Study guide

11.2 kW/ton, BHP/ton, and KPI Dashboards

RETA CIRO Certified Industrial Refrigeration Operator Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction & Exam Overview

1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 Test-Day Tools, On-Screen References, and Calculators 1.3 CIRO vs CARO and the RETA Credential Path

2 IIAR and ASHRAE Standards

2.1 IIAR 2 and ASHRAE 15 Machinery-Room Design 2.2 IIAR 6 Inspection, Testing, and Maintenance 2.3 IIAR 7 Operating Procedures and IIAR 9 Existing Systems

3 OSHA Process Safety Management

3.1 PSM Applicability and the 14 Elements 3.2 Process Safety Information 3.3 Process Hazard Analysis 3.4 Operating Procedures, Training, Contractors, and PSSR

4 Integrity, Change, and Emergency Programs

4.1 Mechanical Integrity and Pressure-Relief Valves 4.2 Hot Work and Management of Change 4.3 Incident Investigation and Compliance Audits 4.4 Emergency Planning, EPA RMP, and the General Duty Clause

5 Ammonia Hazards and Machinery-Room Safety

5.1 Ammonia Properties, SDS, and Exposure Limits 5.2 Detection, Ventilation, and Emergency Shutdown 5.3 Eyewash, PPE, Materials Compatibility, and ASME B31.5 Piping

6 Three-Phase Motors and Starting

6.1 Three-Phase Motors, Nameplates, and FLA 6.2 Wye-Delta and Reduced-Voltage Starting 6.3 Voltage Unbalance 6.4 Single-Phasing, Rotation Checks, and Screw Compressors

7 Ladder Diagrams, VFDs, and Power

7.1 Ladder Diagrams, Seal-In Circuits, and Safety Interlocks 7.2 Variable-Frequency Drives in Refrigeration Plants 7.3 Power Factor, kW/HP, Overloads, and Machinery-Room Electrical Classification

8 Pressure-Enthalpy Diagrams and Properties

8.1 Reading the Ammonia P-h Diagram 8.2 Saturated Properties, psia vs psig, and Saturation Temperature 8.3 Superheat, Subcooling, and Flash Gas

9 Capacity, COP, and Efficiency

9.1 Enthalpy, Latent Heat, and Net Refrigerating Effect 9.2 COP, Tons of Refrigeration, and Heat Rejection Ratio 9.3 BHP/ton, Isentropic Efficiency, and Theoretical Discharge Temperature

10 Heat Transfer and Rejection

10.1 Q = UAΔT, LMTD, and Heat Exchangers 10.2 Condensers, Approach, and Wet-Bulb Limits 10.3 Specific Volume, Mass Flow, and Compression Ratio

11 System Screens and Performance KPIs

11.1 Using CIRO Operating Screens (normal vs abnormal) 11.2 kW/ton, BHP/ton, and KPI Dashboards 11.3 Power Cost, Demand Charges, and the Cost of Poor Operation

12 Approach, TD, and Oil-Cooling Diagnostics

12.1 Condenser Approach and Non-Condensables 12.2 Evaporator TD and Superheat Diagnostics 12.3 Thermosiphon Oil Coolers and Oil-Temperature Trends

13 Floating Head, Sequencing, and Slide Valves

13.1 Floating Head Pressure 13.2 Compressor Sequencing 13.3 Screw Slide-Valve Unloading and Feedback

14 Expansion Devices and DX Feed

14.1 Solenoid and TXV Pairs, Equalizers, and Hunting 14.2 Electronic Expansion Valves 14.3 Hand Expansion Valves and DX Coil Distribution

15 Pressure-Regulating and Pilot-Operated Valves

15.1 Back-Pressure Regulators 15.2 Crankcase Pressure Regulators and Gas-Pumped CPR Systems 15.3 Pilot-Operated Valves and High-to-Low Relief Regulators

16 Floats, Checks, Solenoid Failures, and Piping

16.1 High-Side Floats and High-Pressure Receivers 16.2 Check Valves, Discharge Checks, and Defrost Check Valves 16.3 Solenoid Failure Modes, Strainers, King Valves, and Ammonia Piping

17 Flooded and Liquid-Overfeed Basics

17.1 Flooded vs DX Advantages and Charge 17.2 Overfeed Ratios and Recirculation Rate 17.3 Surge Drums, Separators, and Wet Suction Returns

18 Pumps, Oil Management, and Level Control

18.1 Mechanical Liquid Pumps and NPSH 18.2 Oil Drain Pots, Rectifiers, and Thermosiphon Oil Management 18.3 Level Glasses, Float Switches, and High/Low Cutouts 18.4 Liquid-Line Sizing and High-/Low-Pressure Receivers

