Study guide
We Analyse Critically (Level 1)
College of Policing National Sift Police Constable Online Assessment
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
About the College of Policing National Sift Eligibility, CVF Level 1, and What Is Assessed How to Use This Guide
2 Format, Scoring & Policies
SJT and BSQ Format Overview Practice Area, Platform, and 7-Day Window Scoring, Percentiles, and Results Resits, Reasonable Adjustments, and Appeals
3 CVF Framework & Values
CVF 2024 Overview and Code of Ethics Value: Courage Value: Respect and Empathy Value: Public Service
4 CVF Competencies I
We Are Emotionally Aware (Level 1) We Take Ownership (Level 1) We Collaborate (Level 1)
5 CVF Competencies II
We Support and Inspire (Level 1) We Analyse Critically (Level 1) We Are Innovative and Open-Minded (Level 1)
6 SJT Mechanics
SJT Structure and Timing The Five-Point Effectiveness Scale Independent Rating Rules
7 SJT Decision Strategy
Priorities, Consequences, and Who Is Affected Professionalism and the CVF Lens Common SJT Traps and Myths
8 Public-Facing Scenario Themes
Community Concerns and Anti-Social Behaviour Vulnerability and Safeguarding Mindset De-escalation, Fairness, and Public Service
9 Team & Ethics Scenario Themes
Colleague Performance and Ownership Scenarios Collaboration and Prioritisation Scenarios Ethics, Integrity, and Challenging Unprofessional Behaviour
10 BSQ & Integrated Prep
BSQ Format, Scale, and Ranking Honesty, Consistency, and Self-Profiling Study Plan and Next Steps After the Sift
We Analyse Critically (Level 1)
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
We analyse critically means using diverse information and the best available evidence to make effective decisions, considering perspectives and implications rather than jumping to conclusions.
Level 1 behaviours include gathering enough information when time allows, spotting patterns in facts, weighing options and outcomes, checking assumptions, and preferring evidence over rumour or bias.
On the SJT, rate higher actions that gather relevant information before heavy enforcement when no clear offence is established; rate lower actions based on incomplete info, ignored facts, or pure rumour.
Critical analysis is not endless paralysis: when action is clearly needed for safety or duty, effective options move with proportionate speed while still using available evidence.
Explaining reasoning clearly when appropriate is part of Level 1 analysis—opaque snap judgements without a defensible basis are weaker under this competency.
Last updated: August 2026
What “We Analyse Critically” Means (CVF 2024)
In CVF 2024 , we analyse critically means analysing diverse information and the best available evidence to make effective decisions . It includes considering different perspectives , understanding implications , avoiding jumping to conclusions , weighing risk and benefit , and using information carefully .
This competency is the opposite of two common failures:
Reckless certainty — acting on a gut feeling, stereotype, or partial story as if it were proven fact.
Paralysis — gathering information forever when a proportionate decision is already required for safety or duty.
Critical analysis is not academic essay writing. For a Level 1 practitioner, it is the habit of asking: What do I actually know? What am I assuming? What else should I check? What happens if I choose option A versus B?
Why This Competency Matters in Policing Recruitment
Policing decisions affect liberty, safety, trust, and fairness. Even at entry level, poor analysis can escalate a situation unnecessarily, miss a vulnerable person, or act on biased rumour. The national sift does not test criminal law knowledge, but it does test whether your judgement looks evidence-minded :
Do you seek relevant facts before heavy-handed action when the scenario allows?
Do you notice contradictions or missing information?
Do you consider more than one option and the likely outcomes?
Do you resist treating gossip as evidence?
A classic official-style pattern (for example community anti-social behaviour concerns) rewards information-gathering and proportionate enquiry before jumping straight to the most punitive or forceful option when no offence is clearly established in the scenario. That does not mean “never act.” It means match the strength of your action to the strength of your information and the risk present .
Level 1 Style Behaviours (Recognition Table)
Level 1 pattern What it looks like in practice
Gather enough information before acting When time and risk allow, ask clarifying questions, check records or witnesses available in the scenario, and confirm what is known
Identify patterns and problems from facts Connect what you have been told without inventing details the scenario never supplied
Consider different options and likely outcomes Weigh a low-intrusion option against a higher-impact option; think who is affected
Recognise and check assumptions Notice “they always…”, “people like that…”, or single-source claims and test them
Use evidence rather than rumour or bias Prefer observed facts, reliable accounts, and documented information over hearsay and stereotypes
Spot gaps and inconsistencies, and think about what they imply Notice where the account you have been given is incomplete or does not hang together, and consider the potential implications before acting on it
Apply professional knowledge and decision-making frameworks Use structured decision-making alongside your own experience and judgement, rather than relying on instinct alone
Keep clear and accurate records Write up what you did and why, accurately and promptly, so decisions can be evidenced later
Explain reasoning clearly when appropriate Be able to say why a course of action is proportionate and based on what is known
- Core Meaning Broken Down
- 1. Diverse information and best available evidence
“Best available” recognises that you rarely have perfect information. Critical analysis means using what you can reasonably obtain, not waiting for omniscience. It also means not cherry-picking only the facts that support your first impression.
On the SJT, if an action ignores key facts already stated in the scenario, rate it lower. If an action seeks missing information that would change the decision and the scenario does not show immediate danger requiring instant force, that information-seeking often rates higher.
2. Different perspectives and implications
A resident, a young person, a business owner, and a colleague may each hold part of the picture. Considering perspectives is not “everyone is equally right.” It is refusing to treat one loud voice as the whole truth . Implications include short-term calm versus long-term trust, escalation risk, and whether a vulnerable person is hidden in the noise.
