Study guide
8.3 Profit, Loss, Marked Price, Discount & Dishonest Seller Traps
SBI Clerk Junior Associate
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: Exam Structure, Eligibility, Selection & Winning Strategy
1.1 SBI Clerk Overview, Eligibility & Two-Stage Selection 1.2 Exam Pattern, Sectional Timing & Negative Marking Mechanics 1.3 Time Allocation, Question Selection & Cutoff Strategy 1.4 Final Selection, Local Language Proficiency Test & Joining Formalities
2 Chapter 2: Reasoning — Coding, Series, Relations & Input-Output
2.1 Alphanumeric, Symbol & Number Sequences 2.2 Coding-Decoding Techniques 2.3 Blood Relations 2.4 Input-Output (Machine Input) Arrangements
3 Chapter 3: Reasoning — Direction, Ranking, Inequalities & Miscellaneous
3.1 Direction Sense & Distance 3.2 Order, Ranking & Comparison Tests 3.3 Coded and Direct Inequalities 3.4 Alphabet Test, Word Formation, Calendar & Clock
4 Chapter 4: Reasoning — Syllogisms, Critical Deduction & Data Sufficiency
4.1 Standard Syllogisms & Venn Diagram Foundations 4.2 Advanced Syllogism Cases: Only a Few & Possibility Models 4.3 Critical Reasoning for Mains Examination 4.4 Reasoning Data Sufficiency
5 Chapter 5: Reasoning — Seating Arrangements
5.1 Linear Seating Arrangements 5.2 Parallel Row Seating Arrangements 5.3 Circular & Square/Rectangular Seating Arrangements
6 Chapter 6: Reasoning — Puzzles & Complex Enigmas
6.1 Floor and Flat-Based Puzzles 6.2 Box-Based Puzzles & Vertical Stacks 6.3 Scheduling, Month-Date & Multi-Variable Matrix Puzzles
7 Chapter 7: Quantitative Aptitude: Speed Math & Number Foundations
7.1 Speed Math, Vedic Shortcuts & BODMAS Simplification 7.2 Approximation Strategies for High-Speed Calculations 7.3 Missing and Wrong Number Series
8 Chapter 8: Quantitative Aptitude: Equations & Percentage Mathematics
8.1 Quadratic Equations & Root Comparison 8.2 Percentages, Base Conversions & Successive Changes 8.3 Profit, Loss, Marked Price, Discount & Dishonest Seller Traps
9 Chapter 9: Quantitative Aptitude: Interest, Ratio & Partnership
9.1 Simple & Compound Interest Mechanics 9.2 Ratio, Proportion & Variation Techniques 9.3 Partnership Mathematics
10 Chapter 10: Quantitative Aptitude: Averages, Mixtures & Time-Work
10.1 Averages, Weighted Averages & Age Problems 10.2 Alligation Method & Solution Replacement Problems 10.3 Time & Work, Efficiency Ratios & Pipes and Cisterns
11 Chapter 11: Quantitative Aptitude: Speed, Motion & Applied Mathematics
11.1 Speed, Time & Distance Principles 11.2 Problems on Trains, Platforms, and Boats & Streams 11.3 2D/3D Mensuration & Banking Permutation, Combination, Probability
12 Chapter 12: Quantitative Aptitude: Data Interpretation & Sufficiency
12.1 Tabular, Bar & Line Graph Data Interpretation 12.2 Pie Charts & Paragraph-Based Caselet DI 12.3 Advanced Mains DI & Quantitative Data Sufficiency
13 Chapter 13: English Language: Grammar & Usage
13.1 Core Grammar Rules for Banking Exams 13.2 Tenses, Prepositional Usages & Conditional Clauses 13.3 Error Spotting & Sentence Correction Strategies
14 Chapter 14: English Language: Comprehension, Vocabulary, Idioms & Discourse
14.1 Phrase Replacement, Single/Double Fillers & Sentence Improvement 14.2 Reading Comprehension Mastery 14.3 Cloze Tests, Para Jumbles & Discourse Connectors 14.4 Vocabulary: Synonyms, Antonyms, One-Word Substitution & Word Usage 14.5 Idioms, Phrasal Verbs, Spelling & Odd Sentence Out
