Study guide
5.2 Assessment of Developing Literacy & Data-Driven Intervention
TExES Core Subjects EC-6 391
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Exam Overview, Structure & TEKS Curriculum Framework
1.1 TExES 391 Exam Structure, Scoring & Test Strategy 1.2 Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) & Curriculum Architecture
2 ELAR: Oral Language, Phonological Foundations & Word Analysis
2.1 Oral Language Development & English Learner Support 2.2 Phonological Foundations for Struggling Upper-Elementary Readers 2.3 Word Analysis & Identification: Phonics, Syllables, Morphology & Word Relationships
3 ELAR: Fluency, Vocabulary, Comprehension & Literary Genres
3.1 Reading Fluency Development & Guided Oral Reading 3.2 Vocabulary Acquisition, Tiered Words & Semantic Mapping 3.3 Reading Comprehension Strategies & Informational Text 3.4 Literary Genres, Literary Analysis & Responding to Multiple Texts
4 ELAR: Inquiry, Research & Writing
4.1 Reading, Inquiry, and Research Across Content Areas 4.2 Writing Conventions, Spelling Development, Handwriting & Grammar 4.3 Written Communication & The Stages of the Writing Process
5 ELAR: Viewing, Representing & Literacy Assessment
5.1 Viewing, Representing & Media Literacy 5.2 Assessment of Developing Literacy & Data-Driven Intervention
6 Mathematics: Instruction, Discourse & Assessment
6.1 Mathematics Learning Theories, CPA Sequence & Manipulatives 6.2 Mathematical Discourse, Assessment & Error Analysis
7 Mathematics: Number Concepts, Operations & Number Theory
7.1 Number Systems, Place Value, Operations & Estimation 7.2 Number Theory: Primes, Factors, Multiples & Counting
8 Mathematics: Fractions, Decimals, Percents & Proportional Reasoning
8.1 Fraction Concepts, Models & Operations 8.2 Decimals, Percents, Ratios & Proportional Reasoning
9 Mathematics: Patterns, Functions & Algebra
9.1 Patterns, Sequences & Functions 9.2 Equality, Equations, Inequalities & Coordinate Graphing
10 Mathematics: Geometry & Measurement
10.1 Geometric Thinking, Polygons, Angles & Congruence 10.2 Three-Dimensional Figures, Transformations, Symmetry & Tessellations 10.3 Measurement: Units, Conversions, Formulas, Time & Money
11 Mathematics: Statistics, Probability, Processes & Perspectives
11.1 Statistics: Data Displays, Measures & Investigations 11.2 Probability, Counting Techniques & Simulations 11.3 Mathematical Processes: Problem Solving, Reasoning & Communication 11.4 History of Mathematics & Financial Literacy
12 Social Studies: Instruction, Sources & Historical Thinking
12.1 Social Studies Instruction: TEKS Strands, Inquiry & Planning 12.2 Primary Sources, Historical Thinking, Chronology & Decision-Making
13 Social Studies: Texas History
13.1 Native Peoples, European Exploration & Spanish Colonial Texas 13.2 Mexican Texas, the Empresarios & the Texas Revolution 13.3 The Republic of Texas, Statehood, Civil War & Reconstruction
14 Social Studies: United States History
14.1 Colonial America, the American Revolution & the Constitution 14.2 Expansion, Reform, the Modern United States & Twentieth-Century Texas
15 Social Studies: Geography & Culture
15.1 Geography Themes, Maps & Geographic Tools 15.2 Texas Natural Regions, Physical Processes & Population Patterns 15.3 Culture, Society, Diversity & Science and Technology
16 Social Studies: Economics
16.1 Economic Concepts, Economic Systems & Free Enterprise 16.2 Economic History, Measuring the Economy & the Texas Economy
17 Social Studies: Government & Citizenship
17.1 Foundations of Government & Founding Documents 17.2 Structure of Government, Lawmaking, Local Government & the Courts 17.3 Citizenship, Civic Participation & Symbols
18 Science: Safety, Nature of Science & Science in Society
18.1 Lab Safety, Equipment, Measurement & Data 18.2 History and Nature of Scientific Inquiry 18.3 Science, Technology, Society, Health & the Environment
