Study guide

19.3 Science Assessment: Formative, Summative & Performance Assessment

TExES Core Subjects EC-6 391

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Exam Overview, Structure & TEKS Curriculum Framework

1.1 TExES 391 Exam Structure, Scoring & Test Strategy 1.2 Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) & Curriculum Architecture

2 ELAR: Oral Language, Phonological Foundations & Word Analysis

2.1 Oral Language Development & English Learner Support 2.2 Phonological Foundations for Struggling Upper-Elementary Readers 2.3 Word Analysis & Identification: Phonics, Syllables, Morphology & Word Relationships

3 ELAR: Fluency, Vocabulary, Comprehension & Literary Genres

3.1 Reading Fluency Development & Guided Oral Reading 3.2 Vocabulary Acquisition, Tiered Words & Semantic Mapping 3.3 Reading Comprehension Strategies & Informational Text 3.4 Literary Genres, Literary Analysis & Responding to Multiple Texts

4 ELAR: Inquiry, Research & Writing

4.1 Reading, Inquiry, and Research Across Content Areas 4.2 Writing Conventions, Spelling Development, Handwriting & Grammar 4.3 Written Communication & The Stages of the Writing Process

5 ELAR: Viewing, Representing & Literacy Assessment

5.1 Viewing, Representing & Media Literacy 5.2 Assessment of Developing Literacy & Data-Driven Intervention

6 Mathematics: Instruction, Discourse & Assessment

6.1 Mathematics Learning Theories, CPA Sequence & Manipulatives 6.2 Mathematical Discourse, Assessment & Error Analysis

7 Mathematics: Number Concepts, Operations & Number Theory

7.1 Number Systems, Place Value, Operations & Estimation 7.2 Number Theory: Primes, Factors, Multiples & Counting

8 Mathematics: Fractions, Decimals, Percents & Proportional Reasoning

8.1 Fraction Concepts, Models & Operations 8.2 Decimals, Percents, Ratios & Proportional Reasoning

9 Mathematics: Patterns, Functions & Algebra

9.1 Patterns, Sequences & Functions 9.2 Equality, Equations, Inequalities & Coordinate Graphing

10 Mathematics: Geometry & Measurement

10.1 Geometric Thinking, Polygons, Angles & Congruence 10.2 Three-Dimensional Figures, Transformations, Symmetry & Tessellations 10.3 Measurement: Units, Conversions, Formulas, Time & Money

11 Mathematics: Statistics, Probability, Processes & Perspectives

11.1 Statistics: Data Displays, Measures & Investigations 11.2 Probability, Counting Techniques & Simulations 11.3 Mathematical Processes: Problem Solving, Reasoning & Communication 11.4 History of Mathematics & Financial Literacy

12 Social Studies: Instruction, Sources & Historical Thinking

12.1 Social Studies Instruction: TEKS Strands, Inquiry & Planning 12.2 Primary Sources, Historical Thinking, Chronology & Decision-Making

13 Social Studies: Texas History

13.1 Native Peoples, European Exploration & Spanish Colonial Texas 13.2 Mexican Texas, the Empresarios & the Texas Revolution 13.3 The Republic of Texas, Statehood, Civil War & Reconstruction

14 Social Studies: United States History

14.1 Colonial America, the American Revolution & the Constitution 14.2 Expansion, Reform, the Modern United States & Twentieth-Century Texas

15 Social Studies: Geography & Culture

15.1 Geography Themes, Maps & Geographic Tools 15.2 Texas Natural Regions, Physical Processes & Population Patterns 15.3 Culture, Society, Diversity & Science and Technology

16 Social Studies: Economics

16.1 Economic Concepts, Economic Systems & Free Enterprise 16.2 Economic History, Measuring the Economy & the Texas Economy

17 Social Studies: Government & Citizenship

17.1 Foundations of Government & Founding Documents 17.2 Structure of Government, Lawmaking, Local Government & the Courts 17.3 Citizenship, Civic Participation & Symbols

18 Science: Safety, Nature of Science & Science in Society

18.1 Lab Safety, Equipment, Measurement & Data 18.2 History and Nature of Scientific Inquiry 18.3 Science, Technology, Society, Health & the Environment

