Study guide
11.2 Precedent and Case Law
Solicitors Qualifying Examination Part 1 SQE1
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction and Exam Overview
1.1 Current SQE1 Exam Facts 1.2 Single Best Answer Technique and Assessment Day 1.3 Qualifying as a Solicitor After SQE1
2 Ethics and Professional Conduct
2.1 The SRA Principles 2.2 Code of Conduct: Clients, Confidentiality and Disclosure 2.3 Conflicts, Undertakings and Duties to the Court 2.4 Firms, Managers and Compliance Officers 2.5 SRA Warning Notices: NDAs and SLAPPs
3 Business Organisations and Finance
3.1 Business Organisations, Personality and Limited Liability 3.2 Incorporation, Constitutions and Companies House 3.3 Financing: Debt, Equity, Security and Distributions 3.4 Partnership Decision-Making and Authority
4 Business Governance, Insolvency and Tax
4.1 Directors' Duties and Powers 4.2 Shareholders, Meetings, Filings and Minority Protection 4.3 Insolvency: Options and Procedures 4.4 Claw-Back of Assets and Order of Priority 4.5 Income Tax for Businesses 4.6 Capital Gains Tax for Businesses 4.7 Corporation Tax 4.8 VAT and Business Property Relief
5 Starting and Pleading a Civil Claim
5.1 Choosing Arbitration, Mediation or Litigation 5.2 Limitation, Pre-Action Conduct and Applicable Law 5.3 Where to Start, Issue and Service 5.4 Responding to a Claim and Statements of Case
6 Case Management, Trial, Costs and Enforcement
6.1 Interim Applications 6.2 Case Management, Sanctions and CCMCs 6.3 Evidence, Disclosure and Privilege 6.4 Trial and Costs Management 6.5 Part 36, Security for Costs and Assessed Costs 6.6 Appeals and Enforcement of Money Judgments
7 Contract Formation, Parties and Terms
7.1 Formation of Contract 7.2 Parties, Privity and Third-Party Rights 7.3 Express Terms, Incorporation, Implication and Variation 7.4 Exemption Clauses, Unfair Terms, Classification and Interpretation
8 Vitiating Factors, Termination and Remedies
8.1 Vitiating Factors 8.2 Termination of Contract 8.3 Remedies, Causation and Remoteness
9 Negligence, Defences and Vicarious Liability
9.1 Duty of Care and Breach 9.2 Causation, Remoteness and Personal Injury Remedies 9.3 Economic Loss, Psychiatric Harm and Employers' Primary Liability 9.4 Defences and Vicarious Liability
10 Occupiers, Products, Nuisance and Rylands
10.1 Occupiers' Liability 10.2 Product Liability 10.3 Nuisance and Rylands v Fletcher
11 Courts, Precedent and Legislation
11.1 Courts, Judicial Function and Rights of Audience 11.2 Precedent and Case Law 11.3 Primary Legislation in England and in Wales 11.4 Statutory Interpretation
12 Constitution, Judicial Review, Human Rights and EU Law
12.1 Constitutional Institutions, Devolution and the Rule of Law 12.2 Judicial Review and Public Order 12.3 Human Rights Act 1998 and EU Law in the UK Constitution
13 Legal Services Regulation, Equality and AML
13.1 SRA Regulation, Reserved Activities and PII 13.2 Equality Act 2010 in Legal Services 13.3 Money Laundering: Purpose, Scope and Reporting 13.4 POCA Offences, Defences and Due Diligence
14 Financial Services and Funding Legal Services
14.1 The FSMA Perimeter and Authorisation 14.2 Section 327, Scope Rules and Insurance Distribution 14.3 Retainers, Fixed Fees, CFAs and DBAs 14.4 Civil Legal Aid, Third-Party Funding and Insurance
15 Freehold Conveyancing Practice
15.1 Investigating Freehold Title 15.2 Pre-Contract Searches and Enquiries 15.3 Finance and Acting for a Lender 15.4 Drafting the Contract and Exchange 15.5 Completion, Post-Completion and Delay Remedies
16 Leasehold Practice, Security of Tenure, Planning and Property Tax
16.1 Lease Structure and Granting a Lease 16.2 Assignment, Covenants and Remedies 16.3 Business Security of Tenure (Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 Part II) 16.4 Planning Law and Property Taxation
17 Land: Estates, Title and Co-ownership
17.1 The Nature of Land, Estates and Interests 17.2 Acquiring, Transferring and Protecting Interests in Land 17.3 Registered and Unregistered Title 17.4 Co-ownership and Trusts of Land
