Study guide

14.3 Non-conformance, Corrective Action and Continual Improvement

SACPCMP Construction Health & Safety Officer CHSO

Track your progress as you read

Finished sections get a check mark.

1 Chapter 1: South African Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHS Act 85 of 1993)

1.1 Scope, Purpose, and General Employer Duties (Sections 8, 9, 10) 1.2 Employee Duties, Rights, and Health & Safety Representation (Sections 14, 17, 18, 19, 20) 1.3 Corporate Governance, Accountability, and Mandatary Agreements (Sections 16, 37, 44)

2 Chapter 2: Construction Regulations 2014: Governance & Key Roles

2.1 Scope, Construction Work Permits, and Notifications (Regulations 1, 3, 4, Annexure 2) 2.2 Statutory Duties of Clients, Designers, and Principal Contractors (Regulations 5, 6, 7) 2.3 Site Supervision and Management Appointments (Regulation 8: CR 8(1), 8(2), 8(5), 8(7), 8(8))

3 Chapter 3: Compensation, Liability, and Administrative Regulations

3.1 Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act (COIDA 130 of 1993) & Civil Liability 3.2 General Administrative Regulations (GAR) 2003: Reporting & Investigating Provisions 3.3 SACPCMP Statutory Mandate, Registration Rules, and Code of Conduct

4 Chapter 4: Risk Assessment Methodologies & Types

4.1 The Three Tiers of Construction Risk Assessment: Baseline, Issue-Based, and Continuous (CR 9) 4.2 Qualitative and Semi-Quantitative Risk Scoring (Probability, Severity, Matrix Evaluation) 4.3 Hierarchy of Risk Controls: From Elimination to Personal Protective Equipment

5 Chapter 5: Safe Work Procedures, Method Statements & Dynamic Risk

5.1 Developing Safe Work Procedures (SWPs) from Risk Assessments 5.2 Safe Work Method Statements (SWMS) and Task Execution 5.3 Daily Safe Task Instructions (DSTI), Toolbox Talks, and Dynamic Site Risk Management

6 Chapter 6: Health and Safety File & Planning Documentation

6.1 Client Health and Safety Specifications vs. Principal Contractor Health and Safety Plan 6.2 Structure, Contents, and Maintenance of the Site Health and Safety File (CR 7(1)(b), 7(2)(b) & 7(1)(e)) 6.3 Contractor Vetting, Approval, and Monthly Compliance Auditing (CR 5(1)(o) & CR 7)

7 Chapter 7: Statutory Registers, Checklists & Legal Appointments

7.1 Equipment and Plant Registers: Scaffolding, Ladders, and Portable Electrical Tools 7.2 Medical, Occupational Hygiene, and PPE Registers 7.3 Compiling, Signing, and Enforcing Legal Letters of Appointment on Site

8 Chapter 8: High-Risk Works: Working at Heights & Scaffolding

8.1 Fall Protection Plans, Fall Prevention, and Fall Arrest Systems (CR 10) 8.2 Scaffolding Erection, Tagging, and SANS 10085 Standards (CR 16) 8.3 Suspended Platforms, Boatswain's Chairs, and Rope Access (CR 17 & CR 18)

9 Chapter 9: Groundworks, Temporary Works & Heavy Operations

9.1 Excavations, Shoring, and Ground Stability Safeguards (CR 13) 9.2 Temporary Works, Formwork, and Support Work Safety (CR 12) 9.3 Cranes, Material Hoists, and Mobile Plant Operations (CR 19, CR 22, CR 23, DMR 18)

10 Chapter 10: Site Infrastructure, Fire, Electrical & Occupational Health

10.1 Temporary Electrical Installations and Portable Electrical Tools (CR 24 & SANS 10142) 10.2 Fire Precautions, Flammable Store Management, and Housekeeping (CR 25, 27, 28, 29) 10.3 Occupational Health Hazards: Noise Zones, Hazardous Chemical Agents, and Facilities (CR 30)

11 Chapter 11: Incident Notification, Reporting & Statutory Investigations

11.1 Section 24 Reportable Incidents vs. Minor Work Injuries: Thresholds and Windows 11.2 Incident Scene Management, Evidence Preservation, and Witness Interviewing 11.3 Incident Investigation Methodologies (GAR 9, 5 Whys, Root Cause Analysis) and CAPA

