Study guide
9.1 Duty of Care and Breach
Solicitors Qualifying Examination Part 1 SQE1
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction and Exam Overview
1.1 Current SQE1 Exam Facts 1.2 Single Best Answer Technique and Assessment Day 1.3 Qualifying as a Solicitor After SQE1
2 Ethics and Professional Conduct
2.1 The SRA Principles 2.2 Code of Conduct: Clients, Confidentiality and Disclosure 2.3 Conflicts, Undertakings and Duties to the Court 2.4 Firms, Managers and Compliance Officers 2.5 SRA Warning Notices: NDAs and SLAPPs
3 Business Organisations and Finance
3.1 Business Organisations, Personality and Limited Liability 3.2 Incorporation, Constitutions and Companies House 3.3 Financing: Debt, Equity, Security and Distributions 3.4 Partnership Decision-Making and Authority
4 Business Governance, Insolvency and Tax
4.1 Directors' Duties and Powers 4.2 Shareholders, Meetings, Filings and Minority Protection 4.3 Insolvency: Options and Procedures 4.4 Claw-Back of Assets and Order of Priority 4.5 Income Tax for Businesses 4.6 Capital Gains Tax for Businesses 4.7 Corporation Tax 4.8 VAT and Business Property Relief
5 Starting and Pleading a Civil Claim
5.1 Choosing Arbitration, Mediation or Litigation 5.2 Limitation, Pre-Action Conduct and Applicable Law 5.3 Where to Start, Issue and Service 5.4 Responding to a Claim and Statements of Case
6 Case Management, Trial, Costs and Enforcement
6.1 Interim Applications 6.2 Case Management, Sanctions and CCMCs 6.3 Evidence, Disclosure and Privilege 6.4 Trial and Costs Management 6.5 Part 36, Security for Costs and Assessed Costs 6.6 Appeals and Enforcement of Money Judgments
7 Contract Formation, Parties and Terms
7.1 Formation of Contract 7.2 Parties, Privity and Third-Party Rights 7.3 Express Terms, Incorporation, Implication and Variation 7.4 Exemption Clauses, Unfair Terms, Classification and Interpretation
8 Vitiating Factors, Termination and Remedies
8.1 Vitiating Factors 8.2 Termination of Contract 8.3 Remedies, Causation and Remoteness
9 Negligence, Defences and Vicarious Liability
9.1 Duty of Care and Breach 9.2 Causation, Remoteness and Personal Injury Remedies 9.3 Economic Loss, Psychiatric Harm and Employers' Primary Liability 9.4 Defences and Vicarious Liability
10 Occupiers, Products, Nuisance and Rylands
10.1 Occupiers' Liability 10.2 Product Liability 10.3 Nuisance and Rylands v Fletcher
11 Courts, Precedent and Legislation
11.1 Courts, Judicial Function and Rights of Audience 11.2 Precedent and Case Law 11.3 Primary Legislation in England and in Wales 11.4 Statutory Interpretation
12 Constitution, Judicial Review, Human Rights and EU Law
12.1 Constitutional Institutions, Devolution and the Rule of Law 12.2 Judicial Review and Public Order 12.3 Human Rights Act 1998 and EU Law in the UK Constitution
13 Legal Services Regulation, Equality and AML
13.1 SRA Regulation, Reserved Activities and PII 13.2 Equality Act 2010 in Legal Services 13.3 Money Laundering: Purpose, Scope and Reporting 13.4 POCA Offences, Defences and Due Diligence
14 Financial Services and Funding Legal Services
14.1 The FSMA Perimeter and Authorisation 14.2 Section 327, Scope Rules and Insurance Distribution 14.3 Retainers, Fixed Fees, CFAs and DBAs 14.4 Civil Legal Aid, Third-Party Funding and Insurance
15 Freehold Conveyancing Practice
15.1 Investigating Freehold Title 15.2 Pre-Contract Searches and Enquiries 15.3 Finance and Acting for a Lender 15.4 Drafting the Contract and Exchange 15.5 Completion, Post-Completion and Delay Remedies
16 Leasehold Practice, Security of Tenure, Planning and Property Tax
16.1 Lease Structure and Granting a Lease 16.2 Assignment, Covenants and Remedies 16.3 Business Security of Tenure (Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 Part II) 16.4 Planning Law and Property Taxation
17 Land: Estates, Title and Co-ownership
17.1 The Nature of Land, Estates and Interests 17.2 Acquiring, Transferring and Protecting Interests in Land 17.3 Registered and Unregistered Title 17.4 Co-ownership and Trusts of Land
18 Easements, Covenants, Mortgages and Leases
18.1 Easements 18.2 Freehold Covenants 18.3 Mortgages 18.4 Leases and Licences 18.5 Passing and Enforcing Leasehold Covenants
19 Wills, Revocation and Intestacy
19.1 Validity of Wills and Codicils 19.2 Executors, Alterations, Revocation and Interpretation 19.3 Intestacy and Property Passing Outside the Estate
20 Grants, Administration of Estates and Inheritance Tax
20.1 Grants of Representation and Order of Priority 20.2 Valuation, Excepted Estates and the Burden of IHT 20.3 Administration of Estates 20.4 Family Provision Claims under the 1975 Act 20.5 Inheritance Tax: Lifetime Transfers, Death and Reliefs 20.6 Income Tax and CGT During Administration