19 Two-Stage Compression and Intercoolers

19.1 Why Two-Stage: Compression Ratio and Discharge Temperature 19.2 Interstage Pressure Selection (Geometric Mean) 19.3 Open Flash Intercoolers 19.4 Closed Intercoolers and Two-Stage Troubleshooting

20 Cascade and Secondary Coolant Systems

20.1 NH3/CO2 Cascade Designs 20.2 Glycol and Brine Secondary Coolants (pH, freeze point, inhibitors) 20.3 Why Secondary Coolants and Glycol Testing/Maintenance

21 Evaporator Defrost

21.1 Hot-Gas Defrost Sequence 21.2 Defrost Drain Pressure-Relief Regulators and Soft Equalization 21.3 Time/Temperature Termination, Drain Pans, Water and Electric Defrost

11.2 kW/ton, BHP/ton, and KPI Dashboards

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Three-phase input kW = √3 × V × I × PF / 1000; kW/ton is that input divided by actual plant tons, not nameplate horsepower or design tons.

Shaft HP ≈ input kW × motor efficiency / 0.746; BHP/ton is shaft horsepower divided by tons — lower is better for both KPIs.

A KPI dashboard should trend suction, discharge, condenser approach, evaporator TD, kW/ton, and oil ΔP on a dated log — mechanical-integrity documentation of the readings, not a wallpaper graphic.

kW/ton can rise while amps look 'fine' if tons fall (ice, starve, high superheat), and part-load slide-valve operation often worsens kW/ton even as kW falls.

Last updated: September 2026

11.2 kW/ton, BHP/ton, and KPI Dashboards

Chapter 9 defined BHP/ton as a thermodynamic efficiency KPI. This section is the operator dashboard version: take the electrical fields off a CIRO screen, turn them into input kilowatts , divide by real tons , and watch that ratio over time . Monitoring System Performance is 20 outline items. A large slice of that block is whether you can tell a cheap ton from an expensive ton while the plant still looks "running."

  • Formulas you will type on the simple calculator
  • Input kW = √3 × V × I × PF / 1000

Use line-to-line volts, a representative line current (average the three if they are close; chase unbalance if they are not), and power factor as a decimal . √3 ≈ 1.732 . Displayed kW on a power meter should match this within metering tolerance. If the screen shows kW but not PF, you can back-calculate PF = kW × 1000 / (√3 × V × I) as a sanity check.

Shaft HP ≈ input kW × efficiency / 0.746

Efficiency is the motor efficiency on the screen or nameplate, as a decimal (93% → 0.93). 0.746 kW = 1 HP. This is brake (shaft) horsepower, not nameplate class.

  • kW/ton = input kW / tons
  • BHP/ton = shaft HP / tons

Tons must be actual refrigerating effect from a production screen, a heat balance, or a trusted evaporator load — never "the compressor is a 300 HP machine so it must be making design tons." Lower kW/ton and lower BHP/ton are better. Input kW/ton is always higher than shaft kW/ton because the motor is not 100% efficient.

Shaft kW/ton = BHP/ton × 0.746. Input kW/ton = (BHP/ton × 0.746) / η_motor. If you mix input kW into a shaft COP you will compliment yourself on the electric bill you did not reduce.

Worked screen — high-stage screw HS-1 (original values)

HS-1 is a high-stage ammonia screw on an engine-room screen. It is not the West screw from 11.1, and it is not a copy of a RETA stem.

  • Field Reading
  • Voltage 480 VAC
  • Average current 265 A
  • Power factor 0.85
  • Motor efficiency 92%
  • Slide valve 100%
  • Plant production / evaporator screen 198 tons

Input kW = 1.732 × 480 × 265 × 0.85 / 1000. 831.36 × 265 = 220,310; × 0.85 = 187,264; ÷ 1000 = 187.3 kW .

kW/ton = 187.3 / 198 = 0.95 kW/ton

Shaft HP = 187.3 × 0.92 / 0.746 = 172.3 / 0.746 = 231 HP .

BHP/ton = 231 / 198 = 1.17 BHP/ton

Nameplate theater: 300 / 198 = 1.52 BHP/ton. That number describes a motor that is not on this machine. If someone uses 300 HP in a COP, the COP is fiction.

Trap: amps per ton. 265 / 198 = 1.34 A/ton. That is not kW/ton. Without V and PF it cannot be power.

