Study guide

4.2 Project Delivery Systems and Contract Pricing Structures

Tennessee Contractor Business and Law Examination Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: Business Organization and Entity Structure

1.1 Sole Proprietorships, Partnerships, and Joint Ventures 1.2 Corporations and Limited Liability Companies (LLCs) 1.3 Qualifying Agents, Assumed Names (DBAs), and Mode-of-Operation Changes

2 Chapter 2: Tennessee Contractor Licensing Law and Board Regulations

2.1 Licensing Thresholds, Classifications, and Prov Exam Logistics 2.2 Financial Statements, Monetary Limits, and the Surety Bond Option 2.3 Application Package, Insurance Minimums, Renewals, and Continuing Education 2.4 Bid Envelope Rules, Unlicensed Contracting, and Disciplinary Penalties

3 Chapter 3: Construction Estimating and Competitive Bidding

3.1 Estimating Methods, Quantity Takeoffs, and Waste Factors 3.2 Direct Costs, Labor Burden, Equipment, and Overhead Allocation 3.3 Markup vs. Margin, Bid Buildup, and Change-Order Pricing 3.4 Bidding Procedures, Bid Bonds, Addenda, and Bid Ethics

4 Chapter 4: Construction Contracts and the Tennessee Prompt Pay Act

4.1 Contract Formation, Essential Elements, and Interpretation Rules 4.2 Project Delivery Systems and Contract Pricing Structures 4.3 Key Contract Provisions, Changes, Delays, and Breach Remedies 4.4 The Tennessee Prompt Pay Act and Retainage Escrow Mandates

5 Chapter 5: Project Management, Scheduling, and Field Operations

5.1 Network Scheduling, Critical Path Method (CPM), and Float Calculations 5.2 Schedule Compression, Resource Leveling, and Earned Value Cost Control 5.3 Submittals, RFIs, Quality Control, Inventory, and Project Closeout

6 Chapter 6: Risk Management, Insurance, and Surety Bonds

6.1 Risk Management Framework and Commercial General Liability (CGL) 6.2 Builder's Risk, Workers' Compensation, and Specialty Policies 6.3 Contract Surety Bonds, the Miller Act, and Tennessee Bonding Rules

7 Chapter 7: OSHA and Tennessee TOSHA Jobsite Safety and Environmental Compliance

7.1 TOSHA/OSHA Administration, Recordkeeping, Inspections, and Penalties 7.2 The Construction Focus Four, Fall Protection, Ladders, and Scaffolds 7.3 Trenching & Excavation, Electrical Safety, HazCom, and Environmental Rules

8 Chapter 8: Construction Accounting, Financial Statements, and Cash Flow Management

8.1 Accounting Methods, Financial Statements, and Construction Revenue Recognition 8.2 Financial Ratios, Working Capital, and Integrated Tennessee Limit Math 8.3 Cash Flow Management, Trade Credit Discounts, Break-Even, and Depreciation

9 Chapter 9: Federal and Tennessee Employment and Labor Law

9.1 Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), Wage and Hour Rules, and Overtime Math 9.2 Worker Classification, Form I-9, the Tennessee Lawful Employment Act (E-Verify), and Right-to-Work 9.3 Anti-Discrimination Statutes, FMLA, Prevailing Wage Laws, and Tennessee Protections

10 Chapter 10: Federal and Tennessee Tax Law and Payroll Compliance

10.1 Federal Payroll Taxes, FICA, FUTA, and IRS Deposit Deadlines 10.2 Federal Income Tax, Self-Employment Tax, Form 1099-NEC, and Entity Returns 10.3 Tennessee State Taxes: Sales & Use, Business Tax, SUTA, and Franchise & Excise Tax

11 Chapter 11: Tennessee Mechanics' and Materialmen's Lien Law

11.1 Prime vs. Remote Contractors, Residential Exemptions, and Notice of Nonpayment 11.2 Recording, Serving, Enforcing, and Bonding Off Tennessee Mechanics' Liens

4.2 Project Delivery Systems and Contract Pricing Structures

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

In Traditional Design-Bid-Build (DBB), the owner holds separate contracts with the Architect/Engineer and the Prime Contractor and impliedly warrants the adequacy of the plans and specifications under the Spearin Doctrine.

In Design-Build (DB), the owner executes a single contract with one entity responsible for both design and construction, eliminating designer-versus-builder finger-pointing and enabling Fast-Track (phased) construction.

