Study guide

9.2 Evaluation Boards (AFH-1 Section 9E)

Air Force Promotion Fitness Examination PFE / WAPS

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Introduction

1.1 Current Exam Facts 1.2 WAPS Scoring (AFI 36-2502 Table 2.4) 1.3 ADTC, Catalogs, and E5 vs E6 Chapters

2 Chapter 2: Professionalism

2.1 USAF Professionalism (AFH-1 Section 1A) 2.2 Profession of Arms (AFH-1 Section 1B) 2.3 Air Force Core Values (AFH-1 Section 1C) 2.4 Ethical Standards (AFH-1 Section 1D)

3 Military Organization and Command

3.1 United States Armed Forces (AFH-1 Section 5A) 3.2 Military Departments (AFH-1 Section 5B) 3.3 Military Command Structure (AFH-1 Section 5C)

4 USAF Total Force and Structure

4.1 USAF Total Force (AFH-1 Section 5D) 4.2 USAF Structure (AFH-1 Section 5E)

5 Enlisted Leadership Structure (AFH 1, Chapter 7A–7D)

5.1 Leadership Levels (AFH-1 Section 7A) 5.2 Enlisted Force Structure (AFH-1 Section 7B) 5.3 Duty Titles and Special Positions (AFH-1 Section 7C) 5.4 Force Development (AFH-1 Section 7D)

6 Chapter 6: Training and Education

6.1 Training Responsibilities (AFH-1 Section 7E) 6.2 Professional Military Education (AFH-1 Section 7F) 6.3 Community College of the Air Force (AFH-1 Section 7G) 6.4 Continuing Education (AFH-1 Section 7H)

7 7. Assessments and Recognition

7.1 Airman Comprehensive Assessment (AFH-1 Section 8A) 7.2 Performance Evaluations (AFH-1 Section 8B) 7.3 Reenlistments and Continuation (AFH-1 Section 8C) 7.4 Awards and Decorations (AFH-1 Section 8D)

8 Chapter 8: Promotion Systems

8.1 Promotion Systems and Programs (AFH-1 Section 9A) 8.2 Promotion Cycles (AFH-1 Section 9B) 8.3 Preparation and Responsibilities (AFH-1 Section 9C)

9 Promotion Testing and Evaluation Boards (AFH-1 Sections 9D–9E)

9.1 Promotion Testing (AFH-1 Section 9D) 9.2 Evaluation Boards (AFH-1 Section 9E)

10 10. Personnel Programs (AFH-1 Chapter 11)

10.1 Benefits and Services (AFH-1 Section 11A) 10.2 Leave and Authorized Absences (AFH-1 Section 11B) 10.3 Military Associations (AFH-1 Section 11C) 10.4 Civilian Programs (AFH-1 Section 11D)

11 Chapter 11: Finances and Travel

11.1 Individual Finances and Allowances (AFH-1 Section 12A) 11.2 Official Travel Expenses and Allowances (AFH-1 Section 12B)

12 Manpower and Resources (AFH-1 Sections 12C–12E)

12.1 Manpower Management (AFH-1 Section 12C) 12.2 Resource Management (AFH-1 Section 12D) 12.3 Environmental Commitment (AFH-1 Section 12E)

13 Developing Organizations (AFH-1 Chapter 13) — E6/TSgt PFE only

13.1 Strategic Thinking and Results Focus (AFH-1 Section 13A) 13.2 Resources and Organizational Structure (AFH-1 Section 13B) 13.3 Change and Problem Solving (AFH-1 Section 13C)

14 Chapter 14: Developing Others

14.1 Teamwork (AFH-1 Section 14A) 14.2 Develops People (AFH-1 Section 14B) 14.3 Service Mindset (AFH-1 Section 14C) 14.4 Leadership (AFH-1 Section 14D)

15 Chapter 15: Developing Self (AFH-1 15A–15C)

15.1 Accountability and Self-Management (AFH-1 Section 15A) 15.2 Military Communication (AFH-1 Section 15B) 15.3 Preparing to Communicate (AFH-1 Section 15C)

16 Chapter 16: Communication

16.1 Written Communication (AFH-1 Section 15D) 16.2 Spoken Communication (AFH-1 Section 15E) 16.3 Electronic Messaging (AFH-1 Section 15F)

