Study guide
11.3 Power Cost, Demand Charges, and the Cost of Poor Operation
RETA CIRO Certified Industrial Refrigeration Operator Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 Test-Day Tools, On-Screen References, and Calculators 1.3 CIRO vs CARO and the RETA Credential Path
2 IIAR and ASHRAE Standards
2.1 IIAR 2 and ASHRAE 15 Machinery-Room Design 2.2 IIAR 6 Inspection, Testing, and Maintenance 2.3 IIAR 7 Operating Procedures and IIAR 9 Existing Systems
3 OSHA Process Safety Management
3.1 PSM Applicability and the 14 Elements 3.2 Process Safety Information 3.3 Process Hazard Analysis 3.4 Operating Procedures, Training, Contractors, and PSSR
4 Integrity, Change, and Emergency Programs
4.1 Mechanical Integrity and Pressure-Relief Valves 4.2 Hot Work and Management of Change 4.3 Incident Investigation and Compliance Audits 4.4 Emergency Planning, EPA RMP, and the General Duty Clause
5 Ammonia Hazards and Machinery-Room Safety
5.1 Ammonia Properties, SDS, and Exposure Limits 5.2 Detection, Ventilation, and Emergency Shutdown 5.3 Eyewash, PPE, Materials Compatibility, and ASME B31.5 Piping
6 Three-Phase Motors and Starting
6.1 Three-Phase Motors, Nameplates, and FLA 6.2 Wye-Delta and Reduced-Voltage Starting 6.3 Voltage Unbalance 6.4 Single-Phasing, Rotation Checks, and Screw Compressors
7 Ladder Diagrams, VFDs, and Power
7.1 Ladder Diagrams, Seal-In Circuits, and Safety Interlocks 7.2 Variable-Frequency Drives in Refrigeration Plants 7.3 Power Factor, kW/HP, Overloads, and Machinery-Room Electrical Classification
8 Pressure-Enthalpy Diagrams and Properties
8.1 Reading the Ammonia P-h Diagram 8.2 Saturated Properties, psia vs psig, and Saturation Temperature 8.3 Superheat, Subcooling, and Flash Gas
9 Capacity, COP, and Efficiency
9.1 Enthalpy, Latent Heat, and Net Refrigerating Effect 9.2 COP, Tons of Refrigeration, and Heat Rejection Ratio 9.3 BHP/ton, Isentropic Efficiency, and Theoretical Discharge Temperature
10 Heat Transfer and Rejection
10.1 Q = UAΔT, LMTD, and Heat Exchangers 10.2 Condensers, Approach, and Wet-Bulb Limits 10.3 Specific Volume, Mass Flow, and Compression Ratio
11 System Screens and Performance KPIs
11.1 Using CIRO Operating Screens (normal vs abnormal) 11.2 kW/ton, BHP/ton, and KPI Dashboards 11.3 Power Cost, Demand Charges, and the Cost of Poor Operation
12 Approach, TD, and Oil-Cooling Diagnostics
12.1 Condenser Approach and Non-Condensables 12.2 Evaporator TD and Superheat Diagnostics 12.3 Thermosiphon Oil Coolers and Oil-Temperature Trends
13 Floating Head, Sequencing, and Slide Valves
13.1 Floating Head Pressure 13.2 Compressor Sequencing 13.3 Screw Slide-Valve Unloading and Feedback
14 Expansion Devices and DX Feed
14.1 Solenoid and TXV Pairs, Equalizers, and Hunting 14.2 Electronic Expansion Valves 14.3 Hand Expansion Valves and DX Coil Distribution
15 Pressure-Regulating and Pilot-Operated Valves
15.1 Back-Pressure Regulators 15.2 Crankcase Pressure Regulators and Gas-Pumped CPR Systems 15.3 Pilot-Operated Valves and High-to-Low Relief Regulators
16 Floats, Checks, Solenoid Failures, and Piping
16.1 High-Side Floats and High-Pressure Receivers 16.2 Check Valves, Discharge Checks, and Defrost Check Valves 16.3 Solenoid Failure Modes, Strainers, King Valves, and Ammonia Piping
17 Flooded and Liquid-Overfeed Basics
17.1 Flooded vs DX Advantages and Charge 17.2 Overfeed Ratios and Recirculation Rate 17.3 Surge Drums, Separators, and Wet Suction Returns
18 Pumps, Oil Management, and Level Control
18.1 Mechanical Liquid Pumps and NPSH 18.2 Oil Drain Pots, Rectifiers, and Thermosiphon Oil Management 18.3 Level Glasses, Float Switches, and High/Low Cutouts 18.4 Liquid-Line Sizing and High-/Low-Pressure Receivers
19 Two-Stage Compression and Intercoolers
19.1 Why Two-Stage: Compression Ratio and Discharge Temperature 19.2 Interstage Pressure Selection (Geometric Mean) 19.3 Open Flash Intercoolers 19.4 Closed Intercoolers and Two-Stage Troubleshooting
20 Cascade and Secondary Coolant Systems
20.1 NH3/CO2 Cascade Designs 20.2 Glycol and Brine Secondary Coolants (pH, freeze point, inhibitors) 20.3 Why Secondary Coolants and Glycol Testing/Maintenance
21 Evaporator Defrost
21.1 Hot-Gas Defrost Sequence 21.2 Defrost Drain Pressure-Relief Regulators and Soft Equalization 21.3 Time/Temperature Termination, Drain Pans, Water and Electric Defrost
11.3 Power Cost, Demand Charges, and the Cost of Poor Operation
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Energy cost ≈ kW × hours × $/kWh; at a typical industrial example rate of $0.17/kWh, 240 kW costs $40.80 per hour, $979.20 per 24-hour day, $6,854.40 per week, and $204,000 over 5,000 run-hours.
