white populations, African American and low-income students were disproportionately relegated to basic tracks with no opportunity for mobility.
Ruling : The court ruled that tracking based on standardized tests that were culturally biased against disadvantaged groups violated the Equal Protection component of the Fifth Amendment Due Process Clause. The tracking system was permanently abolished.
7. Larry P. v. Riles (1979; affirmed 9th Cir. 1984; order modified 1986)
Jurisdiction : Northern District of California (Judge Robert Peckham).
Facts : African American children in California represented less than 10% of the general student population but comprised over 27% of students enrolled in classes for the "Educable Mentally Retarded" (EMR). Placement into EMR classes was based heavily on standardized intelligence tests (WISC, Stanford-Binet).
Core Holding : The federal court found that standardized intelligence tests were culturally and racially biased against Black children, possessed discriminatory impact, and had not been validated for the placement of Black children into EMR classes. The court issued an injunction prohibiting the use of standardized intelligence tests to evaluate African American students for EMR placement. In 1986, the injunction was expanded to prohibit standardized IQ testing of African American students for any special education placement in California.
Crucial Praxis Distinction : Larry P. is a state-specific injunction in California. However, its psychometric implications (discriminatory test bias, disparate impact, non-discriminatory multi-method assessment) are codified nationally in IDEA regulations ( 34 CFR § 300.304(c) ).
- Related Services vs. Medical Services
- 8. Irving Independent School District v. Tatro (1984)
Supreme Court Landmark : Addressed the distinction between required "related services" and exempt "medical services" under IDEA.
Facts : Amber Tatro, an 8-year-old child with spina bifida, required clean intermittent catheterization (CIC) every 3 to 4 hours to avoid kidney damage. The district refused to provide CIC, arguing it was an exempt medical service.
Holding : The Supreme Court ruled that CIC is a required related service . The Court established that services that can be performed by a school nurse or trained layperson are non-exempt related services; only services that must be performed by a licensed medical doctor (physician) are exempt medical services.
9. Cedar Rapids Community School District v. Garret F. (1999)
Supreme Court Landmark : Affirmed and cemented the Tatro "bright-line physician rule" regardless of cost.
Facts : Garret F. was a wheelchair-bound, ventilator-dependent student paralyzed from the neck down following an accident. He required continuous one-on-one nursing care during the school day, including ventilator monitoring, suctioning of his tracheotomy tube, and manual catheterization. The school district refused to pay for continuous nursing, arguing that the intensive, constant nature and massive financial cost converted it into an exempt medical service.
Holding : The Supreme Court rejected the district's cost defense and reaffirmed the Tatro bright-line test: Because the continuous nursing services did not require the services of a licensed physician, they were non-medical related services under IDEA that the district was legally mandated to provide and fund to ensure FAPE.
- Zero-Reject & The Educability Fallacy
- 10. Timothy W. v. Rochester, New Hampshire, School District (1989)
Jurisdiction : First Circuit Court of Appeals.
Facts : Timothy W. was a child born with severe spastic quadriplegia, profound cerebral palsy, seizure disorder, cortical blindness, and microcephaly. The local school board determined that Timothy's disabilities were so severe that he was "incapable of benefiting from an education" and therefore ineligible for special education.
Holding : The First Circuit unequivocally overturned the district's decision, establishing the absolute nature of the Zero-Reject principle under IDEA. The court held that IDEA has no requirement that a child demonstrate "educability" or capacity to benefit before being entitled to FAPE. The statute mandates education for all children with disabilities, with highest priority given to children with the most severe impairments.
- School Safety, Threat Assessment, & Duty to Protect
- 11. Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California (1976)
Jurisdiction : Supreme Court of California.
Facts : Prosenjit Poddar, a patient receiving outpatient psychotherapy at the university health center, confided to his psychologist his intention to kill Tatiana Tarasoff. The psychologist notified campus police, who briefly detained Poddar but released him after he appeared rational. The psychologist's supervisor ordered that no further action be taken. Neither Tarasoff nor her parents were ever warned. Poddar subsequently murdered Tatiana Tarasoff.
