Study guide
10.2 The Sales Comparison Approach & Adjustments
Texas Real Estate Broker Exam
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Chapter 1: TREC Authority, Licensing & Qualifications
1.1 TREC Structure, Powers & Rulemaking Authority 1.2 Broker Licensing Requirements & Experience Qualifications 1.3 License Maintenance, Inactive Status & Continuing Education 1.4 Real Estate Recovery Trust Account & Disciplinary Sanctions 1.5 The Broker Examination: Format, Scoring, Retakes & Application Timeline
2 Chapter 2: Broker Supervision & Brokerage Operations
2.1 Broker Supervisory Responsibilities & Written Policies Manual 2.2 Sponsoring Sales Agents & Delegation of Authority 2.3 Broker Advertising Rules & Team Names 2.4 Brokerage Entity Formation & Branch Office Management
3 Chapter 3: Texas Agency & Intermediary Brokerage
3.1 Agency Relationships & Fiduciary Duties in Texas 3.2 Information About Brokerage Services (IABS) Disclosures 3.3 Texas Intermediary Practice & Appointed Licensees 3.4 Representation Agreements & Compensation Compliance
4 Chapter 4: Trust Accounts, Escrow Funds & Financial Operations
4.1 Trust Account Requirements & Depository Standards 4.2 Handling Earnest Money & Security Deposits 4.3 Commingling, Conversion & Trust Account Audits
5 Chapter 5: TREC Promulgated Sales Contracts & Addenda
5.1 Broker-Lawyer Committee & Promulgated Form Rules 5.2 One to Four Family Residential Contract (Resale) Analysis 5.3 Financing Addenda & Critical Promulgated Addenda
6 Chapter 6: Promulgated Options, Amendments & Specialized Contracts
6.1 Option Periods, Amendments & Contract Termination 6.2 Condominium & Farm/Ranch Promulgated Contracts 6.3 New Home Contracts, Infill & Short Sale Addenda
7 Chapter 7: Texas Real Estate Statutes & Consumer Protection
7.1 Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act (DTPA) & Broker Liability 7.2 Texas Homestead Protections & Community Property Law 7.3 Texas Foreclosure Law, Liens & Property Tax Rules 7.4 Landlord-Tenant Law & Statutory Disclosures
8 Chapter 8: Property Ownership, Estates & Encumbrances
8.1 Real Property Concepts, Physical Characteristics & Bundle of Rights 8.2 Estates in Land & Concurrent Forms of Ownership 8.3 Encumbrances, Easements, Liens & Encroachments
9 Chapter 9: Land Use Controls, Environmental Hazards & Legal Descriptions
9.1 Public & Private Land Use Controls 9.2 Environmental Hazards & CERCLA Superfund Liability 9.3 Legal Descriptions, Surveys & Property Measurements 9.4 Broker Disclosure Duties, Latent Defects & Stigmatized Property
10 Chapter 10: Real Estate Valuation & Appraisal Methods
10.1 Principles of Value & Market Analysis 10.2 The Sales Comparison Approach & Adjustments 10.3 The Cost Approach & Depreciation Calculations 10.4 The Income Approach & Capitalization Rate Analysis
11 Chapter 11: Real Estate Financing, Lending Regulations & Markets
11.1 Mortgage Instruments, Theories & Security Devices 11.2 Loan Types, Programs & Underwriting Standards 11.3 Primary vs Secondary Mortgage Markets 11.4 Federal Lending Regulations (TILA, RESPA, TRID, ECOA)
12 Chapter 12: General Contract Law, Title Transfer & Closing Procedures
12.1 General Contract Law Principles & Remedies 12.2 Deeds, Title Transfer & Title Insurance 12.3 Closing Procedures, Settlement & Proration Mechanics
13 Chapter 13: Fair Housing, Broker Risk Management & Leasing
13.1 Federal Fair Housing Laws & Protected Classes 13.2 Broker Risk Management & Errors and Omissions Insurance 13.3 Commercial Leasing & Property Management Operations 13.4 Antitrust Regulations & Real Estate Ethics 13.5 The TREC Canons of Professional Ethics & Conduct
14 Chapter 14: Broker Mathematics & Financial Calculations
14.1 Commission Splits, Net Sheets & Profit/Loss Math 14.2 Area, Acreage & Measurement Calculations 14.3 Property Taxes, Prorations & Loan Calculations 14.4 Investment Property Math: Cap Rate, GRM & Cash Returns
10.2 The Sales Comparison Approach & Adjustments
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
The Sales Comparison Approach relies directly on the Principle of Substitution and is the primary appraisal methodology for single-family residences, residential condominiums, and vacant land.