15 Chapter 15: General & Financial Awareness: Banking System, RBI & Capital Regulation
15.1 Structure of the Indian Banking System 15.2 Reserve Bank of India & Monetary Policy Framework 15.3 Banking Operations, Negotiable Instruments & KYC/AML 15.4 Basel III Capital Framework, Prompt Corrective Action & D-SIBs
16 Chapter 16: General & Financial Awareness: Digital Banking & Financial Inclusion
16.1 Payment Systems, NPCI & Digital Banking 16.2 Priority Sector Lending & Financial Inclusion Initiatives 16.3 Non-Performing Assets & Debt Recovery Mechanisms
17 Chapter 17: General & Financial Awareness: Financial Markets, Economy, Schemes & Current Affairs
17.1 Money Market & Capital Market Instruments 17.2 Flagship Government Social Security Schemes & Union Budget 17.3 Static Banking GK, Financial Regulators & Current Affairs Mastery 17.4 Indian Economy Essentials: National Income, Inflation, Fiscal Indicators, GST & External Sector
18 Chapter 18: Computer Aptitude
18.1 Computer Fundamentals: Hardware Architecture, Memory & OS 18.2 Networking Protocols, Cybersecurity & Microsoft Office 18.3 Number Systems, Logic Gates, Flowcharts & Computer Basics
8.3 Profit, Loss, Marked Price, Discount & Dishonest Seller Traps
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Cost Price (CP) serves as the baseline for Profit and Loss percentages, whereas Marked Price (MP) serves as the baseline for Discount percentages.
The bridge ratio MP / CP = (100 + P%) / (100 - D%) connects Cost Price and Marked Price in a single line, eliminating intermediate Selling Price calculations.
Successive discounts of d1% and d2% produce a single equivalent discount of [d1 + d2 - (d1 * d2 / 100)]%, which is strictly less than their arithmetic sum.
A dishonest trader selling at nominal Cost Price while dispensing a false weight incurs cost only on the weight delivered, yielding Profit % = [Error / (True Value - Error)] * 100%.
In promotional schemes offering 'Buy x Get y Free', the effective discount is determined by the ratio of free items to total items surrendered: Discount % = [y / (x + y)] * 100%.
Last updated: September 2026
8.3 Profit, Loss, Marked Price, Discount & Dishonest Seller Traps
Commercial arithmetic problems evaluating Profit, Loss, Marked Price, and Trade Discounts represent a foundational pillar of the SBI Clerk Numerical Ability syllabus. Beyond standalone arithmetic word problems, these principles feature prominently in commercial caselet Data Interpretation sets (e.g., evaluating retail merchant loan portfolios, micro-enterprise profitability, or inventory financing). Success requires an absolute command of price transition mechanics and the ability to detect subtle deceptive wording in dishonest merchant and retail promotion questions.
The Price Hierarchy: CP, SP, and MP
Commercial transactions follow a defined progression of three financial benchmarks:
Cost Price (CP): The total expenditure incurred to acquire, manufacture, or procure an asset, including overheads, freight, and servicing charges.
Marked Price (MP): Also known as List Price, Printed Price, or Maximum Retail Price (MRP). This is the nominal value displayed before offering concessions.