21 Express Trusts, Resulting Trusts and the Family Home
21.1 Express Trusts: Certainties, Formalities and Constitution 21.2 Beneficial Entitlement and Purpose Trusts 21.3 Resulting Trusts and Trusts of the Family Home
22 Fiduciaries, Trustees and Breach of Trust
22.1 Fiduciary Obligations and Liability of Strangers 22.2 Trustees: Appointment, Retirement and Removal 22.3 Trustees' Duties: Care, Investment and Advancement 22.4 Breach of Trust, Tracing and Equitable Remedies
23 Solicitors' Accounts
23.1 Client Money and the Client Account 23.2 Interest, Breaches and Corrections 23.3 Ledgers, Bills, Third-Party Accounts and Reports
24 Criminal Liability: Offences Against the Person and Defences
24.1 Actus Reus, Mens Rea, Parties and Attempts 24.2 Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person 24.3 Homicide and Partial Defences 24.4 General Defences
25 Theft, Criminal Damage and Fraud
25.1 Theft, Robbery and Burglary 25.2 Criminal Damage 25.3 Fraud
26 Police Station, Bail and Allocation
26.1 Advising at the Police Station 26.2 Bail and First Hearings 26.3 Plea Before Venue, Allocation, Case Management and Disclosure
27 Evidence, Trial, Sentencing, Appeals and Youth Court
27.1 Burden of Proof, Identification and Silence 27.2 Hearsay, Confessions, Bad Character and Exclusion 27.3 Trial Procedure in the Magistrates' Court and Crown Court 27.4 Sentencing 27.5 Appeals in Criminal Practice 27.6 Youth Court Procedure and the Welsh Language
9.1 Duty of Care and Breach
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Donoghue v Stevenson still founds the manufacturer-consumer duty; established duty categories do not need a fresh Caparo inquiry.
Robinson v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police holds that Caparo is a test for novel duties, not a universal three-part hurdle.
A learner driver is judged by the standard of a reasonably competent driver (Nettleship v Weston), not by inexperience.
Bolam and Bolitho govern professional treatment technique; Montgomery governs disclosure of material risks and reasonable alternatives.
Breach is an objective reasonable-person question, weighed by likelihood of harm, gravity of injury, cost of precautions, and social utility.
Last updated: September 2026
SQE1 FLK1 Tort questions on negligence almost always start with a client who has been injured, frightened, or left out of pocket. This independent ExamFinch chapter trains you to apply the functioning legal knowledge listed in the official FLK1 specification: duty of care (the general standard and the professional standard) and breach , before later sections add causation, remoteness, specialised losses, defences, and vicarious liability. You are not being asked to recite every appellate speech. You are being asked to choose the correct legal starting point on realistic facts and to know which leading authorities still govern the result.
Why duty is the first gate
A defendant is not liable in negligence merely because someone was careless in the colloquial sense. The claimant must show that the defendant owed a duty of care to this claimant, that the defendant breached the duty by falling below the required standard, that the breach caused recoverable loss, and that the loss is not too remote . If duty fails, the claim fails, even if the defendant's conduct was shoddy.
Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562 remains the foundation. Mrs Donoghue drank ginger beer bought by a friend. A decomposed snail was in the opaque bottle. She had no contract with the manufacturer. The House of Lords held that a manufacturer owed a duty to the ultimate consumer. Lord Atkin's neighbour principle still appears in functioning answers: you must take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions which you can reasonably foresee would be likely to injure your neighbour — persons so closely and directly affected by your act that you ought reasonably to have them in contemplation as being so affected when you are directing your mind to the acts or omissions called in question.
Established categories versus novel duties
In practice, most SQE1 facts fall into an established duty situation . Drivers owe a duty to other road users. Employers owe a duty to employees (primary liability is covered in section 9.3). Doctors and other clinicians owe a duty to their patients. Solicitors owe a duty to their clients. Occupiers owe statutory duties (a separate FLK1 topic). Manufacturers owe a Donoghue duty to consumers. When the facts sit inside a recognised category, do not invent a three-stage inquiry. The duty exists; move to standard and breach.