Agency Construction Managers act purely as fee-based owner advisors without holding trade subcontracts, whereas Construction Managers at Risk (CMAR) hold trade subcontracts and typically guarantee cost under a Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMP); in Tennessee, any CM on a project of $25,000 or more must hold a Tennessee contractor's license.

A Lump-Sum (Fixed-Price) contract places the highest cost risk on the contractor, whereas a Cost Plus Percentage of Cost (CPPC) contract places the highest cost risk on the owner; a Unit-Price contract places quantity risk on the owner and unit-cost risk on the contractor.

Last updated: October 2026

Every construction project requires two foundational structural choices by the project owner: (1) the Project Delivery System , which defines the contractual relationships, lines of communication, and division of design and construction responsibilities among the Owner, Designer, and Builder; and (2) the Contract Pricing Structure , which establishes how the contractor is compensated and how the financial risks of cost overruns and quantity variations are allocated between the parties.

  • The Four Major Project Delivery Systems
  • 1. Traditional Design-Bid-Build (DBB)

Design-Bid-Build (DBB) is the classic, sequential delivery method used across public works and conventional commercial construction:

Two Separate Contracts (No Privity Between A/E and Contractor): The Owner executes two separate contracts : first, a professional services agreement with an Architect or Engineer (A/E) to prepare 100% complete working drawings and technical specifications; second, a construction contract with a Prime Contractor selected after competitive bidding. There is no direct contractual relationship (no privity of contract) between the Architect and the Prime Contractor.

Linear Sequence and Checks & Balances: Traditional Design-Bid-Build generally bids the completed design for each construction package and follows a sequential schedule ( Design → \rightarrow → Bid → \rightarrow → Build ), which can take longer than overlapping design and construction; separately completed packages can still allow phased work. Its primary advantage to the Owner is clear upfront price competition on a complete design and independent quality oversight by the Architect during construction.

The Spearin Doctrine ( United States v. Spearin ): Because the Owner hires the Architect and furnishes completed plans and specifications to bidders in Design-Bid-Build, the Owner impliedly warrants that the plans and specifications are accurate, free from design defects, and suitable for their intended purpose . Under the Spearin Doctrine , a contractor who builds strictly in accordance with owner-furnished design specifications is not liable if the completed system fails to perform due to a design flaw, and is entitled to a compensable Change Order to correct the defective design.

2. Design-Build (DB)

In a Design-Build delivery system, the Owner executes a single contract with a single Design-Build entity (an integrated design-build company, a prime contractor subcontracting with an architectural firm, or a contractor-architect joint venture) that assumes single-point responsibility for both architectural/engineering design and physical construction.

Single Point of Responsibility: The Owner is never caught in the middle of finger-pointing disputes between an independent architect blaming workmanship and a contractor blaming defective plans—the Design-Builder is legally responsible for both.

Fast-Track (Phased) Construction: Because design and construction are controlled under one roof, Design-Build enables Fast-Track construction , in which early construction packages (site clearing, mass grading, underground utilities, and deep foundations) begin in the field while structural steel, MEP systems, and interior finishes are still being designed. Fast-tracking significantly compresses the overall schedule from concept to occupancy, though it increases the risk of costly rework if late design changes conflict with foundation work already in place.

3. Construction Management: Agency CM vs. CM at Risk (CMAR)

Professional Construction Management (CM) introduces construction expertise during the design phase (constructability reviews, value engineering, cost estimating, and long-lead scheduling), but exists in two legally distinct forms:

Agency Construction Management (CM as Advisor / CMa): The Agency CM acts purely as the Owner's fee-based consultant and advisor . An Agency CM does not perform construction work, does not hold subcontracts (the Owner signs separate contracts directly with multiple trade contractors or a general contractor), and does not guarantee the project's final cost or completion date . The Owner retains the financial risk of trade contractor default and cost overruns.

Construction Manager at Risk (CMAR / CMc): The CMAR acts as an advisor during the pre-construction design phase for a pre-construction fee, and then steps into the legal shoes of a Prime Contractor during the construction phase. Unlike an Agency CM, a CM at Risk holds all trade subcontracts directly in its own name, assumes legal liability for trade performance and schedule, and typically guarantees that total construction costs will not exceed a negotiated Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMP) .