The cardinal rule of appraisal adjustments: ALWAYS adjust the COMPARABLE property, NEVER adjust the Subject property.
CBS Rule (Comparable Better, Subtract): If the comparable has a superior feature or amenity relative to the subject, subtract the contributory value from the comp's sale price.
CIA Rule (Comparable Inferior, Add): If the comparable lacks a feature or is inferior relative to the subject, add the contributory value to the comp's sale price.
Appraisers reconcile adjusted comparable values through professional qualitative judgment and weighted reliability, NEVER by calculating a simple mathematical arithmetic average.
Last updated: August 2026
10.2 The Sales Comparison Approach & Adjustments
Exam Focus: The Sales Comparison Approach (historically known as the Market Data Approach) is the primary valuation methodology tested on the Texas Broker Exam. You must master the exact criteria for selecting valid comparable properties, the ironclad rule of adjustments (never adjust the subject), the application of the CBS and CIA adjustment rules, the sequence of transactional and physical adjustments, and why mathematical averaging is strictly forbidden during reconciliation.
1. Underlying Principles & Primary Applications
The Sales Comparison Approach is founded upon the Principle of Substitution —which holds that an informed buyer will pay no more for a subject property than the price required to purchase an existing, equally desirable substitute property in the open market.
Primary Applications
Single-Family Residences & Townhomes: The undisputed gold standard for valuing owner-occupied residential properties where abundant market transaction data exists.
Residential Condominiums: Highly effective when recent closed sales exist within the same condominium complex or competing buildings.
Vacant Residential Lots & Acreage Parcels: The preferred method for valuing unimproved land (which is also used in the Cost Approach to determine raw land value). ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
- │ CRITERIA FOR SELECTING COMPARABLE PROPERTIES │
- ├─────────────────┬───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ 1. Arm's-Length │ Open market transaction between unrelated, willing parties│
- │ Transaction │ without duress, undue pressure, or non-market terms. │
- ├─────────────────┼───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ 2. Geographic │ Located in the same subdivision, immediate neighborhood, │
- │ Proximity │ or competing market area (typically within 0.5–1.0 mile). │
- ├─────────────────┼───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ 3. Recency of │ Closed within the past 3 to 6 months (maximum 12 months in│
- │ Sale │ slow or rural markets with documented market adjustments).│
- ├─────────────────┼───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ 4. Physical & │ Similar gross living area (GLA), architectural style, age,│
- │ Functional │ condition, lot size, bedroom/bath count, and amenities. │
- └─────────────────┴───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
- Minimum Comparable Requirement
Secondary mortgage market guidelines (Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, FHA, VA) require a minimum of three closed comparable sales that have settled within the past 12 months (preferably within 90 to 180 days). Appraisers may include active listings or pending contracts to illustrate current supply trends, but indicated value must be grounded in verified closed transactions.
2. The Paramount Rule of Valuation Adjustments
When applying the Sales Comparison Approach, no two properties are completely identical. Differences in size, age, condition, location, and amenities must be equalized through financial adjustments.