19 Science: Unifying Concepts, Instruction & Assessment

19.1 Unifying Concepts and Processes in Science 19.2 Science Instruction: Inquiry, the 5E Model & Investigations 19.3 Science Assessment: Formative, Summative & Performance Assessment

20 Science: Force, Motion & Energy

20.1 Force, Motion, Simple Machines & Newton's Laws 20.2 Energy Forms, Transformations & Conservation 20.3 Heat Transfer, Electricity, Magnetism & Static Electricity 20.4 Waves, Sound, Light, Optics & the Electromagnetic Spectrum

21 Science: Properties & Changes in Matter

21.1 Physical Properties of Matter, States & Density 21.2 Chemical Properties, Physical/Chemical Changes & Mixtures

22 Science: Living Things, Classification & Heredity

22.1 Cell Theory, Cell Structure & Organelles 22.2 Basic Needs, Classification, Plant Structures & Human Body Systems 22.3 Reproduction, Life Cycles, Heredity & Genetics

23 Science: Adaptations, Evolution & Ecosystems

23.1 Adaptations, Natural Selection, Selective Breeding & Evolution 23.2 Ecosystems, Food Webs, Populations & Biomes

24 Science: Earth Systems & Cycles

24.1 Earth's Structure, Plate Tectonics & Changes to Earth's Surface 24.2 Minerals, Rocks, the Rock Cycle, Soil & Earth Materials 24.3 Earth Cycles: Water, Rock, Carbon & Nitrogen

25 Science: Weather, Climate & Space

25.1 Weather, Atmosphere, Climate & Ocean Interactions 25.2 Solar System, Celestial Motion, Moon Phases & Space

26 Fine Arts: Visual Arts

26.1 Visual Arts: Elements of Art & Principles of Design 26.2 Visual Arts: Media, Studio Safety, Artistic Development & Assessment 26.3 Visual Arts: Art History, Multiple Heritages & Art Criticism

27 Fine Arts: Music & Theatre

27.1 Music Fundamentals: Elements, Notation, Rhythm & Form 27.2 Music Pedagogy, TEKS, Heritage, Careers & Classroom Management 27.3 Theatre Arts, Creative Drama, Occupations & Theatre History

28 Health Education

28.1 Health Literacy, Wellness, Nutrition & Disease Prevention 28.2 Mental and Social Health, Substances, Growth & Consumer Health 28.3 Personal Safety, First Aid & Child Abuse Reporting

29 Physical Education

29.1 Motor Development, Fundamental Movement Skills & Movement Concepts 29.2 Physical Fitness, FitnessGram, Inclusive PE & Game Tactics

19.3 Science Assessment: Formative, Summative & Performance Assessment

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Assessments should match the learning goal; a skill such as using a graduated cylinder is best assessed by observing a performance.

Science notebooks, checklists, rubrics, portfolios, and student profiles show students' understanding and their participation in inquiry.

Analytic rubrics score each criterion separately and give more detailed feedback than holistic rubrics.

Sharing rubrics and exemplars before a task helps students understand what quality work looks like.

Formative assessment results should guide regrouping, reteaching, and enrichment.

Last updated: October 2026

Overview & Exam Relevance

Competency 006 (Science Assessment) asks you to understand the relationships among curriculum, assessment, and instruction. You must also know how to monitor students' understanding continuously with formal and informal measures, and how to use products such as projects, lab journals, rubrics, portfolios, student profiles, and checklists to evaluate learning and participation in inquiry. The competency also covers selecting performance, self-, formative, and summative assessments and communicating evaluation criteria and results to students. Expect scenario items that ask which assessment best measures a specific skill.

  • Science Assessment Strategies (Competency 006)
  • Formative versus Summative Assessment in Science

Formative Assessment : Assessment for learning conducted continuously during the instructional sequence. Its purpose is to diagnose student misconceptions, evaluate comprehension, and immediately adjust pedagogical strategies. Examples include science probes (Page Keeley concept cartoons), entry/exit tickets, white-board sketch checks, and teacher questioning during lab facilitation.