Core Holding : The court established that mental health professionals have an affirmative "Duty to Protect" (commonly referred to as duty to warn/protect). The confidential character of patient-psychotherapist communications must yield when disclosure is essential to avert danger to others: "The protective privilege ends where the public peril begins." When a clinician determines that a patient poses a serious, credible threat of violence to an identifiable third party, the clinician must take reasonable steps to protect the intended victim (notifying police, warning the victim, or hospitalizing the client).
Application to School Psychology : Governs school-based violence threat assessments. When a student expresses an imminent, serious threat of violence toward an identifiable target (student or staff member), confidentiality must be breached immediately to warn the target and alert law enforcement/crisis teams.
Additional Cases Worth Knowing
The ETS outline names Larry P. , Rowley , and Endrew F. as examples of relevant case law. These decisions also come up often in school psychology practice:
Case Year Holding Practice Implication
Diana v. State Board of Education (N.D. Cal., consent agreement) 1970 Spanish-speaking students had been placed in classes for students with intellectual disabilities based on English-language IQ tests; the settlement required testing in the child's primary language and the use of nonverbal measures Early foundation for native-language, nondiscriminatory evaluation (now in 34 CFR § 300.304)
PASE v. Hannon (N.D. Ill.) 1980 After reviewing test items, the court found that the WISC, WISC-R, and Stanford-Binet were not culturally biased enough to be discriminatory when used with other data Shows that courts split on IQ-test bias; contrast with Larry P.
Honig v. Doe 1988 Schools may not unilaterally exclude students with disabilities for dangerous behavior beyond 10 days; the stay-put provision applies, although schools may seek a court order Foundation for IDEA's disciplinary provisions (Section 10.2)
Schaffer v. Weast 2005 In a due process hearing, the burden of proof rests on the party seeking relief (often the parents), unless state law provides otherwise Documentation and data matter in disputes
Winkelman v. Parma City School District 2007 Parents have their own enforceable rights under IDEA and may pursue IDEA claims in court without an attorney Parents are full participants, not just representatives of their child
Forest Grove School District v. T.A. 2009 Parents may receive tuition reimbursement for a private placement even if the child never received special education from the district, if the district failed to offer FAPE and the private placement is appropriate Failure to evaluate and serve can be costly
Fry v. Napoleon Community Schools 2017 IDEA's exhaustion requirement applies only when the essence (gravamen) of a lawsuit is denial of FAPE; the case involved a student's service dog under the ADA and Section 504 Not every disability claim against a school is an IDEA claim
Perez v. Sturgis Public Schools 2023 IDEA exhaustion does not bar an ADA lawsuit seeking compensatory damages, a remedy IDEA does not provide Families may pursue damages under other disability laws
A.J.T. v. Osseo Area Schools 2025 Students' ADA and Section 504 claims about their education are judged by the same standards as other disability discrimination claims, not a heightened "bad faith or gross misjudgment" standard Makes it easier for students to bring discrimination claims about school services
Two other cases appear elsewhere in this guide: Eisel v. Board of Education of Montgomery County (1991) on the duty to act on suicide risk (Section 10.7), and Goss v. Lopez (1975) on due process for suspensions (Section 10.6).
Master Landmark Case Law Reference Table
Case & Citation Year Primary Legal / Constitutional Basis Foundational Legal Holding School Psychology Clinical Implication
Brown v. Board of Education 1954 14th Amendment Equal Protection Clause Separate educational facilities are inherently unequal; education is a right on equal terms. Established the foundational civil rights doctrine used to overturn exclusion of children with disabilities.
Hobson v. Hansen 1967 5th Amendment Due Process (Equal Protection) Standardized group aptitude tracking racially discriminates against minority and low-income students. Prohibits placing students in rigid educational tracks based solely on culturally biased group tests.
PARC v. Commonwealth of PA 1971 14th Amendment Equal Protection & Due Process Children with intellectual disabilities cannot be denied access to free public education. Established the right to education and legal preference for regular classroom integration.