18 Easements, Covenants, Mortgages and Leases
18.1 Easements 18.2 Freehold Covenants 18.3 Mortgages 18.4 Leases and Licences 18.5 Passing and Enforcing Leasehold Covenants
19 Wills, Revocation and Intestacy
19.1 Validity of Wills and Codicils 19.2 Executors, Alterations, Revocation and Interpretation 19.3 Intestacy and Property Passing Outside the Estate
20 Grants, Administration of Estates and Inheritance Tax
20.1 Grants of Representation and Order of Priority 20.2 Valuation, Excepted Estates and the Burden of IHT 20.3 Administration of Estates 20.4 Family Provision Claims under the 1975 Act 20.5 Inheritance Tax: Lifetime Transfers, Death and Reliefs 20.6 Income Tax and CGT During Administration
21 Express Trusts, Resulting Trusts and the Family Home
21.1 Express Trusts: Certainties, Formalities and Constitution 21.2 Beneficial Entitlement and Purpose Trusts 21.3 Resulting Trusts and Trusts of the Family Home
22 Fiduciaries, Trustees and Breach of Trust
22.1 Fiduciary Obligations and Liability of Strangers 22.2 Trustees: Appointment, Retirement and Removal 22.3 Trustees' Duties: Care, Investment and Advancement 22.4 Breach of Trust, Tracing and Equitable Remedies
23 Solicitors' Accounts
23.1 Client Money and the Client Account 23.2 Interest, Breaches and Corrections 23.3 Ledgers, Bills, Third-Party Accounts and Reports
24 Criminal Liability: Offences Against the Person and Defences
24.1 Actus Reus, Mens Rea, Parties and Attempts 24.2 Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person 24.3 Homicide and Partial Defences 24.4 General Defences
25 Theft, Criminal Damage and Fraud
25.1 Theft, Robbery and Burglary 25.2 Criminal Damage 25.3 Fraud
26 Police Station, Bail and Allocation
26.1 Advising at the Police Station 26.2 Bail and First Hearings 26.3 Plea Before Venue, Allocation, Case Management and Disclosure
27 Evidence, Trial, Sentencing, Appeals and Youth Court
27.1 Burden of Proof, Identification and Silence 27.2 Hearsay, Confessions, Bad Character and Exclusion 27.3 Trial Procedure in the Magistrates' Court and Crown Court 27.4 Sentencing 27.5 Appeals in Criminal Practice 27.6 Youth Court Procedure and the Welsh Language
11.2 Precedent and Case Law
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Stare decisis requires later courts to follow the ratio decidendi of a binding earlier decision on like material facts.
The UK Supreme Court binds all lower courts in England and Wales and is not bound by its own previous decisions, though it departs only with caution (Practice Statement 1966).
The Court of Appeal (Civil Division) is bound by its own decisions subject to the three Young v Bristol Aeroplane exceptions, including per incuriam.
High Court first-instance decisions bind the county court and magistrates' courts but do not bind other High Court judges, though they are strongly persuasive.
Obiter dicta, Privy Council decisions and first-instance judgments may persuade; they do not bind unless a recognised exception such as a UKSC direction in Willers v Joyce applies.
Last updated: September 2026
A solicitor who cannot handle precedent cannot give a reliable advice. FLK1 will not ask you to recite Latin for its own sake. It will give you a short run of authorities and ask whether a later court must follow an earlier one, may distinguish it, or may treat it as merely persuasive. This ExamFinch section is independent teaching of that doctrine for the courts of England and Wales. The same doctrine applies in Cardiff as in Leeds, because Wales is not a separate legal jurisdiction. A Senedd statute may change the statutory rule a court applies; it does not create a Welsh system of stare decisis.
Stare decisis and the judicial function
Stare decisis (stand by things decided) is how the judicial function stays consistent. Like cases are decided alike. Parties can order their affairs. Lower courts are constrained. The doctrine is the practical partner of the point in section 11.1: judges develop the common law only incrementally. They do not hold a general mandate to redesign the law each Monday morning.
