Study guide

17.3 Informed Decision-Making (AFH-1 Section 16C)

Air Force Promotion Fitness Examination PFE / WAPS

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction

1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 WAPS Scoring (AFI 36-2502 Table 2.4) 1.3 ADTC, Catalogs, and E5 vs E6 Chapters

2 Chapter 2: Professionalism

2.1 USAF Professionalism (AFH-1 Section 1A) 2.2 Profession of Arms (AFH-1 Section 1B) 2.3 Air Force Core Values (AFH-1 Section 1C) 2.4 Ethical Standards (AFH-1 Section 1D)

3 Military Organization and Command

3.1 United States Armed Forces (AFH-1 Section 5A) 3.2 Military Departments (AFH-1 Section 5B) 3.3 Military Command Structure (AFH-1 Section 5C)

4 USAF Total Force and Structure

4.1 USAF Total Force (AFH-1 Section 5D) 4.2 USAF Structure (AFH-1 Section 5E)

5 Enlisted Leadership Structure (AFH 1, Chapter 7A–7D)

5.1 Leadership Levels (AFH-1 Section 7A) 5.2 Enlisted Force Structure (AFH-1 Section 7B) 5.3 Duty Titles and Special Positions (AFH-1 Section 7C) 5.4 Force Development (AFH-1 Section 7D)

6 Chapter 6: Training and Education

6.1 Training Responsibilities (AFH-1 Section 7E) 6.2 Professional Military Education (AFH-1 Section 7F) 6.3 Community College of the Air Force (AFH-1 Section 7G) 6.4 Continuing Education (AFH-1 Section 7H)

7 7. Assessments and Recognition

7.1 Airman Comprehensive Assessment (AFH-1 Section 8A) 7.2 Performance Evaluations (AFH-1 Section 8B) 7.3 Reenlistments and Continuation (AFH-1 Section 8C) 7.4 Awards and Decorations (AFH-1 Section 8D)

8 Chapter 8: Promotion Systems

8.1 Promotion Systems and Programs (AFH-1 Section 9A) 8.2 Promotion Cycles (AFH-1 Section 9B) 8.3 Preparation and Responsibilities (AFH-1 Section 9C)

9 Promotion Testing and Evaluation Boards (AFH-1 Sections 9D–9E)

9.1 Promotion Testing (AFH-1 Section 9D) 9.2 Evaluation Boards (AFH-1 Section 9E)

10 10. Personnel Programs (AFH-1 Chapter 11)

10.1 Benefits and Services (AFH-1 Section 11A) 10.2 Leave and Authorized Absences (AFH-1 Section 11B) 10.3 Military Associations (AFH-1 Section 11C) 10.4 Civilian Programs (AFH-1 Section 11D)

11 Chapter 11: Finances and Travel

11.1 Individual Finances and Allowances (AFH-1 Section 12A) 11.2 Official Travel Expenses and Allowances (AFH-1 Section 12B)

12 Manpower and Resources (AFH-1 Sections 12C–12E)

12.1 Manpower Management (AFH-1 Section 12C) 12.2 Resource Management (AFH-1 Section 12D) 12.3 Environmental Commitment (AFH-1 Section 12E)

13 Developing Organizations (AFH-1 Chapter 13) — E6/TSgt PFE only

13.1 Strategic Thinking and Results Focus (AFH-1 Section 13A) 13.2 Resources and Organizational Structure (AFH-1 Section 13B) 13.3 Change and Problem Solving (AFH-1 Section 13C)

14 Chapter 14: Developing Others

14.1 Teamwork (AFH-1 Section 14A) 14.2 Develops People (AFH-1 Section 14B) 14.3 Service Mindset (AFH-1 Section 14C) 14.4 Leadership (AFH-1 Section 14D)

15 Chapter 15: Developing Self (AFH-1 15A–15C)

15.1 Accountability and Self-Management (AFH-1 Section 15A) 15.2 Military Communication (AFH-1 Section 15B) 15.3 Preparing to Communicate (AFH-1 Section 15C)

16 Chapter 16: Communication

16.1 Written Communication (AFH-1 Section 15D) 16.2 Spoken Communication (AFH-1 Section 15E) 16.3 Electronic Messaging (AFH-1 Section 15F)

17 Developing Ideas (AFH-1 Chapter 16)

17.1 What We Know (AFH-1 Section 16A) 17.2 Cognitive Processes (AFH-1 Section 16B) 17.3 Informed Decision-Making (AFH-1 Section 16C) 17.4 What We Don’t Know (AFH-1 Section 16D)

18 Emergency Management (AFH 1, Sections 17A–17C)

18.1 USAF Emergency Management (AFH-1 Section 17A) 18.2 Disasters, Attacks, and Hazards (AFH-1 Section 17B) 18.3 Preparedness and Protection (AFH-1 Section 17C)

