Study guide

12.2 Health and Safety Performance Measurement, Statistics & Trend Analysis

SACPCMP Construction Health & Safety Manager Exam

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: South African Occupational Health and Safety Legislation

1.1 The OHS Act Framework, General Duties of Employers and Employees 1.2 Corporate Governance and Section 16 Liability & Delegations 1.3 Worker Representation: Health & Safety Representatives and Committees 1.4 Mandatary Agreements, Acts/Omissions & Criminal Liability

2 Chapter 2: Construction Regulations 2014 & Legal Appointments

2.1 Construction Work Permits, Notifications & Client Duties 2.2 Designer Duties and Principal Contractor Obligations 2.3 Statutory Construction Supervision Appointments 2.4 The CHS Manager vs CHS Officer vs CHS Agent & Professional Registration

3 Chapter 3: Risk Assessment Methodologies & The HIRA Process

3.1 Fundamental Risk Terminology: Hazards, Risks, Consequences & Tolerability 3.2 The Three Tiers of HIRA: Baseline, Issue-Based & Continuous Risk Assessments 3.3 Risk Rating Matrices: Quantitative, Semi-Quantitative & Qualitative Scoring 3.4 Task-Based Risk Assessments (TBRA) & Workforce Participation

4 Chapter 4: Risk Control Hierarchy & Safe Work Procedures

4.1 The Hierarchy of Controls in Construction Operations 4.2 Developing and Implementing Safe Work Procedures (SWPs) and SOPs 4.3 Daily Safety Task Instructions (DSTI) and Pre-Task Risk Reviews

5 Chapter 5: Specifications, Plans & The Health and Safety File

5.1 Client Health and Safety Specifications 5.2 The Principal Contractor Health & Safety Plan: Structure and Approval 5.3 Compiling and Maintaining the Consolidated Health & Safety File 5.4 Subcontractor Safety File Verification and Onboarding

6 Chapter 6: Specialized Safety Plans, Method Statements & Registers

6.1 Comprehensive Fall Protection Planning (CR 10 Requirements) 6.2 Contractor Method Statements and Risk Alignment 6.3 Statutory Registers, Checklists, and Inspection Logs

7 Chapter 7: Working at Heights & Temporary Works

7.1 Working at Heights: Fall Prevention, Fall Arrest & Rescue Systems 7.2 Scaffolding Standards, Competent Inspection & SANS 10085 (CR 16) 7.3 Temporary Works Management: Formwork, Falsework & Support Structures (CR 12)

8 Chapter 8: Excavations, Demolition & Heavy Plant Operations

8.1 Excavation Safety, Shoring, Battering & Underground Services (CR 13) 8.2 Demolition Work, Structural Assessment & Control Zones (CR 14) 8.3 Mobile Plant, Construction Vehicles & Cranes (CR 22, 23)

9 Chapter 9: Electrical Safety, Hazardous Chemicals & Confined Spaces

9.1 Temporary Electrical Installations, Distribution Boards & SANS 10142 (CR 24) 9.2 Hazardous Chemical Agents (HCA) & the Globally Harmonized System (GHS) 9.3 Confined Space Entry, Atmospheric Testing & Emergency Protocols (GSR 5)

10 Chapter 10: Incident Reporting, Statutory Notifications & Investigations

10.1 OHS Act Section 24 Statutory Reporting Criteria and Timeframes 10.2 Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act (COIDA) Compliance 10.3 Incident Scene Preservation and Evidence Gathering Protocols 10.4 Root Cause Analysis Methodologies (5 Whys, Fishbone) & CAPA

11 Chapter 11: Safety Auditing, Worker Consultation & Site Training

11.1 Internal Audits, Client Oversight Audits & Scoring Protocols (CR 5(1)(o), CR 7(1)(c)) 11.2 Non-Conformance Reports (NCRs), Corrective Actions & Close-Out Mandatory Site Induction, Competency Verification & Training Programs (CR 7(5)–(7)) 11.4 Medical Surveillance, Certificate of Fitness & Hygiene Monitoring (CR 7(8))

12 Chapter 12: Health and Safety Management Systems, Performance & Culture

12.1 Health and Safety Management Systems & ISO 45001 12.2 Health and Safety Performance Measurement, Statistics & Trend Analysis 12.3 Leadership, People & Health and Safety Culture 12.4 Innovation & Technology in Construction Health and Safety

