Study guide
8.3 Evaluating Spirometry Acceptability & Repeatability
NBRC Registered Pulmonary Function Technologist RPFT
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 Content Outline Domains & Study Plan
2 Spirometry Instrumentation
2.1 Spirometer Types, Setup & Maintenance 2.2 Spirometer Calibration & Linearity 2.3 Spirometer Troubleshooting
3 Blood Gas & Gas Analyzers
3.1 Blood Gas Analyzer Setup, Maintain, Calibrate 3.2 Gas Analyzers & Water/Gas Absorbers 3.3 ABG & Gas Analyzer Troubleshooting and QC
4 Body Box, Exercise & Monitoring Equipment
4.1 Body Plethysmograph Setup & Calibration 4.2 Exercise, Field Walking & ECG Equipment 4.3 Pressure Devices, Valves & Gas Delivery Systems
5 Ancillary Equipment & Infection Control
5.1 Body Habitus, Sampling & Aerosol Equipment 5.2 Monitors & Emergency Management Equipment 5.3 Infection Control Materials & Methods
6 Quality Control Systems
6.1 Mechanical QC Devices 6.2 Biological Controls & Proficiency Testing 6.3 Laboratory Quality Management & SOPs
7 Patient Preparation & Safety
7.1 Body Habitus Measurements & Estimates 7.2 Patient Safety, Precautions & Adverse Events
8 Spirometry Procedures
8.1 Selecting Spirometry Protocols & Equipment 8.2 Performing Standard & Position-Variant Spirometry 8.3 Evaluating Spirometry Acceptability & Repeatability 8.4 Bronchodilator Response Studies
9 Static Lung Volumes
9.1 Gas Dilution Lung Volume Methods 9.2 Body Plethysmography Lung Volumes 9.3 Evaluating Lung Volume Validity
10 Diffusing Capacity (DLCO)
10.1 DLCO Protocol & Equipment Selection 10.2 Performing the DLCO Maneuver 10.3 Evaluating DLCO Validity
11 Blood Gas Sampling & Analysis Procedures
11.1 Arterial & Capillary Blood Sample Collection 11.2 Performing Blood Gas Analysis 11.3 CO-oximetry / Hemoximetry Procedures
12 Airway Responsiveness, Resistance & Muscle Strength
12.1 Bronchial Provocation Studies 12.2 Airways Resistance & Conductance by Plethysmography 12.3 Respiratory Muscle Strength (MIP/MEP/CPF)
13 Exercise, Oxygen, Home Testing & Education
13.1 Field Walking Tests (6MWT, Shuttle) 13.2 Monitored Exercise Testing 13.3 Oxygen Assessment & Titration 13.4 Home Testing Instruction & Patient Education
14 Calculations & Reference Ranges
14.1 Spirometry Calculations & Reference Equations 14.2 Lung Volume & DLCO Calculations/Corrections 14.3 Blood Gas & CO-oximetry Derived Calculations 14.4 Exercise, Oximetry & Special Test Calculations
15 Evaluating Result Reliability
15.1 Spirometry & Lung Volume Reliability 15.2 DLCO & Exercise Test Reliability 15.3 ABG, Monitoring & QC Reliability
16 Clinical Implications & Reporting
16.1 Pattern Recognition: Obstruction, Restriction, Mixed, Severity 16.2 Clinical Implications: DLCO, ABG, Airway Response, Exercise & Lab Context
8.3 Evaluating Spirometry Acceptability & Repeatability
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
NBRC Domain II.C.2 a/b requires evaluating whether spirometry efforts are acceptable and whether key indices are repeatable across efforts
Acceptability includes freedom from artifact, good start (back-extrapolation volume within limits), no cough in the first second for FEV1 use, no glottis closure/obstructed mouthpiece/leak, and adequate end-of-test for FVC
Repeatability for ages ≥6 years commonly requires the two largest FEV1 values and two largest FVC values to agree within 0.150 L (150 mL) among acceptable efforts
Aim for at least three acceptable efforts when possible, typically without exceeding about eight attempts; use the largest FEV1 and largest FVC from acceptable curves even if not from the same trial
When ideal criteria are not fully met, grade and report usable data with quality notes rather than silently deleting all results or inventing numbers
Last updated: August 2026
Validity is Domain II.C—not optional “nice to have”
NBRC II.C Evaluate Validity of Results task II.C.2 (spirometry, outline a/b ) asks whether you can judge acceptability of individual efforts and repeatability across efforts. RPFT-level items often show a grid of trial values or describe a curve defect and ask: accept, reject, repeat, or report with caution. This section operationalizes ATS/ERS technical quality concepts used after you have performed maneuvers in 8.2.