17 Developing Ideas (AFH-1 Chapter 16)

17.1 What We Know (AFH-1 Section 16A) 17.2 Cognitive Processes (AFH-1 Section 16B) 17.3 Informed Decision-Making (AFH-1 Section 16C) 17.4 What We Don’t Know (AFH-1 Section 16D)

18 Emergency Management (AFH 1, Sections 17A–17C)

18.1 USAF Emergency Management (AFH-1 Section 17A) 18.2 Disasters, Attacks, and Hazards (AFH-1 Section 17B) 18.3 Preparedness and Protection (AFH-1 Section 17C)

19 Crisis Response, Mishap Prevention, and Risk Management

19.1 Crisis Response and Recovery (AFH-1 Section 17D) 19.2 USAF Mishap Prevention (AFH-1 Section 17E) 19.3 Risk Management (AFH-1 Section 17F)

20 Security (AFH-1 Sections 18A–18C)

20.1 Integrated Defense (AFH-1 Section 18A) 20.2 Operations Security (AFH-1 Section 18B) 20.3 Information Protection (AFH-1 Section 18C)

21 21. Information Access, Cyber Security, and Antiterrorism

21.1 Information Access, Cyber Security, and Mobility (AFH-1 Section 18D) 21.2 Antiterrorism (AFH-1 Section 18E)

22 Standards of Conduct (AFH-1 Sections 19A–19C)

22.1 Way of Life (AFH-1 Section 19A) 22.2 Law of War (AFH-1 Section 19B) 22.3 Code of Conduct (AFH-1 Section 19C)

23 Enforcing Military Standards (AFH 1, Chapter 20)

23.1 Air Force Inspection System (AFH-1 Section 20A) 23.2 Individual Accountability (AFH-1 Section 20B) 23.3 Appropriate Working Relationships (AFH-1 Section 20C) 23.4 Addressing Misconduct (AFH-1 Section 20D)

24 Fitness and Nutrition (AFH 1, Sections 22A–22C)

24.1 USAF Fitness (AFH-1 Section 22A) 24.2 Official Fitness Assessment (AFH-1 Section 22B) 24.3 Nutrition (AFH-1 Section 22C)

25 Substance Use and Readiness State of Mind (AFH 1, Sections 22D–22E)

25.1 Substance Use or Abuse (AFH-1 Section 22D) 25.2 Readiness State of Mind (AFH-1 Section 22E)

26 26. Military Customs and Courtesies (AFH-1 Chapter 24A–24C)

26.1 Honored Traditions (AFH-1 Section 24A) 26.2 Respect for the Flag (AFH-1 Section 24B) 26.3 Respect for Individuals (AFH-1 Section 24C)

27 Ceremonies, Drill, and Heritage (AFH 1, Sections 24D–24F)

27.1 Ceremonies and Events (AFH-1 Section 24D) 27.2 Drill and Formation (AFH-1 Section 24E) 27.3 Preserving Our Heritage (AFH-1 Section 24F)

28 Situational Judgment

28.1 PFE Situational Judgment Format 28.2 Foundational Competencies (AFH 36-2647) 28.3 SJT Decision Strategy for NCOs

9.2 Evaluation Boards (AFH-1 Section 9E)

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

SSgt and TSgt promotions use AFI 36-2502 Table 2.4 WAPS factors, not a central evaluation board; Section 9E is still ADTC B for those grades and produces PFE items about how SNCO boards work.

Each SNCO promotion evaluation board panel consists of one Colonel and two Chief Master Sergeants, and the board president is always a General Officer.

AFH 1 states the promotion evaluation board accounts for over half of the total promotion score points.

Each of three panel members scores 6 to 10 in half-point increments; the 18-to-30 composite is multiplied by 15, producing a board score of 270 to 450.

A difference of more than one point among panel members is a split vote returned for resolution; only members involved in the split may change scores, and unresolved splits go to the board president.

Last updated: August 2026

9.2 Evaluation Boards (AFH-1 Section 9E)

Quick Answer: The SNCO promotion evaluation board accounts for over half of the total promotion score. Each panel is one Colonel and two Chief Master Sergeants; the board president is always a General Officer. Members score records from 6 to 10 in half-point increments. The three-member composite (18 to 30) is multiplied by 15, producing a board score of 270 to 450. Your promotion to Staff Sergeant or Technical Sergeant does not use this board—it uses AFI 36-2502 Table 2.4. Section 9E is still ADTC B for SSgt and TSgt, so the PFE tests how SNCO boards work.