Important

Tennessee Construction Manager Licensing Requirement ( T.C.A. § 62-6-102 ): Under the Tennessee Contractors Licensing Act, the statutory definition of "Contractor" explicitly includes any Construction Manager who performs, coordinates, manages, or supervises construction activities on a project where the total cost of the undertaking is $25,000 or more . Whether operating under an Agency CM or CM at Risk contract, a Construction Manager in Tennessee must hold an active Tennessee contractor's license in the appropriate classification and monetary limit.

4. Turnkey / EPC (Engineering-Procurement-Construction)

A Turnkey project is an expanded form of Design-Build—frequently used in industrial plants, power generation, and commercial real estate development—in which a single Turnkey contractor/developer handles land acquisition, project financing, permitting, engineering design, equipment procurement, construction, and startup commissioning . The Owner simply pays the agreed price upon final completion and "turns the key" to begin operating a fully equipped facility.

Delivery System Owner Contracts Who Holds Trade Subcontracts? Fast-Track Capable? Design Liability to Owner Schedule Speed

Design-Bid-Build (DBB) 2 contracts (1 with A/E, 1 with Prime Contractor) Prime Contractor Usually sequential; phased completed bid packages possible Owner warrants design to Contractor ( Spearin Doctrine ) Typically sequential

Design-Build (DB) 1 single contract with Design-Builder Design-Builder Yes (overlapping phased design & construction) Design-Builder bears single-point design & build liability Fastest

Agency CM (CM as Advisor) Multiple contracts (A/E + CM Advisor + Trade Primes) Owner (Agency CM holds zero trade contracts) Yes (multi-prime phased packages) Owner / A/E (Agency CM provides advisory review only) Fast

CM at Risk (CMAR) 2 contracts (1 with A/E, 1 with CMAR) CM at Risk (acts as Prime during construction) Yes (early site/foundation packages under GMP) Owner / A/E (CMAR guarantees construction cost up to GMP) Fast

Turnkey / EPC 1 single contract with Turnkey Developer/Contractor Turnkey Contractor Yes Turnkey Contractor (includes financing & commissioning) Fast

  • The Four Core Contract Pricing Structures and Risk Allocation
  • 1. Lump-Sum (Fixed-Price / Stipulated-Sum) Contract

In a Lump-Sum Contract , the contractor agrees to furnish all labor, materials, equipment, supervision, overhead, and profit required to complete the entire scope of work shown in the Contract Documents for one fixed total dollar price .

When Used: Requires well-defined, 100% complete plans and specifications at the time of bidding so the estimator can perform an accurate quantity takeoff.

Risk Allocation: Places the highest cost risk on the Contractor and the lowest cost risk on the Owner . If the contractor builds the project more efficiently than estimated, the contractor keeps 100% of the cost savings as additional profit. Conversely, if labor rates, material prices, or crew hours exceed the estimate, the contractor absorbs 100% of the cost overrun (unless the Owner orders a scope change or a compensable Differing Site Condition occurs).

2. Unit-Price Contract

In a Unit-Price Contract , the bidder quotes a fixed dollar price per installed unit of measurement (which includes direct cost, overhead, and profit per unit—such as $140 per cubic yard of mass rock excavation, $85 per linear foot of 8-inch PVC sewer main, or $110 per ton of hot-mix asphalt) based on estimated quantities provided by the Owner's engineer. Final payment is calculated by multiplying the actual field-measured quantities installed by the contract unit prices.

When Used: Ideal for heavy civil, highway, earthwork, deep foundation piling, and municipal utility projects where the nature of the work is clear, but exact quantities cannot be determined until excavation is underway .

Risk Allocation: Splits risk cleanly between the parties: the Owner bears the quantity risk (if 1,500 cubic yards of rock are encountered instead of the estimated 1,000 cubic yards, the Owner pays for 1,500 cubic yards), while the Contractor bears the unit-cost risk (if the contractor's crew costs $160/CY to excavate rock that was bid at $140/CY, the contractor loses $20/CY). Most unit-price contracts include a Variation in Estimated Quantities (VEQ) clause allowing either party to request an equitable unit-price adjustment if actual quantities vary by more than 15% to 25% above or below the estimated bid schedule quantities (protecting fixed mobilization/overhead recovery on major underruns and preventing windfalls on major overruns).