19 Crisis Response, Mishap Prevention, and Risk Management

19.1 Crisis Response and Recovery (AFH-1 Section 17D) 19.2 USAF Mishap Prevention (AFH-1 Section 17E) 19.3 Risk Management (AFH-1 Section 17F)

20 Security (AFH-1 Sections 18A–18C)

20.1 Integrated Defense (AFH-1 Section 18A) 20.2 Operations Security (AFH-1 Section 18B) 20.3 Information Protection (AFH-1 Section 18C)

21 21. Information Access, Cyber Security, and Antiterrorism

21.1 Information Access, Cyber Security, and Mobility (AFH-1 Section 18D) 21.2 Antiterrorism (AFH-1 Section 18E)

22 Standards of Conduct (AFH-1 Sections 19A–19C)

22.1 Way of Life (AFH-1 Section 19A) 22.2 Law of War (AFH-1 Section 19B) 22.3 Code of Conduct (AFH-1 Section 19C)

23 Enforcing Military Standards (AFH 1, Chapter 20)

23.1 Air Force Inspection System (AFH-1 Section 20A) 23.2 Individual Accountability (AFH-1 Section 20B) 23.3 Appropriate Working Relationships (AFH-1 Section 20C) 23.4 Addressing Misconduct (AFH-1 Section 20D)

24 Fitness and Nutrition (AFH 1, Sections 22A–22C)

24.1 USAF Fitness (AFH-1 Section 22A) 24.2 Official Fitness Assessment (AFH-1 Section 22B) 24.3 Nutrition (AFH-1 Section 22C)

25 Substance Use and Readiness State of Mind (AFH 1, Sections 22D–22E)

25.1 Substance Use or Abuse (AFH-1 Section 22D) 25.2 Readiness State of Mind (AFH-1 Section 22E)

26 26. Military Customs and Courtesies (AFH-1 Chapter 24A–24C)

26.1 Honored Traditions (AFH-1 Section 24A) 26.2 Respect for the Flag (AFH-1 Section 24B) 26.3 Respect for Individuals (AFH-1 Section 24C)

27 Ceremonies, Drill, and Heritage (AFH 1, Sections 24D–24F)

27.1 Ceremonies and Events (AFH-1 Section 24D) 27.2 Drill and Formation (AFH-1 Section 24E) 27.3 Preserving Our Heritage (AFH-1 Section 24F)

28 Situational Judgment

28.1 PFE Situational Judgment Format 28.2 Foundational Competencies (AFH 36-2647) 28.3 SJT Decision Strategy for NCOs

17.3 Informed Decision-Making (AFH-1 Section 16C)

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

The CRAAP test evaluates sources on Currency, Relevance, Authority, Accuracy, and Purpose; newspaper articles and scientific papers are normally more reliable than blogs, advertisements, or message boards.

Analytical thinking breaks information apart, compares aspects of a problem, and organizes it; small samples mislead, correlation does not imply causality, and self-selection can spoil comparisons.

Divergent thinking generates multiple varied solutions; convergent thinking seeks the best solution from identified possibilities; formal education often improves convergent skill and may worsen divergent skill.

The Osborn-Parnes model's six stages are mess finding, data finding, problem finding, idea finding, solution finding, and acceptance finding, governed by deferred judgment.

The Vroom-Yetton-Jago model is used for deciding how to decide, with five levels from Decide and Announce through Delegate with Constraints.

Last updated: August 2026

Learning Is Power

Section 16C is ADTC B for TSgt and E-6 only on the 2026 catalogs . AFH 1's stake: from Airman Basic to General, daily decisions affect the delivery of airpower . Critical thinking is not a staff exercise. It is how NCOs reduce the unconscious habit of accepting an available option as satisfactory without exploring feasible options — satisficing with a uniform on.

The process of decision-making is as important as the information analyzed. A TSgt who collects perfect facts and then rams a pre-chosen answer through a meeting has still failed 16C.

Digital Literacy and the CRAAP Test

The internet gives immediate access and real-time updates . It is not regulated for quality and accuracy , so decision-makers must evaluate sources and watch for misinformation . AFH 1's named best practice is the CRAAP test .

Letter Criterion What to ask

C Currency (timeliness) When was it published or updated? Are newer sources available? Does this topic need recent information?

R Relevance (importance for your needs) Does it answer the question? Who is the audience? Is the level right — not too thin, not impenetrable?

A Authority (source) Who published or sponsored it? Credentials and affiliations? Is the author qualified on this topic?

A Accuracy (reliability, truthfulness, correctness) Evidence? Editor or subject-expert review? Can you verify it elsewhere?

P Purpose (why it exists) Inform or teach, or sell, entertain, or persuade? Objective? Political, ideological, institutional, or personal bias?

AFH 1's reliability heuristic: aim at sources with strong incentives to be accurate . A blog or message-board writer often faces little consequence for getting facts wrong ; for-profit copy may mislead . Newspaper articles and scientific papers are normally more reliable because errors damage the author's reputation . A TSgt pasting a viral post into a decision brief without CRAAP is not "staying current."