12 Chapter 12: Emergency Preparedness, First Aid & Safety Culture

12.1 Site Emergency Preparedness Plans, Evacuation Drills, and Alarms (CR 29) 12.2 First Aid Requirements, Box Standards, and Emergency Medical Services (GSR 3) 12.3 Mandatory Site Induction, Worker Participation, and Refusal of Dangerous Work

13 Chapter 13: Health and Safety Management Systems and Governance

13.1 Health and Safety Management Systems: ISO 45001 and the Plan-Do-Check-Act Cycle 13.2 Health and Safety Policy, Organising, and the Section 16(2) Chain of Accountability 13.3 Documented Information, Internal Audit, and Management Review

14 Chapter 14: Health and Safety Performance, Auditing and Reviews

14.1 Measuring Health and Safety Performance: Leading Indicators, DIFR and LTIFR 14.2 Inspections, Audits and Legal Compliance Auditing 14.3 Non-conformance, Corrective Action and Continual Improvement

15 Chapter 15: Health and Safety Procurement, Cost and Contractor Management

15.1 Health and Safety in Procurement and Tendering 15.2 Health and Safety Cost Management: Pricing, Budgeting and the Cost of Failure 15.3 Contractor Management Through the Project Life Cycle

16 Chapter 16: Communication, Safety Culture and Technology

16.1 Health and Safety Communication Management and Reporting to Decision Makers 16.2 People, Safety Culture and Worker Participation 16.3 Innovation and Technology in Construction Health and Safety

17 Chapter 17: Occupational Hygiene, Medical Surveillance, Environment and Ergonomics

17.1 Hazardous Chemical Agents, Asbestos and Lead on Construction Sites 17.2 Medical Surveillance and the Annexure 3 Certificate of Fitness 17.3 Environmental Management on Construction Sites 17.4 Ergonomics, Manual Handling and Physical Agents

18 Chapter 18: Enforcement, Standards and Remaining High-Risk Construction Works

18.1 Enforcement: Inspector Powers, Notices, Inquiries and Penalties 18.2 Incorporated Standards, SANS and Personal Protective Equipment Selection 18.3 Demolition Work and Structural Stability 18.4 Tunnelling, Water Environments, Bulk Mixing Plant, Material Hoists and Explosive Actuated Devices 18.5 Hazard Identification Techniques and Permit-to-Work Systems

14.3 Non-conformance, Corrective Action and Continual Improvement

Key Takeaways Explain This Topic AI

Findings must be classified as unsafe condition, unsafe act, system non-conformance or legal non-compliance, because stopping at the unsafe act produces discipline without change.

A defensible corrective action notice carries a factual finding, a legal reference, a grade, immediate action, root cause, a named owner with a calendar date, and independent effectiveness verification after the due date.

CR 10(4)(d) legislates the hierarchy for work at height: fall arrest equipment may be used only where it is not reasonably practicable to use fall prevention equipment.

Corrective action close-out rate - actions verified effective by due date over total actions raised - is a better health measure than the raw number of findings.

GAR 9(3) requires investigation findings to be entered in Annexure 1 immediately on completion, and GAR 9(4) requires implementation and follow-up that does not wait for the quarterly section 19(4) committee meeting.

Last updated: September 2026

14.3 Non-conformance, Corrective Action and Continual Improvement

Note

SACPCMP Blueprint Context : This section closes the performance chapter by covering what happens after an inspection, audit or investigation produces a finding. It draws on ISO 45001 clause 10.2, on GAR 9(3) and 9(4), and on the stop-work and remediation duties in CR 5(1)(q) and CR 7(1)(c)(viii).

1. Classifying What You Found

Before any corrective action can be designed, the finding must be classified correctly, because the classification determines who owns it and how fast it must move.

Unsafe condition — a physical state: an unguarded penetration, a damaged sling, an untagged scaffold.

Unsafe act — a behaviour: a worker unclipping to move along a leading edge.

System non-conformance — a required process is absent, undefined, or not followed: no anchor points were designed into the slab edge, so unclipping was inevitable.

Legal non-compliance — a specific statutory duty is unmet: no fall protection plan exists at all, contrary to CR 10(1)(a).

The most common professional failure in South African construction is stopping at the second category. "Worker did not clip on" produces a disciplinary record and changes nothing. Behind almost every unsafe act sits a system non-conformance, and the CHSO's value lies in finding it.