Two ideas do the work:
Ratio decidendi — the legal proposition that was necessary for the court's decision on the material facts . That proposition is the binding rule.
Obiter dicta — other statements of law, including hypothetical remarks, illustrations, and discussion not necessary to the result. Obiter may be highly persuasive, especially from the Supreme Court, but it is not binding.
Finding the ratio in practice
Work through four questions:
What facts did the court treat as material (the facts without which the result would have been different)?
What was the issue of law?
What did the court decide on that issue?
What reason was necessary to that decision?
Discard facts that the court itself treated as irrelevant. A later advocate who wants to distinguish will argue that a fact in the later case is material and was not present in the earlier one, so the ratio does not apply.
Split courts. In an appellate court with several judgments, the ratio is found in the majority . A concurring judgment may reach the same result for a different reason; that different reason is not automatically the ratio. A dissent is not the ratio, though a later higher court may adopt it when overruling. Do not treat a law reporter's headnote as the binding text. The judgment is the source; the headnote is a finding aid and can be wrong.
Which courts bind which
Vertical stare decisis follows status in the hierarchy. A court is bound by the ratio of a superior court in England and Wales on the same material facts. It is not bound by an inferior court.
Court that decided the earlier case Binds Does not bind
UK Supreme Court (and former House of Lords) Court of Appeal, High Court, Crown Court, county court, Family Court, magistrates' courts, and tribunals applying the law of England and Wales Itself (see the Practice Statement, below)
Court of Appeal High Court, Crown Court, county court, Family Court, magistrates' courts, and most tribunals on the point The Supreme Court
High Court (including a Divisional Court, with extra weight) County court and magistrates' courts Other High Court judges sitting at first instance (persuasive only); the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court
Crown Court, county court, magistrates' court, First-tier Tribunal Nobody as binding precedent May persuade, especially a fully reasoned Circuit judge or Upper Tribunal decision
Horizontal stare decisis is the question whether a court is bound by itself .
Supreme Court. It is not bound by its own previous decisions. The House of Lords announced that position in the Practice Statement (Judicial Precedent) [1966] 1 WLR 1234, departing from London Street Tramways Co Ltd v London County Council [1898] AC 375. The Supreme Court continues that approach. Departure is exceptional. Certainty matters acutely in criminal law, property and contract. When the court does depart, the new ratio is the law and, in the ordinary way, it is treated as always having been the law (retrospective in the declaratory sense), unless a rare prospective technique is used.
Court of Appeal (Civil Division). It is bound by its own previous decisions, subject to the three exceptions in Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718:
Conflicting Court of Appeal decisions — the later court must choose which to follow.
Cannot stand with a later decision of the House of Lords or Supreme Court — the appellate decision that conflicted with the higher court is not followed.
Per incuriam — the earlier Court of Appeal decision was given in ignorance or forgetfulness of a statute or a binding authority , and that omission led to faulty reasoning. Morelle Ltd v Wakeling [1955] 2 QB 379 is the usual citation for the tightness of this idea.
Davis v Johnson [1979] AC 264 is the warning against inventing a fourth exception for 'the earlier case is clearly wrong'. The Civil Division cannot give itself a general power to overrule itself because it regrets a previous result.
Court of Appeal (Criminal Division). Precedent is slightly more flexible where a previous decision is wrong and a defendant would otherwise suffer injustice. The liberty interest is the reason. Do not import that flexibility wholesale into civil work.
High Court. A judge sitting at first instance is not bound by another first-instance High Court decision but should follow it unless convinced it is wrong. If two first-instance decisions conflict, later or more fully reasoned authority is usually preferred. A Divisional Court has greater weight than a single judge. The High Court is bound by the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court.
Overruling, reversing, distinguishing, disapproving
These verbs are not interchangeable.
Technique What happens Typical actor
Overruling A later case declares that an earlier rule was wrong. The earlier case ceases to be good law on that ratio A court not bound by the earlier decision (usually a higher court, or the Supreme Court departing from itself)
Reversing The result in the same litigation is changed by a court higher in that case The higher court dealing with that dispute
Distinguishing The later court accepts the earlier ratio but holds that the material facts differ, so the ratio does not apply Any later court
Disapproving The later court doubts the earlier reasoning but cannot overrule it A court that is bound, or a court of coordinate jurisdiction
Reversing is vocabulary about the fate of one case. It is not an invitation to map permission applications or routes; those sit outside this chapter. For FLK1 legal system, you need the effect on the body of case law : overruled means the old ratio is gone; distinguished means the old ratio survives for its own facts.