Demand charges ($/kW-month) are a separate bill for the highest 15-minute (or tariff interval) kW in the month — a dirty-condenser peak can set the charge even if you wash the condenser the next morning.
Excess cost of poor operation is extra kW × rate × hours, plus any extra demand kW × $/kW-month; high head from a dirty evaporative condenser is the classic self-inflicted adder.
CIRO screens exist so you can turn abnormal kW into $/hr and energy over time; nameplate horsepower is not a utility meter.
Last updated: September 2026
11.3 Power Cost, Demand Charges, and the Cost of Poor Operation
The January 2023 CIRO Study Guide lists compute cost in $/hr and energy over time as a reason the operating screens exist. A 255 kW abnormal picture is not complete until you can say what it costs . This section uses $0.17/kWh as a typical industrial energy price — the same figure that appears in CIRO study-guide practice prompts. It is a teaching rate , not your plant's tariff and not an official RETA utility table. If a stem gives another rate, use that rate. The method does not change.
Two different utility lines get mixed on exam items and in engine-room arguments:
Energy (kWh) — what you used, priced in $/kWh .
Demand (kW) — how hard you peaked, priced in $/kW-month (or a similar interval).
Cleaning a condenser can cut both. Treating demand as if it were kWh, or kWh as if a one-time peak did not matter, is how people "prove" a wash is not worth the overtime.
- Energy: hour, day, week, 5,000-hour year
- Cost = kW × hours × ($/kWh)
Use input kW from √3 × V × I × PF / 1000, or from a power meter. Do not convert nameplate HP × 0.746 and call it the bill.
Worked — West screw at the 11.1 normal screen, 240.0 kW, $0.17/kWh.
- Period Hours kWh Cost at $0.17/kWh
- 1 hour 1 240.0 $40.80
- 1 day (continuous) 24 5,760 $979.20
- 1 week (7 × 24) 168 40,320 $6,854.40
- 5,000 run-hours (a heavy industrial year) 5,000 1,200,000 $204,000
Arithmetic you should be able to repeat without a spreadsheet:
- Hour: 240 × 0.17 = 40.80
- Day: 40.80 × 24 = 979.20 (or 240 × 24 × 0.17)
- Week: 979.20 × 7 = 6,854.40
- 5,000 h: 240 × 5,000 = 1,200,000 kWh; × 0.17 = 204,000
Per-kW rule of thumb at this rate: one wasted kilowatt running 5,000 hours costs 5,000 × 0.17 = $850/year . Sixteen wasted kilowatts (the 11.1 abnormal delta of about 15.8 kW) is on the order of $13,400/year in energy alone, before demand. You do not need a new compressor to find that money. You need a condenser that still matches wet bulb.
Second machine — HS-1 at 187.3 kW. Hourly energy = 187.3 × 0.17 = $31.84/hr . 5,000 h: 187.3 × 5,000 × 0.17 = $159,205 . If icing drops tons and you start a second 128 kW machine to hold rooms, that second machine is $21.76/hr and $108,800 over 5,000 h at the same rate — often larger than the kW/ton drift on the first machine. Poor operation is not only "amps went up." It is also "we ran an extra frame because the first one stopped making cheap tons."