Hold this distinction on every 9E item: SSgt and TSgt promotions are WAPS selections under AFI 36-2502, 2 July 2026, Table 2.4. No central panel scores your SSgt or TSgt record. Master Sergeant, Senior Master Sergeant, and Chief Master Sergeant promotions use the evaluation board in AFH 1 Section 9E and the board-score math in AFI 36-2502 Table 2.5 . You still study 9E because the ADTC lists it at level B for SSgt and TSgt.

Why SNCO boards dominate the score

AFH 1 paragraph 9.19 says the promotion evaluation board accounts for over half the total promotion score points . Member selection, board process, and the career areas members consider are what later SNCO promotion requires—and what the PFE already asks.

How panels are built

The number of promotion-eligible personnel , identified by major commands and Air Force Specialty Codes , determines the career field backgrounds of board members. Members are divided into panels .

Board panel composition

  • Position Composition / rule
  • Each scoring panel One Colonel and two Chief Master Sergeants
  • Board president Always a General Officer
  • Oath and briefing Members are briefed and sworn to complete the board's task impartially
  • Before live records Extensive trial-run process to lock scoring consistency
  • Same-panel rule The same panel evaluates all eligibles competing in a CEM Code or AFSC

The president is not "usually" a general—AFH 1 says always .

Whole-person areas the board may consider

Paragraph 9.20 lists several areas regarding an Airman's career, which may include :

  • Performance
  • Education
  • Breadth of experience
  • Job responsibility
  • Professional competence
  • Specific achievements
  • Leadership

Board scores vary , often significantly, from one board to the next because of new panel members , changed or improved records , and a pool of new eligibles . Scores also vary between panels , but all records within a Chief Enlisted Manager (CEM) Code or AFSC are evaluated under the same standard . The useful comparison is order of merit among peers , not last year's raw board number.

Board members do not have access to the weighted scores of people competing for promotion. When members disband, they do not know who was selected .

Trial run, secret ballots, and 270 to 450

Before live scoring, members receive two selected sets of records and score them as practice with secret ballots . Each board sets its own standard; everyone in a CEM Code or AFSC is then judged against it.

After the trial run is discussed, panels score live records. Each panel member uses a 6- to 10-point scale and half-point increments . A record may receive a panel composite (three members) from a minimum of 18 (6-6-6) to a maximum of 30 (10-10-10) . The composite is multiplied by a factor of 15 , producing a total board score of 270 to 450 . AFI 36-2502 Table 2.5 repeats that same calculation for MSgt, SMSgt, and CMSgt. AFH 1 and the current AFI still publish those numbers; they are not unofficial study-guide math.

Members score individually with no discussion . Records go to each member, and completed ballots go directly to a recorder , so scoring stays independent.

Split votes

A record scored with a difference of more than one point between any of the panel members (AFH 1's example: 8.5, 8.0, and 7.0 ) is a split vote and is returned to the panel for resolution . Members may then discuss the record openly and explain why they scored it as they did. Only those panel members directly involved in the split may change their scores. If they cannot agree, they give the record to the board president for resolution. That protects consistency and prevents one member from having a major positive or negative impact.

AFH 1's tested split rule is more than one point , not an unofficial 1.5-point shortcut.

Post-board processing and score notices

After the board finishes, weighted factor scores are combined with the board scores in a completely electronic operation that builds an order of merit by total score within each CEM Code or AFSC and applies the promotion quota to each list. After approval, data goes to the military personnel section.

Promotion score notices report relative standing and should never be provided to or used by anyone other than the individual and his or her commander . Scores cannot be disclosed without the Airman's written consent . Commander's support staffs, first sergeants, supervisors, etc., are not authorized access. The commander notifies selection or non-selection and may review the notice, but must limit use to notification and advisory counseling with no further dissemination . After initial selection for the current cycle, Airmen may retrieve a copy on the virtual military personnel flight and compare scores with statistics in the MPF or on vMPF through AFPC.

Section 9E is SNCO machinery. Your SSgt/TSgt stripe still lives in Table 2.4. Learn the board so you can answer PFE items about panels, whole-person factors, 270–450 math, split votes, and score-notice privacy.