Study guide
9.3 Economic Loss, Psychiatric Harm and Employers' Primary Liability
Solicitors Qualifying Examination Part 1 SQE1
Track your progress as you read
Finished sections get a check mark.
1 Introduction and Exam Overview
1.1 Current SQE1 Exam Facts 1.2 Single Best Answer Technique and Assessment Day 1.3 Qualifying as a Solicitor After SQE1
2 Ethics and Professional Conduct
2.1 The SRA Principles 2.2 Code of Conduct: Clients, Confidentiality and Disclosure 2.3 Conflicts, Undertakings and Duties to the Court 2.4 Firms, Managers and Compliance Officers 2.5 SRA Warning Notices: NDAs and SLAPPs
3 Business Organisations and Finance
3.1 Business Organisations, Personality and Limited Liability 3.2 Incorporation, Constitutions and Companies House 3.3 Financing: Debt, Equity, Security and Distributions 3.4 Partnership Decision-Making and Authority
4 Business Governance, Insolvency and Tax
4.1 Directors' Duties and Powers 4.2 Shareholders, Meetings, Filings and Minority Protection 4.3 Insolvency: Options and Procedures 4.4 Claw-Back of Assets and Order of Priority 4.5 Income Tax for Businesses 4.6 Capital Gains Tax for Businesses 4.7 Corporation Tax 4.8 VAT and Business Property Relief
5 Starting and Pleading a Civil Claim
5.1 Choosing Arbitration, Mediation or Litigation 5.2 Limitation, Pre-Action Conduct and Applicable Law 5.3 Where to Start, Issue and Service 5.4 Responding to a Claim and Statements of Case
6 Case Management, Trial, Costs and Enforcement
6.1 Interim Applications 6.2 Case Management, Sanctions and CCMCs 6.3 Evidence, Disclosure and Privilege 6.4 Trial and Costs Management 6.5 Part 36, Security for Costs and Assessed Costs 6.6 Appeals and Enforcement of Money Judgments
7 Contract Formation, Parties and Terms
7.1 Formation of Contract 7.2 Parties, Privity and Third-Party Rights 7.3 Express Terms, Incorporation, Implication and Variation 7.4 Exemption Clauses, Unfair Terms, Classification and Interpretation
8 Vitiating Factors, Termination and Remedies
8.1 Vitiating Factors 8.2 Termination of Contract 8.3 Remedies, Causation and Remoteness
9 Negligence, Defences and Vicarious Liability
9.1 Duty of Care and Breach 9.2 Causation, Remoteness and Personal Injury Remedies 9.3 Economic Loss, Psychiatric Harm and Employers' Primary Liability 9.4 Defences and Vicarious Liability
10 Occupiers, Products, Nuisance and Rylands
10.1 Occupiers' Liability 10.2 Product Liability 10.3 Nuisance and Rylands v Fletcher
11 Courts, Precedent and Legislation
11.1 Courts, Judicial Function and Rights of Audience 11.2 Precedent and Case Law 11.3 Primary Legislation in England and in Wales 11.4 Statutory Interpretation
12 Constitution, Judicial Review, Human Rights and EU Law
12.1 Constitutional Institutions, Devolution and the Rule of Law 12.2 Judicial Review and Public Order 12.3 Human Rights Act 1998 and EU Law in the UK Constitution
13 Legal Services Regulation, Equality and AML
13.1 SRA Regulation, Reserved Activities and PII 13.2 Equality Act 2010 in Legal Services 13.3 Money Laundering: Purpose, Scope and Reporting 13.4 POCA Offences, Defences and Due Diligence
14 Financial Services and Funding Legal Services
14.1 The FSMA Perimeter and Authorisation 14.2 Section 327, Scope Rules and Insurance Distribution 14.3 Retainers, Fixed Fees, CFAs and DBAs 14.4 Civil Legal Aid, Third-Party Funding and Insurance
15 Freehold Conveyancing Practice
15.1 Investigating Freehold Title 15.2 Pre-Contract Searches and Enquiries 15.3 Finance and Acting for a Lender 15.4 Drafting the Contract and Exchange 15.5 Completion, Post-Completion and Delay Remedies
16 Leasehold Practice, Security of Tenure, Planning and Property Tax
16.1 Lease Structure and Granting a Lease 16.2 Assignment, Covenants and Remedies 16.3 Business Security of Tenure (Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 Part II) 16.4 Planning Law and Property Taxation
17 Land: Estates, Title and Co-ownership
17.1 The Nature of Land, Estates and Interests 17.2 Acquiring, Transferring and Protecting Interests in Land 17.3 Registered and Unregistered Title 17.4 Co-ownership and Trusts of Land
18 Easements, Covenants, Mortgages and Leases
18.1 Easements 18.2 Freehold Covenants 18.3 Mortgages 18.4 Leases and Licences 18.5 Passing and Enforcing Leasehold Covenants
19 Wills, Revocation and Intestacy
19.1 Validity of Wills and Codicils 19.2 Executors, Alterations, Revocation and Interpretation 19.3 Intestacy and Property Passing Outside the Estate
20 Grants, Administration of Estates and Inheritance Tax
20.1 Grants of Representation and Order of Priority 20.2 Valuation, Excepted Estates and the Burden of IHT 20.3 Administration of Estates 20.4 Family Provision Claims under the 1975 Act 20.5 Inheritance Tax: Lifetime Transfers, Death and Reliefs 20.6 Income Tax and CGT During Administration