Summative Assessment : Assessment of learning administered at the culmination of an instructional unit or investigation cycle to evaluate cumulative student mastery against TEKS benchmarks. Examples include end-of-unit exams, summative lab reports, and standards-based projects.

Science Interactive Notebooks (INBs)

Science Interactive Notebooks serve as cognitive portfolios documenting student conceptual growth:

Right-Side (Input / Teacher-Directed) : Contains formal, teacher-provided content—lecture graphic organizers, lab safety protocols, investigation procedures, formal scientific definitions, textbook reading excerpts, and structured data tables.

Left-Side (Output / Student-Centered) : Contains student synthesis, cognitive processing, and metacognitive reflection—diagrams, concept maps, written reflections, self-generated hypotheses, drawings, and Claim-Evidence-Reasoning (CER) paragraphs.

Performance-Based Assessments (Lab Practicals)

Rather than relying solely on paper-and-pencil recall, performance-based assessments evaluate whether students can actively execute scientific process skills. A teacher assesses students using an objective rubric as they execute tasks such as correctly taring a triple-beam balance, measuring the volume of an irregular solid using water displacement in a graduated cylinder, properly focusing a compound microscope on high power, or constructing a closed electrical circuit.

The Claim-Evidence-Reasoning (CER) Framework

Developed by Katherine McNeill and Joseph Krajcik, the CER framework provides elementary students with an explicit scaffold for constructing scientific arguments: THE CLAIM-EVIDENCE-REASONING (CER) FRAMEWORK

  • │
  • ├── 1. CLAIM ──────► A concise, direct statement that answers the guiding scientific question
  • │ (The "What do you know?")
  • │
  • ├── 2. EVIDENCE ───► Specific, measurable qualitative or quantitative empirical data from the lab
  • │ (The "How do you know it?")
  • │
  • └── 3. REASONING ──► The scientific law, theory, or concept that explains WHY the data supports the claim
  • (The "Why does your evidence make sense?")

Claim : A direct, declarative sentence answering the guiding scientific research question. A claim must not include explanations or evidence; it is a clear assertion of the finding.

Evidence : Observable empirical data collected during the investigation that directly supports the claim. Evidence must be specific and sufficient. It can include quantitative measurements (numbers, units, statistical averages) or qualitative sensory observations.

Reasoning : The most cognitively rigorous component. Reasoning provides the logical justification that explicitly connects the empirical evidence to the claim by applying established scientific principles, definitions, laws, or theories. It explains why the data counts as valid evidence for the claim.

Assessment Products for Science Inquiry

Product What It Shows Example Use

Science notebook or lab journal Questions, predictions, data, drawings, and conclusions over time The teacher reviews entries for evidence-based reasoning

Checklist Whether specific skills or behaviors were observed Wears goggles, reads graduated cylinder at eye level, records units

  • Rubric Levels of quality on defined criteria An analytic rubric for an investigation report
  • Portfolio Growth across a unit or year Selected notebook pages and reflections

Student profile A record of a student's strengths and needs across many assessments Used to plan small-group instruction

Project or performance task Applying knowledge to design, build, or investigate Designing a water filter and testing it

Analytic vs. holistic rubrics : An analytic rubric scores each criterion separately (for example, the question, procedure, data, and conclusion), which gives detailed feedback. A holistic rubric gives a single overall score, which is faster but less diagnostic.

Matching the Assessment to the Learning Goal

To assess whether students can use a tool , observe them using it (a performance assessment with a checklist), rather than giving a written test.

To assess whether students can design a fair test , ask them to plan an investigation and identify the variables.

To assess conceptual understanding , ask students to explain or predict ("What will happen to the shadow at 3:00 p.m., and why?").

Self-assessment and peer assessment help students reflect on their work against the criteria.

Formative assessment (probes, exit tickets, whiteboards, observation during discussion) guides the next lesson. Summative assessment (unit tests, final projects) evaluates mastery at the end of instruction.

Communicating Criteria and Results

Share rubrics and exemplars before students begin a task so they know what quality looks like. Give feedback that is timely, specific, and focused on the criteria ("Your conclusion states a claim but does not cite your data"). Use assessment results to plan instruction: regroup students, reteach with a new approach, or extend learning for students who have mastered the concept.