Definitions to keep separate:
Acceptability — Is this single effort free enough from defects to use its FEV1 and/or FVC?
Repeatability — Among acceptable efforts, do the best values agree closely enough ?
Usability — Even if not fully ideal, can part of the data (often FEV1) still be reported with a quality statement?
Acceptability checklist (ATS/ERS quality concepts)
Use a mental (or written) checklist on every forced maneuver. Software grades help but do not replace technologist judgment when sensors mis-classify cough or leak.
Master acceptability table
Criterion What “good” looks like Typical reject / caution pattern
Free from artifact Smooth flow–volume and volume–time traces consistent with physiology Large spikes from glottic noise, extra breaths, laugh, equipment bump
Good start (back-extrapolation) Back-extrapolated volume (BEV) ≤ 5% of FVC or 0.100 L , whichever is greater Hesitant start; large BEV; slow PEF rise
No cough affecting FEV1 No cough in the first second if FEV1 is to be used Cough notch in first second → FEV1 not acceptable (later cough may still allow FEV1)
No glottis closure / Valsalva Continuous expiratory flow without abrupt zero-flow stop mid-maneuver Sudden cessation with glottic stop; flat-topped abnormal morphology
No obstructed mouthpiece / tongue Unimpeded blast; PEF plausible Flattened PEF, sawtooth from tongue, debris in filter
No leak Volume does not fall spuriously; seal maintained Inspiratory volume “loss,” poor FVC, audible leak
No early termination (for FVC) Meets end-of-test plateau/duration concepts (8.2) Abrupt stop while volume still rising steeply
Maximal effort PEF and curve shape show true blast; patient coached to peak Multiple weak efforts without improvement despite coaching
- No extra breath Single continuous forced expiration Nested inspiration mid-FVC
- Start-of-test detail: back-extrapolation volume (BEV)
A “good start” is quantified by back-extrapolation . If the patient hesitates, the volume–time curve rises slowly and the extrapolated zero-time error grows. When BEV exceeds the greater of 5% of FVC or 100 mL , the effort fails start-of-test acceptability for standards-based grading. Coaching fix (8.2): explosive onset after full inspiration.
Exam trap: High PEF with huge hesitation is uncommon; more often PEF is low and BEV is high—both point to poor start, not “instant severe restriction.”
Cough rules (high-yield)
Cough in the first second: do not use that effort’s FEV1 .
Cough after the first second may still allow FEV1 use if the first second is clean, but FVC and the later curve can be compromised—judge FVC separately.
Repeated coughing sessions may yield usable FEV1 with limited FVC—report with notes.
Early termination vs obstruction
Severe obstruction produces long emptying times; that is not the same as early termination. Early termination is a premature stop while significant volume remains (no plateau, short FET, patient stops cooperating). Do not label every low FVC as “acceptable obstruction pattern” without inspecting EOT quality.
Repeatability criteria
After you have acceptable efforts, check whether the best values cluster.
FEV1 and FVC agreement (ages ≥6 years—exam workhorse rule)
For patients 6 years and older , ATS/ERS technical standards commonly require that the two largest FEV1 values from acceptable efforts agree within 0.150 L (150 mL) , and the two largest FVC values agree within 0.150 L . If they do not, perform more efforts (within fatigue/safety limits) to improve repeatability.
Younger children
Preschool and young pediatric cutoffs are tighter in relative or absolute terms depending on the standard version and age band (often 0.100 L or 10% type rules appear in pediatric pathways). For RPFT items, read the age in the stem: do not blindly apply 150 mL to a toddler if the question highlights pediatric criteria.
Which values are selected for reporting
Report the largest FEV1 and largest FVC from acceptable efforts—even if they come from different maneuvers (classic rule).
PEF is often taken as the largest PEF from acceptable starts; labs follow ATS/ERS and manufacturer reporting rules.
Do not average all trials as the primary reported FEV1/FVC when standards call for maximum acceptable values.
Minimum number of acceptable efforts
- Target Rationale
- ≥3 acceptable efforts when achievable Demonstrates consistency and supports repeatability checks
- Usually ≤8 attempts in a session Limits fatigue, dizziness, and diminishing returns
- Fewer than 3 acceptable Still may report best usable data with quality grade / comment
Exam trap: “Must always have exactly three curves that are identical.” Reality: three acceptable efforts with FEV1/FVC within repeatability limits—not identical tracings.