21 Express Trusts, Resulting Trusts and the Family Home
21.1 Express Trusts: Certainties, Formalities and Constitution 21.2 Beneficial Entitlement and Purpose Trusts 21.3 Resulting Trusts and Trusts of the Family Home
22 Fiduciaries, Trustees and Breach of Trust
22.1 Fiduciary Obligations and Liability of Strangers 22.2 Trustees: Appointment, Retirement and Removal 22.3 Trustees' Duties: Care, Investment and Advancement 22.4 Breach of Trust, Tracing and Equitable Remedies
23 Solicitors' Accounts
23.1 Client Money and the Client Account 23.2 Interest, Breaches and Corrections 23.3 Ledgers, Bills, Third-Party Accounts and Reports
24 Criminal Liability: Offences Against the Person and Defences
24.1 Actus Reus, Mens Rea, Parties and Attempts 24.2 Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person 24.3 Homicide and Partial Defences 24.4 General Defences
25 Theft, Criminal Damage and Fraud
25.1 Theft, Robbery and Burglary 25.2 Criminal Damage 25.3 Fraud
26 Police Station, Bail and Allocation
26.1 Advising at the Police Station 26.2 Bail and First Hearings 26.3 Plea Before Venue, Allocation, Case Management and Disclosure
27 Evidence, Trial, Sentencing, Appeals and Youth Court
27.1 Burden of Proof, Identification and Silence 27.2 Hearsay, Confessions, Bad Character and Exclusion 27.3 Trial Procedure in the Magistrates' Court and Crown Court 27.4 Sentencing 27.5 Appeals in Criminal Practice 27.6 Youth Court Procedure and the Welsh Language
9.3 Economic Loss, Psychiatric Harm and Employers' Primary Liability
Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI
Pure economic loss from a negligent act is generally irrecoverable (Spartan Steel; Murphy v Brentwood); consequential loss attached to physical damage is recoverable.
Negligent misstatement can found a duty where the defendant assumes responsibility, there is a special relationship, and the claimant reasonably relies (Hedley Byrne).
Primary victims are in the zone of physical danger (Page v Smith); secondary victims must satisfy Alcock controls, and Paul v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust [2024] UKSC 1 generally requires witnessing an accident.
Wilsons and Clyde Coal sets the employer's non-delegable common-law duties: competent staff, adequate plant, a safe system, and a safe place of work.
Section 69 of the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act 2013 removed most civil actions for breach of health and safety regulations, so FLK1 focuses on the common-law primary duty.
Last updated: September 2026
FLK1 groups three specialised areas that ordinary physical-injury analysis does not cover: pure economic loss arising from a negligent act or misstatement, psychiatric harm , and employers' primary liability at common law. Each has control mechanisms. Missing them is a typical way to over-recover on the exam.
Pure economic loss from a negligent act or misstatement
Consequential economic loss — money lost because property or the person was physically damaged — is recoverable. Pure economic loss — money lost without that physical damage to the claimant's person or property — is generally not recoverable when it flows from a negligent act .
Spartan Steel & Alloys Ltd v Martin & Co (Contractors) Ltd [1973] 1 QB 27 is the teaching case. Contractors cut a power cable. Metal already in the furnace was damaged: the physical damage and the lost profit on that melt were recoverable. Profit on melts that could not be processed while the power was off was pure economic loss and not recoverable.
Murphy v Brentwood District Council [1991] 1 AC 398 treats the cost of repairing a defective building as pure economic loss. A claimant who discovers a defect before the building injures anyone is protecting their wallet, not their body. Product and building defects without physical injury to other property therefore usually fail in negligence (statutory product liability is a separate FLK1 topic).
Negligent misstatement is the main exception. Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465 recognised that a duty can arise where the defendant assumes responsibility to the claimant, there is a special relationship , and the claimant reasonably relies on the statement. On the facts, a banker's disclaimer (without responsibility) prevented the duty arising. Social chat at a party is not an assumption of responsibility. A professional who knows the advice will be relayed to a known person for a known transaction may assume responsibility; an auditor reporting to shareholders as a class for the company's governance does not thereby assume responsibility to an individual bidder ( Caparo Industries plc v Dickman ).