13 Chapter 13: Emergency Preparedness, Communication & Health and Safety Procurement

13.1 Emergency Preparedness, Fire Precautions & First Aid (CR 29, GSR 3) 13.2 Health and Safety Communication, Consultation, Meetings & Reporting 13.3 Health and Safety Procurement & Cost Management

14 Chapter 14: Physical Agents, Environmental Management & Specialised Site Controls

14.1 Noise, Physical Agents & Ergonomics on Construction Sites 14.2 Environmental Management on Construction Projects 14.3 Specialised Site Controls: Structures, Platforms, Hoists, Plant & Facilities (CR 11, 15, 17-21, 25-28, 30)

12.2 Health and Safety Performance Measurement, Statistics & Trend Analysis

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Lagging indicators count harm after it happens (injuries, lost days, occupational disease); leading indicators measure the controls that prevent harm (inspections done, audit scores, NCR close-out, training coverage).

A lost-time injury frequency rate is the number of lost-time injuries multiplied by a stated base, usually 200 000 or 1 000 000 hours, divided by the total hours worked.

Severity rates use days lost instead of injury counts, so one serious injury can raise severity sharply while the frequency rate barely moves.

Small projects produce unstable rates, so trends are judged with rolling 12-month figures, Pareto charts of causes and control charts rather than single months.

Accident-ratio triangles do not show that cutting minor injuries will prevent fatalities; serious-injury and fatality precursors need their own indicators.

Last updated: October 2026

1. Why Measure Performance

Health and safety performance measurement tells management whether the system described in Section 12.1 is working. It supports the Check stage of the Plan-Do-Check-Act cycle and gives evidence for decisions on resources and corrective action. On a construction project, the CHSM uses measurement to:

report to the client and its agent, who audit the principal contractor at least once every 30 days under CR 5(1)(o);

give the health and safety committee information on incidents, which it must discuss under section 20(1)(b) of the OHS Act;

identify contractors, activities or areas that need intervention before a serious incident occurs; and

feed the annual management review.

2. Lagging and Leading Indicators

Lagging indicators measure outcomes after harm has occurred:

  • fatalities, lost-time injuries, medical treatment cases and first aid cases;
  • days lost and restricted work days;
  • occupational disease cases, such as noise-induced hearing loss shifts or silicosis findings;

reportable incidents under section 24 of the OHS Act and property damage.

Leading indicators measure the inputs and controls that prevent harm:

  • percentage of planned inspections, audits and safety observations completed;
  • NCRs closed out on time, and the average age of open corrective actions;
  • percentage of workers inducted, trained or holding valid Annexure 3 certificates;
  • number of task-based risk assessments reviewed, permits audited and toolbox talks held;

near-miss and hazard reports submitted, and the time taken to act on them.

A good dashboard uses both. Lagging indicators show results; leading indicators show whether controls are being maintained. Leading indicators must be meaningful: counting toolbox talks says little unless their quality is also checked.

3. Standard Rates and Formulas

Raw injury counts cannot be compared between projects of different sizes, so they are normalised by hours worked. The base must always be stated:

LTIFR = Number of lost-time injuries × Base Total hours worked \text{LTIFR} = \frac{\text{Number of lost-time injuries} \times \text{Base}}{\text{Total hours worked}} LTIFR = Total hours worked Number of lost-time injuries × Base ​

Severity rate = Days lost × Base Total hours worked \text{Severity rate} = \frac{\text{Days lost} \times \text{Base}}{\text{Total hours worked}} Severity rate = Total hours worked Days lost × Base ​

Total recordable injury rate = ( LTIs + restricted work cases + medical treatment cases ) × Base Total hours worked \text{Total recordable injury rate} = \frac{(\text{LTIs} + \text{restricted work cases} + \text{medical treatment cases}) \times \text{Base}}{\text{Total hours worked}} Total recordable injury rate = Total hours worked ( LTIs + restricted work cases + medical treatment cases ) × Base ​

The two common bases are 200 000 hours (about 100 workers working 2 000 hours a year) and 1 000 000 hours . A rate calculated on one base is not comparable with a rate on the other unless converted. Definitions also vary: a client may define a lost-time injury as one that prevents the person returning to work on the next scheduled shift. The CHSM should state the definitions in the project's reporting procedure and apply them consistently to every contractor.