Mills v. Board of Education 1972 14th Amendment Due Process Clause Lack of municipal financial resources cannot justify excluding disabled students from FAPE. Districts cannot cite budget deficits, staffing shortages, or high costs to deny special education services.
Tarasoff v. Regents of UC 1976 California Tort Law (Common Law Duty) Mental health professionals have a duty to protect identifiable third parties from serious violence. Confidentiality must be breached in school violence threat assessments when an identifiable victim is in imminent peril.
Larry P. v. Riles 1979 Title VI, Rehabilitation Act § 504, Equal Protection Standardized intelligence tests are racially biased against Black students; enjoined in CA for special ed. Mandates multi-method, non-biased assessment; strict prohibition on IQ testing for Black students in California.
Bd. of Ed. v. Rowley 1982 Education for All Handicapped Children Act FAPE requires an IEP reasonably calculated to provide "some educational benefit" (floor of opportunity). Established the two-prong FAPE test (procedural compliance + substantive benefit); no maximization required.
Irving ISD v. Tatro 1984 EAHCA / IDEA Related Services Mandate Clean intermittent catheterization is a required related service, not an exempt medical service. Bright-line rule: Services deliverable by a nurse or layperson are required; only physician services are exempt.
Timothy W. v. Rochester 1989 EAHCA / IDEA Statutory Zero-Reject IDEA has no "educability" threshold; all disabled children must receive FAPE regardless of severity. Confirms zero-reject principle; schools cannot exclude profoundly disabled or medically fragile children.
Cedar Rapids v. Garret F. 1999 IDEA (34 CFR § 300.34) Related Services Continuous one-on-one nursing care for ventilator-dependent student is a required related service. Reaffirmed Tatro bright-line physician rule; financial cost cannot excuse a district from funding nursing care.
Endrew F. v. Douglas County 2017 IDEA (20 U.S.C. § 1400) Substantive FAPE Overturned de minimis standard; IEP must be "appropriately ambitious in light of the child's circumstances." IEP goals must be individualized, rigorous, and ambitious; stagnant goals violate substantive FAPE.
Case Vignette: Applying Endrew F. to IEP Goal Construction
Student: Mateo, 4th grade.
Classification: Specific Learning Disability in Basic Reading Skill.
Current Performance: Oral Reading Fluency (ORF) baseline across 3 consecutive probes is 28 Words Correct Per Minute (WCPM) on a 2nd-grade level passage. Typical 4th graders read well over 100 WCPM on grade-level text at midyear (Hasbrouck & Tindal, 2017).
Proposed IEP Goal by District: "Given a 2nd-grade reading passage, Mateo will read 32 WCPM with 85% accuracy by the end of the annual IEP period." (Target growth = 4 WCPM over an entire 36-week academic year; 0.11 WCPM/week).
Legal & Psychometric Analysis Under Endrew F.:
Substantive Inadequacy : Classic grade-4 growth targets are about 0.85 (realistic) to 1.1 (ambitious) WCPM per week ( Fuchs et al., 1993 ), and intensive intervention usually aims higher to close a gap. A goal targeting 4 WCPM of growth over an entire year represents a de minimis , trivial expectation that virtually guarantees Mateo will fall further behind peers.
The Endrew F. Challenge : The parent, represented by an educational advocate, files a due process complaint citing Endrew F. v. Douglas County . Under Endrew F. , an educational program must be appropriately ambitious in light of the child's circumstances and offer the student the chance to meet challenging objectives.
Resolution : The hearing officer rules for the parents, holding that the district's goal was substantively deficient. The IEP team reconvenes, audits the reading intervention, increases SDI to 45 minutes daily of explicit structured phonics instruction, and sets an ambitious, mathematically grounded goal: "Given a 3rd-grade reading passage, Mateo will read 65 WCPM with 95% accuracy by the end of the IEP year" (targeting 1.0 WCPM/week gain), supported by weekly CBM progress monitoring.