THE PARAMOUNT RULE OF ADJUSTMENTS: ALWAYS adjust the COMPARABLE property! NEVER adjust the Subject property! The subject property is the fixed baseline benchmark. We modify the comparable's historical sale price to answer the question: 'What would this comparable have sold for if it had the exact same characteristics as the subject property?' ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
- │ THE CBS AND CIA ADJUSTMENT MNEMONICS │
- ├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ C B S ───► COMPARABLE BETTER ───► SUBTRACT from Comp Sale Price │
- │ If the Comparable has a superior feature that the Subject lacks, │
- │ we SUBTRACT the contributory market value of that feature from the Comp. │
- ├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
- │ C I A ───► COMPARABLE INFERIOR ──► ADD to Comp Sale Price │
- │ If the Comparable is inferior or lacks a feature that the Subject has, │
- │ we ADD the contributory market value of that feature to the Comp. │
- └─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
- Mathematical Application of CBS and CIA
Applying CBS (Comparable Better, Subtract):
Scenario: The Subject property has a 2-car garage. Comparable #1 sold for $350,000 and features a superior 3-car garage (contributory value: $10,000).
Adjustment: Because the comparable is better, we subtract $10,000 from Comp #1's sale price.
Adjusted Sale Price: $350,000 - $10,000 = $340,000.
Applying CIA (Comparable Inferior, Add):
Scenario: The Subject property has a luxury inground pool (contributory value: $25,000). Comparable #2 sold for $320,000 and has no pool.
Adjustment: Because the comparable is inferior, we add $25,000 to Comp #2's sale price.
Adjusted Sale Price: $320,000 + $25,000 = $345,000.
Loading diagram... Sales Comparison Approach Adjustment Logic Flowchart
3. Systematic Sequence and Elements of Adjustment
Appraisers apply adjustments in a standardized, sequential order. The first four adjustments are transactional adjustments (frequently applied as percentage adjustments in sequential compounding order), followed by property-specific physical adjustments :
Real Property Rights Conveyed: Adjusts for differences in legal estate (e.g., fee simple absolute vs. leasehold estate or life estate).
Financing Terms & Concessions: Adjusts for non-standard financing (e.g., creative seller financing with below-market interest rates, or seller-paid closing costs and rate buydowns that inflated the gross sales price).
Conditions of Sale: Adjusts for non-arm's-length motivations (e.g., estate liquidations, foreclosure sales, transactions between family members, or corporate relocations).
Market Conditions (Time / Appreciation Adjustment): Adjusts for changes in economic conditions, inflation, and market appreciation/depreciation between the historical contract date of the comparable and the effective date of the appraisal.
Location: Adjusts for micro-locational differences (e.g., cul-de-sac lot vs. busy four-lane arterial thoroughfare, golf course frontage, greenbelt views, proximity to commercial centers).
Physical Characteristics:
Gross Living Area (GLA): Finished, above-grade, heated and air-conditioned residential square footage.
Site / Lot Size: Differences in usable land area, topography, or frontage.
Room Count: Bedroom and bathroom differentials.
Age / Condition / Effective Age: Modernization, structural updates, and deferred maintenance.
Accessory Amenities: Swimming pools, covered patios, workshops, multi-car garages, fireplaces, and fencing.
- 4. Net Adjustments vs. Gross Adjustments and Reconciliation
- Net vs. Gross Adjustments
Underwriting standards established by mortgage institutions and appraisal organizations evaluate the quality and comparability of selected comps using two mathematical metrics:
Net Adjustment Percentage: The algebraic sum of positive and negative adjustments divided by the comparable's raw sales price.
Formula: Net Adjustment % = (Sum of + and - adjustments / Raw Sales Price) * 100
Standard guideline: Net adjustments should generally not exceed 15% of the comparable's sales price.
Gross Adjustment Percentage: The absolute total sum of all adjustments (treating all positive and negative numbers as positive values) divided by the comparable's raw sales price.
Formula: Gross Adjustment % = (Total Absolute Dollar Adjustments / Raw Sales Price) * 100
Standard guideline: Gross adjustments should generally not exceed 25% of the comparable's sales price (with single line-item adjustments typically under 10%).
