Study guide

9.4 Defences and Vicarious Liability

Solicitors Qualifying Examination Part 1 SQE1

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction and Exam Overview

1.1 Current SQE1 Exam Facts 1.2 Single Best Answer Technique and Assessment Day 1.3 Qualifying as a Solicitor After SQE1

2 Ethics and Professional Conduct

2.1 The SRA Principles 2.2 Code of Conduct: Clients, Confidentiality and Disclosure 2.3 Conflicts, Undertakings and Duties to the Court 2.4 Firms, Managers and Compliance Officers 2.5 SRA Warning Notices: NDAs and SLAPPs

3 Business Organisations and Finance

3.1 Business Organisations, Personality and Limited Liability 3.2 Incorporation, Constitutions and Companies House 3.3 Financing: Debt, Equity, Security and Distributions 3.4 Partnership Decision-Making and Authority

4 Business Governance, Insolvency and Tax

4.1 Directors' Duties and Powers 4.2 Shareholders, Meetings, Filings and Minority Protection 4.3 Insolvency: Options and Procedures 4.4 Claw-Back of Assets and Order of Priority 4.5 Income Tax for Businesses 4.6 Capital Gains Tax for Businesses 4.7 Corporation Tax 4.8 VAT and Business Property Relief

5 Starting and Pleading a Civil Claim

5.1 Choosing Arbitration, Mediation or Litigation 5.2 Limitation, Pre-Action Conduct and Applicable Law 5.3 Where to Start, Issue and Service 5.4 Responding to a Claim and Statements of Case

6 Case Management, Trial, Costs and Enforcement

6.1 Interim Applications 6.2 Case Management, Sanctions and CCMCs 6.3 Evidence, Disclosure and Privilege 6.4 Trial and Costs Management 6.5 Part 36, Security for Costs and Assessed Costs 6.6 Appeals and Enforcement of Money Judgments

7 Contract Formation, Parties and Terms

7.1 Formation of Contract 7.2 Parties, Privity and Third-Party Rights 7.3 Express Terms, Incorporation, Implication and Variation 7.4 Exemption Clauses, Unfair Terms, Classification and Interpretation

8 Vitiating Factors, Termination and Remedies

8.1 Vitiating Factors 8.2 Termination of Contract 8.3 Remedies, Causation and Remoteness

9 Negligence, Defences and Vicarious Liability

9.1 Duty of Care and Breach 9.2 Causation, Remoteness and Personal Injury Remedies 9.3 Economic Loss, Psychiatric Harm and Employers' Primary Liability 9.4 Defences and Vicarious Liability

10 Occupiers, Products, Nuisance and Rylands

10.1 Occupiers' Liability 10.2 Product Liability 10.3 Nuisance and Rylands v Fletcher

11 Courts, Precedent and Legislation

11.1 Courts, Judicial Function and Rights of Audience 11.2 Precedent and Case Law 11.3 Primary Legislation in England and in Wales 11.4 Statutory Interpretation

12 Constitution, Judicial Review, Human Rights and EU Law

12.1 Constitutional Institutions, Devolution and the Rule of Law 12.2 Judicial Review and Public Order 12.3 Human Rights Act 1998 and EU Law in the UK Constitution

13 Legal Services Regulation, Equality and AML

13.1 SRA Regulation, Reserved Activities and PII 13.2 Equality Act 2010 in Legal Services 13.3 Money Laundering: Purpose, Scope and Reporting 13.4 POCA Offences, Defences and Due Diligence

14 Financial Services and Funding Legal Services

14.1 The FSMA Perimeter and Authorisation 14.2 Section 327, Scope Rules and Insurance Distribution 14.3 Retainers, Fixed Fees, CFAs and DBAs 14.4 Civil Legal Aid, Third-Party Funding and Insurance

15 Freehold Conveyancing Practice

15.1 Investigating Freehold Title 15.2 Pre-Contract Searches and Enquiries 15.3 Finance and Acting for a Lender 15.4 Drafting the Contract and Exchange 15.5 Completion, Post-Completion and Delay Remedies

16 Leasehold Practice, Security of Tenure, Planning and Property Tax

16.1 Lease Structure and Granting a Lease 16.2 Assignment, Covenants and Remedies 16.3 Business Security of Tenure (Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 Part II) 16.4 Planning Law and Property Taxation

17 Land: Estates, Title and Co-ownership

17.1 The Nature of Land, Estates and Interests 17.2 Acquiring, Transferring and Protecting Interests in Land 17.3 Registered and Unregistered Title 17.4 Co-ownership and Trusts of Land

18 Easements, Covenants, Mortgages and Leases

18.1 Easements 18.2 Freehold Covenants 18.3 Mortgages 18.4 Leases and Licences 18.5 Passing and Enforcing Leasehold Covenants

19 Wills, Revocation and Intestacy

19.1 Validity of Wills and Codicils 19.2 Executors, Alterations, Revocation and Interpretation 19.3 Intestacy and Property Passing Outside the Estate