19 Science: Unifying Concepts, Instruction & Assessment
19.1 Unifying Concepts and Processes in Science 19.2 Science Instruction: Inquiry, the 5E Model & Investigations 19.3 Science Assessment: Formative, Summative & Performance Assessment
20 Science: Force, Motion & Energy
20.1 Force, Motion, Simple Machines & Newton's Laws 20.2 Energy Forms, Transformations & Conservation 20.3 Heat Transfer, Electricity, Magnetism & Static Electricity 20.4 Waves, Sound, Light, Optics & the Electromagnetic Spectrum
21 Science: Properties & Changes in Matter
21.1 Physical Properties of Matter, States & Density 21.2 Chemical Properties, Physical/Chemical Changes & Mixtures
22 Science: Living Things, Classification & Heredity
22.1 Cell Theory, Cell Structure & Organelles 22.2 Basic Needs, Classification, Plant Structures & Human Body Systems 22.3 Reproduction, Life Cycles, Heredity & Genetics
23 Science: Adaptations, Evolution & Ecosystems
23.1 Adaptations, Natural Selection, Selective Breeding & Evolution 23.2 Ecosystems, Food Webs, Populations & Biomes
24 Science: Earth Systems & Cycles
24.1 Earth's Structure, Plate Tectonics & Changes to Earth's Surface 24.2 Minerals, Rocks, the Rock Cycle, Soil & Earth Materials 24.3 Earth Cycles: Water, Rock, Carbon & Nitrogen
25 Science: Weather, Climate & Space
25.1 Weather, Atmosphere, Climate & Ocean Interactions 25.2 Solar System, Celestial Motion, Moon Phases & Space
26 Fine Arts: Visual Arts
26.1 Visual Arts: Elements of Art & Principles of Design 26.2 Visual Arts: Media, Studio Safety, Artistic Development & Assessment 26.3 Visual Arts: Art History, Multiple Heritages & Art Criticism
27 Fine Arts: Music & Theatre
27.1 Music Fundamentals: Elements, Notation, Rhythm & Form 27.2 Music Pedagogy, TEKS, Heritage, Careers & Classroom Management 27.3 Theatre Arts, Creative Drama, Occupations & Theatre History
28 Health Education
28.1 Health Literacy, Wellness, Nutrition & Disease Prevention 28.2 Mental and Social Health, Substances, Growth & Consumer Health 28.3 Personal Safety, First Aid & Child Abuse Reporting
29 Physical Education
29.1 Motor Development, Fundamental Movement Skills & Movement Concepts 29.2 Physical Fitness, FitnessGram, Inclusive PE & Game Tactics
5.2 Assessment of Developing Literacy & Data-Driven Intervention
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Formative assessment guides day-to-day instruction, while summative assessment measures learning at the end of a unit or year.
Norm-referenced tests compare a student with a norm group, while criterion-referenced tests measure mastery of specific standards.
An informal reading inventory identifies a student's independent, instructional, and frustration reading levels and analyzes word recognition and comprehension.
Within MTSS, data guide increasingly intensive interventions, but a suspected disability requires a referral for evaluation without waiting for tiers to be completed.
Teachers share assessment results with students and families in clear language, along with specific ways to support learning at home.
Last updated: October 2026
Overview & Exam Relevance
Competency 010 (Assessment of Developing Literacy) is one of the most heavily described competencies on the ELAR subject exam. Teachers of grades 4–6 must understand the principles of literacy assessment, choose and give formal and informal assessments, and analyze students' reading and writing to plan instruction. They must also recognize when a student needs classroom intervention or specialized reading instruction, and communicate progress to families. Expect data-based scenarios: interpreting an informal reading inventory, analyzing a writing sample's convention errors, or choosing the next instructional step from screening data.