The Final Reconciliation Process
After deriving the adjusted sales price for each comparable property, the appraiser must reconcile these figures into a single indicated market value for the subject property.
CRITICAL EXAM PRINCIPLE — NEVER AVERAGE THE COMPS! An appraiser MUST NEVER calculate a simple mathematical arithmetic average of the adjusted comparable prices (e.g., adding Comp 1, Comp 2, and Comp 3 and dividing by 3). Arithmetic averaging is an abdication of professional appraisal judgment because it assigns equal weight to poor comparables requiring massive adjustments and ideal comparables requiring minimal adjustments.
Proper Weighted Qualitative Reconciliation
The appraiser applies professional judgment by assigning the greatest weight to the comparable property that:
- Required the lowest gross and net dollar adjustments ;
- Required the fewest individual line-item modifications ;
- Is located in the closest geographic proximity within the same subdivision; and
Closed most recently in time relative to the appraisal date.
5. Comprehensive Worked Mathematical Adjustment Grid
To solidify the sales comparison mechanics, examine the complete appraisal adjustment grid below for a Texas residential subject property:
Subject Property Profile:
- Single-family home, 2,400 sq ft Gross Living Area (GLA)
- 3 Bedrooms, 2.5 Bathrooms, 2-Car Garage
- Has an Inground Swimming Pool
- Modern Condition, Standard Subdivision Lot
Market Contributory Values Established by Appraiser:
- GLA: $80 per square foot
- Full Bathroom: $10,000 | Half Bathroom: $5,000
- Inground Swimming Pool: $25,000
- 2-Car vs. 3-Car Garage: $12,000
- Market Appreciation (Time): +0.5% per month (+3% for 6 months ago)
- Sales Comparison Adjustment Grid Table
- Element of Comparison Subject Property Comparable #1 Comparable #2 Comparable #3
- Sale Price Benchmark $410,000 $440,000 $390,000
- Sale Date / Market Time Current 6 mos ago (+3%) +$12,300 1 mo ago (0%) $0 2 mos ago (0%) $0
- Location Suburban Lot Same Subdivision $0 Same Subdivision $0 Same Subdivision $0
Gross Living Area (GLA) 2,400 sq ft 2,200 sq ft (+$80/sf) +$16,000 2,600 sq ft (-$80/sf) -$16,000 2,400 sq ft (Equal) $0
Bedrooms / Bathrooms 3 Bed / 2.5 Bath 3 Bed / 2.0 Bath (+$5k) +$5,000 3 Bed / 2.5 Bath (Equal) $0 3 Bed / 2.0 Bath (+$5k) +$5,000
- Garage Capacity 2-Car Garage 2-Car Garage $0 3-Car Garage (-$12k) -$12,000 2-Car Garage $0
- Swimming Pool Has Pool No Pool (+$25k CIA) +$25,000 Has Pool (Equal) $0 No Pool (+$25k CIA) +$25,000
- Total Net Adjustment — +$58,300 (+14.2%) -$28,000 (-6.4%) +$30,000 (+7.7%)
- Total Gross Adjustment — $58,300 (14.2%) $28,000 (6.4%) $30,000 (7.7%)
- Adjusted Indicated Value — $468,300 $412,000 $420,000
Professional Reconciliation Analysis:
Comparable #1 ($468,300): Required massive net/gross adjustments (14.2%) across time, GLA, bath count, and pool. Least reliable.
Comparable #2 ($412,000): Required the lowest gross adjustment percentage (6.4%), closed very recently (1 month ago), and needed adjustments only for GLA and garage.
Comparable #3 ($420,000): Required low gross adjustments (7.7%), closed 2 months ago, and matches subject GLA perfectly.
Appraiser's Final Reconciled Value: By placing 60% weight on Comp #2 ($412,000) and 40% weight on Comp #3 ($420,000), the appraiser determines the indicated market value of the subject property is $415,000 .