2. The Corrective Action Notice

A corrective action notice (CAN) is the instrument that moves a finding to closure. A defensible CAN has seven fields, and an auditor reviewing another contractor's system should test for exactly these:

Field What good looks like

Finding Factual and specific: "Openings in the 4th-floor slab at gridlines C3-C5 are covered with unsecured, unmarked shutter ply" — not "poor housekeeping"

Legal / standard reference CR 10(4)(a): all unprotected openings in floors, edges, slabs, hatchways and stairways must be adequately guarded, fenced or barricaded

  • Grade Imminent danger / major / minor / observation
  • Immediate action taken What was done on the spot to make the situation safe
  • Root cause Why the condition arose and why the system did not prevent it
  • Corrective action, owner, due date A named individual and a calendar date
  • Effectiveness verification Signed and dated by someone other than the action owner, after the due date

The last field is the one most often missing and the one that determines whether the same finding recurs.

3. Root Cause: Going Past the Obvious

Root cause analysis techniques are covered in detail in the incident investigation chapter; here the point is that they apply equally to audit findings, not only to injuries. The three questions that reliably move an analysis from symptom to cause on a construction site are:

What made the safe way harder than the unsafe way? Workers overwhelmingly take the path of least resistance. If the nearest anchor point is 12 metres away and the task takes 40 seconds, the control has designed its own defeat.

What changed? New subcontractor, new shift pattern, new supervisor, design revision, weather, programme pressure. Most site failures are traceable to a change that was not managed under ISO 45001 clause 8.1.3.

Who was supposed to catch this, and why didn't they? If a weekly CR 24(d) electrical inspection should have found a damaged distribution board and did not, the corrective action belongs to the inspection process, not just the board.

4. Choosing the Control Level

A corrective action that sits low in the hierarchy of controls is a corrective action that will need repeating. Rank every proposed action:

  • Level Applied to the slab-openings finding
  • Elimination Redesign so the penetration is cast later, after the deck is trafficked
  • Substitution Replace shutter-ply covers with proprietary cast-in covers
  • Engineering Fixed, load-rated covers mechanically secured and painted, or permanent guardrails to CR 10(4)(a)
  • Administrative Permit system for opening a cover; daily inspection; signage

PPE Harness and lanyard to a designed anchor — the last line, and under CR 10(4)(d) fall arrest may be used only where it is not reasonably practicable to use fall prevention equipment

CR 10(4)(d) is a legislated hierarchy: it does not merely prefer fall prevention over fall arrest, it prohibits reaching for arrest while prevention remains reasonably practicable. Any corrective action that proposes harnesses where guardrails would work is, on its face, non-compliant.

5. Escalation and Continual Improvement

Not every finding belongs to the site. A finding that recurs across three audits, or that appears on multiple sites in the same contractor's portfolio, is evidence of a defect at a level the site cannot fix — procurement buying non-compliant equipment, a training provider producing incompetent operators, a tender that priced insufficient supervision. Those findings must escalate to management review under ISO 45001 clause 9.3, where resource decisions can actually be taken.

The measure that tells a CHSO whether the loop is working is not the number of findings raised. It is: Corrective action close-out rate = Actions verified effective by due date Total actions raised × 100 \text{Corrective action close-out rate} = \frac{\text{Actions verified effective by due date}}{\text{Total actions raised}} \times 100 Corrective action close-out rate = Total actions raised Actions verified effective by due date ​ × 100

A site raising 60 findings a month with a 90 per cent verified close-out rate is healthier than a site raising 6 findings a month with a 40 per cent rate. High finding counts with high close-out rates indicate a system that is looking hard and fixing what it finds; low finding counts indicate a system that has stopped looking.

Important

Statutory close-out has its own timetable. For incidents, GAR 9(2) requires investigation within 7 days from the date of the incident; GAR 9(3) requires the findings to be entered in Annexure 1 immediately after the investigation is completed; and GAR 9(4) requires the record to be examined by the health and safety committee at its next meeting, with the necessary actions implemented and followed up to prevent recurrence. Section 19(4) requires that committee to meet at least once every three months, so a corrective action arising from an incident must not be parked until a meeting that may be eleven weeks away — the follow-up duty is continuous, and the committee examination is a governance checkpoint on top of it.

Loading diagram... Finding to Closure: Classification, Root Cause, Control Selection and Escalation