Selling Price (SP): The actual net monetary consideration received from the buyer upon concluding the transaction. [Cost Price (CP)] ---(+ Markup %)----> [Marked Price (MP)]
- | |
- | (- Discount %)
- | |
- v v
- [Profit / Loss %] <---------------------- [Selling Price (SP)]
- Master Commercial Arithmetic Formula Reference Table
Operational Metric Governing Equation Primary Reference Base Multiplier Form
Profit ( P P P ) S P − C P SP - CP SP − CP (when S P > C P SP > CP SP > CP ) Cost Price ( C P CP CP ) S P = C P × ( 1 + P / 100 ) SP = CP \times (1 + P/100) SP = CP × ( 1 + P /100 )
Loss ( L L L ) C P − S P CP - SP CP − SP (when C P > S P CP > SP CP > SP ) Cost Price ( C P CP CP ) S P = C P × ( 1 − L / 100 ) SP = CP \times (1 - L/100) SP = CP × ( 1 − L /100 )
Profit Percentage ( S P − C P C P ) × 100 % \left(\frac{SP - CP}{CP}\right) \times 100\% ( CP SP − CP ) × 100% Cost Price ( C P CP CP ) Base = C P = CP = CP
Loss Percentage ( C P − S P C P ) × 100 % \left(\frac{CP - SP}{CP}\right) \times 100\% ( CP CP − SP ) × 100% Cost Price ( C P CP CP ) Base = C P = CP = CP
Discount ( D D D ) M P − S P MP - SP MP − SP Marked Price ( M P MP MP ) S P = M P × ( 1 − D / 100 ) SP = MP \times (1 - D/100) SP = MP × ( 1 − D /100 )
Discount Percentage ( M P − S P M P ) × 100 % \left(\frac{MP - SP}{MP}\right) \times 100\% ( MP MP − SP ) × 100% Marked Price ( M P MP MP ) Base = M P = MP = MP
Markup ( M M M ) M P − C P MP - CP MP − CP Cost Price ( C P CP CP ) M P = C P × ( 1 + M / 100 ) MP = CP \times (1 + M/100) MP = CP × ( 1 + M /100 )
Markup Percentage ( M P − C P C P ) × 100 % \left(\frac{MP - CP}{CP}\right) \times 100\% ( CP MP − CP ) × 100% Cost Price ( C P CP CP ) Base = C P = CP = CP
Important
The Base Allocation Rule: Profit and Loss are always computed upon Cost Price (CP) unless the problem explicitly states "profit calculated on selling price" . Conversely, Discount is strictly computed upon Marked Price (MP) .
The Central Bridge Equation: Connecting MP and CP Directly
In many SBI Clerk problems, the candidate is given the Markup/Discount percentage and asked to find the net Profit percentage, or vice versa. Solving for intermediate Selling Price ( S P SP SP ) wastes critical seconds. We equate the two independent expressions for S P SP SP : S P = C P × ( 1 + P 100 ) = M P × ( 1 − D 100 ) SP = CP \times \left(1 + \frac{P}{100}\right) = MP \times \left(1 - \frac{D}{100}\right) SP = CP × ( 1 + 100 P ) = MP × ( 1 − 100 D )
Rearranging terms establishes the Universal MP/CP Ratio Equation : M P C P = 100 + P % 100 − D % \frac{MP}{CP} = \frac{100 + P\%}{100 - D\%} CP MP = 100 − D % 100 + P %
If the transaction results in a net loss of L % L\% L % , the formula adjusts to: M P C P = 100 − L % 100 − D % \frac{MP}{CP} = \frac{100 - L\%}{100 - D\%} CP MP = 100 − D % 100 − L %
Practical Application of the Bridge Equation
A retail merchant financed by an SBI SME loan wishes to earn a net profit of 20 % 20\% 20% after allowing a festive discount of 10 % 10\% 10% on the Marked Price. What markup above Cost Price must be applied? M P C P = 100 + 20 100 − 10 = 120 90 = 4 3 \frac{MP}{CP} = \frac{100 + 20}{100 - 10} = \frac{120}{90} = \frac{4}{3} CP MP = 100 − 10 100 + 20 = 90 120 = 3 4
The ratio of M P MP MP to C P CP CP is 4 : 3 4 : 3 4 : 3 .
Markup = 4 − 3 = 1 = 4 - 3 = 1 = 4 − 3 = 1 unit on a base of C P = 3 CP = 3 CP = 3 units.
Markup % = 1 3 × 100 % = 33.33 % \text{Markup } \% = \frac{1}{3} \times 100\% = 33.33\% Markup % = 3 1 × 100% = 33.33% .
The merchant must mark the goods 33.33 % 33.33\% 33.33% above cost.