20 Grants, Administration of Estates and Inheritance Tax

20.1 Grants of Representation and Order of Priority 20.2 Valuation, Excepted Estates and the Burden of IHT 20.3 Administration of Estates 20.4 Family Provision Claims under the 1975 Act 20.5 Inheritance Tax: Lifetime Transfers, Death and Reliefs 20.6 Income Tax and CGT During Administration

21 Express Trusts, Resulting Trusts and the Family Home

21.1 Express Trusts: Certainties, Formalities and Constitution 21.2 Beneficial Entitlement and Purpose Trusts 21.3 Resulting Trusts and Trusts of the Family Home

22 Fiduciaries, Trustees and Breach of Trust

22.1 Fiduciary Obligations and Liability of Strangers 22.2 Trustees: Appointment, Retirement and Removal 22.3 Trustees' Duties: Care, Investment and Advancement 22.4 Breach of Trust, Tracing and Equitable Remedies

23 Solicitors' Accounts

23.1 Client Money and the Client Account 23.2 Interest, Breaches and Corrections 23.3 Ledgers, Bills, Third-Party Accounts and Reports

24 Criminal Liability: Offences Against the Person and Defences

24.1 Actus Reus, Mens Rea, Parties and Attempts 24.2 Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person 24.3 Homicide and Partial Defences 24.4 General Defences

25 Theft, Criminal Damage and Fraud

25.1 Theft, Robbery and Burglary 25.2 Criminal Damage 25.3 Fraud

26 Police Station, Bail and Allocation

26.1 Advising at the Police Station 26.2 Bail and First Hearings 26.3 Plea Before Venue, Allocation, Case Management and Disclosure

27 Evidence, Trial, Sentencing, Appeals and Youth Court

27.1 Burden of Proof, Identification and Silence 27.2 Hearsay, Confessions, Bad Character and Exclusion 27.3 Trial Procedure in the Magistrates' Court and Crown Court 27.4 Sentencing 27.5 Appeals in Criminal Practice 27.6 Youth Court Procedure and the Welsh Language

9.4 Defences and Vicarious Liability

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Volenti is a complete defence requiring free agreement to the legal risk; knowledge of danger is not enough, and Road Traffic Act 1988 section 149 blocks it against many vehicle passengers.

Contributory negligence under the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945 is a just-and-equitable reduction; Froom v Butcher still supplies 25%/15% seat-belt figures; 100% is not available.

Illegality is approached through the Patel v Mirza trio; Henderson v Dorset Healthcare bars losses that flow from a criminal conviction or sentence.

Vicarious liability has two stages: a relationship of employment or akin to employment, then a close connection with authorised activities (Barclays; Morrisons; Christian Brothers).

A person in business on their own account is not akin to an employee (Barclays); a personal vendetta that merely uses workplace opportunity is not in the course of employment (Morrisons).

Last updated: September 2026

Once the claimant has a complete negligence (or other tort) case, the defendant may still reduce or defeat it. FLK1 lists three defences — volenti non fit injuria , contributory negligence , and illegality — and then principles of vicarious liability . Vicarious liability is not a defence; it is a route to a solvent defendant. Keep the two-stage UK Supreme Court analysis. Do not revive tests the Supreme Court has confined.

Volenti non fit injuria

Volenti is a complete defence: no injury is done to one who consents. The defendant must show that the claimant had full knowledge of the nature and extent of the risk and freely agreed to accept that legal risk, not merely that they knew the activity was dangerous.

Knowledge is not consent. An employee who continues to work with a known dangerous machine has not necessarily agreed to waive the employer's duty ( Smith v Baker & Sons [1891] AC 325). Volenti rarely succeeds against employees. It can succeed where the claimant embraces an obvious extreme risk: flying with a drunken pilot after drinking together ( Morris v Murray [1991] 2 QB 6). Drunken passengers in cars are more often dealt with by contributory negligence than by volenti.

Section 149 of the Road Traffic Act 1988 blocks volenti (and certain exclusion notices) in relation to passengers in vehicles that must be insured. On exam facts involving a passenger in a car, do not let volenti wipe out the claim. Rescuers who reasonably intervene are not treated as volunteers to the danger created by the defendant ( Haynes v Harwood [1935] 1 KB 146). Sporting participants accept the inherent risks of the game played according to the rules, not a reckless assault dressed up as play. ICI Ltd v Shatwell [1965] AC 656 is the rare employment success: shot-firers ignored express instructions and statutory rules; they had truly consented.

Contributory negligence

The Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945 , section 1, allows the court to reduce damages to such extent as it thinks just and equitable having regard to the claimant's share in the responsibility. It is a partial defence. Pitts v Hunt [1991] 1 QB 24 confirms that a finding of 100% contributory negligence is not available: that would be a complete defence by another name, and the 1945 Act presupposes fault on both sides.