Per incuriam is not a synonym for 'I disagree'. It is a narrow defect: a relevant statute or binding case was not considered. A decision that considered the authority and got it wrong is not per incuriam merely because a later advocate has a better argument.
Persuasive authority
Not every citation binds. The following are persuasive in the courts of England and Wales unless a specific rule says otherwise:
- obiter dicta, including considered Supreme Court obiter, which later courts treat with great respect;
- first-instance decisions when you are in the High Court or above;
- decisions of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council ;
- Scottish and Northern Irish decisions on shared common-law ideas;
- well-reasoned Commonwealth decisions;
textbooks and articles (never binding; sometimes cited as a convenient statement of principle).
Privy Council after Willers v Joyce . In Willers v Joyce [2016] UKSC 43 and [2016] UKSC 44 the Supreme Court confirmed that a Privy Council decision is not binding in England and Wales. However, if the Board says what English law is, a court in England and Wales should follow that view unless bound by a conflicting decision of the Court of Appeal or Supreme Court. The Supreme Court can also direct that a particular Privy Council decision is to be treated as if it were a decision of the Supreme Court. Until that direction is given, do not tell a client that a JCPC case 'binds the High Court'.
Decisions from other jurisdictions of the United Kingdom can persuade on common-law questions. They do not bind, because Scotland and Northern Ireland are separate legal jurisdictions. Welsh law does not create a third common-law system; it is statute applied by the same courts under the same doctrine of precedent.
Law reports and neutral citations
A competent solicitor cites an authoritative report where one exists. The Incorporated Council of Law Reporting Law Reports (Appeal Cases, King's Bench, Chancery, Family) remain the preferred series in court. The Weekly Law Reports and All England Law Reports are widely used. Unreported transcripts are a last resort when no report exists.
Neutral citations have been used since 2001. They identify the court and the case number independently of any commercial series:
- Court Example
- UK Supreme Court [2026] UKSC 10
- Court of Appeal (Civil) [2026] EWCA Civ 50
- Court of Appeal (Criminal) [2026] EWCA Crim 12
- High Court, King's Bench [2026] EWHC 100 (KB)
- High Court, Chancery [2026] EWHC 100 (Ch)
- High Court, Family [2026] EWHC 100 (Fam)
- High Court, Administrative Court [2026] EWHC 100 (Admin)
When a case is reported, cite the neutral citation and the law report: Pepper v Hart [1993] AC 593 is a House of Lords decision from before neutral citations. A 2026 Supreme Court case should carry both the neutral citation and, when available, the Appeal Cases reference.
Original precedent and the declaratory theory
Sometimes no binding ratio covers the point. The court then creates original precedent . Older theory said judges only declare what the common law has always been. Modern candour accepts that judges make law in the gaps, still constrained by statute, by higher courts, and by the need to justify the step from existing principle. That is why Duport Steels and stare decisis are taught together: the judicial function includes modest law-making, not legislative redesign.
Worked advice pattern
A client in Newport asks whether a 2018 Court of Appeal civil decision still governs a 2026 dispute. Method:
State the material facts of the 2018 case and extract the ratio.
Compare those facts with the client's facts. If a material fact differs, consider distinguishing.
Search for a later Supreme Court decision that overrules or makes the 2018 case impossible to stand with ( Young exception 2).
Check whether the 2018 court missed a statute or a House of Lords/UKSC case ( Young exception 3).
If the 2018 ratio still stands and the facts match, advise that the county court and the High Court are bound. Do not tell the client that the Court of Appeal can simply ignore the 2018 case because it now seems inconvenient ( Davis v Johnson ).
If the dispute is governed by a Senedd Act passed after 2018, start with the statute. Precedent interprets the statute; it does not repeal it.
FLK1 traps for this section
Treating every sentence in a judgment as ratio.
Telling a High Court judge they are bound by another first-instance High Court decision.
Treating the Court of Appeal as free to overrule itself whenever it thinks a previous civil case was wrong.
Citing the Privy Council as automatically binding in the Administrative Court.
Using a county court judgment as if it bound the Court of Appeal.
Ignoring a later statute that has overtaken the case law.