Successive Discounts & Single Equivalent Discount (SED)
Retail establishments frequently promote multiple successive discounts (e.g., "30% off plus an additional 20% clearance discount" ). Successive discounts operate on diminishing intermediate balances, meaning their cumulative effect is strictly less than their arithmetic sum.
Two Successive Discounts Formula
For two successive discount rates d 1 % d_1\% d 1 % and d 2 % d_2\% d 2 % : Single Equivalent Discount (SED) = ( d 1 + d 2 − d 1 × d 2 100 ) % \text{Single Equivalent Discount (SED)} = \left(d_1 + d_2 - \frac{d_1 \times d_2}{100}\right)\% Single Equivalent Discount (SED) = ( d 1 + d 2 − 100 d 1 × d 2 ) %
Example: Two successive discounts of 20 % 20\% 20% and 10 % 10\% 10% : SED = 20 + 10 − 20 × 10 100 = 30 − 2 = 28 % \text{SED} = 20 + 10 - \frac{20 \times 10}{100} = 30 - 2 = 28\% SED = 20 + 10 − 100 20 × 10 = 30 − 2 = 28%
Three or More Successive Discounts (Fractional Multiplier Method)
When evaluating three discounts ( d 1 , d 2 , d 3 d_1, d_2, d_3 d 1 , d 2 , d 3 ), applying the two-stage formula repeatedly is cumbersome. Instead, compute the surviving Selling Price fraction: S P M P = ( 1 − d 1 100 ) × ( 1 − d 2 100 ) × ( 1 − d 3 100 ) \frac{SP}{MP} = \left(1 - \frac{d_1}{100}\right) \times \left(1 - \frac{d_2}{100}\right) \times \left(1 - \frac{d_3}{100}\right) MP SP = ( 1 − 100 d 1 ) × ( 1 − 100 d 2 ) × ( 1 − 100 d 3 ) SED = ( 1 − S P M P ) × 100 % \text{SED} = \left(1 - \frac{SP}{MP}\right) \times 100\% SED = ( 1 − MP SP ) × 100%
For discounts of 20 % 20\% 20% , 25 % 25\% 25% , and 10 % 10\% 10% : S P M P = 4 5 × 3 4 × 9 10 = 27 50 = 0.54 \frac{SP}{MP} = \frac{4}{5} \times \frac{3}{4} \times \frac{9}{10} = \frac{27}{50} = 0.54 MP SP = 5 4 × 4 3 × 10 9 = 50 27 = 0.54 SED = ( 1 − 0.54 ) × 100 % = 46 % \text{SED} = (1 - 0.54) \times 100\% = 46\% SED = ( 1 − 0.54 ) × 100% = 46%
The Dishonest Merchant / False Weight Traps
Questions involving dishonest shopkeepers represent one of the most reliable question archetypes in banking exams. Candidates frequently falter because they benchmark profit against the nominal quantity requested by the customer rather than the physical inventory actually parted with by the merchant.
Conceptual Core: The Real Cost Incurred
A dishonest trader professes to sell goods at Cost Price ( S P = C P SP = CP SP = CP per kg) but uses a fraudulent weight that measures only 800 g 800\text{ g} 800 g instead of a true 1000 g 1000\text{ g} 1000 g ( 1 kg 1\text{ kg} 1 kg ).
The customer pays for 1000 g 1000\text{ g} 1000 g worth of goods.
The merchant actually surrenders only 800 g 800\text{ g} 800 g of inventory.
The merchant's cost is strictly the cost of 800 g 800\text{ g} 800 g .
The merchant's profit is the value of the 200 g 200\text{ g} 200 g withheld.