Froom v Butcher [1976] QB 286 still supplies the working figures for seat belts in England and Wales: 25% if wearing a belt would have prevented the injury entirely; 15% if it would have reduced the injury; nil if it would have made no difference. Similar structured reasoning is used for cycle helmets, though the percentages are not a separate statute. Children are judged by the standard of a reasonable child of their age ( Gough v Thorne [1966] 1 WLR 1387). A very young child may bear no reduction. Failure to mitigate is related but distinct: it concerns unreasonable conduct after injury, not fault in the accident itself.

Illegality (ex turpi causa)

A claim may fail if allowing it would be inconsistent with the integrity of the legal system. Patel v Mirza [2016] UKSC 42 (a restitution case) replaced a rigid reliance test with a trio of considerations : the underlying purpose of the prohibition that was transgressed, any other relevant public policies, and whether denying the claim would be a proportionate response.

In tort, Henderson v Dorset Healthcare University NHS Foundation Trust [2020] UKSC 43 is the functioning illustration. A claimant who, during a psychotic episode, killed her mother and was convicted of manslaughter on the ground of diminished responsibility could not recover losses that flowed from the sentence and the conviction . The court applied Patel but also the consistency principle associated with Gray v Thames Trains Ltd [2009] UKHL 33. By contrast, Stoffel & Co v Grondona [2020] UKSC 42 allowed a conveyancing-negligence claim to proceed despite an unlawful mortgage background: the illegality was not a proportionate reason to strip the client of a remedy against a negligent solicitor.

Pitts v Hunt also shows two drunken motorcyclists on a joyride: the passenger's claim failed for illegality as well as running into the 100% contributory-negligence limit. On SQE1, ask whether the loss claimed is the product of the crime (sentence, confiscation, the inability to rely on one's own serious offending) or merely a background that is not central to the measure of loss.

  • Defence Effect Frequent FLK1 limit
  • Volenti Complete Rare in employment; blocked for many vehicle passengers by RTA 1988 s.149
  • Contributory negligence Partial reduction Cannot be 100%; Froom guidelines for seat belts
  • Illegality Complete if it applies Patel trio; Henderson bars losses flowing from conviction or sentence
  • Vicarious liability: two stages, current UKSC law

Vicarious liability makes D pay for a tort committed by X. D need not be at fault. Two stages must both be satisfied ( Various Claimants v Barclays Bank plc [2020] UKSC 13; WM Morrison Supermarkets plc v Various Claimants [2020] UKSC 12; the relationship-plus-connection structure is restated in later UKSC authority including X v Lord Advocate ).

Stage 1 — relationship. Historically this was employment . It now includes a relationship akin to employment ( Various Claimants v Catholic Child Welfare Society (the Christian Brothers case) [2012] UKSC 56; Cox v Ministry of Justice [2016] UKSC 10; Armes v Nottinghamshire County Council [2017] UKSC 60). Lord Phillips listed five incidents that often justify the extension: the defendant is more likely to have the means to compensate; the tort is committed as a result of activity undertaken for the defendant; the activity is part of the defendant's business activity; the defendant created the risk by assigning the activity; and there is an element of control. Those factors help in doubtful stage-1 cases. They are not a free-standing overlay that abolishes the independent-contractor rule.

Barclays is the correction. A doctor engaged to examine job applicants, paid a fee per report, carrying on his own medical practice from his own premises, was an independent contractor . The bank was not vicariously liable for alleged sexual assaults during those examinations. The Supreme Court confirmed that a person in business on their own account is not in a relationship akin to employment merely because the bank arranged appointments and used a pro forma report. Do not tell the examiner that Christian Brothers replaced the independent-contractor rule.

Stage 2 — close connection. The question is whether the wrongful conduct was so closely connected with acts the employee was authorised to do that it can fairly and properly be regarded as done in the course of employment (Lord Nicholls in Dubai Aluminium Co Ltd v Salaam , adopted in Morrisons ). Lister v Hesley Hall Ltd [2001] UKHL 22 shows that sexual abuse by a warden of a residential school can be closely connected with the authorised pastoral role.

Morrisons confines a looser reading of Mohamud v WM Morrison Supermarkets plc [2016] UKSC 11. An internal auditor, authorised to send payroll data to external auditors, copied the data and published it online as a personal vendetta . Vicarious liability failed. Employment that merely gives the opportunity to commit a wrong is not enough. Acting on a personal frolic, rather than furthering the employer's business, points against stage 2. The Court of Appeal had wrongly used the Christian Brothers stage-1 factors to decide stage 2 . Do not repeat that error.

What not to do: recite the old Salmond formula (authorised acts versus unauthorised modes) as if it were the current test; treat course of employment as any act at work; apply akin-to-employment factors to a true independent professional; skip stage 1 because the tort is heinous; or treat Mohamud as if any customer-facing job makes the employer an insurer for every crime.

A worked fork: a supermarket employee attacks a customer. Ask first whether the attacker is an employee or in a relationship akin to employment. Then ask whether the assault was a way of carrying out authorised duties (a confrontation while serving, as later explained in the Morrisons reading of Mohamud) or an independent personal campaign. Then, separately, consider the employer's primary duty if the claimant is a fellow employee. Vicarious liability and primary liability can both appear on the same facts; they answer different questions.