Study guide
We Are Innovative and Open-Minded (Level 1)
College of Policing National Sift Police Constable Online Assessment
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction & Exam Overview
About the College of Policing National Sift Eligibility, CVF Level 1, and What Is Assessed How to Use This Guide
2 Format, Scoring & Policies
SJT and BSQ Format Overview Practice Area, Platform, and 7-Day Window Scoring, Percentiles, and Results Resits, Reasonable Adjustments, and Appeals
3 CVF Framework & Values
CVF 2024 Overview and Code of Ethics Value: Courage Value: Respect and Empathy Value: Public Service
4 CVF Competencies I
We Are Emotionally Aware (Level 1) We Take Ownership (Level 1) We Collaborate (Level 1)
5 CVF Competencies II
We Support and Inspire (Level 1) We Analyse Critically (Level 1) We Are Innovative and Open-Minded (Level 1)
6 SJT Mechanics
SJT Structure and Timing The Five-Point Effectiveness Scale Independent Rating Rules
7 SJT Decision Strategy
Priorities, Consequences, and Who Is Affected Professionalism and the CVF Lens Common SJT Traps and Myths
8 Public-Facing Scenario Themes
Community Concerns and Anti-Social Behaviour Vulnerability and Safeguarding Mindset De-escalation, Fairness, and Public Service
9 Team & Ethics Scenario Themes
Colleague Performance and Ownership Scenarios Collaboration and Prioritisation Scenarios Ethics, Integrity, and Challenging Unprofessional Behaviour
10 BSQ & Integrated Prep
BSQ Format, Scale, and Ranking Honesty, Consistency, and Self-Profiling Study Plan and Next Steps After the Sift
We Are Innovative and Open-Minded (Level 1)
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
We are innovative and open-minded means being open to new ideas and ways of working, questioning established habits when better options exist, and solving problems creatively within values, lawfulness, and proportionality.
Level 1 behaviours include welcoming feedback, suggesting practical improvements within role, learning from colleagues and communities, and adapting when the first approach is not working.
On the SJT, rate higher creative but proportionate community or workplace solutions; rate lower rigid “we’ve always done it this way” refusal or reckless novelty that ignores safety and professionalism.
Innovation is not rule-breaking for fun: better ways must still respect public safety, ethics, and professional boundaries.
Open-mindedness includes learning from partners and the public, not only from people who already agree with you.
Last updated: August 2026
What “We Are Innovative and Open-Minded” Means (CVF 2024)
In CVF 2024 , we are innovative and open-minded means being open to new ideas and ways of working , questioning established approaches when something better exists, using creative problem-solving within values , lawfulness , and proportionality , learning from others , and adapting when needed.
This competency is easy to caricature. It is not :
- ignoring rules because “innovation”
- chasing novelty for its own sake
- dismissing experience and procedure as “old thinking” without evidence
- redesigning national policy as a brand-new constable on day one
It is the professional habit of asking: Is there a better way to achieve a safe, fair, lawful outcome here? and being willing to try a proportionate alternative when the first approach stalls.
Why This Competency Matters on the National Sift
Communities, colleagues, and problems are not identical. Rigid scripts fail when:
- a standard approach is not reducing harm
- a community offers local knowledge you have not used
- a colleague’s idea would solve the problem more fairly or efficiently
- feedback shows your first plan is not working
The SJT often rewards candidates who can adapt , listen to alternatives , and problem-solve creatively without abandoning safety or professionalism. It penalises candidates who treat “how we always do it” as a moral absolute even when the scenario shows that approach is failing—or who invent reckless shortcuts dressed up as creativity.
On the BSQ, open-mindedness statements often touch feedback, learning, flexibility, and willingness to consider other views. Extreme claims (“I never like any existing process” / “I never change my mind”) both undermine credibility.