3. Avoid jumping to conclusions
Jumping to conclusions often looks decisive and therefore “police-like” to unprepared candidates. Under CVF analysis, unsupported leaps are weak. Decisive and evidence-based is the goal.
4. Weigh risk and benefit
Critical analysis includes risk thinking: what is the harm of acting now, and what is the harm of delay? A high-risk scenario (clear immediate danger) justifies faster action with the information you have. A low-clarity, lower-imminent-harm scenario justifies more enquiry first.
5. Use information carefully
Careful use means accuracy, confidentiality where relevant, and not spreading unverified claims. It also means updating your view when new facts appear—stubbornness is not analysis.
- How This Competency Appears on the SJT
- Actions that often rate higher (analyse-critically aligned)
Asking relevant questions before choosing an intrusive option when no clear offence or imminent harm is established
- Checking facts already available (what was said, by whom, what was observed)
- Considering alternative explanations and proportionate options
- Pausing a rushed plan that rests on assumption or rumour
- Explaining a decision by reference to known information and risk
Seeking advice or specialist input when complexity exceeds your knowledge—while still owning the need to progress
- Actions that often rate lower (analysis failures)
- Acting on incomplete information when a short check was possible and risk did not forbid it
- Ignoring facts the scenario already gave you
- Treating rumour, stereotype, or a single unverified claim as proof
- Choosing the harshest option purely to “show authority” without an evidence basis
- Freezing indefinitely when the scenario shows clear need for timely action
- Inventing facts that are not in the scenario to justify a preferred option
- Official-style ASB / community concern pattern
Many candidates over-enforce. If the scenario describes community concern about behaviour but does not establish a clear offence or immediate danger, actions that:
- listen and gather information,
- engage proportionately,
- consider multi-agency or problem-solving angles where appropriate,
- avoid unnecessary criminalisation based on assumption,
often align better with critical analysis (and with public service and respect) than actions that jump straight to the most punitive response.
Conversely, if the scenario does show clear risk or a clear need to protect someone now, an action that only “makes notes for later” while harm continues is not good analysis—it is avoidance dressed up as thoughtfulness.
Balance Trap: Over-Analysis vs Recklessness
Hold both ends of the scale:
Trap How it shows up Better Level 1 pattern
Over-analysis / paralysis Endless checking while risk grows; refusing any decision Decide with best available evidence; review if new facts appear
Recklessness Instant heavy action on thin information Gather enough when possible; match force of response to evidence and risk
- Confirmation bias Only seeking facts that support first guess Actively consider alternative explanations
- Rumour as evidence “Someone said” becomes “we know” Verify before high-impact action
Critical analysis is a quality of decision-making, not a requirement to delay every decision forever.
Common Traps for Candidates
Equating speed with competence. Fast wrong decisions are not analytical excellence.
Equating delay with intelligence. Slow inaction under clear risk is not clever.
Importing TV policing. You do not need to “crack the case” with illegal shortcuts; you need proportionate, fact-based judgement.
Assuming the loudest complainant is always fully correct. Listen, but still check.
Assuming the complained-about person is always fully wrong. Same rule.
Writing law essays in your head. The sift is not testing statute recall; it is testing whether you use information given carefully.
- Mini Scenarios (Recognition Practice)
- Scenario A — Incomplete ASB report
A resident demands that “those youths” be arrested for anti-social behaviour. The scenario gives limited detail and no clear offence description.
Action idea Analyse-critically read
Immediately pursue the harshest enforcement option based only on the demand Lower — incomplete info, risk of unjustified heavy action
Gather more information: what happened, when, impact, witnesses, any vulnerability, what has already been tried Higher — evidence before high-impact action when situation allows
Refuse to engage at all because “not enough proof for court” and walk away without any enquiry Lower — ignores problem-solving and information role
- Invent a backstory that the youths “are always troublemakers” Lower — bias and assumptions
- Scenario B — Conflicting accounts
Two colleagues give different versions of an incident. You must decide a next step.
- Action idea Analyse-critically read
- Pick the account of the more senior or more popular person automatically Lower — status is not evidence
Note the differences, seek clarifying facts, and avoid locking a narrative too early Higher — check assumptions, use available information carefully
- Accuse one person of lying publicly with no further check Lower — jump to conclusion
- Scenario C — Clear immediate risk
The scenario indicates someone is at clear, immediate risk of harm.
- Action idea Analyse-critically read
- Spend a long time debating theories before any protective action Lower — paralysis when action is needed
Take proportionate protective steps with the information available, then continue to refine understanding Higher — best available evidence + risk weighing
Linking Analyse Critically to Values and Other Competencies
Public service: better analysis protects the right people in the right way.
Respect and empathy: checking facts reduces unfair treatment driven by stereotype.
Courage: sometimes analysis means admitting you do not know yet, or challenging a popular but unsupported plan.
We take ownership: analysis should lead to a decision you can own, not endless deferral for its own sake.
We are innovative and open-minded: good analysis often surfaces alternative options (see next section).
We are emotionally aware: strong emotion in yourself or others is data about impact—not a substitute for evidence.
Mental Model for Live SJT Rating
For each action, ask:
What facts does the scenario actually give?
What is still unknown , and does the action care?
Is the response proportionate to evidence and risk?
Does the action rely on rumour, bias, or assumption ?
If delay is involved, is it useful enquiry or avoidance ?
Rate higher where the action uses information carefully and weighs outcomes. Rate lower for fact-ignoring haste, rumour-based force, or freeze when protection is required.