Same kW, fewer tons — the KPI that amps will not show

Ice on the low-temperature coils, a starved DX battery, or a recirculator that lost a pump can drop evaporator effect while the high-stage screw still sees roughly the same suction and still draws 187.3 kW . Production falls to 155 tons .

kW/ton = 187.3 / 155 = 1.21 kW/ton

The ammeter did not have to look like a wreck. Tons fell. That is why the dashboard includes both power and capacity. A CIRO abnormal screen that holds amps steady and drops the tonnage field is still abnormal.

Part load: slide valve down, kW/ton often up

HS-1 unloads to 55% slide. Current 198 A, PF 0.78 (light-load PF usually sags), evaporator screen 118 tons .

Input kW = 1.732 × 480 × 198 × 0.78 / 1000. 831.36 × 198 = 164,609; × 0.78 = 128,395; ÷ 1000 = 128.4 kW .

kW/ton = 128.4 / 118 = 1.09 kW/ton

Power fell from 187.3 kW to 128.4 kW. The KPI worsened from 0.95 to 1.09 kW/ton. Slide-valve unloading is not a linear "55% slide means 55% kW and 55% tons." Internal leakage and part-load losses spend extra kW per remaining ton. Sequencing another machine at a better load point can beat parking one screw at 55% — Chapter 13 is the sequencing chapter; here you only need to compute the worse kW/ton so you do not celebrate the lower ammeter.

What belongs on the KPI dashboard

Trend at least these, on a dated sheet or historian, at a defined operating mode (for example "HS-1 at 100% slide, rooms at setpoint"):

  • KPI Why it is there
  • Suction pressure / T_sat Lift, room temperature, evaporator feed
  • Discharge pressure / T_sat Lift, condenser health, floating-head target
  • Condenser approach (T_cond − wet bulb on an evaporative unit) Dirt, scale, fans/spray, noncondensables
  • Evaporator TD (room or fluid minus T_evap) Coil ice, air/glycol flow, feed
  • kW/ton (and BHP/ton if you compute shaft) Cost of each remaining ton
  • Oil ΔP (filter and/or lubrication, labeled) Mechanical integrity of lubrication

Add oil supply temperature if the package is thermosiphon-cooled. Add slide-valve percent and VFD Hz so you do not compare a 40% slide day to a 100% baseline and call it a condenser miracle.

A dashboard without dates is a CIRO screen: NORMAL or ABNORMAL with no elapsed time. Mechanical integrity under OSHA PSM and inspection/testing/maintenance under current IIAR 6 expect recorded readings, not a remembered vibe. The log is how you prove the 28°F approach started in July, not this morning. It is also how you prove a PRV, oil filter, or condenser wash was due from data , not from a fight with production.

Building a weekly trend (original log)

HS-1, 100% slide, similar wet bulb, rooms at setpoint:

  • Week ending Suction (psig) Discharge (psig) Approach (°F) Evap TD (°F) kW/ton Oil filter ΔP (psi)
  • 2 Aug 19.6 151.7 18 10 0.95 8
  • 9 Aug 19.4 155.0 20 10 0.98 9
  • 16 Aug 19.5 162.0 23 11 1.04 11
  • 23 Aug 18.8 175.0 27 13 1.14 12
  • 30 Aug 18.1 181.1 28 15 1.21 13

Discharge climbed while suction sagged and evaporator TD opened — coils are icing and the condenser is drifting. kW/ton rose from 0.95 to 1.21 . Oil-filter ΔP moved, but not enough to explain 30 psi of extra head. The dashboard's job is to show which KPIs moved together so you wash the condenser and defrost, instead of changing oil filters as a personality trait.

If 23 Aug had been the only screen you were handed on CIRO, you would still compute kW/ton and approach. You would not know it took four weeks. That is the whole teaching point of timestamp-free troubleshooting screens: the exam tests whether you can name the abnormal state . The plant tests whether you documented the path .

Sanity checks before you trust a kW/ton

Voltage is line-to-line and the motor is actually at that voltage (a 460 V nameplate on a 480 V bus is normal; 430 V on one phase is not).

PF is included. Forgetting PF inflates kW by 1/PF (about 18% at 0.85).

Tons are live. A frozen "design 200 tons" in a spreadsheet produces a fake KPI.

Compare like modes. 55% slide versus 100% slide is not a condenser scorecard.

Oil ΔP label. Filter versus lubrication. Logging the wrong one trains the wrong work order.

Exam traps

Nameplate HP / design tons as BHP/ton.

Amps/ton or PF itself as if it were kW/ton.

Celebrating lower kW at part load while kW/ton got worse.

A dashboard with no dates, then claiming mechanical integrity.

Mixing input kW/ton with shaft COP without saying which work you used.

HS-1 kW/ton trend at comparable 100% slide (original weekly log)

Loading diagram... From screen fields to KPIs that belong in the MI log