Level 1 Lens: Practical Creativity, Not Strategic Redesign
- Level 1 (sift-appropriate) Too high-level / off-target
- Suggest a practical improvement within your role Rewrite force strategy single-handedly
- Try a different lawful approach when the first fails Break rules to “get results”
- Learn from a community partner’s insight Dismiss partners as irrelevant
- Adapt after feedback Double down to protect ego
Innovation at Level 1 is usually local, practical, and reviewable —a better conversation plan, a different information source, a community-based solution, a small process improvement—not a fantasy reorganisation of policing.
Level 1 Style Behaviours (Recognition Table)
Level 1 pattern What it looks like in practice
Open to new approaches and feedback Listens when someone suggests another way; does not reject ideas only because they are unfamiliar
Suggest practical improvements within role Offers a realistic tweak that could improve service or teamwork
Learn from colleagues, communities, and partners Treats local knowledge and partner expertise as valuable information
Adapt when the initial approach is not working Changes plan based on evidence of failure, not pride
Reflect on experience and act on the learning Looks back on how different situations went and actually changes practice as a result, rather than repeating the same approach unexamined
Adapt flexibly to change, and help others do the same Adjusts willingly when the need arises and encourages colleagues through the change instead of resisting or complaining
Avoid rigid custom when evidence supports change Questions “we’ve always done it this way” if outcomes are poor
Balance innovation with public safety and professionalism Creativity stays lawful, proportionate, ethical, and safe
- Core Meaning Broken Down
- 1. Open to new ideas and ways of working
Open-mindedness starts with listening . On the SJT, an action that shuts down a reasonable alternative without consideration often rates lower. An action that gives a fair hearing to a new approach—and adopts it if it is better and safe—often rates higher.
Open-mindedness is not agreeing with everything. You can reject an unsafe idea after considering it, with reasons grounded in risk and professionalism.
2. Question established ways when better exists
Habit is efficient until it becomes harmful. Critical openness means distinguishing:
- Useful standard practice (consistent, fair, tested) from
- Empty custom (done only because it is familiar, even when it fails people)
If the scenario shows a standard approach is not working, clinging to it solely for tradition is weak under this competency.
3. Creative problem-solving within values and lawfulness
Creativity in policing is constrained by ethics and law. A clever idea that humiliates someone, discriminates, endangers the public, or corrupts evidence is not good innovation. The best SJT “creative” options usually expand the toolset for legitimate aims : engagement, prevention, partnership, communication, problem-solving—while staying proportionate.
4. Learn from others
Colleagues, partner agencies, and community members often hold pieces of the solution. Learning is a Level 1 strength, not a weakness. Actions that dismiss partners or the public as “not real work” often fail open-mindedness and collaboration / public service.
5. Adapt
Adaptation is the operational form of open-mindedness. When feedback, new facts, or failed attempts show the plan is not working, effective practitioners adjust. Stubborn repetition of a failed approach is not resilience; it is rigidity.
- How This Competency Appears on the SJT
- Actions that often rate higher (innovative and open-minded aligned)
- Trying a proportionate alternative when the first approach fails
- Considering a community-based or partnership solution where it fits the problem
- Welcoming a colleague’s constructive idea and testing whether it improves outcomes
- Adjusting communication style to reach a better result without abandoning standards
- Suggesting a practical improvement that stays within role and professional limits
- Learning from what similar situations taught the team
- Actions that often rate lower (rigidity or reckless novelty)
- Refusing to consider any option except “how we always do it,” despite evidence of failure
- Dismissing feedback automatically as criticism of you personally
- Ignoring community or partner insight that could solve the problem safely
- Inventing a reckless shortcut that ignores risk, dignity, or professionalism
- Changing everything randomly with no link to the problem (novelty without purpose)
- Mocking new ideas so nobody shares improvements again
- Balance: innovation vs ignoring safety
Trap Example Better pattern
Rigidity “We never speak to youth workers; that’s not policing.” Consider partnership if it could reduce harm lawfully
- Reckless novelty Skip safeguards “to try something fresh” Innovate inside safety and professional boundaries
- Ego lock Reject a good idea because it was not yours Adopt the better idea and share credit
Cosmetic change Change language only while ignoring the real problem Target the outcome that matters for the public
Common Traps for Candidates
Thinking innovation means rule-breaking. Unlawful or unprofessional “creativity” is counterproductive.