Literacy Assessment Frameworks (Competency 010)
To make valid instructional decisions, educators must select assessments that align precisely with their measurement purpose. Understanding the four core assessment dichotomies is fundamental for the TExES exam. THE LITERACY ASSESSMENT TAXONOMY
- │
- ├── Formal vs. Informal (Standardized administration vs. Classroom observations)
- ├── Formative vs. Summative (Assessment FOR learning vs. Assessment OF learning)
- ├── Criterion vs. Norm-Referenced (Mastery of standards vs. Peer percentile rank)
- └── Screening vs. Progress Monitoring (Universal risk check vs. Rate of improvement)
- 1. Formal vs. Informal Assessment
Formal Assessments : Standardized, scientifically validated assessment instruments characterized by strict administration protocols, uniform scoring procedures, and statistical validity and reliability (e.g., STAAR, Woodcock-Johnson, DIBELS benchmark probes). They produce quantitative data used for accountability and eligibility determinations.
Informal Assessments : Flexible, classroom-embedded measures integrated into daily instruction (e.g., teacher checklists, running records, exit tickets, anecdotal reading notes, student reading conferences). They provide immediate, qualitative insights to guide day-to-day differentiation.
2. Formative vs. Summative Assessment
Formative Assessment (Assessment FOR Learning) : Ongoing, in-flight checks for understanding conducted during the learning process. The primary purpose is to identify misconceptions, provide constructive feedback, and immediately adjust instructional pacing and methods (e.g., thumb checks, one-minute quick-writes, mid-lesson whiteboard responses).
Summative Assessment (Assessment OF Learning) : Evaluative measures administered at the end of an instructional sequence (end-of-unit exam, cumulative post-test, STAAR exam). The primary purpose is to assign grades, certify competence, or measure programmatic efficacy against grade-level standards.
3. Criterion-Referenced vs. Norm-Referenced Assessment
Criterion-Referenced Assessment : Measures an individual student's performance against a predetermined, absolute benchmark of mastery or specific curriculum standards (TEKS). Performance is reported as pass/fail, percentage correct, or performance levels (e.g., Approaches, Meets, Masters Grade Level on STAAR; a state driver's license exam). Every student could theoretically achieve 100% mastery.
Norm-Referenced Assessment : Compares an individual student's performance against a statistically representative sample of peers (the "norm group"). Performance is reported as percentile ranks (e.g., 78th percentile) , stanines, or standard scores mapped onto a normal bell curve. Norm-referenced tests are designed to rank-order students across a broad distribution rather than verify specific instructional mastery.
4. Diagnostic Screening vs. Progress Monitoring
Universal Screening : Brief, standardized assessments administered to 100% of students three times per school year (Beginning of Year [BOY], Middle of Year [MOY], and End of Year [EOY]) to detect early literacy risk factors (e.g., dyslexia screening, phonemic segmentation fluency).
Progress Monitoring : Brief, frequent assessments administered weekly or bi-weekly to students receiving supplemental intervention to quantify rate of improvement (slope) and determine whether the intervention is closing the performance gap.
Comprehensive Assessment Matrix
Assessment Typology Primary Function & Timing Scoring & Reporting Format Classroom Example Primary Exam Distinction
Formal Standardized measurement with uniform administration Standard scores, percentiles, scaled scores State-mandated STAAR Reading exam Strict adherence to standardized administration scripts is legally required
Informal Flexible, ongoing classroom data collection Rubric scores, error tallies, observational notes Running record conducted during guided reading Adjusts dynamically to student responses; non-standardized
Formative Informs daily instructional adjustments during learning Qualitative notes, ungraded checkmarks, exit slips 3-2-1 exit ticket at the conclusion of a phonics lesson Low stakes; goal is immediate instructional feedback, not grading
Summative Evaluates cumulative mastery at end of unit/semester Numerical grades (e.g., 88%), letter grades (B+) End-of-unit expository writing assessment High stakes; evaluates curriculum mastery after instruction has ended
Criterion-Referenced Verifies student mastery against absolute standards (TEKS) Performance tiers (Meets/Masters), percent correct 4th-grade criterion test on identifying text structures Compares student to a fixed standard, NOT to other students
Norm-Referenced Compares student performance against a peer norm group Percentile ranks (e.g., 65th percentile), stanines Iowa Assessments or TerraNova standardized tests Designed to yield a normal distribution; scores do not describe specific TEKS mastery
Screening Identifies students at risk of literacy failure (3x/year) Benchmark cutoff scores (At Risk / Low Risk) Texas Primary Reading Inventory (TPRI) administered in fall Universal screener administered to every student, not just struggling readers
Progress Monitoring Tracks intervention response frequency (weekly/bi-weekly) Graphic slope charts displaying target aim lines 1-minute Oral Reading Fluency (ORF) weekly probe Quantifies rate of growth to validate or adjust Tier 2/3 interventions
Diagnostic Literacy Assessment Tools
Elementary educators deploy specific diagnostic instruments to uncover the root causes of reading difficulty:
1. Running Records and Qualitative Miscue Analysis
Conducted one-on-one using a standardized coding system (checkmarks, substitutions, omissions, insertions, self-corrections).