Demand charges are a separate penalty
A demand charge bills the highest electrical kW recorded in a defined interval — commonly 15 minutes — during the billing month, at $/kW-month . The rest of the month can be gentle. If the dirty-condenser afternoon set a 15-minute peak, that peak can set the demand line for the entire month .
Example teaching demand price: $12.50 per kW-month . This is an illustration, not a tariff.
If West screw's 15-minute average is 240 kW during the plant's peak interval, that machine contributes 240 kW to billed demand:
240 × 12.50 = $3,000/month of demand allocated to that kW , on top of the kWh in the table above.
If a fouled condenser and extra lift push that same interval to 265 kW :
- Extra demand kW = 25 kW
- Extra demand cost = 25 × 12.50 = $312.50 that month
If the plant peaks at that dirty condition every month, extra demand is 312.50 × 12 = $3,750/year , in addition to extra kWh.
Demand does not care that you washed the condenser at 18:00 if the peak was at 14:00. It does not care that nights are light. Operators who only quote $/kWh understate the cost of a high-head afternoon coinciding with the rest of the site's peak (production, freezers coming out of defrost, and every other motor).
Ratchet / lookback (awareness, not a number to invent). Some industrial tariffs include a demand ratchet: a fraction of a prior peak follows you for months. CIRO will not make you recite an unpublished tariff. It will expect you to keep demand conceptually separate from energy and to see why a short abnormal kW spike is still expensive.
Excess cost of dirty condensers and high head
Lift kills COP. High condensing temperature means more compressor work per remaining ton, higher discharge temperature, more oil-cooler load, and often fewer tons if the machine hits a limit. The screen translation is extra input kW and sometimes a second machine.
Worked — same West screw, badly fouled evaporative condenser (original values).
Normal (11.1): 480 V, 328 A, PF 0.88 → 240.0 kW . Condensing 85°F, wet bulb 67°F, approach 18°F.
Fouled teaching case: 480 V, 375 A , PF 0.85 , same suction, condensing 95°F+ , approach in the high 20s.
Input kW = 1.732 × 480 × 375 × 0.85 / 1000. 831.36 × 375 = 311,760; × 0.85 = 264,996; ÷ 1000 = 265.0 kW .
- Clean Fouled Excess
- Input kW 240.0 265.0 25.0 kW
- $/hr at $0.17/kWh $40.80 $45.05 $4.25/hr
- $/day (24 h) $979.20 $1,081.20 $102.00/day
- $/week $6,854.40 $7,568.40 $714.00/week
- 5,000 h energy $204,000 $225,250 $21,250/year
- Demand if this kW is the monthly peak adder at $12.50/kW-month — — $312.50/month ($3,750/year if every month)
Combined self-inflicted bill if the 25 kW of dirt is both always-on energy and the demand adder all year:
$21,250 + $3,750 = $25,000/year for one screw, before counting lost tons or a second compressor.
If tons also slip from 210 to 190, kW/ton goes from 240/210 = 1.14 to 265/190 = 1.39 . You paid more money for less refrigeration. That is the definition of poor operation on a monitoring item.
Noncondensables look like a dirty condenser on the screen (high head, wide approach to wet bulb, discharge temperature up) and cost the same extra kW until you purge. Failed fans or spray on an evaporative unit do the same. Floating head in the other direction is free money: if wet bulb is 50°F and you still hold 95°F condensing with a flooded pile of discharge pressure, you are buying lift nobody ordered. Chapter 13 covers floating-head strategy; here you only need to price the kW you did not have to draw.
How to attack a CIRO cost item under the clock
Compute input kW (include PF).
Multiply by the given $/kWh (or $0.17/kWh if that is the stem's example) for $/hr .
Multiply hours: 24, 168, 5,000 — read which period the question wants.
If the stem mentions demand , compute extra kW × $/kW-month separately. Do not add demand dollars into a kWh product without converting units.
Excess cost of poor operation is (kW_bad − kW_good) × rate × hours , plus demand if the peak moved.
Exam traps
Using nameplate 300 HP × 0.746 as billed kW.
Dropping PF, then pricing the kVA-shaped number as if it were kWh.
Quoting $0.17 as if it were dollars per hour with no kW.
Mixing demand ($/kW-month) into a kWh multiplication.
Pricing only the hour and ignoring 5,000-hour energy, or pricing only energy and ignoring a peak that sets the month.
Assuming a washed condenser erases a demand peak that already occurred.