Analytical Thinking

Informed decisions need more than a fact dump. They need analytical thinking: systematically break information apart, compare different aspects of a problem, and organize information for complex, multidimensional issues . First move: healthy skepticism and several potential causes for what you observe — not the first story that fits the shop narrative.

Limitations of small sample sizes. Judgments from many observations are more likely to be accurate than judgments from a few. AFH 1's university example: friends are happy at University A but your short visit went poorly; friends dislike University B but your visit went well. Gut says pick B. The handbook asks how much of the school, how many classes, how many people you actually saw. Friends had longer, broader contact. Impressions from a few days or a few people usually lose to larger observation sets. A TSgt who changes a shift policy because two Airmen complained last Tuesday is making a small-sample decision.

Correlation does not imply causality. Related factors are not automatically cause and effect. Use a control group and ask whether the groups are otherwise mostly the same . AFH 1's XYZ supplements example: the base offers them free; takers improve fitness scores and non-takers do not. Before crediting the pill, ask whether takers already trained more, ate better (self-selection), differed in age, or had fewer pre-existing conditions . The more similar the groups, the more reasonable a causal claim. The gold standard AFH 1 names for firm scientific inference is double-blind randomized clinical trials . Self-selection bias appears when a comparison group has unforeseen qualities that tilt the result .

Divergent Thinking, Convergent Thinking, and Osborn-Parnes

Creative problem solving has two named components:

  • Type AFH 1 definition
  • Divergent thinking Generate multiple varied solutions. Brainstorming is a divergent task
  • Convergent thinking Seek the correct or best possible solution from identified possibilities

Formal education and training tend to improve convergent skill and may even worsen divergent skill. Both are required. A TSgt who only picks among the first three options is over-trained in convergence.

The Osborn-Parnes model is the recommended approach that uses both. Central principle: deferred judgment — let ideas flow (divergent) without internal or external evaluation; evaluate only after many ideas exist (convergent). Each stage alternates divergent and convergent work .

Stage What you do

1. Mess Finding Identify the problem. Summarize as a "How to…" statement (handbook example: How to reduce the number of Airmen calling in sick )

2. Data Finding Seek relevant facts. Ask who, what (and examples), when, where, why ; note missing facts and where to find them

3. Problem Finding State what you want to accomplish more specifically. Brainstorm "In What Ways Might We…" (IWWMW) statements; the first framing may hide another need. Pick the statement that captures the underlying problem (handbook example: Decrease the spread of COVID-19 in the squadron )

4. Idea Finding As many solutions as possible , including far-out ones. Set a numeric goal (for example 50–75 ideas) before discussing. Incubate if time allows; positive mood and rest help ; anonymity may help in groups because extrinsic pressure undermines divergent thinking . Then narrow toward 6–8 ideas

5. Solution Finding Weighted criteria (time, cost, feasibility, safety, morale), 1–10 weights , a decision matrix , ratings times weights

6. Acceptance Finding Gain acceptance, plan, implement, follow through

AFH 1 maps this onto Chapter 13's practical problem-solving method: Mess, Data, and Problem Finding support clarify and validate the problem ; Idea, Solution, and Acceptance Finding support develop countermeasures . The testable name is still deferred judgment .

Vroom-Yetton-Jago: Deciding How to Decide

AFH 1 says many models exist; the military-adopted one here is Vroom-Yetton-Jago , used for deciding how to decide . Five levels , each a different involvement or complexity .

Level Leader action Benefit Cost

I — Decide and Announce Makes the decision and announces it Speed ; leader control May miss information and alienate people . Explain why it was unilateral

II — Gather Input from Individuals and Decide Consults selected people one by one, then decides Experts without a full-group meeting Others may resent not being asked and see favoritism , then resist implementation

III — Gather Input from the Group and Decide Group input, then the leader decides Synergy and a better-informed call If the decision differs from the group's lean , people may feel used ; takes more time

IV — Facilitate Consensus Presents the issue and facilitates the group's decision , retaining the option to decide if consensus fails Buy-in, ownership, education, faster implementation once decided, trust More time ; the result may be adequate but not optimal because groups compromise

V — Delegate with Constraints Authorizes the group to decide inside stated boundaries while providing support and resources . Leaders do not abandon the group Builds team leadership and ownership ; frees the leader More time ; the decision may not be one the leader likes ; the team may lack skill , producing disharmony

Level IV keeps fallback authority; Level V gives the decision to the group inside constraints. That distinction is the usual trap. Level V is not walk-away leadership.

The two models combine. A leader can run Osborn-Parnes alone at Level I , pull others into Idea Finding only at Level I or II , or have the group apply Osborn-Parnes at Level IV or V . Process choice and participation choice are separate questions — which is the entire point of deciding how to decide .