3. Cost-Plus (Cost-Reimbursable) Contracts

In a Cost-Plus Contract , the Owner reimburses the contractor for actual, documented, auditable direct project costs (field payroll, materials, subcontracts, equipment rentals) plus an agreed Fee to cover the contractor's home-office general and administrative (G&A) overhead and profit. Cost-plus contracts require open-book accounting and a strict contractual list separating Reimbursable Job Costs from Non-Reimbursable Home-Office Costs . There are three primary Cost-Plus structures:

Cost Plus Percentage of Cost (CPPC): The Owner pays actual direct costs plus a fee calculated as a percentage (e.g., 15 % 15\% 15% ) of those actual costs. CPPC places the highest financial risk on the Owner (and lowest on the contractor) because every dollar of waste, inefficiency, or material price inflation increases the contractor's dollar fee. Because it rewards overspending, CPPC is prohibited in federal government contracting.

Cost Plus Fixed Fee (CPFF): The Owner reimburses actual direct costs plus a predetermined, fixed dollar fee (e.g., actual reimbursable costs + $95,000 fixed fee). Because the contractor's fee remains fixed at $95,000 even if direct costs rise, the contractor has no financial incentive to inflate job costs (and has an incentive to finish quickly to earn the fixed fee in fewer months).

Cost Plus with Guaranteed Maximum Price (Cost-Plus GMP): The Owner reimburses actual direct costs plus the contractor's fee only up to a contractual ceiling known as the Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMP) . If total actual costs plus fee exceed the GMP , the contractor must absorb 100% of the overrun above the GMP out of its own pocket. If total actual costs plus fee come in below the GMP , the resulting cost savings (underrun) either revert 100% to the Owner or are divided between the Owner and Contractor according to a Shared-Savings (Incentive) Clause (such as 70% to Owner / 30% to Contractor). Contractor Payout under Shared-Savings GMP = { Actual Cost + Base Fee + s c × ( GMP − ( Actual Cost + Base Fee ) ) if ( Actual Cost + Base Fee ) < GMP GMP if ( Actual Cost + Base Fee ) ≥ GMP \text{Contractor Payout under Shared-Savings GMP} = \begin{cases} \text{Actual Cost} + \text{Base Fee} + s_c \times (\text{GMP} - (\text{Actual Cost} + \text{Base Fee})) & \text{if } (\text{Actual Cost} + \text{Base Fee}) < \text{GMP} \\ \text{GMP} & \text{if } (\text{Actual Cost} + \text{Base Fee}) \ge \text{GMP} \end{cases} Contractor Payout under Shared-Savings GMP = { Actual Cost + Base Fee + s c ​ × ( GMP − ( Actual Cost + Base Fee )) GMP ​ if ( Actual Cost + Base Fee ) < GMP if ( Actual Cost + Base Fee ) ≥ GMP ​

4. Time and Materials (T&M) Contract

A Time and Materials (T&M) Contract compensates the contractor based on fixed composite hourly labor billing rates (which already include base wages, payroll taxes, workers' compensation, overhead, and profit per hour) plus actual material and equipment invoices plus an agreed markup percentage . T&M is widely used for emergency repairs, small unquantifiable remodeling tasks, or force-account change orders . Because an open-ended T&M contract exposes the Owner to productivity risk, Owners typically require daily signed field time tickets and a Not-to-Exceed (NTE) cap.

Worked Numeric Example: Cost-Plus GMP with a 75% / 25% Shared-Savings Clause

Suppose a Tennessee CM at Risk signs a Cost-Plus Fixed Fee contract with a Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMP) to construct a medical clinic in Chattanooga under the following terms:

Target Direct Cost Estimate: $2,000,000

Contractor's Fixed Fee: $180,000

Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMP): $ 2 , 000 , 000 + $ 180 , 000 = $ 2 , 180 , 000 \text{\textdollar}2,000,000 + \text{\textdollar}180,000 = \text{\textdollar}2,180,000 $ 2 , 000 , 000 + $ 180 , 000 = $ 2 , 180 , 000

Shared-Savings Clause: Any savings below the $2,180,000 GMP are split 75% to the Owner and 25% to the Contractor .

