Study guide
16.1 Consent & Confidentiality
MFDS Part 1 Membership of the Faculty of Dental Surgery
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
Current Exam Facts How to Use This Guide Eligibility, Booking & the MFDS Pathway
2 Basic Sciences, History Taking & Clinical Assessment
1.1 Head & Neck Anatomy and Underpinning Basic Sciences 1.2 History Taking, Communication & Clinical Examination 1.3 Special Tests, Investigations & Diagnostic Accuracy 1.4 Differential Diagnosis, Triage & When to Biopsy 1.5 Dental Anomalies & Developmental Conditions
3 Cariology, Operative Dentistry & Endodontics
2.1 Cariology & Caries Diagnosis 2.2 Caries Management & Prevention 2.3 Operative Dentistry & Cavity Preparation 2.4 Endodontics 2.5 Tooth Surface Loss & Tooth Discolouration
4 Periodontology & Prosthodontics
3.1 Periodontology 3.2 Fixed Prosthodontics 3.3 Removable Prosthodontics 3.4 Occlusion & Occlusal Assessment
5 Paediatric Dentistry, Orthodontics & Dental Trauma
4.1 Paediatric Dentistry 4.2 Orthodontics 4.3 Dental Trauma 4.4 Orthodontic Assessment, Indices & Referral 4.5 Impacted Teeth & Radiographic Localisation
6 Oral Surgery, Treatment Planning & Prevention
5.1 Oral Surgery & Extractions 5.2 Treatment Planning & Patient Management 5.3 Prevention & Health Promotion
7 Cardiovascular, Respiratory & Endocrine Disease
6.1 Cardiovascular Disease 6.2 Respiratory Disease 6.3 Endocrine Disease & Diabetes 6.4 Bleeding Disorders & Anticoagulation
8 Haematology, Infection & the Medically Compromised Patient
7.1 Haematology 7.2 Infectious Disease 7.3 The Medically Compromised Patient 7.4 Neurological & Gastrointestinal Disease
9 Medical Emergencies in Dental Practice
8.1 Medical Emergencies & Resuscitation 8.2 Anaphylaxis & Acute Allergy 8.3 Emergency Drugs & the Resuscitation Kit
10 Special Care Dentistry, Mental Health & Anxiety Management
9.1 Special Care Dentistry & Patients with Disability 9.2 Mental Health & Behavioural Science 9.3 Dental Anxiety & Behaviour Management
11 Oral Medicine — Mucosal Disease & Orofacial Pain
10.1 Oral Mucosal Disease & Lichen Planus 10.2 Vesiculobullous & Ulcerative Disorders 10.3 Candidiasis & Fungal Infections 10.4 Orofacial Pain & Neuropathic Disorders
12 Oral Pathology — Lesions, Cysts, Tumours & Salivary Glands
11.1 Premalignant Lesions & Oral Cancer 11.2 Odontogenic Cysts 11.3 Odontogenic & Non-Odontogenic Tumours 11.4 Salivary Gland Disease
13 Pharmacology — Local Anaesthesia, Analgesia & Sedation
12.1 Local Anaesthesia 12.2 Analgesics & NSAIDs 12.3 Conscious Sedation
14 Pharmacology — Antimicrobials, Prescribing & Drug Interactions
13.1 Antimicrobials & Antibiotic Stewardship 13.2 Prescribing & Drug Interactions
15 Dental Materials
14.1 Properties & Testing of Dental Materials 14.2 Amalgam & Metal Restorations 14.3 Composite Resin & Adhesive Dentistry 14.4 Impression Materials, Cements & Other Materials
16 Microbiology, Infection Control & Radiology
15.1 Oral Microbiology & Infection Control 15.2 Dental Radiology & Imaging 15.3 Radiation Protection
17 Law, Ethics, Professionalism & Evidence-Based Dentistry
16.1 Consent & Confidentiality 16.2 GDC Standards & Professionalism 16.3 Safeguarding & Duty of Candour 16.4 Evidence-Based Dentistry & Research Methods 16.5 Records, Information Governance & Regulation 16.6 Communication, Teamworking, Human Factors & Raising Concerns
18 Statistics, Dental Public Health, Critical Appraisal & Exam Strategy
17.1 Statistics & Critical Appraisal 17.2 Dental Public Health & Epidemiology 17.3 SBA Technique & Exam Strategy 17.4 Final Review & Key Points
16.1 Consent & Confidentiality
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Valid consent requires three elements: the patient has capacity, receives adequate information (including material risks), and gives consent voluntarily without coercion.
Adult capacity is presumed (Mental Capacity Act 2005); a person lacks capacity if, at the material time, they cannot understand, retain, use/weigh the information, or communicate their decision — and decisions are made in their best interests.
Consent for a child under 16 is assessed by Gillick competence (understanding the treatment); parental responsibility otherwise; 16–17-year-olds are presumed competent to consent, and refusal can be overridden in their best interests.