The Universal False Weight Profit Formula Profit % = ( Error True Value − Error ) × 100 % = ( Error Weight Actually Dispensed ) × 100 % \text{Profit } \% = \left(\frac{\text{Error}}{\text{True Value} - \text{Error}}\right) \times 100\% = \left(\frac{\text{Error}}{\text{Weight Actually Dispensed}}\right) \times 100\% Profit % = ( True Value − Error Error ) × 100% = ( Weight Actually Dispensed Error ) × 100%
Substituting the values: Profit % = ( 1000 − 800 800 ) × 100 % = 200 800 × 100 % = 1 4 × 100 % = 25.00 % \text{Profit } \% = \left(\frac{1000 - 800}{800}\right) \times 100\% = \frac{200}{800} \times 100\% = \frac{1}{4} \times 100\% = 25.00\% Profit % = ( 800 1000 − 800 ) × 100% = 800 200 × 100% = 4 1 × 100% = 25.00%
Warning
The 20% Distractor Trap: Untrained candidates compute 200 1000 × 100 % = 20 % \frac{200}{1000} \times 100\% = 20\% 1000 200 × 100% = 20% . This option is intentionally placed as a prominent distractor. Profit must be calculated on the goods actually surrendered by the seller ( 800 g 800\text{ g} 800 g ), never on the nominal weight requested by the buyer ( 1000 g 1000\text{ g} 1000 g ). The correct profit is 25 % 25\% 25% .
Dual Deception: Markup Coupled with False Weight
If a merchant marks up the goods by m % m\% m % above cost AND additionally uses a false weight that is w % w\% w % short, the net multiplier is compound: Overall Multiplier = ( 1 + m 100 ) × ( Claimed Weight Actual Weight Dispensed ) \text{Overall Multiplier} = \left(1 + \frac{m}{100}\right) \times \left(\frac{\text{Claimed Weight}}{\text{Actual Weight Dispensed}}\right) Overall Multiplier = ( 1 + 100 m ) × ( Actual Weight Dispensed Claimed Weight )
Promotional Schemes: "Buy x x x Get y y y Free"
Retail marketing schemes offering free inventory units are mathematically equivalent to trade discounts:
Derivation of Effective Discount
Suppose a store advertises: "Buy 4, Get 1 Free" .
Let the Marked Price of each individual item be Rs. 100.
The customer takes home a total of 4 + 1 = 5 4 + 1 = 5 4 + 1 = 5 items.
The total Marked Value of goods transferred is 5 × 100 = Rs. 500 5 \times 100 = \text{Rs. } 500 5 × 100 = Rs. 500 .
The customer pays cash for only 4 items: 4 × 100 = Rs. 400 4 \times 100 = \text{Rs. } 400 4 × 100 = Rs. 400 .
The effective monetary concession is Rs. 100. Discount % = ( Free Items Total Items Transferred ) × 100 % = ( y x + y ) × 100 % \text{Discount } \% = \left(\frac{\text{Free Items}}{\text{Total Items Transferred}}\right) \times 100\% = \left(\frac{y}{x + y}\right) \times 100\% Discount % = ( Total Items Transferred Free Items ) × 100% = ( x + y y ) × 100%
For "Buy 4 Get 1 Free": Discount % = 1 4 + 1 × 100 % = 1 5 × 100 % = 20 % \text{Discount } \% = \frac{1}{4 + 1} \times 100\% = \frac{1}{5} \times 100\% = 20\% Discount % = 4 + 1 1 × 100% = 5 1 × 100% = 20%
Hybrid Retail Schemes (Free Items Plus Cash Discount)
When a merchant offers "Buy 4 Get 1 Free AND an additional 20% discount on cash payment" , calculate the compound effect using successive discounts:
First Discount ( d 1 d_1 d 1 from free items): 1 4 + 1 = 20 % \frac{1}{4+1} = 20\% 4 + 1 1 = 20% .
Second Discount ( d 2 d_2 d 2 from cash discount): 20 % 20\% 20% .
Single Equivalent Discount: SED = d 1 + d 2 − d 1 × d 2 100 = 20 + 20 − 400 100 = 40 − 4 = 36 % \text{SED} = d_1 + d_2 - \frac{d_1 \times d_2}{100} = 20 + 20 - \frac{400}{100} = 40 - 4 = 36\% SED = d 1 + d 2 − 100 d 1 × d 2 = 20 + 20 − 100 400 = 40 − 4 = 36%
- Step-by-Step Worked Commercial Examination Problems
- Problem 1: Combined Markup, Discount, and Net Profit
Problem: A shopkeeper marks an article 40 % 40\% 40% above its Cost Price and sells it after granting a discount of 15 % 15\% 15% on the Marked Price. If the shopkeeper realizes a net profit of Rs. 380, determine the Cost Price of the article.