Worked example

A project records the following over 12 months:

600 workers on average, working 2 200 hours each: 600 × 2 200 = 1 320 000 600 \times 2\,200 = 1\,320\,000 600 × 2 200 = 1 320 000 hours;

4 lost-time injuries with 96 days lost in total;

10 medical treatment cases.

Then:

LTIFR (200 000 base) = 4 × 200 000 ÷ 1 320 000 = 0.61 = 4 \times 200\,000 \div 1\,320\,000 = 0.61 = 4 × 200 000 ÷ 1 320 000 = 0.61

LTIFR (1 000 000 base) = 4 × 1 000 000 ÷ 1 320 000 = 3.03 = 4 \times 1\,000\,000 \div 1\,320\,000 = 3.03 = 4 × 1 000 000 ÷ 1 320 000 = 3.03

Severity rate (200 000 base) = 96 × 200 000 ÷ 1 320 000 = 14.5 = 96 \times 200\,000 \div 1\,320\,000 = 14.5 = 96 × 200 000 ÷ 1 320 000 = 14.5 days lost per 200 000 hours

Total recordable injury rate (200 000 base) = 14 × 200 000 ÷ 1 320 000 = 2.12 = 14 \times 200\,000 \div 1\,320\,000 = 2.12 = 14 × 200 000 ÷ 1 320 000 = 2.12

Average days lost per lost-time injury = 96 ÷ 4 = 24 = 96 \div 4 = 24 = 96 ÷ 4 = 24

If one more injury causes 180 days lost, the LTIFR rises only from 0.61 to 0.76, but the severity rate more than doubles to 41.8. Both figures are needed to see the full picture.

4. Reading Trends Correctly

Construction workforces change month by month, and a single injury on a small project makes the monthly rate jump. Sound trend analysis uses:

Rolling 12-month rates : each month, recalculate the rate over the last 12 months to smooth random variation.

Pareto analysis : rank incidents by cause, activity or contractor; typically a few categories (falls from height, struck by plant, hand injuries) account for most harm, which shows where to focus.

Control charts : plot monthly figures against a mean and control limits to separate normal variation from a real change.

Exposure context : compare against the hours worked in each phase; earthworks, steel erection and roofing phases carry different risk.

Leading-to-lagging links : if inspection completion falls in a month and injuries rise in the next, the link is worth investigating.

5. The Limits of Accident Triangles

Heinrich (1931) proposed a ratio of serious injuries to minor injuries to no-injury accidents, and Bird (1969) published a larger ratio of 1 serious injury to 10 minor injuries, 30 property damage incidents and 600 near misses. These triangles are useful to show that minor events are common and worth reporting. However, they do not prove that reducing minor injuries will reduce fatalities in proportion. Serious injuries and fatalities often come from different, high-energy hazards (falls from height, collapse, crush by plant, electrocution) that minor-injury counts do not track. Good practice therefore uses serious injury and fatality (SIF) precursors , such as work at height without fall protection, lifts without a lifting plan, or entry into unsupported excavations, as leading indicators.

6. Under-Reporting and Perverse Incentives

Low injury rates are only meaningful if reporting is honest. Bonuses tied only to "zero LTIs", or pressure to bring injured workers back on light duty so that a lost-time injury is not recorded, hide risk and can breach section 24 reporting and COIDA claim duties. The CHSM should:

  • reward reporting of near misses and hazards, not only the absence of injuries;
  • reconcile site incident records with first aid records, clinic visits and COIDA claims;
  • check that every incident covered by section 24 has been reported to the provincial office; and

audit restricted-work cases to confirm that the work offered is genuine and medically appropriate.

7. Reporting Performance

A monthly health and safety report to the client and management typically contains:

  • hours worked and headcount per contractor;
  • lagging and leading indicators against targets, with rolling 12-month rates;
  • significant incidents, investigation status and corrective actions;
  • audit and inspection results and open NCRs;

upcoming high-risk activities and the controls planned for them.

The report should be short, use the same definitions every month and lead to decisions, not just display numbers.

Loading diagram... From Raw Data to Performance Decisions