Evaluates the MSV (Meaning, Structure, Visual) cueing systems to discover what cognitive information the student uses or ignores during decoding breakdowns.
2. Validated Phonics and Early Literacy Screeners
TPRI (Texas Primary Reading Inventory) : A state-developed diagnostic tool for Grades K–2 assessing graphophonemic knowledge, phonological awareness, reading accuracy, and comprehension.
DIBELS / Acadience Reading : Standardized Curriculum-Based Measurements (CBM) assessing Letter Naming Fluency (LNF), First Sound Fluency (FSF), Phoneme Segmentation Fluency (PSF), Nonsense Word Fluency (NWF), and Oral Reading Fluency (ORF).
3. Analytic vs. Holistic Rubrics
Holistic Rubrics : Provide a single overall numerical score based on an integrated impression of the entire piece of student writing. Efficient for large-scale grading, but offers minimal diagnostic feedback.
Analytic Rubrics : Break performance down into discrete criteria evaluated independently (e.g., Organization, Evidence, Voice, Sentence Fluency, Conventions). Essential for formative feedback and targeted instruction.
4. Literacy Portfolios and Kid-Watching
Portfolios : Longitudinal, purposeful collections of student work across time, incorporating self-reflection and authentic growth evidence across writing genres.
Kid-Watching (Yetta Goodman) : Systematic, disciplined observational note-taking documenting authentic student language behaviors during collaborative literacy tasks.
Informal Reading Inventories and Matching Readers to Texts
An informal reading inventory (IRI) is an individually given assessment in which a student reads graded word lists and passages aloud (and sometimes silently) and answers comprehension questions. The teacher records oral reading errors, calculates accuracy, and scores comprehension to estimate three levels:
Independent level : The student reads with high accuracy and strong comprehension without help. Use it for independent and home reading.
Instructional level : The student makes some errors and has adequate comprehension with support. Use it for guided reading and small-group instruction.
Frustration level : Accuracy or comprehension breaks down. Avoid these texts for instruction, though students may still enjoy them as read-alouds.
Teachers use these levels to select materials and to guide students' choice of independent reading. Analysis of the errors themselves shows why reading breaks down. Examples include skipping endings, mispronouncing multisyllabic words, or reading accurately but without understanding. The analysis guides focused instruction.
Other informal tools include running records, retellings, think-alouds, comprehension questions at literal, inferential, and evaluative levels, and fluency probes. Formal reading measures include criterion-referenced state tests (such as STAAR Reading Language Arts) and curriculum-based assessments, plus norm-referenced standardized tests.
Assessing Writing and Writing Conventions
Writing samples over time : Collect drafts and final pieces in a portfolio to monitor growth in ideas, organization, voice, and conventions.
Error analysis : Categorize convention errors (capitalization, end punctuation, subject-verb agreement, homophones, spelling patterns) to find patterns. For example, a student who writes "hopeing" and "makeing" needs instruction in the drop-final- e rule, not more random spelling lists.
Rubrics and checklists : Analytic rubrics give feedback on specific traits; checklists support self-editing.
Self- and peer-assessment : Students judge their own and classmates' writing for clarity, interest to the audience, and completeness, using shared criteria.
Comparing to the TEKS : When a student's performance falls below the grade-level writing expectations in the TEKS, plan additional help or intervention.