Solution:
Let the Cost Price ( C P CP CP ) be 100 x 100x 100 x .
The Marked Price ( M P MP MP ) is marked 40 % 40\% 40% above cost: M P = 100 x × 1.40 = 140 x MP = 100x \times 1.40 = 140x MP = 100 x × 1.40 = 140 x .
Discount of 15 % 15\% 15% is deducted from M P MP MP : Discount = 140 x × 0.15 = 21 x \text{Discount} = 140x \times 0.15 = 21x Discount = 140 x × 0.15 = 21 x
Compute the Selling Price ( S P SP SP ): S P = M P − Discount = 140 x − 21 x = 119 x SP = MP - \text{Discount} = 140x - 21x = 119x SP = MP − Discount = 140 x − 21 x = 119 x
Compute the net profit: Profit = S P − C P = 119 x − 100 x = 19 x \text{Profit} = SP - CP = 119x - 100x = 19x Profit = SP − CP = 119 x − 100 x = 19 x
Equate to the actual profit of Rs. 380: 19 x = 380 ⟹ x = 380 19 = 20 19x = 380 \implies x = \frac{380}{19} = 20 19 x = 380 ⟹ x = 19 380 = 20
Cost Price = 100 x = 100 × 20 = Rs. 2 , 000 = 100x = 100 \times 20 = \text{Rs. } 2,000 = 100 x = 100 × 20 = Rs. 2 , 000 .
Problem 2: Dishonest Merchant with Compound Deception
Problem: A grocery dealer claims to sell pulses at a loss of 5 % 5\% 5% on Cost Price, but uses a fraudulent weight measuring 900 grams 900\text{ grams} 900 grams in place of 1 kilogram 1\text{ kilogram} 1 kilogram ( 1000 grams 1000\text{ grams} 1000 grams ). What is the dealer's actual overall percentage gain or loss?
Solution:
Let the Cost Price of 1000 g 1000\text{ g} 1000 g be Rs. 1000 (i.e., Re. 1 per gram).
The dealer professes to sell 1000 g 1000\text{ g} 1000 g at a 5 % 5\% 5% loss: Nominal Selling Price for 1000 g = 1000 × ( 1 − 0.05 ) = Rs. 950 \text{Nominal Selling Price for } 1000\text{ g} = 1000 \times (1 - 0.05) = \text{Rs. } 950 Nominal Selling Price for 1000 g = 1000 × ( 1 − 0.05 ) = Rs. 950
However, the dealer physically dispenses only 900 g 900\text{ g} 900 g of pulses.
The actual cost incurred by the dealer for the dispensed goods is: Actual Cost = 900 × 1 = Rs. 900 \text{Actual Cost} = 900 \times 1 = \text{Rs. } 900 Actual Cost = 900 × 1 = Rs. 900
The dealer receives Rs. 950 from the customer while incurring a cost of only Rs. 900.
Compute the net profit: Net Profit = 950 − 900 = Rs. 50 \text{Net Profit} = 950 - 900 = \text{Rs. } 50 Net Profit = 950 − 900 = Rs. 50
Calculate percentage profit on the actual cost: Profit % = 50 900 × 100 % = 5 90 × 100 % = 1 18 × 100 % = 5 5 9 % ≈ 5.56 % \text{Profit } \% = \frac{50}{900} \times 100\% = \frac{5}{90} \times 100\% = \frac{1}{18} \times 100\% = 5\frac{5}{9}\% \approx 5.56\% Profit % = 900 50 × 100% = 90 5 × 100% = 18 1 × 100% = 5 9 5 % ≈ 5.56%
Despite advertising a 5 % 5\% 5% loss, the fraudulent scale yields an actual net gain of 5.56 % 5.56\% 5.56% .