Confidentiality is a legal and ethical duty (GDC, GDPR/Data Protection Act 2018, common law); disclosure requires patient consent, a legal duty, or a public-interest justification (e.g. serious crime, risk to others).
Material risks must be disclosed — Montgomery (2015) shifted UK law to what a reasonable patient would want to know, not the Bolam professional-standard test, for the disclosure of risks.
Last updated: August 2026
Elements of Valid Consent
Valid consent requires:
Capacity — the patient can understand and decide.
Information — adequate explanation of the proposed treatment, alternatives, benefits, and material risks .
Voluntariness — the decision is made freely, without coercion or undue influence.
Consent may be written, verbal, or implied , but the form is not the consent — the process is. For significant interventions, written consent is best practice and provides evidence of the discussion.
The Consent Process
The discussion should cover:
The diagnosis and proposed treatment.
Alternative options , including no treatment.
Material risks (see Montgomery below).
The benefits and likely outcome.
Costs and what happens after treatment.
Consent should be taken by a clinician competent to perform the procedure, in advance, with time for the patient to reflect.
Capacity — the Mental Capacity Act 2005
A person aged 16 or over is presumed to have capacity unless shown otherwise. The Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA) (covering England and Wales) provides the framework.
Test for Lack of Capacity (Two-stage)
Diagnostic — an impairment of, or disturbance in, the functioning of the mind or brain.
Functional — because of that impairment, the person cannot, at the material time, do one or more of:
Understand the information.
Retain the information long enough to decide.
Use or weigh the information as part of deciding.
Communicate the decision (by any means).
If capacity is lacking, decisions are made in the patient's best interests — consulting those close to them, considering past wishes, and the least restrictive option. Capacity is decision-specific and time-specific: a person may have capacity for one decision but not another.
Principles of the MCA
Presume capacity unless shown otherwise.
Support a person to make their own decisions where possible.
A person can make an unwise decision and still have capacity.
Act in the best interests of those who lack capacity.
Use the least restrictive intervention.
Children and Consent
Age Rule
Under 16 Consent if Gillick competent — understands the treatment and its implications; otherwise consent from someone with parental responsibility
16–17 Presumed competent to consent (Family Law Reform Act 1969); a competent refusal can be overridden in their best interests
- 18 and over Full adult capacity (MCA)
- Gillick Competence
A child under 16 can consent to treatment if they demonstrate sufficient understanding and intelligence to appreciate the nature, purpose, and risks of the treatment — the Gillick test from Gillick v West Norfolk AHA (1985). If competent, they can consent independently of their parents; the Fraser guidelines apply specifically to contraceptive advice.
Parental Responsibility
Held by the mother automatically; the father if married to the mother, named on the birth certificate (post-2003), or by parental responsibility agreement/order. A person with parental responsibility can consent on behalf of a child who is not Gillick competent.
The Montgomery Standard of Risk Disclosure
UK law on risk disclosure changed with Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board (2015) .
Bolam (1957) — the test was what a responsible body of medical opinion would do (a professional standard).
Montgomery (2015) — the test is now what a reasonable patient in the patient's position would attach significance to: a doctor must take reasonable steps to ensure the patient is aware of material risks , and of reasonable alternatives.
A risk is material if a reasonable person in the patient's position would be likely to attach significance to it, or the clinician is/should be aware the particular patient would. This is a patient-centred, not professional-standard, test.
Applying Montgomery in Dentistry
Disclose common risks (pain, sensitivity, the need for further treatment) and serious risks (nerve injury in lower third molar surgery, sinus communication, the possibility of extraction needing surgical removal).
Individualise: a professional singer may attach greater significance to nerve injury.
Document the discussion and the risks explained.
Confidentiality
Confidentiality is owed at common law and under the GDPR / Data Protection Act 2018 , and is a GDC Standards duty. Patient information is shared on a need-to-know basis, only for the purpose for which it was given.
Maintaining Confidentiality
Discuss patient information only with those involved in care, and only what they need to know.
Store records securely; control access; avoid identifiable discussions in public areas.
Take care on the telephone and in correspondence.
Disclosing Without Consent
Disclosure without consent is justified only where:
- The patient has consented (or it is in their best interests if lacking capacity), or
- There is a legal requirement (court order, statute, notification of certain diseases), or
There is a public interest that outweighs the duty of confidence.
The Public-Interest Test
A disclosure in the public interest (e.g. a serious risk to others, a serious crime, a notifiable disease) is weighed against:
The seriousness of the harm risked by non-disclosure.
The likelihood of that harm.
The harm to the patient (and the trust relationship) from disclosure.
Where possible, seek the patient's consent first; disclose the minimum necessary to the right person; document the reasoning.
Caldicott Guardians and Information Governance
Every NHS organisation has a Caldicott Guardian responsible for protecting confidentiality of patient information and governing its use. Information governance training is mandatory for NHS staff and is examined at a knowledge level.