Scenario A — Cost Underrun (Actual Direct Costs = $1,860,000):

Total Cost + Fixed Fee before savings split: $ 1 , 860 , 000 + $ 180 , 000 = $ 2 , 040 , 000 \text{\textdollar}1,860,000 + \text{\textdollar}180,000 = \text{\textdollar}2,040,000 $ 1 , 860 , 000 + $ 180 , 000 = $ 2 , 040 , 000

Total Savings Below GMP: $ 2 , 180 , 000 − $ 2 , 040 , 000 = $ 140 , 000 \text{\textdollar}2,180,000 - \text{\textdollar}2,040,000 = \text{\textdollar}140,000 $ 2 , 180 , 000 − $ 2 , 040 , 000 = $ 140 , 000

Contractor's 25% Incentive Share of Savings: 0.25 × $ 140 , 000 = $ 35 , 000 0.25 \times \text{\textdollar}140,000 = \text{\textdollar}35,000 0.25 × $ 140 , 000 = $ 35 , 000

Total Contractor Fee Earned: $ 180 , 000 + $ 35 , 000 = $ 215 , 000 \text{\textdollar}180,000 + \text{\textdollar}35,000 = \mathbf{\text{\textdollar}215,000} $ 180 , 000 + $ 35 , 000 = $ 215 , 000

Total Amount Paid by Owner: $ 1 , 860 , 000 + $ 215 , 000 = $ 2 , 075 , 000 \text{\textdollar}1,860,000 + \text{\textdollar}215,000 = \mathbf{\text{\textdollar}2,075,000} $ 1 , 860 , 000 + $ 215 , 000 = $ 2 , 075 , 000 (saving the Owner 0.75 × $ 140 , 000 = $ 105 , 000 0.75 \times \text{\textdollar}140,000 = \text{\textdollar}105,000 0.75 × $ 140 , 000 = $ 105 , 000 below the GMP).

Scenario B — Cost Overrun (Actual Direct Costs = $2,110,000):

Total Uncapped Cost + Fixed Fee: $ 2 , 110 , 000 + $ 180 , 000 = $ 2 , 290 , 000 \text{\textdollar}2,110,000 + \text{\textdollar}180,000 = \text{\textdollar}2,290,000 $ 2 , 110 , 000 + $ 180 , 000 = $ 2 , 290 , 000

Because $2,290,000 exceeds the $2,180,000 GMP by $110,000, the Owner pays exactly the $2,180,000 GMP ceiling , and the contractor absorbs the $110,000 overrun, reducing the contractor's net realized fee to $ 180 , 000 − $ 110 , 000 = $ 70 , 000 \text{\textdollar}180,000 - \text{\textdollar}110,000 = \mathbf{\text{\textdollar}70,000} $ 180 , 000 − $ 110 , 000 = $ 70 , 000 .

Contract Pricing Type Required Design Completeness Who Bears Cost Overrun Risk? Contractor Incentive to Control Costs Typical Construction Application

Lump-Sum (Fixed-Price) 100% complete plans & specs Contractor (100%) (highest contractor cost risk) Maximum (contractor keeps 100% of savings) Standard commercial & public buildings with complete plans

Unit-Price Clear work unit definitions; unknown total quantities Owner bears quantity risk; Contractor bears unit-cost risk High on unit productivity Highway paving, utility trenching, mass earthwork & rock excavation

Cost Plus % of Cost (CPPC) Minimal / emergency Owner (100%) (highest owner cost risk) None / Negative (higher cost = higher fee) Emergency private disaster work (banned on federal jobs)

Cost Plus Fixed Fee (CPFF) Partial / preliminary scope Owner on direct costs; Contractor fee is capped Moderate (finishing faster frees resources) Research facilities, complex historic renovations

Cost Plus with GMP Design sufficiently defined for agreed GMP scope Owner up to GMP (often shared); Contractor 100% above GMP High (especially with a shared-savings clause) CM at Risk and Design-Build commercial projects

Time & Materials (T&M) Undefined small or emergency scope Owner (unless capped by a Not-to-Exceed / NTE limit) Low unless capped by NTE Service work, emergency repairs, disputed change-order directives

Delivery comparisons describe typical arrangements. Design-bid-build can use separately designed bid packages; design-build does not guarantee the absence of disputes. A GMP’s design-completion percentage, variation-in-quantity trigger, shared-savings split, and reimbursable costs come from the particular agreement. Turnkey/EPC scope does not automatically include land acquisition or financing unless contracted.

Loading diagram... Risk Allocation Spectrum and Project Delivery Selection Flow