Acceptability vs repeatability decision table
- Situation Acceptability Repeatability Technologist action
- 3 clean efforts; FEV1 within 100 mL; FVC within 120 mL Pass Pass Complete session; report best FEV1/FVC
5 efforts; only 1 free of cough in first second Mostly fail FEV1 on others Cannot establish FEV1 repeatability Keep coaching; may report single usable FEV1 with note if no more possible
3 efforts; all good starts; two best FEV1 differ by 280 mL Pass each Fail Additional efforts to tighten agreement
Beautiful loops but BEV always high Fail start N/A until fixed Reteach blast; do not pass on pretty shape alone
Plateau never met; FET 16 s; patient exhausted FVC may be usable under EOT duration concepts Check remaining indices Stop for safety; grade FVC carefully
Grading and reporting when criteria are not fully met
Real patients—especially children, neuromuscular disease, acute illness, and elderly—do not always produce A+ sessions. Domain II.C expects mature judgment:
Do report (with transparency)
Best usable FEV1 even if FVC failed EOT, when clinical need exists and defects are documented.
Number of acceptable efforts, which criteria failed, and whether repeatability was met.
“Session ended for dizziness after six attempts; two acceptable FEV1 within 140 mL; FVC not repeatable due to early stops.”
Do not
Discard all numeric results solely because the session was imperfect if usable efforts exist and the lab/reporting standard allows graded reporting.
Select a middle “pretty” curve that is lower than a higher acceptable FEV1.
Edit raw points to force BEV or repeatability compliance.
Report post-bronchodilator change using pre efforts that were not acceptable (see 8.4).
Quality grades (conceptual)
Many systems assign letter grades or star ratings based on number of acceptable efforts and repeatability. Know the concept: higher grades need multiple acceptable, repeatable efforts; lower grades flag caution for interpreters. Your narrative comment still matters when the grade is intermediate.
Waveform pattern recognition for validity
- Display clue Validity concern
- Slow rise to PEF, large BEV flag Poor start
- Notch/cough spike in first second FEV1 invalid
- Sudden flow to zero mid-expiration with volume incomplete Glottis closure / early stop
- Parallel shift leak pattern / inability to hold zero Leak
- PEF cutoff flat top from equipment or tongue Obstructed mouthpiece / poor blast path
- Escalating FVC each trial without plateau of values Still learning; continue coaching within limits
Declining FVC/PEF each trial after good first effort Fatigue; rest or end session; don’t chase eight exhausted blows
Special populations and validity
Neuromuscular / supine testing: Acceptability rules still apply; patients may meet FEV1 usability before full FVC. Positional comparison is only meaningful if both positions have transparent quality.
Severe obstruction: Long FET is expected; do not fail FVC solely because the patient blew longer than 6 seconds.
Pediatrics: Prioritize free effort and start quality; use age-appropriate repeatability; document effort cooperation.
RPFT validity vignettes
Vignette A: Trials FEV1 = 2.50, 2.48, 2.20 L (all acceptable starts). Two largest differ by 0.02 L → repeatable . Report 2.50 L (largest).
Vignette B: Trials FEV1 = 3.10, 2.80, 2.78 L, all acceptable. Two largest differ by 0.30 L → not repeatable —obtain more efforts before finalizing.
Vignette C: Best-looking loop has cough at 0.5 s; another effort has clean first second but early stop. Use clean-first-second effort for FEV1; do not prefer the “pretty” coughed curve.
Vignette D: Only two acceptable efforts possible after eight tries; FEV1 within 100 mL. Report with grade/comment that only two acceptable efforts were obtained—do not fabricate a third curve.
Link to Domain III (preview)
Validity decisions feed reference comparisons and clinical calls in Domain III. A repeatable but poorly acceptable session misleads percent predicted as badly as a math error. Master II.C.2 so later interpretation questions start from trustworthy numbers.
- Numbers and rules to memorize
- BEV ≤ max(5% FVC, 0.100 L) for good start
- No cough in first 1 second for FEV1 acceptability
- Repeatability (≈≥6 y): FEV1 and FVC within 0.150 L
- Goal ≥3 acceptable efforts; practical max ~ 8 attempts
- Report largest acceptable FEV1 and FVC (may be different trials)
- Incomplete sessions → grade + comment , don’t invent data
- Link forward
Bronchodilator response studies (8.4) require valid pre and post sets under the same acceptability/repeatability logic, plus correct drug timing and significance thresholds from current ATS/ERS interpretive strategy documents.