Caparo Industries plc v Dickman [1990] 2 AC 605 is the test for novel duty questions. The court asks whether (1) harm of the relevant type was reasonably foreseeable , (2) there was proximity between claimant and defendant, and (3) it is fair, just and reasonable to impose a duty. Caparo itself concerned auditors and investment loss. The three-stage formulation was later used more widely, and then confined.
Robinson v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police [2018] UKSC 4 is the modern correction you must know at functioning level. The Supreme Court held that Caparo is not a universal three-part hurdle for every negligence claim. The court starts with existing authority and develops the law incrementally. Police officers who, during an arrest, knocked over a nearby pedestrian could owe a duty; the old slogan that the police never owe a duty of care is too crude. On the exam, if a person is physically injured by a positive negligent act , you are usually in ordinary Donoghue territory, not a policy-barred omission case.
Omissions are different. There is generally no duty to rescue a stranger ( Smith v Littlewoods Organisation Ltd ). Exceptions include a defendant who assumes responsibility , has control over a third party or a hazard, or creates the danger . Public-authority omission cases are fact-sensitive; do not assume a council or the police must act merely because intervention would have helped.
The general standard of care
Breach is judged against the reasonable person in the defendant's position ( Blyth v Birmingham Waterworks Co ). The test is objective. A learner driver is judged by the standard of a reasonably competent driver ( Nettleship v Weston [1971] 2 QB 691). Inexperience is not a defence against the injured third party. Children are judged by the standard of a reasonable child of the same age ( Mullin v Richards ).
Courts then weigh the practicalities of the activity:
Likelihood of harm: a cricket ball hit out of the ground once in many years did not require a higher fence in Bolton v Stone [1951] AC 850.
Gravity of injury: extra care was required for a one-eyed worker in Paris v Stepney Borough Council [1951] AC 367.
Cost and practicability of precautions: spreading sawdust after a flood was enough in Latimer v AEC Ltd [1953] AC 643; the factory did not have to close.
Social utility: an emergency fire-engine run may justify a risk that would be unacceptable in ordinary driving ( Watt v Hertfordshire County Council ).
Res ipsa loquitur (the thing speaks for itself) can help a claimant who cannot say exactly how the accident happened, if the thing was under the defendant's control and accidents of that type do not ordinarily occur without negligence ( Scott v London and St Katherine Docks Co ). It is an evidential tool, not a separate tort.
The professional standard: Bolam, Bolitho and Montgomery
Where the defendant is exercising a professional skill , the general reasonable-person standard is replaced, for the skilled task, by the Bolam test ( Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] 1 WLR 582). A doctor is not negligent if they acted in a way that a responsible body of professional opinion would regard as proper, even if another body disagrees. Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority [1998] AC 232 adds a judicial safety-valve: the court is not bound by expert evidence that cannot withstand logical analysis . Bolam is not a rubber stamp.
Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11 is the trap. It governs the clinician's advisory role when obtaining consent, not the Bolam question of how to perform surgery. The doctor must take reasonable care to ensure the patient is aware of material risks of injury and of reasonable alternative treatments . A risk is material if a reasonable person in the patient's position would be likely to attach significance to it, or if the doctor is or should reasonably be aware that this particular patient would. A diabetic woman of small stature was not told of a 9–10% shoulder-dystocia risk associated with vaginal delivery; that was a breach of the disclosure duty. On SQE1 facts, if the complaint is that the patient was not told, start with Montgomery. If the complaint is that the operation was performed incompetently, start with Bolam and Bolitho.
- Issue Standard Leading authority
- Ordinary activity (driving, walking) Reasonable person in that position Blyth; Nettleship for learners
- Child defendant Reasonable child of similar age Mullin v Richards
Professional treatment or skilled technique Responsible body of opinion, capable of logical support Bolam; Bolitho
- Disclosure of treatment risks and alternatives Material risk to this patient; not Bolam Montgomery
- Applying the law on typical FLK1 facts
A newly qualified solicitor advising after a road accident should not write a mini-dissertation. Identify the relationship (driver and pedestrian is established). Ask whether the driving fell below a competent driver. Leave professional-standard analysis for clinicians, solicitors, and other skilled defendants. Leave Caparo for truly new relationships, especially pure economic loss and psychiatric harm, which section 9.3 covers.
Common errors: using Caparo on a straightforward road-traffic collision; applying Bolam to a consent conversation; allowing a learner to be judged as a learner vis-à-vis an injured pedestrian; treating res ipsa as automatic liability; and treating a police-omission complaint as if it were the same as a police officer knocking someone over during an arrest.