Communicating Progress to Families and Colleagues
Share growth with concrete evidence: compare an early and a recent writing sample, show reading-level progress, and explain next steps in plain language. Use conferences, notes, portfolios, and student-led conferences. Collaborate with reading specialists, ESL and special education staff, and dyslexia specialists when data show a student needs more than classroom support. For English learners, include language-proficiency information (such as TELPAS results) so families understand both literacy and language growth.
Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS) & Response to Intervention (RTI)
The MTSS / RTI framework is a proactive, data-driven instructional continuum designed to prevent academic failure through increasingly intensive tiers of evidence-based intervention. THE THREE-TIER MTSS / RTI PYRAMID
- ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
- │ TIER 3: Intensive Individual Intervention (~5% of Pop) │
- │ • Daily 45-60 min explicit instruction (1:1 or 1:3) │
- │ • Specialized reading specialist / interventionist │
- ├────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ TIER 2: Targeted Small-Group Intervention (~15% of Pop)│
- │ • 20-30 min sessions, 3-4x weekly (1:4 to 1:6 ratio) │
- │ • Supplemental to Tier 1 core instruction │
- ├────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ TIER 1: High-Quality Universal Core (100% of Students) │
- │ • Grade-level TEKS instruction with differentiation │
- │ • Universal screening 3x annually (BOY, MOY, EOY) │
- └────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
- Tier Descriptions and Intervention Protocols
Tier 1: Core Classroom Instruction (Universal - 100% of Students) :
High-quality, evidence-based reading instruction aligned with the TEKS delivered by the general education teacher.
Differentiated instruction accommodates diverse learner readiness through flexible small-group guided reading.
Universal screening three times per year identifies students falling below benchmark thresholds.
Tier 2: Targeted Small-Group Intervention (Strategic - ~15% of Students) :
Provided to students who fail to meet benchmark cutoffs on universal screening probes.
Delivered in small groups of 4 to 6 students for 20 to 30 minutes, 3 to 4 times per week, in addition to (never replacing) Tier 1 core instruction.
Focuses explicitly on diagnosed skill gaps (e.g., blending consonant digraphs or vowel-consonant-e patterns).
Progress monitoring occurs bi-weekly using standardized curriculum-based measurement probes.
Tier 3: Intensive Individualized Intervention (Specialized - ~5% of Students) :
Provided to students who demonstrate insufficient responsiveness to high-quality Tier 2 interventions.
Highly individualized, explicit, and systematic instruction delivered daily in 45- to 60-minute blocks with very small teacher-to-student ratios (1:1 to 1:3).
Progress is monitored weekly. If data demonstrates flat or stagnant progress after sustained intensive Tier 3 intervention, the student is referred for formal comprehensive special education evaluation (e.g., for specific learning disabilities like dyslexia under IDEA).
Classroom Scenario Application
Classroom Context: In October, Ms. Rivera reviews informal reading inventory results for Andrés, a fifth grader. On a fourth-grade passage he reads with 96% accuracy and answers 8 of 10 comprehension questions. On a fifth-grade passage his accuracy drops to 88%; he skips or guesses at multisyllabic words such as "population" and "announcement" and answers 5 of 10 questions.
Diagnostic Analysis: The fourth-grade passage is near Andrés's independent level, and fifth-grade text is at his frustration level. The pattern of errors on long words, not on short high-frequency words, points to a gap in multisyllabic decoding and morphology rather than a general comprehension problem.
Data-Based Plan:
Targeted small-group instruction : Three times a week, Ms. Rivera teaches syllable types, syllable division, and common suffixes such as -tion and -ment , then has students apply them in connected text.
Appropriate text : For guided reading she uses instructional-level texts and builds toward grade-level text with support. Andrés self-selects independent reading from fourth-grade-level books on topics he enjoys.
Progress monitoring : Every two weeks she checks accuracy on grade-level passages and his reading of multisyllabic word lists.
Communication : She shows Andrés's family his two reading samples, explains the goal, and suggests reading together for 15 minutes each night.
Next steps : If progress stalls despite good instruction, she will consult the campus reading specialist about more intensive support and, if a disability is suspected, about a referral for evaluation.