White v Jones [1995] 2 AC 207 extends assumption of responsibility to disappointed beneficiaries where a solicitor's delay meant a will was never executed. The solicitor's duty is ordinarily to the client, but the specific testamentary intent would otherwise be empty.
Even when a duty exists, recoverable loss is limited by the scope of the duty . Manchester Building Society v Grant Thornton UK LLP [2021] UKSC 20 and Meadows v Khan [2021] UKSC 21 (the SAAMCO line) ask what risk the service was supposed to protect the claimant against. An auditor who should have spotted a hedge-accounting problem is not thereby the insurer of every business risk. A doctor who should have tested for a genetic condition is responsible for the costs associated with that condition, not for the whole ordinary cost of raising a child. On the exam, match the lost money to the purpose of the advice.
Loss Typical result Illustration
Lost profit because a machine was physically smashed Recoverable consequential loss Damaged melt in Spartan Steel
Lost profit because the power was off and no physical damage to the claimant's goods Pure economic loss; generally no duty Later melts in Spartan Steel
- Cost of making a defective house safe Pure economic loss after Murphy Defective foundations
- Lost investment relying on a paid-for reference Possible Hedley Byrne duty Special relationship plus reliance
- Will never executed; intended gift fails Possible White v Jones duty Disappointed beneficiary
- Psychiatric harm
Grief, anger, and ordinary distress are not enough. The claimant needs a recognised psychiatric illness .
Primary victims are in the zone of foreseeable physical danger . If some personal injury to them was reasonably foreseeable, they can recover for psychiatric injury even if the mechanism is shock and their body is untouched ( Page v Smith [1996] AC 155). They are not required to satisfy the Alcock control mechanisms.
Secondary victims witness injury to someone else. Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1992] 1 AC 310 (Hillsborough) imposes control mechanisms: a close tie of love and affection (presumed for spouses and parent/child, proved for others); proximity in time and space to the accident or its immediate aftermath ( McLoughlin v O'Brian [1983] 1 AC 410); perception with the claimant's own unaided senses , not television or a later news report; and a sudden shocking event , not a gradual realisation. Siblings and friends failed in Alcock. Identification in a mortuary hours later was not the aftermath.
Rescuers are not a privileged class. Police officers at Hillsborough who were not themselves in physical danger were treated as secondary victims and failed ( White v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1999] 2 AC 455). If a rescuer is in physical danger, they may be a primary victim.
Paul v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust [2024] UKSC 1 is now essential functioning knowledge. Daughters saw their father collapse and die in the street from a heart condition that, it was alleged, should have been treated earlier. Other conjoined appeals involved parents witnessing a child's death, or coming upon a body shortly afterwards, after missed diagnoses. The Supreme Court (Lord Burrows dissenting) held that secondary-victim liability is geared to witnessing an accident — an unexpected event external to the primary victim — not to witnessing death or injury from an earlier failure to treat disease . The claims were struck out. Do not advise that a relative who watches a hospital death after clinical negligence automatically has an Alcock claim.
Workplace psychiatric injury from occupational stress is a different route. The employer who knows, or ought to know, that the particular employee is at risk of psychiatric injury from workload can owe a duty ( Hatton v Sutherland [2002] EWCA Civ 76, approved in Barber v Somerset County Council [2004] UKHL 13). Foreseeability of harm to this employee is the practical question.
Employers' primary liability
Do not confuse this with vicarious liability (section 9.4). Primary liability is the employer's own duty to the employee. Vicarious liability is the employer's liability for a tort committed by another person.
Wilsons and Clyde Coal Co Ltd v English [1938] AC 57 sets out the classic common-law duties: competent staff , adequate plant and equipment , a safe system of work , and a safe place of work . The duty is personal and non-delegable . Appointing a competent contractor to design the system does not discharge the employer if the system remains unsafe ( McDermid v Nash Dredging & Reclamation Co Ltd [1987] AC 906).
The standard is reasonable care, not strict liability. Latimer v AEC Ltd shows that reasonable steps (sawdust on a flooded floor) can suffice; the employer need not close the factory if that would be disproportionate. The claimant still has to prove breach and causation in the usual way.
Civil claims for breach of health and safety regulations were largely removed by section 69 of the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act 2013 . FLK1 therefore focuses on the operation and effect of the common law principles . Regulations remain relevant as evidence of what reasonable care required, but a regulatory breach is not, by itself, a civil cause of action in the way it once was.
A typical exam fork: an employee is injured by a colleague's negligence. Consider (1) the employer's primary duty (training, system, equipment) and (2) vicarious liability for the colleague's tort. They are cumulative, not synonyms. Another fork: an employee is injured because a specialist contractor designed an unsafe system. Primary liability can still attach to the employer because the safe-system duty is non-delegable, even though vicarious liability for a true independent contractor will usually fail after Barclays (section 9.4).