Thinking open-minded means agreeing with everyone. You can disagree after fair consideration.
Equating tradition with professionalism. Professionalism can include improving methods.
Equating change with chaos. Stable standards and adaptive methods can coexist.
Over-scoping. Level 1 is practical improvement, not pretending you are redesigning the whole service alone.
Ignoring analysis. Innovation without any fact base is guesswork; link this competency to we analyse critically .
- Mini Scenarios (Recognition Practice)
- Scenario A — Approach not working
Your first attempt to resolve a neighbourhood tension has not reduced complaints. A partner agency suggests a different engagement method that remains lawful and safe.
- Action idea Innovative / open-minded read
- Refuse because “we don’t work that way” with no consideration Lower — rigid custom
Consider the suggestion, weigh risks and benefits, try a proportionate alternative if it is sound Higher — open to new approaches within professionalism
- Adopt any idea instantly with no risk thought because “innovation” Lower — reckless novelty
- Scenario B — Colleague feedback
A colleague suggests your update to a member of the public was technically correct but hard to understand, and offers a clearer wording.
- Action idea Innovative / open-minded read
- Take offence and refuse to change anything Lower — closed to feedback
- Thank them, adapt the explanation, and keep the accurate professional content Higher — learn and adapt
Hand the entire conversation to them forever to avoid learning Mixed/low — avoids growth; may also fail ownership
Scenario C — Community idea
Residents propose a practical, low-risk idea that could reduce friction (for example better lighting discussion via partners, a mediated conversation, or a timed engagement plan). Nothing in the scenario makes the idea unlawful.
- Action idea Innovative / open-minded read
- Dismiss residents as “not experts” without listening Lower — closed; weak public service
Listen, evaluate, and support or progress appropriate elements through proper channels Higher — learn from community; creative problem-solving
Promise outcomes you cannot control just to sound innovative Lower — fails honesty/courage even if creative-sounding
Linking Innovation to Values and Other Competencies
Public service: the purpose of new approaches is better outcomes for communities, not personal cleverness.
Respect and empathy: open-mindedness includes taking seriously people who experience the problem differently.
Courage: sometimes the open-minded option is unpopular with peers who prefer the old habit.
We analyse critically: innovation should be evidence-informed; analyse whether the new way is actually better.
We collaborate: many innovations are co-produced with partners and colleagues.
We support and inspire: welcoming ideas builds a climate where people contribute.
We take ownership: if you try a new approach, you still own the outcome and any need to correct course.
All Six Competencies: Closing the Level 1 Map
With this chapter, you now have the second trio of competencies that complete the SJT map:
- Competency Level 1 essence for sift rating
- We support and inspire Climate, encouragement, modelling standards, help without takeover
- We analyse critically Evidence, assumptions checked, options weighed, risk-aware decisions
- We are innovative and open-minded Practical alternatives, learning, adaptiveness, safe creativity
Together with emotionally aware , take ownership , and collaborate (previous chapter), these six Level 1 competencies are what the national sift SJT assesses. You do not need to label each live scenario with a competency name—but fluency in what good looks like is how you rate actions consistently.
Mental Model for Live SJT Rating
For each action, ask:
Does this show openness to a better way, or locked habit?
Is any new idea proportionate, lawful, and safe ?
Does it learn from colleagues, partners, or communities?
If the first plan failed, does the action adapt ?
Is “creativity” solving the real problem—or just looking different?
Rate higher for constructive, safe flexibility. Rate lower for rigid refusal to consider options or reckless novelty that ignores public safety and professionalism.